The worst customer service! Rude and obnoxious. I will never go back. I pre ordered 1 dozen pastries to be picked up at 9am on a Sunday. When I arrived there was a long line, I wasn't sure how pickups were handled so I walked in to ask. The owners wife screamed at me to get out and go to the back of the line. I walked out and went elsewhere. An hour later I get a phone call from the bakery asking if I was going to pick up my order. I informed her that I was there but after being treated so poorly I left. I was a customer for yrs. Never again. I didn't want to give them 1 star but had no choice. read more

Best cookies ! It's a winner. small lots huge taste. Everything they have is outstanding. Cookies danish bread cakes. Once we give Kriegs as a gift and now those people became huge Kriegs fans read more

The jelly donuts and bear claws are the best within 100 miles. I am always looking for jelly generous donuts that have real raspberry taste and hands down this is the best! Get there early and they will be warm! The downside is they are closed Mon and Tues read more

The baked goods are very delicious, and made with love. The family who are the owners are of the highest quality. That sums it up.

Omg old world traditional bakery from Europe DON'T BLINK DON'T AVOID BC OF JAMMED LOT worth it Coffee tea with Starbucks creamers. Fresh bread rolls pastries cakes specialty cakes galore. Open to 5 pm A must stop along your travels to the Hamptons read more

Krieg's Bakery - Fresh crumbs - Bakeries Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Hands down best donuts I have ever had. I find myself going every twice a week to indulge in the Boston Cream donut. 10/10 Fresh bread is delicious Only caveat is it's cash only, but the. Again if you only have 2.50(formerly $2) means you can only get one donut not two which may not be a bad thing. read more

See all

We have been loyal Krieg customers for 28 years. Yesterday I bought 12 donuts and a pound of butter cookies. 6 of the donuts were for my neighbor who no longer drives. The donuts were compressed , chewy and odd. I should have looked more closely because they looked different. What a disappointment. Thinking that they would appreciate feedback (as in, maybe something isn't right with the ingredients or how they were cooked) I called. Right from the start I stated that I wasn't looking for compensation , that I simply wanted to let them know they weren't right. The owners wife was rude , cut me off and then hung up on me. Shameful. I had dropped off the donuts to my neighbor, called her today and she said "What happened to these ? They are inedible ". The photos on their website look nothing like what I got yesterday. Looking like they were run over by a car , I should have taken my $45 elsewhere . My mistake for not walking out but we won't be walking in there again. Very shoddy product and owner customer service. Disgraceful read more

Krieg's is a staple in the Hampton Bays community. I love their crumb and cheese danishes. They are so fresh and taste incredible. This bakery has become a popular spot and there is now a line. Get there in the early morning right when they open. Staff is helpful and friendly. I get nostalgic when I visit Krieg's. I like that it hasn't changed and the pastries taste just the same as when I ate them as a child. read more

Krieg's Bakery - Boston cream donut, crumb and cheese danishes - Bakeries Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Every thing is great! Don't miss the jelly donuts! A line in the summer - super busy- off season the owners are friendly and chatty.

Old fashioned bakery hiding in a shopping center! Come here for their Apple fritters, crumb danishes and buns, and assorted donuts! Friendly faces and good service. Obviously a neighborhood gem by the familiarity with the customers. It's no frills - get your bakery goods and go on your merry way! read more

Wonderful people and great items especially Old Fashion Crullers and And Anise cookies. They also remember you and what you like read more

This place is ridiculous. Bought a crumb cake and it was stale and not good. We brought it back and the woman started to scream at us that it was fresh and screaming at us to get out. We spent $90 here and the customer service is horrible. read more

Awesome Bakery! Every thing is DELICIOUS ! Do not miss the Lemon Meringue Pie. It's the best and they are always happy to take a custom order to make it year round. It's visually beautiful and the taste is simply the best. The pastries are delightful. The fresh baked rolls are what gets a friend of mine out of bed every morning - the apple fritters.... Yum-o. If you want a VERY special cake... do your self a favor and order a Black Forest cake. I ordered one for my wife's birthday and it was the star of the table. It was spectacular! Spectacular Spectacular! They are absolutely welcoming, friendly and lovely to interact with. We have been going for many years and have never been disappointed. Exceeds expectations! read more

