La Tolteca should have 5 stars across the board!! I LOVE THE FOOD. Honestly I could eat those chicken chimichangas every day and not get sick of them. And their chicken tortilla soup is to die for. This is far and away my fav Mexican restaurant. Service is great, they get you in quick and are lovely and provide wonderful service. Will be back!!! read more

No complaints. The food is really great. I got a burrito bowl with chicken and then I recommend getting a side of corn and guacamole to really take the dish to the next level. Our waiter, Jared was very kind and attentive. read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Burrito Bowl - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

The dinner crowd last night was surprisingly slow. People staying home because of the upcoming storm? Well service was quick & friendly. The chips & salsa we started with were fresh. My friends both ordered the $5 margarita special & I ordered a beer, a dos equis. We all ended up ordering the same thing, carnitas. That never happens! Anyhow, I've somehow never had that before. The pork was pull apart tender & flavored so we'll. The rest of the dish was typical rice & beans. No bad, just nothing special. I really enjoyed the pork but will most likely go back to my normal fajita order. Overall good meal & great service. 2024-100 read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Today's special - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

Stopped in for lunch on the day before Cinco de Mayo. There's plenty of parking in the lot of this former Perkins on Transit Road. All the signage was up and they were expecting a good crowd . I met friends who arrived before me so, there were warm chips and salsa on the table when I sat. The waitress was quick to bring me a margarita and a menu. We ordered some guacamole and queso blanco for the chips as well. The guacamole was delicious and had a nice fresh taste. The queso was good and as expected. I ordered the enchiladas supreme which was one each chicken, beef, bean and cheese. All four were good but the chicken had the best taste while the beef could have used a little more flavor. There are many lunch specials that feature the most wanted items at a savings. Everyone was pleased with the lunch. The service was great! I have eaten here before. It's standard fare in an American/Mexican restaurant. No real surprises in this clean and comfortable restaurant. read more

This was my very first time here, I loved the vibrant colors and art, even the booths were beautiful. This place was soo good, my new favorite Mexican spot. Even our server was kind and attentive. The steak fajitas were so good, steak was flavored well, and melt in your mouth. Amazing. The veggies were delicious. My husband got a burrito with carnitas, the carnitas were seasoned very well, and meat was tender. The coconut margarita tasted tropical, I could have swore I was on the beach with every sip. This place was top notch! read more

See all

I thought I left a review here before. This is our favorite restaurant. The molcajete is amazing. It is enough to feed the whole family though it is meant for two people. It gets crazy busy on Friday and Saturday but the rest of the week you get in pretty quickly. The staff is friendly and do a great job. read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Molcajete - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Forever my original favorite when I come back home to visit. The pico de gallo is addictive, as is the queso, and the Burritos Deluxe is my go-to. You cannot beat the lunch specials and the fresh food, friendly staff, and decorative ambiance. read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Speedy Gonzalez lunch - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

I love love love it here. This place is always busy, but somehow has room for my party. The place is full, but never too loud to hear the conversation at the table. The chips and salsa are FREE!! So of course we splurge and get queso for the table. It's nothing spectacular, but it gets the job done! My glass stays full and my food comes fast. I am a creature of habit and get the same thing every time, but it never disappoints. I get the original tacos, soft shell, with chicken, and double rice. read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Chips, salsa, queso, double rice, original chicken tacos, and a steak burrito - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

I've been coming to this place for a few years now and I always end up ordering the Hawaiian fajitas - they stuff a half pineapple with your choice of shrimp, chicken, or both! I remember they used to have a steak option too, but I bet you could still ask for it. The portion size is huge and they really fill up that pineapple. Because of some food sensitivities, my plate looks a little different with just mushroom and zucchini and pineapple, but it usually comes with bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, zucchini, and pineapple. My boyfriend decided to try the Texas fajitas this time and he loved them - the portion was big and he said they were delicious, but he still prefers the Hawaiian one. Our food came out hot and tasty, and we were very satisfied. We went on a Tuesday evening around 5:30, so it wasn't too crowded. Another group came in a bit later and they seemed like regulars - they were friends with our server and having a blast. It was definitely a fun taco Tuesday vibe! The decor and atmosphere here give off a super fun Mexican party feel. Our server was fine, did what he needed to do. I'll definitely be returning here in the future for more good food and vibes. Can't wait! read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Hawaiian Fajitas (modified) - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

