Walked in 15 minutes before closing and asked if I was going to inconvenience them. Nope, I was told, we have a little dough left. I decided to order the large supreme which was an excellent idea on my part. The pizza was incredible!! They make their own dough, kinda like a sourdough, just thin enough to have a bit of crisp but folds easily to stuff in your mouth. Fresh toppings and just the right amount of cheese. I will be definitely make the detour to this delicacy. read more

Pizza was fantastic. Would order tonight if they delivered to NC. Service was also great!! True hole in the wall with great .

This place is off the charts good! We came here after the town's tree lighting ceremony and parade. Our kids were hyped up on sugar overload but this spot was so welcoming to our family. We met the owner and could tell she took such great pride in providing not just a nice setting but high-quality food. Without a doubt, you need to order the dough balls for an appetizer. We got the ones stuffed with cheese and sauce as well as the dough balls stuffed with cheese, jalapeños and ham. They were fantastic and didn't last long! For the main course, we ordered a straight up cheese pizza. It came out hot and fresh. Our kids just loved it and so did we. Everything about the meal was spot on. read more

Great local pizza spot! After a long day at Luray Caverns, we stopped by here to get some pizza. While it did take a while to receive our food, the quality was great! When we were there, only 3 staff members were working, and there were a ton of customers so I was more than willing to wait patiently. Plenty of seating to sit and eat/wait inside. read more

Jenny Lynd's Pizza - Garlic Chicken Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Virginia

Bit of a drive from Graves Mountain Lodge but worth the drive. Pizza was very good. My wife picked up the pizza as carry out. Service was excellent. read more

The best pizza in the area. And I should know. I'm a Jersey girl at heart , and I'm very, very picky about my pizza. This is beyond decent, and the best pizza in the area. (Maybe just a scosh under Jersey standards, but pretty darn close.) read more

We were in town at a Revival for Kingdom Movement with Ryan Edberg and KellyK ministries and Crystal not only made 30 pizzas/bread sticks but delivered them to us but also gave our group a discount! Great service, Great attitude and delicious pizza! read more

Friendly, neighborly service. The garlic chicken supreme pizza was delicious! Crispy bread w fresh toppings. Would go here again! read more

Jenny Lynd's Pizza - Garlic chicken supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Virginia

The pizza here is hot and fresh! The toppings are priced interestingly but c'est la vie. I watched the employee effectively make everything from start to finish and the personal pizza is a great size for a lunch meal. Highly recommend going here simply due to affordability and the quality of the food. The garlic breadsticks make a great snack as well! The décor seemed a bit dated but at the end of the day, taste is king! read more

Jenny Lynd's Pizza - the dining area - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Virginia

See all

Better than averages this place is a treat, even a tot appetizer which was my first time, but is now a staple that is so yummy it makes me too full for the rest, there are worse problems to have! Also, I've had the 3 cheese pizza + pepperoni and that was a winner. I would love some béchamel and pesto and local tomatoes when it's time Jenny! I've enjoyed a few delicious and Huge calzones, next time is Stromboli. Thank you for being in Madison. read more

Friendly local service and atmosphere. The pizza was excellent.The pizza dough was fresh, homemade pizza sauce, and fresh toppings. I had a pizza off the menu and my husband built his own pizza. They were both equally tasty. The staff remembered last time we were there. The staff cares about the people they serve. Definitely recommend it! read more

A very special place in a small town, Jenny Lynd's pizza is as good as it gets. The crust is homemade, chewy, and delicious, and it reheats better than any pizza I've ever had. There are a few other dishes. My wife has had the chicken parmesan, and loves it. There are a few simple desserts, but the pizza is the main attraction. read more

We have had a lot of trouble finding good non-greasy pizza in Ruckersville and it's worth driving 15 or so minutes to Madison for their pizza...it's fresh and non-greasy and has a great crust. Definitely worth the trip!! read more

Absolutely a must to have lunch at. The chicken Philly deluxe was spot on. We will be back!!

We occasionally drive through Madison to travel to Front Royal and today we missed breakfast. So we were starving by 1pm and I looked up a sandwich shop. Jenny Lynd's popped up and we stopped in. I got a cheesesteak and my husband got a hot italian sub. Both were amazing. We also got the funnel cake fries with raspberry sauce. I highly recommend this place. Friendly workers and amazing food. read more

We get pizza from here every month or so and always enjoy it. It's always quick, hot, tastes good and is fresh. It's a good deal as well!

Great Wings, Great PIzza and wonderful customer service. i Highly recommend this place if you are craving pizza.

Amazing pizza! Great flavors, new options - a really good pizza. However, they always seem to be running late. I find the lateness frustrating, but the pizza is awesome! She also has stocked and sold items during COVID that were hard to find. I appreciate her ingenuity! read more

Great pizza. OK atmosphere. seems they were rearranging the booths. Very friendly staff and fast service.

