While Mabel's isn't as charming as it once was it remains a staple for Clearfield. Not the best pizza by far but the value remains and specializing in slices versus whole pies is a great advantage over the other offerings in town. If you're ever in Daytona Beach go to Panheads which is a full restaurant and bar and a very different experience but still Mabel's pizza. read more

Passing through PA on a cross-country winter trip, checked local options and Mabel's was near the top of the list. It's tucked away in a residential neighborhood and a clear local favorite! Is it the best pizza in the Alpha Quadrant? It's up there! They were likely slammed by Super Bowl orders and still managed to provide great service and a great square pie with a perfectly crispy crust. Cash only. Love the order window. Bravo! read more

Mabel's Pizza Shop - Mabel's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Clearfield, Pennsylvania

Great pizza They said to pickup in 45 minutes but it took a hour Limited parking Great pizza read more

So I'm not usually writing a review after one visit to an establishment but this time I'll make an exception. I was working in the area and asked for a recommendation on any restaurants that were good. I was working with 8 or so people and I couldn't get a recommendation., so I turns to Yelp and saw Mabel's. They mentioned it wasn't open at our lunchtime. I had some shopping to do after work so I decided to try it for dinner. I am going to say it was the best square cut pizza I've had outside of NEPA ( north eastern Pennsylvania ) if you know you know that's a pretty bold statement. I ordered the white pizza with tomatoes. No toppings . It was perfect, crispy dough with a great dough to cheese ratio. I can't wait to make it back to try the red pizza. The Service was great. Do not let the humble, store front fool you this place is a hidden gem, you won't regret finding. read more

Wow! This pizza was reallllllly good! Ordered a veggie pizza and a cheese pizza. Even the plain cheese pizza was flavorful and crust was fresh and delicious! It was worth the wait! read more

Mabel's Pizza Shop - Pizza Near Me - Clearfield, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in the world. Crust is wonderful. Owner is great along with worker. Always busy and it's a long wait but worth it

Mabel's is the best pizza in Central Pennsylvania. It's a little out of the way, but well worth the effort to order and pickup. You might have to wait on your phone to get through to this very busy shop, and you may need to wait outside, but you will be rewarded. It's clean and safe, a pleasant place to visit (Clearfield's historic East End.) read more

Great pizza and perfect crust. The only downside is remembering to have cash for when that pizza craving hits.

There are only 2 places in Clearfield for me that I like their pizza, Mabels is the first, Scott's is the second. They both run neck in neck. Great pizza! read more

I was looking for a quick bite while traveling thru PA. I checked yelp for local places to eat while getting gas. Mabel's had good reviews so we headed there, it's a little off the beat and path , near an industrial area. It was take out only and there were a decent number of people getting their pies or slices. I ordered two slices and the price was very reasonable including an extra topping . The crust was nice and crispy, kind of like a thinner Sicilian crust. The slices are not huge but it was good . You walk up to a takeout window and place your order read more

Fantastic pizza and friendly staff. Will go back again and again. Large portion for a full pizza but great for Lucy the next day! Can't wait. read more

Best Pizza , hometown atmosphere! Service is friendly and courteous! Just the best in every way!

Delicious pizza !! Small an quaint.. They only make pizza & stromboli's. But they do it right !! Only carry out an NO credit cards accepted. Only open Closed Monday thru Wednesday. Seems like a lot just for pizza no cc, only carry out, closed 3 days a wk, an when open closes by 9 or 10pm. HOWEVER......Well Worth it, to go by a have a taste, u will not regret it !!!!!!! Must find & try if in the area. Family & workers very nice. read more

Mabel's Pizza Shop - Small quaint most delicious pizza I've had in a long while !! 5 stars an 2 thumbs up !!! - Pizza Near Me - Clearfield, Pennsylvania

I love Mabel's Pizza! They have great toppings and a terrific sauce and crust! Delicious and satisfying! Try Mabel's Pizza Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday 4-10!!! read more