As a Western New Yorker who lives 5 miles away from the Batavia Downs Casino ,when I'm in Buffalo this is my favorite Mexican restaurant for the past decade da food is always good , I usually get a GRANDE chicken burrito or shrimp fajitas they are delicious . The staff is friendly and helpful NEVER had a bad meal so I give it 5 stars ,highly recommend this place!! read more

I really liked the Mexican theme in here! Lots of neat details to look at! Service was great. Food was pretty good too. I had the carnitas with rice. I enjoyed everything. My friend enjoyed his grande burrito. I would eat here again. read more

See all

Four of us went to dinner last night to enjoy a Margarita and some food from south of border flavor. We weren't disappointed. We started out with the fresh corn chips and tasty salsa to enjoy with our lime and mango margaritas. Then three of us ordered enchiladas which was served with the expected beans and rice. We each enjoyed a different variety from chicken to an especially tasty Tecas enchilada that was a vegetarian delight with poblanos, onions and corn covered with enchilada sauce and cheese. Our fourth diner ordered pork tamales and was very satisfied with the flavor. For dessert we shared a flan which one of our diners, more experienced in Mexican cuisine, said was very authentic. The service was top notch and the ambiance was colorful and fun. The impossibly varied menu definitely calls for a return visit. read more

Nice colorful decor. Large menu of choices. Service was good and quick. Large portions. Complimentary chips and tasty salsa. read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

It's decent, but not a place I personally would pick to go for Mexican food. We had a family gathering and La Tolteca was picked by my younger brother. Free chips & salsa come out to your table complimentary, which is nice &from my experience pretty standard at dine in Mexican restaurants. But, the salsa was pretty bland. My older brother ordered queso because he doesn't like salsa, and it was super thin and just dripped off the chips. I ordered a shrimp & vegetable dish with a tomato based sauce. The tomato sauce tasted like canned tomato soup which was not pleasing to the palate. At least the shrimp and vegetables were well cooked. My one brother did not care for his food and the other family members (2 kids & 3 adults) said their food was good, but nothing to write home about. read more

See all

Had a visit for lunch with work folks. Attentive friendly service, you know the kind where refills are brought before you ask. I opted for a taco salad. Plentiful chips and salsa with plenty of hot sauce bottles if you needed to spice it up. Enjoyed the casual lunch experience. read more

Food was served in a timely manner and everything tasted pretty good. Waiter was friendly and attentive. Mexican themed decor is very lively, colorful and interesting to look at. Everything is clean and tidy. Prices are competitive. The portions are fair as well. read more

I went to la Tolteca for dinner last week with some girlfriends and had such a fun evening! We walked in to this cute authentic Mexican place in Buffalo and were greeted immediately by the friendly staff! We were seated immediately and just in time to order some margaritas for happy hour! We started off with some chips, salsa and queso which was delicious!!! Always a must for me when I go for Mexican! After reviewing the large menu, I decided on the enchiladas with chicken! They came also with rice and beans which was the perfect paring to my enchiladas! They were delicious! The portions were so large too that I had leftovers for lunch the next day! My mom ordered the Hawaiian fajitas which actually came in a whole pineapple! It was such a fun way to present a dinner and it looked so fancy! I loved the atmosphere and have an amazing girls night chatting and eating delicious Mexican food! I will definitely be returning to this place again! read more

See all

I don't remember specifically what the meal is called that I ordered, but it was on the lunch menu. The enchilada and rice and beans were yummy. The taco was good, but needed a sauce. The chips and salsa were good. The chips were perfectly crispy and not too oily. The salsa was fresh. Ordered guac and queso also, both were yummy. The service was quick and good. read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Place is decent and is always fairly busy. The service and food are average. I didn't mind the margaritas but they do have that slightly premix taste to them. The queso is pretty delicious but ours was had that weird "skin" chunks in it from when melted cheese gets cold. I really liked the quesadilla & chile releno but the tamale was incredibly dry. read more

