Cancel

Open app

Search

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

4.4 (21 reviews)
Closed 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Order Jeremiah's Italian Ice Takeout or Delivery

Jeremiah's Italian Ice Photos

Business Info

Recommended Reviews - Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Peppermint Bark
Sarah T.

I love this place. People are always so kind and fast. I love that they change flavors up. I recently got the peppermint bark and it was exactly up my alley. It was so good and festive. I believe it was cookies and cream ice with vanilla and crushed peppermint add on. The proportions and how well everything complemented each other. Then I had to come again but ended up sampling the mango and boy oh boy that mango was delicious. I came in wanting another peppermint but HAD to get the mango. I wish I had some chamoy and tajin to go with it but it was still a hit. I mixed it with strawberry because I was feeling spontaneous. Anyways, just go! Sample eat and enjoy.

Medium Italian Ice
Aviator D.

Great! I enjoyed my build your own dessert. I got it with salted caramel Italian ice, vanilla chocolate swirl soft serve, and Biscoff crumbles. If that sounds good then I highly recommend. Looks like they get a lot of mobile orders, the workers were doing exceptionally well considering there were only two of them, poor things. The one who took our order, I did not catch her name but she was wearing a veil and a Taylor Swift hoodie, she was so so friendly and sweet please give that girl a raise. Didn't use the bathrooms so I can't comment on them but the place was clean. Thank you (:

Amber E.

If there's a Jeremiah's Italian ice nearby, I will definitely be there! I love this place and the Italian ice is so good! It literally melts in your mouth and it's perfect with vanilla ice cream.

Small strawberry shortcake
Jacqueline W.

I've been twice in one week. The strawberry shortcake is fantastic. I like the blend between the ice cream, crumbles, and Italian ice - great blend of texture and flavor. The flavor is interesting in each bite and on par with the descriptions. The small size looks mini, but it's truly enough. Increase size if you're up for overindulging. Price is a little high - small almost 7. The service is meh, both servers were nice but the first clearly distracted by his phone. I had to wait for him to finish whatever he was doing on his phone to place my order - genuinely thought about leaving. There is plenty of seating indoors and for nicer days there are shaded picnic tables on the side.

Maggie H.

I loved the Italian ice I got. I came in the afternoon, and it was fairly empty. The workers were chill and nonchalant and let us try flavors. I got a small and liked how I could put three flavors in the cup- wound up getting mango, orange smash, and piña colado. Would 100% come back here again. There's a bunch of parking spots in the lot.

Birthday cake
Joy M.

I really enjoyed it. I had the birthday cake. We went after having our Easter meal. The service was great she let me taste another combination with nerds it was good but I was not the biggest fan of it. My son had cookies and cream. He first recently tried Jeremiah's on spring break in Panama City. Cool vibe not busy at all because of Easter I assume, but very bright and different. Will definitely be back

a mural in a restaurant
Matthew D.

Stopped into Jeremiah's the other night. I absolutely love Italian ice and have been wanting to try it. The employees were super friendly and helpful with the menu. I ordered the watermelon and the Bahama breeze, the flavor were super refreshing and delicious. Can't wait to go back to try the other flavors and soft serve.

Strawberry Small Italian Ice and Small Vanilla Ice Cream
Mallori J.

I am so glad I found out about Jeremiah's Ice! They serve the best Italian ice and ice cream I have ever had! On my most recent visit, I ordered the strawberry Italian ice and vanilla soft serve ice cream. LORD HAVE MERCY! Where do I start? The Italian ice is soft, but not to the point where it melts and gets messy. It's also the perfect amount of sweetness. The soft serve is so creamy and delicious. Let's talk about the service: I was greeted by the manager (African American young lady with head wrap), who was extremely knowledgeable about the Italian ice and soft serve ice cream. She made comparisons between Jeremiah's Ice and other ice cream shop's ice cream/Italian ice. She also provided a sample so I could make a decision. Great customer service! Honestly, I am so glad that there is a Jeremiah's Ice in Decatur now! (:

Italian ice (cherry, sour green apple with Nerds)
Tank J.

We dropped into this place looking to just sample a couple Italian ices. We were so impressed that we ordered a tadpole-sized wild cherry, sour green apple and Nerds Italian ice. Will return the next time we're in the area! Very refreshing!

Blue razz, cherry and tropical flavors

See all

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Joy M.
4
115
144

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Was better than I thought tried different flavors with the fam would recommend will go back

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Tank J.
2
94
184

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Josh H.
145
25
10

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Butter & Cream

Butter & Cream

4.5
(497 reviews)
0.9 mi
$$

Love this little ice cream shop!…read more I've visited Butter & Cream before, but my latest visit was a favorite. After spending a sunny afternoon celebrating my besties birthday with her and a few of our girlfriends, we decided to keep the fun going with some ice cream. Never too old for a random sweet treat! Although we were already in the neighborhood, we lucked up on a day when everybody and their mama were outside, which meant limited parking. So we had to pay for parking on this visit, but ended up making it worthwhile by strolling around Decatur Square with our cones. I When we entered, there was one employee behind the counter and they were so kind. There were a few customers in front of us and some behind us in line, so apparently we weren't the only adults in the city who were craving a sweet treat. The store was so cute and covered in art and clocks created with ice cream scoops. We decided to taste a few flavors that were new to us and the employee was so patient with us. We all decided to go with the honeycomb flavor, and I added on a scoop of strawberry because I believe in treating myself. I was bummed that they didn't have sugar cones, but a waffle cone worked. My ice cream was SO good! And they were quite generous with the scoops. As I'm writing this out, I'm wanting a fresh pint of my own again. Such a great stop when you're craving something sweet!