Mediocre pie. Not much in the way of toppings. Mushrooms ... from cans? A square pizza? Can't be bothered with extra sauce. The owner is a condescending jerk who I've only met once and who says my name disapprovingly because I was outed as a "dissenter" of klan-like town of Clearfield in the "time before," which is past because no future here. Concept of present not to be mentioned. Too racy. Anyway, I simply cannot think of this man's name because it is of no importance in my life other than in this candid, hidden diary-post I dare keep. Some context: I was cast out because I cared enough to share my God honest opinion about something completely benign, an ad on beloved FOX News that has been replaying since 1989 and which sells fraudulent collector coins to swindle older viewers out of their retirement. I guess the post shattered the entire town's already broken, fragile idea of what reality is. I only posted that it was a scam, not a sound investment, much like my Mabel's pizza, scant on sauce, just OK IMO. It should be made known that the owner only does business with locals and is not taking new customers at this time. Doesn't answer phone when it gets busy and will tell you as much over the phone, just so you are aware. Rude insider of collective conscious otherwise known as groupthink that is hardly conscious because it's a small commune of Trumpers who feel it safer to not question anything, like their beloved FOX Newspeak. I believe it was made known via Gant Daily that Clearfield is to indulge in an 8-minute hate of Barack Hussein Obama each morning before life purpose, menial labor, during a daily book burning bonfire and Fourth Reich youth in the making. In any news, I will be taking my business elsewhere because dough man now refers to me by order number, not name and landline phone number that he memorized for no particular reason other than to unknow me. read more

Excellent place for excellent pizza. Best pizza that I have ever had in my entire life

Driving back to NY from OH, Mabel's is worth a short detour off I-80. Crisp, square, pan pizza with excellent dough, punchy oregano in the tomato sauce, and nicely browned cheese on top. So satisfying on the rest of the drive! Don't let the folksy pick-up window on the porch of a house fool you - if this were in DUMBo, there would be a line around the block. P.S. cash only read more

Really great pizza. They are also very affordable. They make the pizza fresh for you. read more

Best pizza we have in our local area it's a staple if you visit the small town of Clearfield extremely busy place so keep dialing until you get an answer but well worth the wait read more

Greatest pizza in the area! Unique crust sets it apart from all others. Sort of like a pizza and a croissant had a child.

The pizza comes through a slot in a plastic sheet hanging from the doorway of what looks a beat up old house in residential neighborhood. I guess this is NY pan style pizza, so you order it by the cut or square. It's a no frills cash only operation, but the pizza was pretty good. read more

Ordered three pizzas and they were awful. No sauce, over baked, and mostly ended up in the garbage. The white pizzas literally were so over seasoned and the pepperoni pizza was so dried out. We traveled over an hour round trip and I won't be back. read more

I've taken New York City Pizza Tours, Chicago Deep Dish tours and all the rest...loved it all. Honestly though, I would put Mabel's at the top of the list. It is unique in it's own category of pizza: a light airy crust that is crispy on the bottom. Delicious sauce and cheese and always cooked to perfection. I've eaten here for decades and never once had a bad experience. One time, I thought my friend ordered my pizza with his. We drove 20 minutes over to Mabels and it turns out he accidentally did not place my order. Brad still served me a pie, even though I am positive it set him behind as they are always extremely busy, (BTW, call ahead for sure or you will wait due to their phone ringing off the hook for A+ pizza.) They take care of their customers and always make every pizza with maximum effort and care. read more

Be advised they do not take credit cards, and food is strictly for take out. Food is excellent!