Worst service ever. Got in line and was told there was 25 minute wait. We waited OVER AN HOUR and THEY DIDNT PUT US ON THE LIST. We then got seated and waited about 40 minutes for our food. Waited 20 for our waters. Got tacos, NO CHEESE! Asked for cheese, cheese took 20 minutes. Queso was looking a lot like milk. Also late. Very sad and will not be returning. read more

So, last time I hated my dinner and vowed never to come back! But, it was my son and daughter in law's birthday dinner, what could I do? Well, I was pleasantly surprised. I order chimichanga, one beef and one chicken. Usually the come as huge square mounds, these were smallish cylinders and deep fried. The were both very tasty! Service was a little slow but the place was hopping. Of course the decor is still cute Mexican. I might even come back! read more

There were 6 of us and a baby, I'm starting backwards the service was great , friendly on top of it and quick. Now the food , 3 liked it 3 didn't . I liked mine , i got the chimichangas, 1 shredded beef 1 chicken they werehot and flavorful. The refried beans were good. The 3 that disliked theirs said the chicken was bland, no spice or flavor as was the rice, they didn't eat the rice and flooded the chicken with salsa! Not going to return. read more

See all

This is the best Mexican restaurant in Buffalo! Always consistently delicious and reasonably priced! We love it here! Everyone is always so friendly and welcoming. The waiters and waitresses are attentive to your needs! It's so authentic and the decor makes you feel like you're in Mexico! read more

Food is fresh and delicious! Jared was friendly and welcoming! Knowledgeable in all suggestions on the menu. Food came popping hot! I am thinking of coming back this evening for dinner w my family! This will definitely be a good to place of favorite! read more

See all

Disclaimer: this is an older review that was stuck in my drafts. Have not been there for dine-in for about a year. I'm not sure why I haven't reviewed this place yet as it's my favorite Mexican place around! I have been coming here for years and I keep trying the new places that open but they can't compare. My only issue with here is that sometimes they are really busy. Their salsa is so fresh and the best I've had. There are also a few people that work there that have been there for a long time and always make the experience enjoyable. When I visited yesterday I thought they may have changed the menu since the last time I was there and it didn't seem as large but I always go for the chimichangas so that didn't change my review. It was so delicious I have to keep myself from going back toda read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Queso and the best salsa ever - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

La Tolteca is one of my favorite Mexican joints in the area. I came here for lunch with my mom and stepdad and we were seated right away on a Saturday. We decided to day drink and each ordered a margarita. I ordered a lime, on the rocks marg, which could have used a little more tequila. My mom had a mango marg that she enjoyed and my stepdad had a raspberry marg, which he said was ok, but he liked my mom's mango better. The chips and salsa flowed and the server was very friendly and accommodating. She brought over another serving of chips after we went through the first basket, and it was on the house. I ordered the burrito tonala, which is a complete departure from my usual order. Recently, I have been trying to kick my life up a notch and try new things. The burrito tonala had onions, peppers, mushrooms, zucchini, tomatoes and I chose chicken packed inside. It was topped with queso and green tomatillo sauce and topped with pico de gallo. It also came with rice and beans, which I love. The lunch special was large enough where after I gorged myself on chips and salsa before the meal, and then ate chips with beans, I had a couple bites of the burrito and took the rest home and had another meal with it. I can never resist the chips and beans and salsa. It is just so delicious. Would I order the burrito tonala again? I think I would. I liked the fresh taste and that it wasn't fried. My mom enjoyed her chimichanga and my stepdad enjoyed his burrito. It is always a great experience at La Tolteca. read more

See all

This place is great - fun atmosphere, huge menu, delish food and drinks. The free chips and salsa are a nice touch (just wish the chips had a tiny bit of salt....). I've never had a bad experience or meal here and I can no longer order quesadillas anywhere else as La Tolteca has THE BEST! HUGE platter with salad is enough for 2 meals or an appetizer to share. This is the best Mexican place! read more

