If I could eat this custard everyday, I would. The base custards are vanilla and chocolate, but there are so many options for toppings. Concrete means the toppings are evenly mixed in. Jackhammer means there's a "hollow" center that is filled with toppings of your choice. I love adding hot fudge to my center. There's a drive thru too if you would like to take it to go. Service has always been super friendly. read more

We were visiting family in Atlanta and noticed a new ice cream store nearby! We decided to try out Andy's! I'm somewhat of an ice cream custard aficionado growing up in Youngstown, Ohio with Handel's custard. It's one of the best in the Country! I got the vanilla custard and my partner got the chocolate. The ice cream was rich and creamy - everything you'd expect from a good custard! Both the vanilla and the chocolate were delicious!! read more

See all

No matter how many times I go to Andy's not what state I'm in, I always go in REALLY wanting to like it and come out disappointed. It's such a cute ice cream shop but the treats are never excellent. This time, we parked and ate on their benches outside. I chose Andy's as the special treat to celebrate my daughter's last day of camp and final performance. She had a shake and was happy about it. My husband ordered a banana spilt and enjoyed it, minus it not having any syrup on top. I ordered the shake that comes with espresso, but the espresso flavor was lacking. When I asked about it, they offered to remake it. My friend suggested they just give me a side of the espresso to add to my cup, to cut down on their work. The staff agreed to that but then when providing it, noted they needed to charge me for it. I paid without complaint but I really should've just allowed them to remake it as that would've been free. And here's the kicker: it wasn't any more flavorful after adding what they provided. Unfortunately, my take ways are: (1) I really should stop trying with Andy's; (2) I shouldn't try to save the staff time and energy when it comes to improving my experience. My husband thought his banana split was a 5-star experience despite not having all the ingredients he wanted. He, however, had the following critiques: we didn't get napkins, there are no tables, and the production is a little slow. He pointed out a customer who opted to leave after seeing the pace was a bit slow. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I made my first visit to Andy's after a late dinner and was craving something sweet. I got a triple chocolate concrete. I think the idea was better than how it tasted. It tasted like melted ice cream, kinda soupy. Plenty of parking around the shop. There's a few benches you can sit on. Service was quick read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - BootDaddy Concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

How did I go so long without discovering the magic of frozen custard? A few months ago, I made my first visit to Andy's and ordered a concrete with Oreos and pecans--and after just one bite, I was completely hooked. The custard is rich, creamy, and insanely delicious. The portions are generous, so my partner and I usually split a small concrete, which is still plenty to satisfy our sweet tooth. We've had fun trying different mix-ins and recently tried a Jackhammer--basically a concrete with a core of gooey hot fudge. I prefer the concrete because the fudge melted the ice cream and was a little too sweet for me, but my partner is team Jackhammer. On top of the treats, the staff is always friendly, and service is impressively quick. Andy's has definitely become a go-to dessert stop for us! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - ! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

At first glance, I thought this was an auto store lol. After going on a long walk, I wanted something cool. I looked up ice cream places in the area and Andy's was close by, and I realized what it actually was. Andy's has a drive thru and some parking around the building, but it can be tricky to get into because it's on the corner of a busy intersection. However, it's worth the effort. There's a large menu on the wall and the employees are nice. I got a small BootDaddy concrete, which has vanilla custard, Oreos, caramel and hot fudge. It was still huge, but it was delicious. Custard is thicker and creamier than ice cream, so it's very decadent! I would love to go back with friends and family to try other items. Definitely recommend! read more

I've been hearing great things about this place but I'm never in Toco Hills. The moment I did, I swerved my car so quick to enter their drive thru line to order a sweet treat. Not going to lie but I was a bit overwhelmed plus saw the calorie count on what I actually wanted so I just opted for a vanilla cone. I was shocked when asked how many scoops I wanted so I just said one - I guess this was a kids cone? It was around $3, which I thought was quite pricey for a scoop of frozen custard but the flavor on that was so good. It was rich and creamy and delicious with the perfect amount of sweetness. Will definitely be going back next time to try more of their sweet treats. read more