Great local pizza joint in Madison. It's a great place to stop on your way back from a hike! The pizza is great, starting with the crust and toppings! The crust is on the lighter, fluffy side, not thin. The ingredients are delicious, especially the pepperoni, sausage, and Greek pizza toppings! The buffalo wings are worth trying, but they aren't the best. Stick with fries, mozzarella sticks, and fried pickles for sides. I'm pretty sure all of these sides are frozen foods that are reheated in store, but are still good. The staff is very friendly, especially the owner Crystal. She offers very personal and friendly service. Last note: this is Madison, VA folks, not NYC. Sorry that this small town pizza shop doesn't measure up to NYC. Not sure why that reviewer who left a one star had to reassure us that she must "know" pizza simply for the fact that she lived in NY/NJ for over a decade. Give this joint a try! read more

Great pizza with fresh ingredients and a great crust. Service is always friendly, and service is timely. If you call ahead, the management will give you a very accurate time when your order will be out of the oven. This is a great place to pick up dinner before heading out for a beer at Bald Top brewery, about mile away. read more

What fantastic pizza! Our family ordered a bunch, including the Buffalo chicken, a spinach and feta, and a veggie pizza sub. By rights that last one shouldn't be allowed -- it's a sub sandwich with pizza as the "bread" -- but my goodness it was delicious. Crucially, the pizza crust is fantastic: not too crispy, not too doughy -- a Goldilocks level of perfection. Also, the service is fantastic: friendly, funny, and fast. Can't beat that! We'll be back when we're next in the area. Highly recommended! read more

Kind of disappointing. So me and my family have eaten here a couple times now. The food has always been decent, nothing to special about anything other than their pizza. The staff is kind of hit or miss in terms of politeness. The male members of the staff at the time that I'm writing this review are always nice and treat me and my husband with respect. The other young female employee... not so much. The owner has her moments, I have not experienced this personally, but I have heard from friends that they have witnessed it. But the main reason that I am posting such a low review is not because of the food or the attitude of the staff. The last time I went into the restaurant, I had a rather unpleasant shock. First and foremost I had to wait an extra 15 to 20 mins for my food even though I called ahead and gave them an excessive amount of time. For the reason I will not be returning to Jenny Lynd's is that when I finally did get my food. I notice the younger woman using an electronic cigarette right by the food prep area. Now I for one can understand needing to go outside for some sort of smoke break, but doing it in the restaurant right by the food is a little much. Also the owners does this too according to others customers that I asked but I have never seen it myself. Lastly the most ironic thing is that the door leading into the establishment has a sign that says no E-cigs. So eat here for ok food and ok staff, but know you might have smoke blown onto your food as they make it. read more

Super tasty pizza, glad I was able to grab a pie! Call in your order. Nice staff. Waiting inside is like covid roulette so don't show up early. read more

The pizza crust is not done--makes the pizza super soggy. They don't put enough sauce on it either so its substandard. They just don[t know how to make a pizza ! I even asked for and paid for more sauce, but it didnt happen. Kinda reminded me of a saltine with a thin smear of ketchup on it. PLace is real smelly too, like tons of onions. YUCK ! I won't go again if there is any choice at all. read more

I got spaghetti which had no flavor at all and the meat balls looked under cooked pink in the middle I won't be going back

Pizza is hit or miss, our last calzone had to be remade 3 times due to training? And the one we got was raw and not cooked all the way. Might be a bit before we try again read more

A great place for pizza and ordering take out. Not fancy but good food. I always enjoy a nice hot pizza!

Wings were great - the sauce wasn't dripping off nor were they soggy! The pizza was good - the crust/bread was really what made it enjoyable! read more

We've driven past this place on our hiking/fishing trips and always wanted to try it. We finally did and I'm glad! Our pepperoni pizza was delicious! And even though we ordered 30 minutes before they closed, the staff was very friendly and attentive. Will definitely be coming back! read more

Amazing flavors throughout. The pizza crust perfectly cooked. The sandwich perfectly portioned. The hospitality was family friendly and very welcoming. Thank you for a great meal and friendly conversation read more

I have lived in Madison my whole life. Just a couple months back my parents told me they tried the food here and it was really good. I took their advice and tried it. I am SO glad I did!! I don't know how I've lived here for so long and would choose Subway or McDonald's when this lovely place was here all along!! I am OBSESSED with the Greek Salad!! It is by far the best Greek Salad I have had EVER!! Every time I am asked what I want to eat, that is what immediately pops in my head! We have tried multiple pizzas, meatball sub, mozzarella sticks, chicken wings, etc. Everything has tasted phenomenal! And everyone when we order and pick up is always so nice!! We have never had a bad experience here and we can honestly say this is our favorite place!! It's like a little piece of heaven located right here in our beautiful Madison County read more

Stopped by after a doing a few wine tastings. The wings were great and the pizza excellent. It really hit the spot. We had the Greek pizza with Italian sausage added. Everything was fresh but the roasted garlic and dough really made it. read more

Pizza was awesome. Crust was great. Wings were crispy and perfect. Definitely will be back and tellin my friends!

New owner and new name, still the best pizza around. Hours are not a late night pizza kind of place but the pizza is some of the best south of New York and the people who work there are great. Good sandwiches, too. read more

The pizza and the service were amazing! Friendly staff and great food! Definitely ask about specials and desserts.

Their pizza is awesome! We get the meatlovers and the favor and seasoning is spot on. It is a new and small business so don't go there expecting a there page menu but what they have is good and priced right. Well worth your time! read more

It's honestly hard to find good pizza in Virginia, but this place has GREAT pizza. Perfect hand tossed style crust and fresh toppings. The service is very personal and I always feel like my order is made with care. Really great addition to Madison. read more

Stopped by today expecting to see pie in the sky ....was not disappointed they were gone. Pizza was amazing and the meatball parmigiana was too. I'm pretty picky when it comes to meatballs! Can't wait to get back to Madison for more of this yummy food. Place is clean and customer service is 5 Star. Ya gotta try this place . read more

My husband and two friends and I loved this restaurant. Each of us ordered something different and it was great we are getting ready to order dessert now because we assume it's going to be just as good. The owner was very friendly and made our stay great. Or rather made our dinner great. We are not from around here so we probably won't be coming back. Because we live all the way in Florida but if I wanted to drive somewhere to go get food this is worth the drive just not from Florida LOL. But if you're in the area stop here. So glad we found it. read more