What a cute toy store..... my nieces picked out some stress ball toys for themselves. The toy…read moreselections are mostly European based & chosen with care built to last long. The shop owner was super nice and friendly!

Just had to pop on a quick review for this lovely, local toy store! We recently visited Lake Geneva…read morefor the weekend and did some holiday shopping while in town. Very delighted to stumble upon Allison Wonderland. I feel like they just don't make toy stores like this anymore. Independently owned, and packed with so many great toys, activities, books, and more. We have a kiddo of our own, along with nieces and nephews we were shopping for, and we found something for everyone! I most loved the sustainable wooden toy selection, and all of the great puzzles/building-type options. If you can skip the fast-shopping online from places like Amazon or Target, be sure to! This small shop could of course use the support, but they also genuinely have it all. Oh and the man working was very sweet and passionate about the store - love that!

I love this place. New candy and nostalgic candy as well. They also have ice cream and freeze-dried…read morecandy. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful. This is a must-visit place if you are anywhere in the area.

I think it's closed for good..never open when I stop over..I wanted to sell a bunch of funko pops…read morebut..

I went to find this place just to find out it was out of business…read more Check the dates on all of the other reviews............ Why don't they take down these old websites that still have stores on it that have been closed for awhile?????????

This is a super fun locally owned small business for both young and old! The shop owner is a gem…read morewho thoroughly enjoys their business and it shows! They are friendly and extremely helpful. I've come here several times now for neat gifts and creative projects, as well as fun little things for my own office. Each time I've been here I have found it well organized, easy to shop, and affordable. They have everything from silly putty and books to puzzles and craft kits. If you like supporting small businesses then give them a whirl while you enjoy the shops of Cedarburg!

A charming local toy store with great service, unique finds, and a warm neighborhood vibe.read more

The grandkids love this store! Great candy and slime selection, and you can always count on finding…read moreproducts that are trending on TikTok--which is very important when you're 10 . It's a great place to stop for a quick treat that won't break the bank.

Went there last sunday. The staff were yelling across the store to eachother, and the woman that…read morewas running the register (not sure why they took away the self checkouts) was busy showing her co workers videos on her phone and laughing while we were waiting to check out. That carried on through out the checkout process. Not a professional staff at all that night.

Lots of unique toys, clothes and other stuff for the kids. Not your run of the mill toy store or…read moreclothing store. Think more of the one of a kind finds instead of where to go for the coveted toy of the season. Prices are higher than the mass produced department stores, but you won't find most of these items elsewhere. Many handmade and customized accessories and clothes. Fun colors, designs and textures. It's small, cozy and welcoming. Friendly and helpful staff without being pushy. They have toys and clothes for all ages, both boys and girls. Due to the size of the store, they may not have the exact size of the item you like available but ask and they will try to get it for you. If you are looking for unique gifts for the little monsters in your life, this is your place!

This place came highly rated on yelp, so since I was in the area I decided to check it out. As a…read moretoy collector, a lover of the unique, an Uncle of 10 and a new proud parent, I thought this place would be right up my alley. Don't believe the hype folks. "Not your run of the mill kids stuff" Reality- It's true, it's damn true. They have toys in here that I didn't even know existed. It's stuff that you won't see on the shelves at your local big box or even regular toy stores. As far as gifting goes, if you buy something from here, you won't have to worry about someone else getting the same gift. These toys are pretty cool, and that's the problem- I think they're pretty cool. Will your kid think they're cool? Probably not. Take for example the line of Fischer Price "Retro" toys they carry. They caught my eye right away, they're the toys we used to play with, like the rotary telephone with the goofy eyes on it or the record player with the plastic records. It's a great gift to get the adults in the room talking, but lets be honest, what kid knows what a record player or rotary phone is? So why would they play with it? Most kids wake up in the morning, eat their Lucky Charms to get their Spongebob toy out of the box, put on their Spider-Man shoes and Batman shirt to go to Legoland for a McDonalds Happy Meal lunch featuring Hot Wheels toys. They have barely anything that has a license. Just some small Hello Kitty toys. Anything that's not on a Saturday morning cartoon could get you mean mugs from little ones. That's not saying they don't have anything the kiddies wouldn't like. They have two racks of small toys and accessories that are expensive, but are the perfect little gifts for party favor bags if you throw a kids party. I might stop back for a few of these around my little ones BDay. "Baby gear and furniture" Reality- Where is this stuff? This store is super small, and outside of a few racks of clothes, all I really see is toys. "Unique Gifts" Reality- I think "Unique" is a code word for "Expensive". I may live cheap, but I have absolutely no problems spending big money on cool stuff, as evidenced by the toys my daughter already owns. But the markup at this place is ridiculous. I saw the clothes, and knowing my daughter needed some onesies, I asked the lady if they had any. She showed me about 3 of them and they were pretty cool. Cool little drawings of animals on the front, 100% organic material, I was sold. I remember thinking that they were so cool, I'd pay $20 for one. I asked the lady how much for this one, she told me "37.50"! 37 bucks? My jaw dropped. Does she realize that a baby is just going to make a mess of this onesie for six months? Maybe if my wife and I were Kim and Kanye we could do this, but I have a hard time believing that in a blue collar city like this a store with so little to offer continues to exist. Bottom line- Good for rich Grandparents, Aunts or Uncles to get the kids in their lives some toys that are nice to look at but probably won't be played with, but bad for parents.

Great place to visit on your hunt for seeing some rare and unique toys, however that's all you'll…read morebe doing is "seeing" them because pretty much all the vintage and rare items are not for sale. Owner is very friendly and nice, but it's really not a shop you need to visit if you're actually trying to purchase something for your collection.

Great shop packed with something for everyone…read more Visited from Ohio last weekend and was blown away by the selection. Everything from wrestling to horror toys to NES games. Prices were fair and ranged depending on the item. The shop owner was nice & helpful. Don't pass this place up of you're in the area.