I like my sandwiches HOT as in the opposite of cold, i.e. not spicy. Mike's has a grill and half their menu is cheesesteaks including six different chicken cheesesteaks. I ordered a #17 which is their famous Philly with grilled onions and peppers. The sandwich tasted excellent. The perfect combination of ingredients cooked thoroughly with melted cheese. Super delicious! Service here was fast and my order was correct. If you don't want fountain soft drinks they offer bottled soft drinks, Pure Leaf tea, sports drinks and water. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - The Jersey Mike's Famous Philly - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I went to retrieve my birthday sub. The workers said that was no longer a thing after explaining that I received the email that morning. They told me to put in my phone number, and I did have the points to redeem my free sub. They didn't give me a hard time making my veggie sandwich on the grill as I had an issue last Sunday at a different location. They seemed to be more excited that it was my birthday than I was, which made my day. My sandwich was AMAZING. Just like I like it. I'm glad that I didn't let the experience earlier in the week deter me from going back again because I love this place. Being vegan/sometimes vegetarian is hard to find good food. Plus they made my birthday even more special with their customer service. Thank you. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Front of the store - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

It has been a while since I've had Jersey Mike's and it was delicious. I ordered the club, and it had all the right fixings and the veggies are fresh. They have a wide variety of hot and cold subs. The deli meat is sliced at the counter when they prep the sandwiches. The staff worked efficiently to manage the long line of customers. They also have great cream soda and root beer! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Club Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

These guys are artists. I drive 35 miles one way just to get a sub. I have been to several jersey mikes but the one in greenfield makes the best subs. read more

See all

They always do a great job here. The sandwiches are quality, they make them properly according to their descriptions, and they move at a very reasonable pace. Best jersey mikes in the area for sure. They do justice to the brand. read more

What's not to love about Jersey Mike's. Sandwiches and ingredients are fresh. Mikes way is the only way. Staff is friendly at this location. It's a great sub shop! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love Jersey Mike's Subs and loathe the fact that there aren't more locations, so ever since I realized there was one in this shopping plaza near Castleton Square Mall, I make it point to stop in a grab a sub (or two) when I'm in the area! I dropped in on Sunday and apparently, I wasn't the only person craving one of their beautifully-crafted sandwiches. There was a family of four and another lady ahead of me, but I was greeted right away and able to let the staff member know what I wanted. I ordered the BLT, which isn't listed on their menu, and the Italian. I like to get my BLT without the T and add mayo and a hearty smear of pepper relish. If you haven't tried their pepper relish, please do. It's got a nice kick! I got my Italian "Mike's Way" minus the tomato and added mayo and banana peppers. I had the BLT during the ride home and the Italian the next day! They were both so yummy! The staff was working hard to provide quick service, which resulted in a bit of chaos. They started on the order of the lady in front of me, but forgot to toast her sub, so then they started building my subs. After preparing one of mine, hers came out of the toaster. I assumed that they would finish hers and allow her to pay, but then things got confusing. They asked what I wanted and then asked her what she wanted....began working on hers, called me over to pay and finished her sub. Being that I was called away to pay, I was hoping they got my order right. I didn't see them complete it, but it was correct. read more

They literally always close 15-20 minutes early. Like it's a Saturday, how are you going to lock your doors at 8:40pm??? Do better.

Yep, this is one of my favorite sandwich places! The employees were very friendly here, too. I had previously only ever ordered the #7 Turkey and provolone sub Mike's way (so good!!!) but recently branched out and tried the big kahuna cheesesteak, which is also delicious. I tried the Buffalo chicken cheesesteak which, to be honest, I personally wouldn't get again just because it was very messy. Butttttt I still plan to keep returning for the first two and hopefully to try all the others as well! Xoxo, Is this thing on? read more

Horrible! They laughed at me because I had the audacity to try to order 1 hour and 20 minutes before closing!! Both high as kits and the open sign off. I hope you like a lot of spit in your sandwich read more

The staff here is so awesome! Always greeted with a smile and they seem to actually care how my day is going. The meat is sliced fresh and the sandwiches are made right in front of you. Also, don't forget to get it "Mike's Way" with oregano, vinegar, oil - it makes the sandwich 10x better! Such an upgrade from a standard Jimmy John's! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Turkey Turkey Breast And Provolone on wheat - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This Jersey Mike's is always fast and efficient. The store is clean and the employees are pleasant. I really like their club sandwich and the Big Kahuna cheesesteak. The nice thing about their deli meat sandwiches is you can get the meat sliced to the thinness or thickness you like. I always get my sub "Mikes Way". That includes onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices, read more

I recently had the craving for a Turkey sandwich. I hate subway and Indy apparently doesn't have a ton of sandwich shops. I saw the name as I was driving down 82nd and swung by. Man, this is pretty great sub! I ordered they Turkey with provolone on white. Added LTO, Mayo, banana peppers, and vinegar. I am surprised to be so impressed with a sandwich but I am. Love this Turkey sandwich. read more

I haven't had Jersey Mike's in YEARS!!! Decided to give it a try. Why didn't you all tell me how delicious it was??? I ordered the Big Kahuna and it was the best sandwich I've ever had at a sub shop. The bread was just right, cheese was was super melty, peppers taste fresh. Everything about that sandwich was a 10/10. Staff was great also. Good job!!! read more

Best Jersey Mike's in Indianapolis! Always pleasant staff and great subs! I love Jersey mikes subs!!!!!!!!!! read more

I ordered the steak Philly sub. Service was fast and friendly. The meat was cooked and seasoned well. Overall a good sub, my only hang up was that there was more bread than meat which is a bit frustrating for a $10 sub. read more

I just love these subs. I think they are the best! My favorite is the Italian sub with everything on it.

Jersey Mike's always comes through in the clutch for a quick lunch. My go to is the Original Italian made Mike's way (vinegar & oil, oregano, salt & pepper, and tomatoes) add bacon. The size of the sandwich is great for the price. read more

My favorite sub place on the northside. What makes the sandwiches delicious is they cut the meat and the cheese fresh for each sandwich. I like the #7 (turkey & provolone). The #13 Italian is also good. Be sure to get it Mike's way which comes with shredded lettuce, tomato, onion, vinegar, oil, salt, & pepper. The combination of the freshly cut meat and cheese with the Mike's way toppings is splendid. What makes this location even better is how friendly and skilled the staff is. They do a great job making the sandwiches and even how they bag them is neat to watch. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Tried a new place today for lunch! Got the regular turkey and provolone sandwich on white bread with extra mayo and lettuce. It was really tasty and I loved that they didn't hold back on filling the sandwich. It was substantial and I appreciated that. Staff was great and fast. I'll definitely stop in here again for a tasty lunch! Next time, I'll order my sandwich 'Mike's Way' which includes onion, red wine vinegar, oregano, salt, and pepper. MMmmmmmmmm read more

LOVE THIS PLACE turkey is my fav! The recently remodeled. Store looks brand new! They have hot and cold subs to choose from Toppings are lettuce onion vinegar oil oregano tomato banana peppers mayo pickles and they have this sauce call hot pepper relish. It is the best part, if it's your first time there ask for it on the side. It's amazing. Sign up for their rewards program and you get points and potentially you can get free subs! Who doesn't dig free food!!? read more

Being from New Jersey I can say that the number nine is very authentic! Mike's way is definitely the way to go. I feel the sandwiches are a little overpriced but the cost of food hasn't paced with the money that we make. I love jersey mikes !! read more

Not a bad sub shop. The bread is fresh, they slice the meat and cheese when you order. Hot and cold subs. The Italian was delicious, had it served "Mike's Way" Fast and WAY better than Subway. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Double point Monday's are always my favorite day to pop in for lunch! Not just for the double points tho. Every Monday the same three guys (Mike, Mike, and Jake) are working at the 82nd St. location and they are always fast and courteous!! They make every new visit just as good as the last!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This specific location employees customer service 10/10. The food as well 10/10. Definitely coming back! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The worst. I ordered my sub online for delivery. Nobody showed up for 45 minutes. I called and was told that they didn't get my order. I called back to tell them that I was charged. The manager said "ok man. I don't know how to do it. I'll ask". He didn't ask for my name, never called me back. So I got food somewhere else. About 45 minutes later some guy shows up at my door and hands me a crumpled brown bag. My sub sucked. The club supreme was only bread, meat cheese. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - I ordered this, I got this - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Was looking forward to jersey mikes. Left the gym early to go as they close at 9 pm. Got there 20 minutes before 9 and the doors were locked and they wouldn't let us in. I didn't know that closing at 9 pm meant closed at 8:40 pm. Disappointed. read more

Customer service was good. Everyone was welcoming and friendly and helpful. I got the Philly cheesesteak. It was just ok to me. Temperature was good. I probably won't be back unless it's free again. read more

Quality service. Quality product. Tasty sandwich! Very fresh. Probably the best sub shop I have found in Indy for the price. They even let me use a coupon I brought up on my phone although the coupon said I had to print it out. read more

I am gluten free and they wiped down the whole counter and the deli meat slicer to make sure it was nice and clean and didn't cross contaminate! this is the first place i have gone to that has done this for me. great job! read more

your order to Jersey Mikes will be ready for pickup at 2:17pm. 5025 E. 82nd Street Indianapolis IN 46250Questions? Call us: 317-595-9993---- We like SuperSubby's when visiting out of town; Our friends say, "you don't know good subs til you had Jersey Mikes!!!" Wow how awful. Details Quantity Price $ 7.50 #13 The Original Italian Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Wheat, Red Wine Vinegar, Olive Oil Blend, Oregano, Salt, Mayo 7.5 Subtotal: $7.50 Tax: 0.68 Total: $8.18 Best described as a big hearty heavy sub, full of meat which should be the star of the sub, however, if you star is slapped between dry dull chunks of bread, the star seems to diminish its shine greatly. "You don't ever want another sub from Jersey Mikes?" ........."No, that's okay, it wasn't good for lunch" ---------------Ouch turning down free food? JerseyMikes disappoints. if ever in Ohio SUPERSUBBY's read more

5 star for the food. I had the # 4 cold Mike's way extra wet and it was awesome. Wifey had the hot chicken phillie w/ shrooms and very good. We've been going to Jersey Mike's southeast coast locations for over 20 years and like their food. I've highly recommended this location to my friends and coworkers as it's the only one near Carmel. So...why the 2 star rating? Because management doesn't appear to care one whit about restrooms (yes plural) cleanliness. Massive FAIL I frequent this store but am giving serious consideration to never returning - guess I should check out restrooms before I go through the line. Do the prep and storage areas suck this badly as well? I hope not. Do staff get trained on sanitation best practices? That thought certainly gives me pause. I could probably get the standard canned response, "well, we were swamped" - but it was 2:00p on a Sunday with 5 'kids' at the counter - yeah the Colts were playing (Detroit) but it wasn't busy and they didn't seem to care about the game. Either too many 2nd lieutenants and no grunts or the cat's away. Frankly there are no excuses for this - only reasons - and I'm still peeved 20 hours later. [insert grimace icon here] read more

The manager is AMAZING! He is always engaging to every customer and you can tell his employees are genuinely happy. Even when he isn't there; everyone is so polite and seems to be in such a great mood. The food is delicious and is always made quickly too. Model location for ANY customer facing place of business. read more

The service here is super fast! They are always wells staffed and the guys who work there are super friendly. Everything is fresh and tastes wonderful. Only once have I had an incorrect order. Otherwise they get it right! read more

Great subs. Pretty fast. I like the mini Italian. It's not that mini. You can pick and choose what you but I always have it "Mike's way."

The best subs in Indy! A true sandwich from the east coast! The sandwiches comes in 3 sizes but I would recommend the giant! It can easily be split between two people! The sandwich is huge! It's a little pricey but totally worth it! They have wraps, cold and hot sandwiches and little sides. My favorite is #13 the original Italian. You must get it the Mike's way to truly have an authentic east coast sub! It is the perfect place to go to get a healthy and quick meal! Make sure to sign up for their rewards program to collect points! This place is one of Indiana best kept secrets for sure! I hope it gets more popularity with the more frequent advertisements on tv! read more

I lovee me some Jersey Mike's! I love how they're different from any other sub shop. They have those few, key ingredients and it makes every sub perfect! The guy that took our order was amazing! He was nice, and extremely patient! read more

Food was sooo good! I had the giant steak and cheese sub with some sweet juicy banana peppers. Good people treated, first time going here but I will go back again!!! read more

Jersey Mikes ranks #1 in cold sandwiches and firmly sits at #3, behind firehouse and penn station when rating quality/price of quick sandwich spots. This is the second time I've been to one in Indiana, but taste is consistent across states. I grabbed a roast beef + provalone/Mike's way. I'm glad they keep the toppings to a minimum and font drown everything in sauce. I tried to utilize my birthday reward, but had some issues. Even though the scanner was malfunctioning, they still honored my code, which was great. I'll print it out when I come back next year :D read more

My first Jersey Mike's was out by Cherry Hill, NJ. Lots in New Jersey. I went into this one and have 5 starred other Jersey Mike's. This one gets 2 stars for not one single salt packet in the place. I asked for salt packets for my roast beef and they don't have any and the gal begrudgingly gave me their salt shaker behind the counter to use and give back. They don't welcome you like other Mike's. They placed my wrapped sub on spilled drink on the stainless steel counter. They just let you come in and the employees talk among each other and expect you to assert your order and then the gal appeared put-off to enter my order. I'm really sorry, I apologize for bothering these employees. My apologies. (Ask them about the salt to verify, like I'm a liar.) read more