Krieg's Bakery - Black Forest heavenly cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Small bakery in a strip mall that sells cookies, breads, pies and jelly donuts. As a jelly donut connoisseur who still laments the loss of Storks Bakery 10 years ago, I'm always up for testing a new jelly donut when recommended and a number of people suggested Kreig's. While it wasn't a Tier 1 version I'd say it was a very good Tier 2. Unlike many jelly donuts I've tried, this one had high quality jelly and there was no shortage of it. For me, Tilda edges Kreig's for best Suffolk County jelly donut. I'd recommend if you know what you want to call ahead as they often sell out of items especially by the afternoon. read more

We ordered sourdough but it was white bread? Not sure if they gave us the wrong bread or if the sourdough is just really really bad...

When I'm in the hamptons I love that bakery. Great break and I love the crumb cake it's a cake we always ate after church on Sunday's..

When I go to Kriegs bakery, I always get their jelly donuts. They are delicious and the cookies are good too The service is good. I like the ambience too. Will be going back again. It'll be my third time. read more

I cannot stress enough that we all should support all the little local stores in towns that we live in or visit! Especially during these times! Krieg's is a 4th generation Bakery that has weathered all the economic storms from the Depression era up until today's covid 19. The current owner/ Baker's father was a recipe formulator for Hostess back in the day, so this family definitely knows the scientific ins and outs of baking. Most of the offering are traditional German baked goods, however because his wife is Brazilian, they also offer a few Brazilian Delicacies when she can get into the kitchen to bake as well. Their donuts alone are not to be missed! The jelly filled are exactly what I grew up with back in the 80s when NYC had diners that baked their own jelly filled yeast doughnut themselves. Their chocolate chip cookies are the most addictive and delicious I've tasted in a long time, and I'm a chocolate chip cookie baking connoisseur. The chocolate chip cookies are not clawingly sweet, slightly chewy yet have a super tender flakey crumb. Their baguettes remind me of those that I've had in France super crunchy on the outside and Arie and hoist on the inside, just a perfect combination. Sadly it looks like once this Baker is ready to retire, this place will close since his kids have their own aspirations of being a doctor and an engineer, which are cool in its own right. So get here before it's too late! read more

See all

We were looking for a good bakery in the area and other than baked goods at the supermarket chains or in Riverhead, there did not seem to be any. Krieg's is a little bakery hidden in a strip mall that if you aren't looking for it, you could miss it time and time again. I know people rave about the pastries and jelly donuts, but we were going there for their breads, The rye bread that they make is delicious. I bought it multiple times, initially without seeds [it was good] but then with seeds [even better] They make pies as well. There are two problems I have though-no reflection on their baked goods-parking is a problem and they are closed on both Monday and Tuesday. If you have a hankering for something, you have to wait until they reopen. Other than that, their rye bread with seeds is a winner! read more

Jelly donuts! The best anywhere! They have other stuff too which look good, but get the jelly donuts!

I've moved and when I came back for a visit, I made sure to stop at my old culinary haunts. Kriegs was always known for their delicious pastries. I had a hankering and lo and behold the jelly donut met my every expectation and more. Little shop, no fanfare, and great service. read more

always great pastries and cookies,always fresh, large variety staff pleasant and helpful read more

The bakery is a small store in a strip mall on the main street through Hampton Bays, so it's easy to miss. That would be sad, though, since the baked good are excellent! We got there late in the day, so they were pretty well cleaned out, but managed to get some cupcakes and butter cookies. They were excellent, and the staff there were so, so kind! They were cash-only when we were there, not sure if it's always that way. But the prices are very, very reasonable, especially for the quality of the baked goods. read more

The best donuts, sugar cinnamon or plain a perfect 10. You won't believe how delicious these are!

Great doughnuts and danishes! Make sure you try the German butter bread, it's as good as it looks!

The best in the East End. Always fresh baked and very personable. You can give a special order and nothing is a problem. The best.

