We were considering a piece for almost a week, had been in 3 times or more to see it with price…read moreclearly attached to the item and another on paperwork, when in to purchase, owner realizes another price on the back of papers, extremely higher than what we were watching, tells us he can't sell it for price we saw, then threatens to just keep it and sell for higher price, we had take it for $500 more than what we saw and last kick, we also have to pay high credit card fees! another $167! never going back! I say Karma is coming

STAY AWAY!!!! Terrible store management, very unprofessional. The two gentlemen running the store…read morehad an attitude and everything is 3x the price of the actual items value. Better off shopping on Ebay and Amazon, only reason I'd give one star is they had cool items For a garage sale. Don't bother trying to negotiate, they will just kick you out and cuss you out.

Absolutely the best people to deal with. Sean is super honest and fair with his merchandise. I've…read moreprobably purchased 12 or so firearms from him in the last two years and I usually have Guns I order online shipped to him for a background check. I will buy from him as long as it's there. Can't say enough good things about this place. Highly recommended!!!!!!

From the owner: Specializing in: - Guns & Gunsmiths…read more- Pawnbrokers - Check Cashing Service

We are on vacation in Key West. I noticed my diamond wedding ring had a broken prong. I took it…read morehere for repair. This is a very small shop, but the owner has some fabulous jewelry in here for sale and he really knows what he's doing. He recommended that I replace the entire head that holds the diamond, rather than just try to repair the one prong. He showed me how the prongs had been repaired multiple times and were not strong enough to hold a 3 carat diamond safely. So we went ahead and replaced the whole head and I am so glad that I took his advice. The new head is much stronger and more substantive than the old head and I feel like my Diamond is really safe now. He did a nice nice job. It looks great.

Very talented shop. Can make custom jewelry. Great communication too. The prices are reasonable…read more The are able to get the job done timely as well

I love the service here. Kelby is always so nice. They have the best for your money. You should…read moredefinitely check it out.

From the owner: Pawn Shop Salesread more

Best pawn shop experience I have ever had. The owner is great, honest and fair. I highly recommend…read moreseeing him if you have anything of value, jewelry or antiques. I'll be back to purchase from him next time.

I highly recommend Keys Pawn for the purchase of your next high end watch or unique time piece. The…read moreexperience was great and Iook forward to my next purchase with them. Melvyn over delivered in knowledge, service and value. This is my go to place going forward. I received two beautiful watches at very fair prices. Check them out,

My husband came in to buy a guitar while we were on vacation. The owner Jim was a super nice guy…read more They talked for awhile and looked over the selection. My husband found a basic Jasmine acoustic. It suited what he needed. He quoted $150 and preferred cash. He wouldn't budge on the price. Online, brand new, they were going for that or a little less. So there was no deal. A little overpriced really for a pawn shop, but supply and demand.. Ya know. We get it. And better to have spent money in a small business than a big corporation. He couldn't find the case.. Or even any picks, but my husband left happy that he had something to noodle with, so there are no complaints. The shop itself is a bit disheveled. Nothing is price marked. And the couple things I asked price on,I believed to be overpriced. But again, supply and demand. You're in a tourist spot on a small island.. so I guess it is what it is. He has a large selection of tools and building equipment. Fishing poles. Knickknacks. And what nots. Certainly worth stopping in, if not to just say hi to the guy and listen to his stories.

DO NOT GOT HERE. HES ALREADY BEEN RAN OUT OF HIS FIRST LOCATION FOR SHADY BUSINESS…read more This man literally stole my chain, lied about losing it, and gave me pennies on the dollar for it, and then threatened me with violence when I brought up the fact I was cheated out of my dead brother's gold chain. The old owner even told me I should call the cops because he doesn't actually have his pawn license or at least did not at that time. This was 2024 when it happened. Nobody go here! you will get robbed. Me and my family have lived in Marathon for 10+ years and I have never seen such an egregious theft that was so public and left completely unresolved. Avoid them at all costs, trust me. I was very naïve and young at the time, not that I'm much older/wiser now, but boy did he take advantage of me. I pawned a $3000 chain for $600 and came back with the $600 in cash not 4 days later to pick up my chain. He gave me the run around for nearly a week, Claiming he was out of town. Turns out he didn't have it! He claimed he lost the key to his safety deposit box that he put it in, and he needed his business partner's key to open it. His business partner apparently took two months to come to town and in the meantime, he trusted me with a fake Rolex watch to buy time and prevent me from going to the police. At the end of it all he came to my work while I was serving tables and said that he doesn't know what happened to the chain, but that he could help my father Ray, win his run for city Council if I just let it go and took the $1400 he was offering me in its place. Lucky for him. I was too stupid at that time in my life to look at the price and value of gold on the stock market. It was a 70gram, 18 karat solid gold, Cuban Link chain that was worth over $3,500. Not to mention that it belonged to my late brother who was a marine and died in an oil rig after returning from 2 tours in Afghanistan, which was explained to the Mr. "Jimmy Mac". The only reason I never called the cops was because I took the money in order to pay my rent, being that I was in a pinch at the moment. So there wasn't really much I could do. When I brought it to his attention that I felt mislead and lied to for monetary gain, he then threatened to come to my job and even my parents house bearing arms. Not that I was afraid, but I let this bully win because I don't want the drama in my life at that time. Now I am done being silent about this matter. DO NOT become his next victim. THERE ARE OTHER PAWN SHOPS AND YOU DO NOT NEED THE MONEY THAT BAD. TRUST ME!!!

They have a little bit of everything. Employees are friendly. Southern Hospitality at its best.read more

This place always has a good stock of Ammo. They have unique guns and also do great layaway.read more

I ordered my ps5 via online went to pick it up in store with zero issues whatsoever.Employees were…read morevery helpful

Fabian Melendez is an amazing salesman he has much patience. I went in there with my mom (she's a…read moreregular there she speak broken English ) and he took his time communicating with her, he tried his best to get he something in her budget. Oh He's such a accommodating person , I recommend this shop. 9 out of 10