Came in at 3:30 on a pretty hot day. There were several families there seated at tables but not a…read morehuge rush. I was looking through the flavors as a person working patiently was waiting for me to make my choice. While I could have sampled I confidently went for a medium salted caramel. It came out to around $6 with tax and everything. And the gelato was very good! Creamy and rich, really flavorful, and overall great! I'll definitely be back to try their other flavors.

This spot has been on my list for a while, and I'm so glad I finally made it in!! Huge parking…read morelot, decent seating, amazing service, free samples, airy gelato, and so affordable. The portions are huge. I got a medium cup (up to 3 flavors) for just $5.50!! I came toward the end of the day, so they were out of their tiramisu flavor, but I ended up with guava cheesecake, pistachio, and Oreo--all of which were still delicious. I'll definitely be back to try the tiramisu gelato and their mangonada. Pistachio - One of their most popular flavors, and for good reason. You can taste the real pistachio--no artificial flavor at all. Light, airy, and not overly sweet. I just wish the pistachio flavor was a touch stronger. Guava Cheesecake - My favorite of the day! Tastes exactly like it sounds--sweet guava paired with creamy cheesecake. Reminds me of Porto's Bakery's guava cheese roll. Oreo - Classic Oreo flavor--exactly what you'd expect. Not mind-blowing, but still tasty. Their gelato overall is so airy and fluffy, without the heavy feeling of regular ice cream. Can't wait to come back!

If you think you've had great gelato, Caffe Italia will make you question everything you thought…read moreyou knew. The man behind the magic is Mike, the owner -- and he is the real deal. Born in Italy and trained by the best, making gelato isn't his job, it's his calling. You can taste that distinction in every single bite. Mike is constantly developing new recipes, hand-picking fresh fruit at the market, and importing specialty ingredients straight from Italy when he can't find what meets his standards locally. This is a man who simply refuses to cut corners. My family and I have been loyal customers for nearly 8 years, and what's remarkable is that it's just as mind-blowing today as it was the very first time we walked through the door. That kind of consistency is rare -- and it speaks volumes. Over the years, we've brought roughly 40 friends and family members here for the first time. Every single one of them has raved about it. That's not a coincidence. That's excellence. If you're visiting for the first time, do yourself a favor: try the rainbow cookie gelato. You can thank me later. And while many people get it to go, I suggest having it there. The shop is tastefully decorated, it's clean, it's comfortable. For fifteen minutes you'll think you're in Italy. Caffe Italia isn't just the best gelato in the county -- it may very well be the best you'll ever have. Don't walk. Run.

What a nice owner. He greeted me and he also knew about potential allergens in the food. I've…read morealways had issues with restaurants and the servers or owner not knowing if it has eggs or not, but this owner knows his gelato. I got a small gelato with a scoop of strawberry and cookies and cream. It was so much, I was honestly surprised I ordered a small. It was a fantastic gelato and hit the sweet spot.

My dad and I stopped by for a scoop and had a lovely experience. I misunderstood one of the topping…read moreoptions and the fantastic team at Gemelli were so accommodating in redoing my scoop. Great service and delicious gelato. The outside is so cute too, perfect for a relaxing summer night!!

Cute little gelato shop right off the highway that satisfy the need for something cold on a sunny…read moreday. The owner was originally from Jackson Heights, where one of my friends with me is currently living. He and the server were both quite friendly. Three of us enjoyed their product over the weekend and felt that it was good, but melted a bit too easily, which made it messy to eat. My favorite flavor was definitely Hazelnut, but Pistachio was good too.

if ur hours say open til 9:30. the doors shouldn't be locked until 9:30…read more (the actually gelato was good the one time i've had it - been wanting to come back but the hours suck)

I was looking for a meal replacement, so I decided to try this place. I wished I sampled the flavor…read morebefore making my decision! This was awful, I did even get to half of the shake! Hazelnut is one of my favorite flavors, but this tasted very soapy!

Truly amazing gelato. Around here, we've regrettably gotten used to chain-type ice cream places -…read moreyou know, factory-made ice cream, regional or national chains where the flavors taste synthetic. In contrast, this place is a real treasure. Flavors actually taste like their proper ingredients. Just wish they had pistachio more often!

The Gelato was very good. I have had Gelato all over Rome. There was not one store that did not…read morehave coffee, espresso, cappuccino or pistachio flavors. Newbury has not one of these standard flavors! Very surprising! Coffee, by far was the largest seller in Italy. Tony O. from Ct.

Until I went to Pompelmo Gelateria, if you asked me if I liked gelato, I'd say it's fine, but I'm…read morenot a big ice cream/gelato person (lactose ). BUT Mel makes absolutely killer, world renowned gelato that it's flipped my whole perspective on gelato. She and her team are so good about allergens and cross-contamination- there's always multiple gluten-free and vegan options that make no sacrifices in taste or texture. My go-to is some sort of fruit flavor (limoncello/mojito/forest berry) + dark chocolate and it always slaps. Last- I have mad respect to business owners who continue to work in their shop day in and day out. It's pretty common for ice cream shops to be staffed by high school kids which is fine, no shade, everyone needs a day off, but Mel being there scooping really ensures the quality of the gelato and cleanliness of the shop stay at the highest level. no doubt!

The Gelato is absolutely delicious! The vanilla berry is my favorite. Fresh ingredients and made…read moredaily. Lots of flavors to choose from. Right in downtown Westerly.

The whole family was in the evening we visited and it was so great to meet them and hear their…read morestory, from having a candy truck (bringing sweets to the streets) to opening a brick and mortar, in memory of Tierra's (owner's) best friend, Candi. Grace's is a new Black Owned Business that has only been open a few weeks and is serving up some nostalgia...with a side of gelato or sorbet. They have some hard to find goodies available (when's the last time you saw freeze dried candy/ice cream or a Kit Kat Churro Candy Bar available locally), drinks you and your kids will love in the cooler by @averysbeverages, @drink_warheads and @prime_energy__drinks, and gelato and sorbet locally made by @gelatogiuliana_newhaven! I mean when you have kids to help with the selection, who better to advise on what kids (and anyone with a sweet tooth) want?!? Check out my reel on ig (@clinkdrinkeat.com) and see for the cutest *clink* I've ever captured by the owner's 9-year old twins, Jae'quese and Jahlil. I love how bright and inviting the shop is, with a big candy mural by @b_tatt2dude. Go check it out and find some candy you'll remember from your childhood! You may know I have a frozen dessert addiction so I had scoops of the following flavors: Coconut, Chocolate, All'Oreo, and Espresso Macarpone Chocolate gelato, AND Passionfruit Peach and Blood Orange Raspberry sorbet (oh how the pieces of fruit and seeds in the sorbet let you know it's locally made with love). Yes, 6 scoops. Don't judge. Which are you grabbing on your visit?i

This shop is so beautifully decorated and spotless. There used to be a candy shop in the 80's in…read moreNorth Haven - Sweet Licks and it reminds me of it. I got two candy selections for my girlies, and coconut and Reese cupcakes for myself & the hubs (cupcakes are sourced from Perfect Poundcakes) nice selection of gelato and cool flavored sodas. If they branch out to doing kids parties it would be bringing the fun. Easy peasy checkout with Square.

great Italian ice flavor and love the varieties. these place is assume with reasonable prices…read more highly recommend and wish they were open year round. they make authentic Italian ice that is perfect.

Excellent product and flavor selection. Staple of Middletown since 1930. Very affordable…read more Very friendly family owned and run business. Old school charm. Nice historic nostalgic place. Will be back soon !!