La Tolteca is one of my favorite Mexican restaurants in WNY. Their chips and salsa and queso are delicious. Their margaritas are my #1 fav in all of WNY, specifically the frozen strawberry mango. I've tried a lot of stuff on their menu and I've never been disappointed. The Pechuga Burracha is my current go-to, highly recommend! read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Pechuga Borracha - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

The food was delicious. The Texas fajita had a lot of meat. The service was great. The atmosphere was pleasant. I would come here again. read more

See all

This place never misses! We got take-out today and everything was just as good as dining in. We always get the tricolor enchiladas & queso. Was ready super quick and was packaged great! Everything was hot and nothing leaked. The server that took my phone order [Jared N] & the bartender that cashed us out were both kind and very efficient! Thx! read more

Great food, drinks and dessert. We went here for lunch to celebrate my cousin's birthday. I didn't get a picture but you must try the Chori-Fries...chorizo covered fries! read more

See all

We had a very nice experience here. The entree portions are decent, easily enough for a second meal. My fiancé said the margarita was very good. They have a nice house salsa and decent queso blanco. The entrees were good quality and very fresh. I like their unique carved and painted furniture in the place, as well. read more

See all

This place is such a vibeeee! I've never heard of this spot but I am always in the mood for Mexican food. I started of with the guac dip with chips. Absolutely delish! The guac was flavored fantastically with a hint of lime and spice. For my entree, I opted for the camarones al mojo de ajo which came with large shrimps cooked with garlic and spices, salad, tortillas, and rice! The shrimps were cooked to perfection and I really enjoyed my meal. Overall, I would return here!!! read more

La Tolteca - Buffalo - Camarones a Mojo de Ajo - Mexican Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

This place is my go-to restaurant. When asked where I would like my birthday dinner I always request to go here, it's been that way for 4 years now. I've introduced both family and friends to this restaurant and not one person has said anything negative. Service is always friendly, food is always served warm (if you order warm food ofc) and perfectly seasoned, and everyone that's there always seems to be happy. One thing I will say is the parking looks small from transit but once you pull in there's a whole lot in the back. read more

The food was excellent! Hot and fresh. Rice and beans tasted very good. It had perfect seasonings. The service was very fast and friendly. The ambiance was traditional Mexican decorations and music. There is an open bar to sit at for drinks or snacks. Very clean, bright place. Prices are very reasonable and a children's menu as well. Good family, date night, or for just friends looking for a place to eat. Parking is located in front and back lot for free. Handicap accessible as well. read more

See all

Good food, good service but was a little surprised that a request for more service to finish the chips we had was an additional charge

Silverware was very dirty. Had old food on it from previous people. The food was not good (personal preference maybe). As soon as the waitress took our food away she asked us to either leave or go to the bar because other people were waiting. Mind you there were at least 6 other open tables and only one couple waiting. read more

Pathetic place. Sat down to eat with a group of friends. We were at our table for about 45mins and I was about halfway through my meal. Our waiter says "we are really busy and I'm going to bring you your check". I couldn't even finish my meal. That's pathetic for a restaurant. We were not sitting wasting time, we were literally still eating our meal. We were not notified before sitting down that we only had less than 45mins to eat and talk. Unacceptable. read more

Honestly this place is probably my least favorite mexican restaurant in WNY. That doesn't necessarily mean it's bad, just doesn't leave me hoping to come back over another place. I stopped in on a busy night with a friend and ordered dinner and margs. The margs were good, not sour. The queso blanco was also really good. The quesadilla I ordered wasn't really that great. The place was super crowded but our waitress was nice and prompt. Prices felt a little high compared to other mexican places but the margs were about average priced. $27 for a pitcher. read more

See all

Probably one of the best authentic Mexican restaurants in the Buffalo area. The food is always delicious and so are the drinks, whether it's a margarita or a daquiri they have just the right amount of booze! For lunch I usually get the 4 crispy tacos (2 beef & 2 chicken) with rice & beans. My wife absolutely loves the fajitas and I'm a fan as well. Chimichangas are good, enchiladas, burritos, you name it, it's good! Frozen lime margaritas, banana daquiris, Pina coladas, all delicious. read more