Loved this spot! The service here was so friendly and helpful! They have so many options that idek what I ordered. We got the small custard with the strawberries and the strawberries were so fresh and a great tart addition to the sweet custard. They also have a drive thru and lots of seating. I definitely will be back to try their other options. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Hit the spot! Plenty of parking, shade from the heat, benches under the trees as well, clean place, open space , sundaes were delicious, service was quick. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Straw-ana sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Andy's so good that I had this place 3 times in a week! When we were driving past this place, it looked so intriguing that we decided to give it a try and I'm so glad that we did! We had the cream custard, bootlegger, and butter pecan. I liked how there was not a wait and it's so quick to order our food and we get what we ordered within minutes! They were all so yummy my personal favorite is butter pecan because it's not as sweet as the other options! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Bootlegger - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The wait was totally worth it--I really liked what I got! I made my own "Concrete" and added cheesecake and strawberries. The cheesecake came in big chunks too!! Definitely a treat. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Custom Concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I'm not in Atlanta anymore but I am literally thinking of this frozen custard that I had twice while visiting. This is delicious custard! The waffle cone was oddly salty but when paired with a cake cone, both the chocolate and vanilla were amazing! It would be cool if they sold their pints as scoops but I am sure there's a reason for them not doing it. Truly a highlight of my eating experience in Atlanta. read more

What's not to like? Think of your favorite superlative and attach it to this business. First of all, if you don't like frozen custard, something is wrong with you. This is good frozen custard. Smooth. Creamy. Delicious. Combined with a veritable potpourri of toppings, and you'll go home happy. I had something with caramel and pretzels. It was immediately addictive. And the small size was enough for me. But you should go nuts. Get the large! There's plenty of parking, and plenty of seating around the property. The whole place was clean and well maintained. And staff was only too happy to make me happy. And I'm happy about that. I'll happily go back. Holler if you're coming with. read more

Super cheap food, friendly staff, and nice location. Never a bad experience try the tea!

I went here 2/15/2024 first time ever. I was on my phone on my lunch break and this place popped up on my feed on ig. After I got home from work and got showered I went to this location. I got the biscoff pint mixed with custard delicious! I initially went inside to the counter where the employee gave me 2 samples of the custard chocolate and vanilla. I got home and opened this up and proceeded to eat it. I intended on saving half for later. My mind told me to put it in the fridge but my hand wouldn't let me put the spoon down. Next time I'm going to try the biscoff mixed with cookie butter option they call it concrete. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Custard mixed with biscoff cookies! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I normally don't go with vanilla as my choice of ice cream (or in this case frozen custard), but this has to be the only exception. A double scoop of vanilla never fails me here. There is almost always a line here as well - both for cars and for people walking up -which goes to show how good this place is. Let's not get started on that hot fudge brownie sundae. It is a high quality brownie which feels pretty fresh compared to buster's (who also does a great job) and the combo of hot fudge on cold ice cream. A true beauty. If you're in the area, its worth a visit read more

The custard was really good and the staff was very friendly. We'll be going back. Go for the Ozark Turtle sundae

Finally, my daughters and I was able to stop and try this new spot on Druid Hills. The place hasn't been open that long but it is very open and airy. We went through the Drive-thru which was very convenient. I got the Peach Concrete and the girls got Butter Pecan which they both altered to some degree and the cashier was very accommodating. Service was fast and good. Let me tell you, once I started eating it I did not stop until it was finished! It was soooo good and refreshing! When you get a chance stop by and treat yourself. Heck treat the whole family! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Peach Concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

prices are on the higher end, but serving sizes are definitely huge! their custard is very creamy with a wide range of toppings you can choose from. they also have a few flavor combinations that pair really well together. I got the nutty waffle (waffle pieces, melty choc chips, and crushed nuts) and it was absolutely amazing. workers bring out orders fairly quickly and I love the whole retro design of the place. lots of benches to sit at! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Every time we've passed by this place since opening it's been completely mobbed and we haven't felt like waiting, but finally on a rainy weeknight with no one there we were able to try Andy's for the first time. I had the Boot Daddy Concrete which is like a DQ blizzard or a McDonald's McFlurry. The top was a bit melted perhaps due to the hot fudge and even the small size was large, and a bit too much sweet for me. In hindsight I should have just gotten custard (which I liked a lot) and one or two toppings. My bf had a concrete (can't remember the name, it isn't on the online menu) that had peanuts and pieces of their house made waffle cone. We both really liked the waffle pieces so that's promising for next time. We live in the area so I'm sure we will be back! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Boot Daddy Concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

