I would like to give them at least three stars, but the truth is I will likely not be back to Kilwins. Seeing other reviews I was so exited to try the place I ran down to fix an ice cream urge that had come over me. For me it breaks down like this. The place is OK, just OK, Not really A-OK, I would return to an A-OK place. I don't have an issue with the service received or the food in terms of quality, both were fine. As a matter of fact late on a Sunday night when it looked like they were already in the process of cleaning up for the night, the "Hello" was offered without and begrudging and truly sounded sincere. I ordered a two two-scoop sundaes one with strawberry chunk ice cream and the other with Mint chocolate chip. The strawberry had chocolate sauce over top, while the mint had caramel and rainbow sprinkles. Looking in the candy counter I found a few delectable treats to add onto he order a milk chocolate peanut butter cup and chocolate covered graham crackers. Graham crackers were business card sized but covered with plenty of chocolate and maintained their crunch. at $2 a pop, these were a little pricey but an indulgence I wouldn't hesitate to take. The Peanut butter cup was about double the size of the ones you get in the orange package. I expected a "fresh from the factory" taste, but not so much on these. They tasted like a mass produced large peanut butter cup. Nothing wrong with that at all, except if they are $5 each. When I saw the price I was a little taken aback, but I rationalized for the size and assumed freshness they were worth a try. Given the forgoing they are not worth a retry. I'll take a four pack of the king Size cups in the orange package instead and pocket at least a buck. Looking at the rest of the chocolate it seemed all prices were higher than other chocolatiers on the island. I verified this after stopping into another of my haunts a few days later. The Ice creams were OK as well, just nothing to write home about. My Sundae losses some point because the chocolate sauce was so poor. The sauce on top of the ice cream looked like it had separated leaving chocolate "water" on top and the thicker sauce had run down to the bottom of the cup. All this for the low price of a little more than $3 per scoop of ice cream. My total bill $25. I just don't see me making this trip again to get what was, besides the Graham crackers, just an OK treat. read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - There's a reason your feeling like a kid in a candy store. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Be ready to open your wallet as wide as it stretches or steer clear of this place. While everything we tried was good, the prices will keep me from becoming a regular. $15 per quart of ice cream, $10 per slice of fudge. Numbers I'd spend more willingly after putting down a few drinks. It's just insane to charge those kind of numbers even if the ice cream is high quality. And it honestly wasn't anything above or beyond what we get from other local ice cream shops. The only other thing I wanted to mention that sucks here.. They have a frequent customer punch card thingy. It sucks because I buy quarts that cost $15 which they give the same credit as if I were to buy a 1 scoop cone. Perhaps it was an oversight, but I even asked the girl "So $30 for 2 quarts gets me 2 stamps for a free cone?" Seems odd. Should be a free quart if I'm crazy enough to piss away $150 on 10 quarts of ice cream. In comparison, $150 at Baskin Robbins sends you home with 30 prepacked quarts. 3.5 stars for the fudge and ice cream. 0 stars for their insanely high prices. read more

Service was very personable and helpful. As others have said, price was steep. However, if the quality is top notch, I am willing to pay. Now on to the treats. Pecan brittle, amazing. Best I have ever had. Caramel popcorn with nuts, good, but didn't seem very fresh. Peanut butter balls, for $2.50 a piece they best be good. Unfortunately, they were not. Peanut butter tasted old. I actually threw it out and I NEVER ever dump candy!! All in all, I will be back if in the area again, but will try different goodies. read more

Omg! Yes patchogue needs a chocolate/icecream shoppe!!! First time here few weeks ago. We all got icecream and enjoyed it. It is nice to have a place like this in your neighborhood. I really like that they have late ish hours. Perfect to get dessert here after having dinner in ptown. I must return! Tomorrow if n I can convince hubby. read more

Great ice cream and the staff was SO friendly!!! The Ice cream doesn't even compare to Carvel or Baskin Robins and is worth the few dollars more for the better quality ice cream read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Patchogue, New York

$61 dollars a pound for chocolate? really? I am not cheap by any means....20, 30 even 40 a pound but 60 a pound? and the girl telling us that its because of covid......so now im paying for you all to get your money back?....we were all affected in business the same way. shame on this place. but I guess when people pay $61 a pound they think there getting the best thing....my $17.00 box included a piece of pecan bark maybe 2x3 and 2 chocolate cherries.....imagine if I had the kids with me! read more

Loved this place. The employees at the establishment were attentive and welcoming. You get to even try the ice cream before purchase! I got the Superman flavor (I think that's what it was called) it was beyond delicious! read more

One of my fav joints in the Village! Fun and delish!!! You can actually watch them make the goodies!!

