This new shop is located in an unusual strip of older stores. There's a pawn broker next store…read more Even so, this should not keep you from stopping by. Inside it is bright and sparkling clean. They have a variety of ice creams. And they offer milk shakes, scoops, waffles, etc. You can see the menu on the wall above the counter. I'd seen their info on Instagram and was following them there. You might wish to do so too as they offered a recent special online. We came here last month for their buy one, get one milk shake. I ordered their classic vanilla shake, and my husband requested their strawberry shake. They come in two sizes, and we got the smaller one. We got them to go. My husband's strawberry was the prettier of the two, with extra strawberry syrup on the bottom and top. But I liked my vanilla shake the best. The ice cream was rich and creamy. Their prices are comparable. And it was a nice "dessert" stop to have after our lunch nearby.

Excellent ice cream I will be going back for sure! The service was great, friendly face and…read moreexplained all the flavors! As for the ambience, it's perfect for a ice cream parlor. Do yourself a flavor and go.!

I love ice cream! It was a beautiful Saturday afternoon when I was walking along Lake Avenue and…read morespied the Ice Cream Affair and I knew it was time for an ice cream treat. The shop was clean, and the young girls working were welcoming. There's a lot of artwork on the walls. There's a few tables inside as well as outside. They have two sinks, including a cute kid-sized one for washing before or after your ice cream. They have a lot of flavors making for a difficult decision, but samples were pleasantly provided. I opted for the garbage dump which included chunks of seven different candies. The ice cream was good and the price was as expected.

Cute little ice cream spot for a quick treat. Sadly, 3…read moreflavors were not available that we wanted to try, so I was a bit disappointed. I went with the single scoop pistachio, and it was ok. Bits of pistachio through out. Staff were friendly, greeted guests as soon as they walked in. Inside has a few tables, and some beautiful wall art. It's a standard ice cream spot.

For context, I rate products and businesses on a simple scale: 5 stars means I love it, 4 stars…read moremeans I like it, 3 stars is okay, 2 stars means I didn't like it, and 1 star means I hated it or think it's unsafe. I love this place. It's not the ice cream shop yet but getting there is part of the experience, the drive through Manalapan is really scenic with beautiful trees, flowers, and some amazing homes along the way. It's located in a shopping plaza that used to be a bit larger before some stores closed and a Publix was added, but it's still a nice plaza with some unique shops. The Ice Cream Club itself is on the smaller side, but the ice cream is outstanding. It is a bit pricey, but definitely worth it. On this visit, I had a hot fudge sundae with their garbage can ice cream, which is vanilla ice cream loaded with ground peanuts and chunks of different candy bars. It was so good. I was also tempted to try the Heavenly Hash and the chocolate moose track, both looked really rich and chocolatey. If I had just gone with a cone, I probably would have picked one of those. I've been here several times over the years and have never had a bad choice. It's one of those places I keep coming back to. 5 stars as always here.

What a fun & irreverent ice cream shop! We couldn't stop laughing at the wall art with Monica…read moreLewinsky and Stormy Daniels. The 2 girls working were sweet and helpful. It was our first time there and we tried several flavors. I landed on raspberry & truffle. It had huge chunks of chocolate that added a nice crunchy texture to the creamy ice cream. I also got the blueberry cheesecake, rich & a bit too sweet for my palate. Very clean ice cream shop, will be back.

It's been my goto late night ice cream spot. I always come for the ice cream banana split and its…read morelike 3-4 scoops at least and always delicious. Also very reasonably priced. Even though its a little shack on the side of the road, don't sleep on this place!

Le daría zero estrellas si pudiera por qué te cobran mal y aparte te cóbrate mal te cobran extra…read morepor cosas que ni pides, pidan su recibos y chequen los. Una tal mariana los cobro extra y cuando les fuimos a preguntar se enojó y doy una pésima actitud como se no le pagaran para trabajar ahí. Su respuesta fue que supuestamente no los cobra ella pero claramente está en el recibo su nombre de ella. Horrible experiencia y cambien sus empleadas por que va a dejar en la ruina su negocio por su actitud que se cargan.

The owner, Mimi, is the best! She serves Bassett, the best ice cream in the area and makes the…read morevery best Açaí bowls. You will not find better. Her turkey bacon and Avocado sandwich is a winner! Her place is very friendly to children as she provides games and lots of candy options. Check her out! You don't find many reasonably priced old school luncheonettes like this anymore!

This place is very cute and charming. It's very family friendly and there's little games for kids…read morelike a big connect four etc.. The ice cream is always good and the staff is always nice.

We stopped by 16 Handles on the Fourth of July just after 9:00 p.m., and it was such a great first…read moreexperience! The three young men working were all so friendly and had such positive attitudes, especially considering they were working on a holiday. They were welcoming and made sure we knew we could sample any of the flavors. We loved that they had dairy free and vegan options, and the topping selection was incredible. Everything was fresh, especially the whipped cream, which was so good! The topping bar was spotless, and the entire store was very clean and well maintained. The frozen yogurt was delicious, and we'll definitely be back! We enjoyed it all so much that we had eaten most of it before we realized we forgot to take pictures, so we're definitely going to have to take them next time we're there.

My daughter was craving ice cream and I've always driven past. This used to be a taco stand called…read moreLa Placita and it was surely missed but glad it became a frozen yogurt place and not an empty space. They have indoor and outdoor seating with a patio on the side. Cute place to hang out at night. Loved the variety of flavors. My daughter made her own Neapolitan frozen yogurt and I decided to get the original tart since I miss the frozen Greek yogurt in Miami. It's pretty comparable except a bit icier and not as creamy but still satisfies that craving. Will have to come back when we are in the area.

I've been here multiple times already and every time I come there are only like 5 options. They…read morealso don't change the options enough for the 5 options reasonable. The good part about this place is the variety of toppings they have laid out for us to choose from!!! So many options! Just not in the frozen yogurt... The people that work the cash register have not once greeted me or addressed any concerns I've had. They just talk to each other and ring me up. There seems to be no training in customer service. I will say, that each time I've gone to the bathroom here, it is quite clean! I often come back because it's the closest place to me with decent frozen yogurt, but I've been to better frozen yogurt places.

Won't be coming back to this location. I asked about a promo they had, and the manager stood there…read morenext to the employee and just stared at me and my kids the whole time like we were in the wrong place. It was honestly weird and uncomfortable. She even kept watching us after we walked away. The ice cream selection was pretty limited and scarce. Skip this place for the overall experience. Overall, we left with cold ice cream and cold stares.

I sell ice cream so of course I had to stop in here. What a really great place. Welcoming staff,…read moreclean, nice vibe, and put on a great presentation. If you live in the area give this place a try you will not be disappointed

So nice to have a new ice cream place to try. It's located next to the vape shop so there no sign…read moreon the marquis yet. But follow the address numbers and you'll be fine if you enter by the Starbucks. They have meals, as well as pastry type desserts like cupcakes, etc. plus the ice cream. If you get the ice cream, there are cups and cones and lots of topping choices. We just got a couple small cups, but they were quite full of ice cream scoops. He tried their pistachio and I tried the coffee flavor. Both were quite good. There weren't that many choices of flavors, but the toppings -- all sorts of them -- make for interesting combos. There were several families enjoying a treat should we were there. Service was friendly. And helpful (you can taste flavors if you wish). I'm sure we will be back again when we need an ice cream fix.