Last Friday night, my family and I decided to dine at L'Italiano Trattoria around 5:15 pm, without a reservation. To our surprise, the restaurant was bustling with reserved tables, yet the staff graciously accommodated us with the understanding that we would vacate by 6:45 pm. This initial gesture of hospitality set the tone for our entire experience.
As we settled in, I noticed the familiar interactions between the staff and other patrons, many of whom were greeted by name - a true testament to the regular clientele that this charming eatery has cultivated. It's clear why L'Italiano Trattoria doesn't have a plethora of online reviews; it's a hidden gem treasured by a loyal, perhaps less tech-savvy, crowd who value tradition over trendiness.
Service was impressively swift. We were promptly provided with water and complimentary bread that was a delightful prelude to our meal. The waitstaff's ability to take our order without writing it down spoke volumes about their professionalism and experience.
Our appetizer, the Misto Oreganato, was evidently homemade, with a light, non-floury breading that allowed the natural flavors to shine, especially the white wine in the sauce. The entrees were equally impressive. The Pasta Primavara, shared by my two sons, was served on two separate plates, a thoughtful touch that didn't go unnoticed. The fresh, light flavors of the vegetables were a perfect balance to the dish. The Calamari Salad was a generous serving of perfectly grilled calamari, complemented by a light dressing and a mix of romaine and arugula. The Cannelloni, with its perfectly cooked pasta and flavorful ricotta filling, was an absolute delight.
We chose to take our desserts to go - a decision influenced by the server's recommendation of his mother's cheesecake recipe. This choice did not disappoint; the cheesecake was light, fluffy, and reminiscent of the renowned Eileen's Cheesecake in Nolita. The Nutella Mousse Chocolate Cake was a hit too, with its light and airy texture.
The convenience of tableside card payment was another plus, making our overall dining experience efficient and hassle-free.
L'Italiano Trattoria is a restaurant where tradition meets exceptional service and culinary excellence. We are already planning our next visit, this time with a reservation, as that seems to be the norm for this beloved local treasure. read more