We just happened to be walking down Main Street last night, the delicious smell drew us in. Let's just see what they have. We walked out wit the most milk chocolate sea salt caramel marshmallow pop and the s'mores. Oh my god, we will be back!!! So so good!!! read more

The staff is so friendly and helpful. The confections are very good and so is the ice cream. It's a great place to stop in for a tiny desert after a good meal on Main Street. read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Kilwins is the perfect stop after dinner or just strolling through the village of Patchogue. The fudge is amazing and hand made in store, like most other things in this store. They'll give you samples of anything you want to try and the staff there are very friendly and helpful. We've had the German Chocolate Fudge and the Dark Chocolate Fudge, and both satisfy any chocolate or sweet tooth craving. We also picked up a bag of chocolate covered espresso beans which are a staple in our home and we are happy we can find them so close to home. They offer a variety of other typical sweet shoppe candies, mainly an assortment of chocolate dipped creations, but they do sell candied apples in a variety of flavors, as well as marzipan, lemon drops, and sour gummy bears. We look forward to going back and trying out their ice cream and other candies! read more

This place & the employees are AWESOME! Employees are so personable, offer samples of anything you want are friendly & make you feel welcome! Love how you can sample & watch them make fudge. The toasted coconut ice cream is my personal favorite and I can't get enough of it. They also have a frequent buyer club card which helps with my wanting to go there every chance I get. read more

Best ice cream, Fudge and chocolate candy, Employees are very nice. Smile and help you right away.

An absolute delight! Another cool place on Main Street in Patchogue worth a visit! For one thing, I love how quiet it is; the employees aren't shouting at each other and are very respectful of each other and anyone who walks in. Their caramels are mouth watering, not too sweet, not hard to chew and thankfully gelatin free! I've also gotten chocolates and other assorted candies for myself and friends and we all loved them! The ice cream was delicious and creamy too! I myself am prone to soft serve because I'm sensitive to the icy feeling on my teeth, but this was perfect! One of the best milkshakes I've had out! I can't rave enough about the fudge either! I've had classic, dark, chocolate raspberry, salted caramel, and all have gone above and beyond! I love when chocolate actually tastes like chocolate and not just sweet and gross. You won't find that here! What gem, shall return there shortly! read more

DELECTABLE!!!! Freshly made Caramel!!!! My husband and I happened to do a walk by and we were so impressed. We were so overwhelmed with how delicious everything looked we didn't know where to begin when it came to ordering. There was one young gentlemen working on shift that we won't forget, because he was extremely friendly and helpful. Wish I had remembered his name. Unfortunately, at the time I had a pregnancy brain (aka very forgetful) place was pricey for sweets but worth it! read more

OMG..... love the atmoaphere and custom service. Ice cream is delicious but how could it not be especially since they make there own. Chocolate treats always hit the sweet spot and keep for mpre then 24 rs.. a must try if looking for a happy sweet ending to your patchogue trip read more

Kilwin's, while expensive, is by far the highest quality, best tasting ice cream and confectionery on the island. Their staff is patient, respectful and offers the highest level of customer service. You will pay more here, but you won't be more satisfied anywhere else around. I'm a frequent flyer here, and with Kilwin's you get what you pay for, and you'll never see anyone leave without a smile. I hope this is helpful. read more

Good ice cream! It was crowded and they are no lines or organization with placing an order... So it was everyone for themselves. They had a great selection of chocolate and candies! It's a great addition to Main Street! Make sure to visit.. And get your rewards card too! read more

Some of the BEST ice cream I've ever had. It's a bit pricey but wrote every penny. I love the praline pecan!

