Awesome this place was so much fun. I love the ice cream Staff was friendly and helpful. The…read more store had a lot of fun choices and was very cute.

Went here on a whim while in lake Geneva for a weekend , got there at 750 with an 8pm close the…read moreladies working couldn't of been nicer to all the people in line , got a great sundae and some candy , service alone you should stop by this place and the sundae was great. Will definitely stop by again when in town.

Took the kids in for a small treat! Right now they have a lot of Easter themed candy that is all…read moremade in house. Their chocolate is awesome! I love their dark chocolate! This time I got a piece of the dark chocolate peanut lovers bark! So good! My kids got the small cake pieces. The staff here is always friendly and helpful and the atmosphere is great! This place is also known for its candy apples! We have had them in the past and they're amazing !

If you're a fan of caramel apples and sweets, you must stop by Amy's!! They offer a wide variety of…read morechocolate/sweet assortment and dipped apples that are so delicious and gigantic ! My top choice is the pecan caramel apple! I've also tried a few of their chocolate truffles- super tasty. I appreciate that the staff is always very kind and efficient with their service, especially in the busy season. Definitely recommend trying out if you have a sweet tooth and are looking for top tie caramel apples!

Decided to go to public market today in Milwaukee. I stopped at this candy shop. Excellent customer…read moreservice and amazing chocolate. The chocolate covered strawberry special was amazing! Would highly recommend. Can't wait to go back!

Good flavor and quick service. Very refreshing for a hot day. Place is pretty slow for a busy…read moreSaturday afternoon

Great place to purchase homemade fudge and chocolates! They have been around for 100 years! Great…read morequality of chocolate! One of the staff was so friendly, explained all the detailed information about the store. It is a cute countryside candy shop!

Welllll, chocolate is not my favorite sweet treat, but here it's pretty darn good. I love the…read morecaramel and chocolate dipped pretzels with nuts, and their caramels are the best anywhere. It's pricey yes but all worth it and fresh. I remember finding this place years ago and since been living everywhere for years and unfortunately for my waistline, it is way too accessible to me now. Lol. I am glad to have rediscovered it. Worth the money and the calories for when you get that sweet tooth craving., It can be a long wait on weekends but definitely worth it.

offered a delightful variety of sweets, from classic chocolates to unique handmade treats that…read morebrought back childhood memories. Lisa was friendly and the vibrant atmosphere made the whole experience even more enjoyable.Very talented Chocolatier and Sweets expert! We'll 100% be back

Stopped by today and tried pumpkin espresso and pumpkin pecan fudge. Oh my goodness. Lisa makes…read morethe most devine, creamy, perfectly flavor balanced fudge. There is no skimping on high quality ingredients.

Heading south from Sheboygan with my family I had a craving for ice cream, so I pulled up the…read moreoptions around Port Washington. The "best" local place that was open in January was The Chocolate Chisel. My family and I stopped and each got a cone. I also got three truffles. The truffles I bought were chai tea milk, experimint milk (ganache with peppermint extract), and peppermint hot chocolate. The chai tea and experimint milk truffles both tasted like they should based on their descriptions, but I wouldn't wantto buy either again. The peppermint hot chocolate had some crushed peppermint on top, but other than the chocolate being in the shape of a mug, nothing about it reminded me of hot chocolate. Ultimately I don't think any of them were worth the price. The ice cream was lackluster. Both of my kids got cookies and cream in a cake cone and thought it was skimpy on the cookies part. My wife and I sprung for waffle cones with ours and were both disappointed in the excessive cone to ice cream ratio that heavily favored the cone. She got plain chocolate and it was fine. I, however, got banana-rama and ended up throwing it out because it tasted more like butter pecan than anything banana related. I even went back inside and verified with the employee that it wasn't mislabeled in the case.

The chocolate is very good. The service is 1star. Ordered online 5/16/26 because I saw them on PBS…read moreJohn mcgivern. And received on 6/4. Ordered for a gift, but came way too late. No communication with company or shipping company (shop). I reached out to chocolate chisel and was told, waiting on a product for gift package and they apologized.

Date of visit: July 28, 2025…read more I stopped in here as I am leading an effort to find local vendors that we can order from as part of a holiday gift effort for some of our customers. I perused the store and selected brittle, taffy, and chocolates as part of a taste testing for the whole team to determine which items were the best to consider as gifts for our customers. Staff was friendly and accomodating, and even offered me a sample after I completed my purchase. Oddly, despite spending about $70 and explaining what I was doing with my purchases, I didn't get a receipt. I dropped an email to the store and received a quick reply and was provided with a picture of the receipt that was quite small and blurry, though thankfully our AP department didn't question it too much and I still got reimbursed for the purchase! And if you were wondering, the taffy was surprisingly good, but wasn't labeled on the package in terms of what flavors were in each bag, so that was a big turn off for our taste testers. The chocolates were a big hit and will be a finalist for our customer gifts!

We love to check out boutique confectionaries. Chocolates can be a tricky business, so finding one…read morethat checks all the boxes is an amazing experience. First time stopping in here. I read about Burke moving in to this Whitefish Bay location, so I wanted to give them a try. I really wanted to give them the highest rating, but unfortunately that wasn't the case. Super cute shop. Has a nice old time feel to it. Walking in to the place, you find a large selection of many different confections. The "factory" is at their other location downtown Milwaukee. Got greeted by two friendly staff members. Very helpful at explaining the different items and offered to allow me to sample (I did have one piece of the peanut butter crunch). You can either get individual items from the case, or there are pre-packed items on the other walls. I got a mix of different items. Ones that I have found can be a big tricky to make. Fairy Food, Marshmallow, and Caramel. And to be honest I was a bit disappointed. Summer can be a hard to time to make/keep sponge candy (fairy food), and some places don't even make it this time of year because the humidity can make it sticky. Marshmallow has a short shelf life and can get tough. This was exactly my experience with these two items. The chocolate itself was very good. And the presentation was also very impressive wit the other items. They did wrap up everything in attractive cellophane bags with ribbon, and placed in a gift bag with a custom ribbon. Perfect for gift giving. So overall a good (but not great experience). I would stop back again, but keep away from some of the humidity sensitive items.