Thank you for all the time and hard work you put in. It takes real love & effort to be so consistently good. We only had a chance to visit you once this year, but will return again. So thankful you guys are still here! read more

It's a cute bakery pleasant staff always, I was told way back about there jelly donuts when my son was much younger am still buying the jelly donuts and he's much older now ! Love them delicious taste but also love all of bakery good great place glade it's not far from where I live! read more

We came after checking yelp for bakery close to us. Ordered the Apple fritter, jelly donut and a coconut stick?? The Apple had no Apple, coconut a smattering of coconut on the outside and the jelly, decent amount of jelly when you got inside. Everything basically tasted the same. Just doughy. Will not be back. read more

Amazing cupcakes and cake! We came here for our wedding and were so impressed! Absolutely beautiful and delicious! So happy we found you! Thank you! read more

Krieg's Bakery - Our wedding cake and cupcakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

First time here and it's an old school bakery full of fresh goods. Seems popular with the locals. We picked up some fresh jelly donuts and a loaf of Rye bread. Both are delicious. Service was kind, as it should be. We'll be back for sure. read more

Great treats and super service. One of the few family owned bakeries left. I would highly recommend a shopping stop at this bakery.

Amazing -- been coming here for years and consistently high quality and amazing baked goods!

This is the best bakery....evvverrr!!! My mom just bought a house in the Hamptons so on my Yelp findings I stumbled across Krieg's and boy are we glad we did! Everything is fresh, delicious, and so danm good :). So far we have tried the cheese Danish, cookies, Boston cream donuts, canolis, eclairs, cream puffs, cheese ring....Ha! Just about everything and we have yet to be disappointed. Everything is made fresh daily so there's always a variety. We live in the city and have had our fair share of "good old school Italian bakeries" from Manhattan to Brooklyn to Queens and this is simply the best! The family is so nice, always willing to chit chat and make us feel welcome. Heads up- go early otherwise your favorites might be gone! read more

Krieg's Bakery - Can't keep our hands off! - Bakeries Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

5 star CRULLER. So I got a message that got me to go back and read my review of this place many years ago. Now that was a funny memory. Fast forward to this crazy year of 2020, my dad can sadly no longer go out. So we went all the way out here and brought him back his favorites. Unfortunately they don't bake certain things on weekdays, only on weekends. But the jelly donut was excellent. And if you can get there early morning to get the crullers fresh out of the oven. Go. That cruller was one of the best things I've ever eaten. Well worth the fat, calories and at a nice low price. read more

Krieg's is a world-class bakery, enough said. My personal favorites are the crumb pastries and cheese danish. read more

The bakery is fine. Unfortunately one of the attendants is the nastiest person around. Case 1. I asked - very nicely- to get the pieces from the center of the pan. I literally got yelled at. She is nuts. Case 2. Today. Someone was at the counter, so I was socially distancing and waiting for him to finish to start the order. Third person comes in. The nasty starts taking care of her, and tells me I had my turn. Worse than the soup nazy! The pastries are ok, nothing out of this world. Please give this woman her meds!! Do you yourself a favor and avoid this place. To many much better bakeries in the area. read more

Went in & was surprised to see they had nothing left in the case. I asked the woman standing behind the counter if they had anything else & she started screaming for me to "go to hell! Go to hell! Get out of my store!" All I said was "awww, everything's gone?" and she lost it. Wouldn't go back after being attacked like that. COVID NOTE: She was not wearing a mask either. Standing behind the counter around food and no mask. read more

Best bakery, hands down. The crumb buns are legendary and the crumb danish are beyond amazing. Mrs. Krieg is a legend and everything is made fresh daily. No frills and none are needed. read more

It took two days for someone to answer the phone at this bakery. When I finally got through, I started asking the woman about some pies and other items I saw on their website because I am going to a barbecue and wanted to make sure I ordered enough. She was a little short with me and I guess I asked too many questions because she said "I just told you and hung up on me", I was going to place a nice size order but now I find another bakery. I ordered from this bakery last year & they messed up my order but I thought I would give them another chance because the food is good but now I would not recommend this bakery. read more