Wow where do I even begin! This place is the biggest hidden gem in Elk County! My family has been…read moregetting the specialty pies for the past two summers and we have all always been more than satisfied which is incredibly hard to do when feeding three different families all with different taste. I think at this point I've had every pizza here, but the wise guy, good fella, and mobsters have been my favorites. The pizzas are huge and so reasonably priced- these things are COVERED in toppings! They're also cut in a bunch of pieces instead of your typical triangular cut, so you can try a number of pies if you get multiple. I seriously cannot say enough good things about this place, a must try for anyone traveling through Weedville or the greater Elk County area on weekends in the summer months. Wish they had the ability to be open all the time but I totally understand why they aren't, especially as we emerge from the pandemic. Wish I had photos to share with you all!

Owners were very friendly! We had subs and a monster stromboli. Everything was delicious! Unique…read moreatmosphere. Definitely worth stopping in.

This is great Pizza, I missed the NY style thin crust and they have the closest I've had in a long…read moretime. The crust is excellent as well as the sauce. The atmosphere inside is like a perfect pizzeria type and the staff is incredibly nice and helpful. I highly recommend this place if you enjoy pizza, calzones....they even Sicilian style and White Pizza. Yum.

Took the grandkids here. They loved it. And so did I! I will be coming back. Thank you Napoli's.read more

Food and service was great! 16th Anniversary and we even…read morereceived a free deep pan pepperoni pizza.

We gave the restaurant another chance when we were in town. We were immediately seated, the food…read morewas great and arrived promptly. The waitress was attentive and checked on our table frequently. Everyone can have an off day, and this visit shows how well they respond to any issues. I'm pleased we have our favorite place to eat back.

Came in at 2pm, it was pretty dead. Got seated right away and waited on quickly. The waitress was…read morevery pleasant and it was very quiet inside. I got a sriracha bourbon burger which the sauce on it is great, and a perfectly cooked thick burger. The Bun for all our meals were the same and definitely could be upgraded. My daughter had a barbecue chicken sandwich which she said was a 6.9 out of 10. It was actually really good, but that bun again. My wife had a brisket pulled pork sandwich which was really good and huge but that dang bun again. They have a barbecue sauce on the table that is unbelievable, warning it has a little bite to it. Pretty close to the best barbecue sauce anywhere. Biggest downside was those pesky buns and the normal French fries are flavorless and would never get again, especially when the sweet potato fries are fantastic and the Carmel dip for them is great. Almost snuck down to a 3 star but could easily be a 5 star with a few small changes. So close to perfect on different levels. Will come back in the future to check it out again for sure.

One of the only restaurants in Penfield, PA, this charming BBQ restaurant is a good stop for those…read moretraveling through the area. I know that the restaurant originally started as a food truck/BBQ pit and grew into the restaurant today. I've spoken to friends and family who have eaten here before me, and they all rate the food as "pretty good!". I ordered a pulled pork sandwich and my fiance ordered a brisket sandwich. My pulled pork was pretty standard. They provided a squeeze bottle of BBQ sauce to top my pork with. My fiancé's brisket sandwich was somewhat unexpected. Instead of being thick slabs of meat, the brisket was shredded like pulled pork. There was really long strands of meat in his sandwich that he could wind around his fork like spaghetti. I'm not a BBQ expert to know if this is normal or acceptable, but it just seemed odd. Overall the BBQ taste was great. The menu didn't state that the sandwiches came with a side of potato chips, so when the waitress asked if we wanted fries or onion rings, we decided to split some. When the food arrived, I had potato chips in my basket and my fiance had 4 onion rings in his basket. Unfortunately the onion rings were EXTREMELY greasy and we chose not to eat them out of fear of an upset stomach while we were traveling. I also learned after this visit that one of the owners is also the waitress, a curly blonde woman. Our encounters with her were just...awkward. There's a sign at the front door that said Please Wait to be seated. My fiance and I waited at the door. There was only one other table seated in the entire restaurant. After an awkward amount of time, she told us to pick one of the booths (I guess we weren't allowed a table?). She handed us the menus and then awkwardly stared at us. I broke the silence by ordering a drink. Later in the meal, she came over to grab my finance's cup to refill it and just clearly stared at me until I offered up mine too. She was weird. I hope they find a real waitress soon. The two sandwiches, two Diet Pepsi, and the "shared" onion rings came to $38 including tip. The prices seemed high for the area and for BBQ. Would I come here again? Yes. Would it be my first option? No.

Enjoyed some hot out of the oven tasty pizza! The ingredients were fresh, beer options were…read moreabundant, and the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. Highly recommend, especially if you have kids and/or a hankering for some yummy local brews while enjoying the rail car vibes or deck views. Great spot for dinosaur lovers too.

I agree with all previous 15 posters. Great pizza great price in Rail Car! Yes I would return and…read morerecommend

Everyone raves about their pizza! So I finally got to try some ! Was perfectly cooked , sauce…read moredelicious ... everything you want your pizza to be! My mom has special memories of her dad bringing home pizza from here when he was done working at the mines! I was happy they have half baked pizzas frozen that I could get and bring home for her.

Not as good as it used to be. Got the appetizers and pizza at the same time after a long waitread more

Delicious pizza !! Small an quaint.. They only make pizza & stromboli's. But they do it right !!…read moreOnly carry out an NO credit cards accepted. Only open Closed Monday thru Wednesday. Seems like a lot just for pizza no cc, only carry out, closed 3 days a wk, an when open closes by 9 or 10pm. HOWEVER......Well Worth it, to go by a have a taste, u will not regret it !!!!!!! Must find & try if in the area. Family & workers very nice.

While Mabel's isn't as charming as it once was it remains a staple for Clearfield. Not the best…read morepizza by far but the value remains and specializing in slices versus whole pies is a great advantage over the other offerings in town. If you're ever in Daytona Beach go to Panheads which is a full restaurant and bar and a very different experience but still Mabel's pizza.

I'm a native NY'r and somewhat a Pizza/ Italian foody…read more Stopped here a few weeks ago and had lunch with a friend. We had Italian Heros and the were delish. Place is cute & clean, and feels like a NY pizzaria. I'm always skeptical when I see a restaurant with a NY or Italian name, so many places just pick a "fun name" that associates to Italians or NY because we are Known for great food. We met the owner and his daughter. He is originally from NY or Jersey, I forget....non the less.....same thing in my eyes. His family descents are from Italy. I enjoyed a great sandwich and a friendly conversation with a fellow paesano about the "old land"....NY and Italy. I will def be going back, and pizza is on my list to try next.

Stopped here on way to a cabin from Pittsburgh area. Staff were great and offered suggestions…read morearound the area. Recipes are noticeably original. We tried the cheese curds and fried mac & cheese which were good portions to not get stuffed on. The hawaiian pizza with jalapeños was amazing!! One the best I tried with jalapeño juice cooked into just to die for! Highly recommend nice small shop in a little town.