Really good ice cream with some unique flavors. Love the chocolate cashew. The caramel and chocolate covered apples are also amazing. They have a nice selection of candies and other confections including seasonal treats like chocolate covered strawberries for valentines day and chocolate bunnies for easter. read more

As I sit here, I'm tasked with the feat of writing a review that does Kilwins justice. I don't really know how one does that, but I'm going to try anyway. I should state first that I am quite the conundrum: I absolutely adore ice cream, but can't stomach anything overbearingly sweet. That leaves a really narrow margin of viable ice cream spots for me, but that's okay because I've finally discovered Kilwins! Kilwins sells a variety of confections - I'm sure every one just as glorious as the other, but what drives me here from over 10 miles away is their ice cream. It's so extraordinarily rich and creamy that even the "classic" flavors are imbued with a subtly that makes them stand apart. They offer decadent and indulgent flavors sure to please chocoholics, the range of classics to satisfy the most finnicky, and some fruity flavors as well. Let me be the first to say I've never been fond of fruity flavors or ice cream with things added to it (I'm that one person who dislikes Ben & Jerry's and Coldstone), but this place? This place gets it right. Their Georgia Peach is so refreshing and light. Perfect for those summer nights when you're strolling down the strip. Their lemon flavors are just tart enough where it gives your taste buds a little zing, but you don't feel like you've just gobbled a Warhead. Trust me, from my abundant samples (bonus points for any ice cream place that allows you to sample), the chocolate infused flavors and their classics are just as amazing. It may not be homemade and perhaps it can get quite pricey, but it's definitely worth the splurge. I'm just salivating at the thought of it. read more

Came here to treat myself to some chocolate on Valentine's Day as it was featured on News12. "Meh" sums it up. It was very expensive, but I have no problem paying if it's worth it. It wasn't. Average at best. I'm guessing this place is better known for it's ice cream, which I'm open to trying once the weather warms. Fingers crossed. I'm new to the area and would love to find some "go-to" places. read more

$10 for a shake. Clearly not a thick shake! Although it tasted good it was like a very tasty chocolate milk with some ice cream. Won't be back. read more

Was in town today and my kids wanted ice cream, never did I think 2 small, one scoop cones would cost me almost $14, and they didn't even have a topping! I didn't pay much more for a full lunch for the 3 of us. I'm sorry, yes it's a nice place inside and yes it's full of sweets but their prices are ridiculous! Sadly will not bring my kids back. read more

So I live right down the block from Kilwin's and wanted to try the ice cream and fudge for quite some time. I have been there several times for the ice cream and am OBSESSED!!!! Everything is fresh as well as the waffle cones. It is a perfect summer treat. The small cone is reasonable for $5.98 and leaves you feeling full afterwards. The only reason I can't give it 5 stars is because how expensive the store is. I have wanted to try the fudge, but don't want to spend that much on a piece of chocolate. There are a lot of other places that sell it cheaper. It looks so delicious though! If you are in the Patchogue area, stop into this place! read more

Delicious! Went in for some fudge, went home with 3 slices of fudge, Kilwins own Destiny Roll, a smores popsicle, hand made peanut butter cup (mind blowingly good!) and the biggest, most delicious chocolate covered strawberries I have ever seen. Special Valentine's/Birthday treats for my wife ... & ok me too! read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Amazing hand dipped chocolate covered strawberries (2 milk, 1 dark) for my wife's Valentine-Birthday. Yes, they taste as good as they look! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Fresh ice cream, fudge and desserts... What more could you ask for? I've been waiting for a premium ice cream shop in Patchogue for a while. Most people will complain about prices however milk, butter and electricity are at an all time high... That's what drives the prices naturally they reflect that. However Carvel is equally priced and half the quality!! I love the attentive young help that educates customers on what the store offers. They also I believe go the extra mile offering up free samples and devoting more time then the standard do you know what you want? I love this place and will continue to support. read more

After having Kilwins ice cream, theres really no comparison. If you love peanut butter like me I suggest their chocolate peanut butter ice cream. All of their fudge and chocolates are hand made in the store, which I think is awesome! Not only is their product high quality their staff was very accommodating. They let me try samples of the fudge and ice cream and were very knowledgable about their products. I think Kilwins is a sweet addition to Patchogue Village! read more

Excellent customer service! Ice cream that is out of this world! Fudge is incredible! Store is clean and well stocked and employees are friendly and knowledgeable! read more

Great place, friendly service, and delicious chocolate and caramel apples! Welcome to the neighborhood!