Butter & Cream in downtown Decatur is typically my go to spot when I am in the area and craving ice…read morecream, so I was excited to try something new on this visit. I ordered the Cookie Monster with toffee cone bits on top. The texture of the ice cream was great, very smooth and creamy, which is exactly what you want. However, the flavor itself just did not come through. It almost tasted like a base without much depth. The only moments of real flavor were when I bit into the cookie pieces or the toffee bits, which were both enjoyable, but the ice cream on its own felt like it was missing something. It is a bit hard to describe because the consistency was there, but the taste simply did not match. That said, I am not writing Butter & Cream off at all. I have had other flavors here that were absolutely delicious, which is why I am willing to give this one another try. Overall, still one of my preferred ice cream spots in Decatur. I am just hoping for a little more flavor the next time I order the Cookie Monster.

Photos
Dairy-Free Vanilla
Dairy-Free Vanilla
Voices of Children (bottom - 100% of proceeds went to Ukraine-based Voices of Children) & Honeycomb Forest (top) @tiffhuangry
Voices of Children (bottom - 100% of proceeds went to Ukraine-based Voices of Children) & Honeycomb Forest (top) @tiffhuangry
Single scoop cup: og goodness

See all

Single scoop cup: og goodness
Paolino

Paolino

4.4
(232 reviews)
1.9 mi
$$

The vibe is awesome , Paul one of the owners greeted us and we have a nice conversation... even in…read moreSpanish :) Seated in the bar, Theresa our bartender was pretty cool and informative about the food and how everything was handmade on site . The marinate sauce and bolognese sauce was great . The complete experience was better than expected. Totally recommended

My husband and I made reservations at Paolino. It was our first time here, so we were excited to…read moretry it out. When we arrived, there was a short wait while they cleared off some tables. Since it was a nice day outside, we decided to dine al fresco. Once we were seated, we encountered another wait, but this time it was because they hadn't assigned a server to our table. We had to get someone's attention because we noticed other people seated after us were being waited on. We ended up with Sienna as our server. She started us off with complimentary bread. We decided to order our cocktails, appetizers, and entrees since we had been waiting. I had the sangria, and my husband had the limoncello. We enjoyed both cocktails. For appetizers, we had calamari and cheese sticks, and the cheese sticks were definitely our favorite--they had a unique twist. For entrees, we ordered the lamb ragu and the chef's special, which was seafood ravioli. To end the night, we had the brownie sundae with salted caramel gelato. We thoroughly enjoyed our food and drinks. Although the service was a bit slow at first, Sienna was attentive. We look forward to visiting Paolino again in the future.

Photos
Paolino
Lamb Ragu
Lamb Ragu
Fresh hot bread

See all

Fresh hot bread
Rebel Teahouse

Rebel Teahouse

4.6
(120 reviews)
0.9 mi
$$

I hate almost nothing more than driving somewhere, finally arriving, and then having to hunt for…read moreparking and pay for it at a place I'm already spending money. Rebel Tea House and the shops on the block got it right with the free two-hour parking deck, which honestly was the first thing that drew me in. The space itself is boutique, quaint, clean, and smells amazing, with beautiful Chinese-inspired decor. I'm no stranger to bubble tea or fruit teas, but it was my first time here and I wanted to try something different. The woman at the register was incredibly helpful. After I mentioned that I don't like drinks that are overly sweet, she explained the sweetness levels and recommended a tea that ended up being perfect. I stayed for a couple of hours working on my computer and watched the place gradually fill up during the lunch rush. I loved the mix of people coming through -- parents with babies and strollers, people working quietly on laptops, friends playing Uno and Connect Four, and locals just stopping in for their usual tea. It felt welcoming. Also worth mentioning, the bathroom was spotless and fully stocked, which always says a lot to me about a business. Overall, it was just a really pleasant experience from start to finish, and I'll definitely be back.

My family loves Rebel Teahouse! The drinks are tasty and just the right texture. I had never had…read moretaro before and it was fun to try it! The flavors aren't so intense as to feel like you're drinking pure [insert ingredient] concentrate, but strong enough to taste everything. The interior is really nice, with lanterns, fairy lights, flowers painted on the wall, a mural on the counter, artificial flowers hanging beautifully in the seating area and in the bathroom (bathroom not pictured). The seating is comfortable and there is good lighting. There are board games you can play and merchandise you can buy, as well. The employees are helpful and friendly. They were able to help me with nutrition information, telling me how much of each sugary ingredient so I could figure out how much insulin I needed. The owner also donates some of their profits and stuffed animals to the charity my sibling receives support from. I had a great experience from ordering to leaving, and I will be back

Photos
Cozy, colorful, and full of good energy
Cozy, colorful, and full of good energy
Thai Milk Tea
Thai Milk Tea
Dragon  fruit Jasmine tea

See all

Dragon fruit Jasmine tea

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - desserts - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...