Best pizza in clearfield, sold by the slice or by the pie. perfectly balanced in sweetness with an authentic, crunchy crust. Must check out, whether it's a quick snack or a family dinner. read more

They may be good business people but terrible humans. Their dog attack my tiny Min Pin leaving a deep puncture wound with sepsis where his scrotum use to be. It ripped out canine tooth. The front left leg has nerve & tissue damage. The did nothing to help, she walked away and didn't check on him. The rules don't apply to the wealthy read more

Love! Love! This pizza recipe has a long history in Clearfield. The crust is chewy with just the right amount of sauce to give you mushy goodness! Excellent! read more

We stopped by on Friday evening. We were driving back from Erie to Allentown and stopped in Clearfield for the night (we visited the Elk Country Visitor Center prior).......my wife found Mabel's through Yelp! Mabel's is out of the way - so you won't find this on "Main St" - but well worth putting in your GPS and seeking it out!! The slices are modest - so have them show you - or order more than you think...... GREAT PIZZA! affordable......and very nice ownership/staff (family). when we arrived they had sold out for the night - so don't wait to get your order in....... Delicious, We'll be back on our next pass through.......we generally stop at the PSU Berkey Creamery too! read more

Best Pizza in Clearfield County PA. Generous sizes fresh meats and when you ask for extra they are not skimpy. We order from them at least 2x per month. No indoor eating it's always been takeout. Good pricing and friendly staff and service. read more

Perfect place to get a takeout pizza for dinner if you are traveling on route 80 across PA. They were extremely friendly, it was inexpensive and very tasty. We took our pizza to a little park next to the library and police station down the road by the river and ate at a pavilion covered picnic bench. The play ground was clean and kids played after eating pizza. Great way to take a short break from a road trip. read more

Mabel's Pizza Shop - a volleyball court and picnic area - Pizza Near Me - Clearfield, Pennsylvania

Great pizza! Nice people. Only open Thursday through Sunday and do not accept credit cards. Carry out only. Totally worth it! read more

Love, love, love this pizza. Quite unique and I try to get it every time my wife and I are in town. Mild pepper rings and sausage are my personal favorite toppings. read more

We love Mabel's pizza! Brad always makes the best pizza and stromboli's! The wait is well worth it.

I am a pizza fanatic and this is by far the BEST pizza I've ever had! The crust is like no other! The sauce is tasty! Overall just delicious! The price is unbeatable! The pick up times they give you when you call in are accurate! The staff are friendly and efficient! All around a 5 star place! read more

So, it turns out the best pizza in the world isn't in Naples. It's not in Brooklyn either. Or New Haven, Detroit or Jersey City. It's in Clearfield PA? A small town off I-80 that I had to have stopped in a dozen times on the run from NYC to Detroit and back. Rectangular pies, a Sicilian/Detroit style hybrid is the best way in can describe it. But oh my goodness, this crust is addictive. The toppings are fairly vanilla, but don't worry, it's probably for the better. This isn't a pizza that needs gimick or frills to deliver. If you find yourself on the road near Clearfield during their open hours, this detour is WELL worth it. read more

One of the best pizzas I've had in awhile. Their dough is awesome. Holds shape, not doughy in the middle, and just the right amount of crispiness. read more

I luuuurve this pizza. Anytime I come back to the "Field" I have to get Mabel's. They do not deliver. They do sell by the slice... Which is so awesome. I called ahead and my order was ready ahead of schedule. I'm not entirely sure what it is that makes me so crazy about it... Maybe it's the light, airy dough. Maybe it's the lightly sauced, heavily cheesed goodness of it. Maybe it's the weirdly, undercooked pepperoni. Who knows. All I know is that it's amazing and I'm taking a bag of frozen Mabel's with me to Washington. If you are in the "'Field" get you some Mabel's... It's amazeballs. read more

Mabel's Pizza Shop - This is where the magic happens! - Pizza Near Me - Clearfield, Pennsylvania

See all

Every town has the "you've gotta go here, I grew up on this stuff" pizza shop. This is clearfields... and it's pretty darn good. Nothing fancy-- just good pizza, to go. read more

This pizza is ALWAYS mouth watering, and very addicting. The only downer is there's always a wait.

Mabel's has by far the most unique pizza I've ever had in Clearfield or any other place I have lived. (There are quite a few places too.) The crust is unique-crispy yet chewy-with delicious sauce and the right amount of cheese. Their white pizza is also delicious. The staff and owner are very polite and courteous even when they are swamped. (That is most of the time they are open.) read more