The best ice cream and fudge around ! Forget about regular froyo garbage . Kilwins ice cream blows that out of town! Everything there is made to perfection! Definitely going there from now on! Everyone must try this place! read more

You make your first step into the store, and you are greeted with the aroma of warm chocolate, buttery caramel, freshly baked waffle cones. The entire store is aesthetically sophisticated, clean and whimsical. There is a cook in the kitchen, carefully measuring ingredients for the next batch of fudge to be made. Behind the counter, a stack of pretzels and oreos are just waiting to be submerged into a pot of silky chocolate, then decorated with colorful sprinkles. A display of fresh, creamy fudge immediately catches your eye, and the staff is cheerfully ready to sample any of their delectable combinations, like sea salt caramel, chocolate raspberry, peanut butter chocolate chunk...With fudge sample in hand, you notice the glass case with an array of chocolate treats in every chocolate flavor -- rich dark, smooth milk, and sweet white. From chocolate dipped rice krispie treats, to the peanut butter fluff sandwich... how can you make up your mind? Everything in the case is made by the impressively talented staff, so you know these treats are made with care. Raspberry jellies, cashew tuttles, and other heavenly truffles shine in the next case, and trust me when I say, there is no way you can buy just one. They are perfect for nearly every occasion, and each one is simply divine. If you're a fan of peanut brittle, look no further, because there is a center structure adorned with nut brittle's and caramel corn, which I had recently learned were made fresh in the store's kitchen as well... Last, but not least, you see the lights of the ice cream cases, and, I warn you again, making a decision is going to be tough. The ice cream is spectacular, super premium, and, ultimately, delicious. My go-to is a small toasted coconut in a waffle bowl, with extra (freshly made!) whipped cream and sprinkles. If I'm feeling extra indulgent, I ask for a drizzle of their signature hot fudge. Honestly, this is one of the best chocolate and ice cream shoppes I have ever been to.The staff incredibly genuine, knowledgeable and helpful.. and being in the store is a treat on it's own! The quality of everything in the store is well worth the prices. I highly recommend Kilwins in Patchogue as your staple summer ice cream shop. Don't waste another minute! read more

Went to Kilwins the other night. The owner is great and so into it. But of course personality isn't the reason you are there!!! The chocolate and treats surpass all you would expect. Try the fudge (incredible) the caramel apples (incredible) the assorted chocolates are great too. I like the whole look. The staff are friendly and make you feel like you are In a quaint chocolate shop. We enjoyed everything we bought. Of course it's more expensive than chocolate you would buy in CVS but to me chocolate is like wine. You can get a box o wine or a Loire Valley Chardonnay. So if your going for the calories enjoy it. GOOD JOB Kilwins. read more

Awesome new addition to The Village of Patchogue. Be prepared for total sensory overload - there are so many delectable options that it can be overwhelming. Luckily, the friendly staff are always willing and able to guide you through the homemade goodies, offering free samples of the delicious fudge and ice cream and making suggestions as to all the other sweet treats. Here you'll find top-notch quality that is worth every penny. Bonus points - the store is always sparkling clean! read more

Came in here for the first time last week and everything was great! They have amazing icecream flavors! The worker was great. Second time I came in I had the same worker and I was very disappointed. Had a very bad attitude and was super rude. I got my icecream and left right after. Wonderful place , terrible workers. read more

Found out that Kilwin's opened up near me on the Island. Was excited to go and relive my Kilwin's experience in Naples Florida (best ice cream and service). I was disappointed in the portion the Patchogue location served. The same serving in Naples was at least double. The staff was friendly but could use some more training. I'd expect more from a high end store, it felt like I was in Friendly's. read more

Went last night at around 630 after a walk down by the water. We just wanted simple ice cream floats and nobody knew how to make them. We settled for a couple of scoops of ice cream that was awesome. Not knocking the store or the goods. But the management needs to train their new workers better then that. They were very friendly though. read more

Quite honestly some of the best ice cream I've ever had, and the fudge puts everyone elses to shame. They make almost everything in the store by hand on the spot! I'm talking down to the little things like hot fudge and hot caramel for the ice cream, even the whipped cream is made by hand and isn't that canned stuff. It doesn't get much better than that. Walk by outside and see the fudge or caramel corn being made right in the window, not to mention the fact you can smell it being made half a mile away. The quality of everything in the store is unrivaled and the prices, in my opinion, are more than fair. You get what you pay for in this life, and if you want top quality ice cream and chocolates, Kilwins is your best bet. The staff are so knowledgeable and very friendly as well, always offering samples and answering questions. Next time you go to dinner on Main Street, stop in to Kilwins for dessert. You won't regret it. read more