New location at Toco Hills. Perfect health score, private parking lot with benches outside for enjoying the treats. Having the app opens up rewards after several purchases and birthday surprises. Service was quick and associates were friendly. read more

After dinner, we went to Andy's Frozen Custard! I love custard more than ice cream! We had Nutty Waffle Crunch Concrete & BootDaddy Concrete. Yummy! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - We had Nutty Waffle Crunch Concrete and BootDaddy Concrete. Yummy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Great service and amazing fruit friendly treat. Great atmosphere to enjoy your treat.

Andy's Soup Custard?!? Wow. I know this place is new but ya gotta make sure it's not melted within moments after receiving it. I've had other Andy's and this was a first. Here's pix of my kiddos after 5min tops. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Soup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Solid custard place. The workers were really friendly and welcoming. I got the triple chocolate concrete that tasted like Hershey's chocolate syrup which isn't my jam. However, even though the flavor wasn't there for me, the texture was great! Not icy at all, very smooth and creamy. The small was also still a large amount of custard. My mom got the strawberry shortcake one that she loved and the vanilla custard was definitely better tasting than the chocolate. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Triple chocolate concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Took my mom to try this place yesterday. I drove 23 miles after seeing them on Atlanta Eats. This is good quality custard. Fast service too. Don't walk away from the window after you pay. Your order will be ready in under 2 minutes! They also have doggie cups. read more

I wish they had the strawberry shortcake and the Oi gooey butter cake sundaes all the time. I would certainly eat here a lot more. They are so good read more

My first trip to Andy's was a few weeks after it first opened. The place was pretty hoppin' and I could tell there were some growing pains, so managed my patience accordingly, knowing there would be a bit of a wait. The cashier at the time was a quiet worker who didn't seem too engaged, so it was a bit difficult to complete my order over the counter, but I managed. As a note for the management, it might be better to put "louder" folks up front during busy hours, because the open room concept where the walk up window is can get pretty noisy with a lot of people (and dogs) in there and it can be a bit difficult for folks who are hard of hearing to order. I don't know if this is what led to this, but the sizes of mine and my boyfriend's orders were switched. On another note, this place seems to be very dog friendly! There's a picture attached but I saw lots of well-behaved pups while I was there. If you're someone who is afraid of dogs, I would maybe avoid going up to the walk up on busy nights where the weather is great. There is also a drive-thru option! For my first time I got a plain vanilla custard cone to get a sense of the custard by itself. It was VERY good and definitely elevated from my usual QT soft serve cone. My second trip to Andy's happened earlier this week and I can say it went much better. There was a new worker at the front and her attitude was great and I definitely got service with a smile this time. I opted for a vanilla custard sundae with waffle cone pieces, hot fudge and strawberry topping. As someone said in a previous review, the strawberry topping is definitely stored in a syrup of some sort, so if you don't love overly sweet strawberry topping or don't like fruit syrup, maybe opt out. Besides that, I have really enjoyed my visits to Andy's and I think it is a must go spot for folks looking for some late night ice cream. There is plenty of parking and bench seating around, and it's a great place to chill out for a few minutes and people watch. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Definitely a dog friendly place! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Staff was friendly and the service was fast at the location on N Druid Hills Road in Toco Hills. This was my first time. There is a drive thru, but we parked and walked up to the counter. I picked the healthiest thing I could find, the straw-Ana sundae and enjoyed it immensely. My husband got a chocolate shake. They are open to 11 pm on most days, and until 11:30 pm on Fridays and Saturdays, so great for a late night treat! read more

This place is delicious! They are running some grand opening specials. Today was $2 sundaes. The custard is sooo good! Very nice employees. They take time to explain the new menu. It was crowded due to the grand opening, so I opted to drive thru which had no wait at all, then I parked to look around. It's very clean, open air location. I 100% recommend! Yummy! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - A grand opening special $2 caramel sundae, with almonds and coconut. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The service is good. We've only used the drive-thru. The quality of the frozen custard is wonderful as one should expect. The amount of pecans, fudge, and toppings in general has been insufficient every single time we've been to this location. I would recommend Andy's,, maybe go to another location because this place is a little cheap with their toppings - which make a difference. read more

First timer. I ordered the boot daddy custard which was so great. I love the look of the place. The garage doors on the place were a nice touch. I plan to go back and try the other flavors. read more

Custard vs gelato vs ice cream, semantics maybe, but arguably custard is the best. Why you ask, maybe it's the egg yolk, maybe it's just personal feelings. Either way the frozen custard is coming in hot! Ok maybe cold... So I've been lucky enough to try the double double malt and the root beer float. What a whimsical experience, the flavors dance on your tongue, and maybe if you buy into the custard is better than the rest then you'll agree. I think the double double malt flavor was a great vanilla flavor and the float had a great chocolate taste. Idk what it is. But come here, I'll be back for sure. Custard man to the rescue! It'll save you from a bad day. read more

We decided to stop here on a Sunday afternoon while coming from the park and I must say that it was a great way to top off a Sunday (no pun ) I ordered the BootDaddy concrete. It was a hard decision because they have so many great sounding and looking(from the pictures) items on the menu. It didn't disappoint! It was great! If you've never had custard, it's just like ice cream but prepared a little differently, but if no one told you it was custard you would think that you were eating ice cream. The wife had the Chocolate Sunday with pecans & from my big spoonful that I had of hers, it was delightful! Go check out one of their locations when you get a chance. You will not be disappointed. Oh yeah.. it's crowded because who don't like custard or ice cream on a nice sunny day? But the line moves fast and your treat comes out to you pretty quick. I'll be back! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - BootDaddy Concrete. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I love all the different flavors they have. Definitely something for everyone in the fam. There indoor/outdoor seating if you have time to pull up and sit outside. They also have a drive through. Service is always nice and quick. Nice little vibe to take the kids for a frozen treat on a hot day. The reason for 4 stars is because the custard does melt pretty quick. read more

LOVED my first visit to Andy's. Frozen custard invokes a lot of nostalgia for me, because my family and I used to go to get frozen custard weekly from another establishment that has since closed. I was beyond excited to see Andy's open nearby. I got the butter pecan concrete and it was extremely fresh and so delicious. I went through the drive thru, which was a bit confusing to navigate. They had a menu before the window, but no speaker to communicate with staff and order or anyone standing outside, so you had to order at the window. That seemed to slow the process down and I really hope they work out the kinks with the drive thru soon. Because this location is off of Clairmont and North Druid Hills, turning in and out can be challenging, but otherwise, Andy's seems to be a great addition to the Toco Hills area read more

Always exceptional customer service and great taste!! This is my go-to dessert place!! I always get the James Brownie Jackhammer and add pecans. No, I don't want to try anything else because This is My Jam Andy's stays open late. So if you get a hankering for a sweet snack late at night, check them out! read more

Absolutely delicious frozen custard!!! I got the straw-Ana sundae and truly loved it. My only complaint is that their strawberries aren't fresh and are likely stored in a sugar solution so they just taste overly sweet. Besides that, I really enjoyed my order. I'm also excited about this new location since they're open until at least 11pm year-round. So I'm looking forward to coming back here again with friends for late night dessert cravings :)) read more

I tried this location this week after previously having been to another and everything tasted just as good. I had a milkshake which was delicious. My dog got her pup cup. The drive thru moved quickly. Glad to have this in a new neighborhood. read more

Dangerous though. Delicious but very decadent. Kids loved it. Fun atmosphere. Good service. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Andy's frozen custard. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia