Eric at Watchtower Comics provides a great comic shop experience. The store is well-kept, and…read moreEric's expertise and friendliness really stand out. There's a solid selection of comics and collectibles, and the prices are reasonable. It's definitely a place worth visiting!

...a compact establishment with some really great books. Graded and raw so something for everybody…read more It does have some fungos which I believe is overtaking most comic book stores but the books are what is highlighted here. I'll be back...

Trip Review 15.5( 16 but I like the name better ). All…read moreAmerican Cards and Comics - Boardman, OH (52 Boardman Canfield Rd.) Greg's 2nd location. All American Cards and Comics in Boardman is a fantastic extension of the Warren location--think of it less as a carbon copy and more like Warren's little brother with its own distinct charm. Housed in a convenient strip mall, it's a bit more compact, but that actually works in its favor. The layout is streamlined, clean, and incredibly well-organized, making it easy to browse whether you're hunting for back issues, the latest comics, Magic: The Gathering singles, or gaming supplies. While it may not have the same size as the Warren location, this shop holds its own with a focused selection and top-notch customer service. Every major purchase I've made from owner Greg Bartholomew has come from this very store, and the quality has always been outstanding. Most recently, I picked up a pristine copy of All-Star Comics featuring the first appearance of Power Girl. One major highlight is the adjacent gaming annex. Instead of cramming tables into the retail space, they've dedicated a separate area next door for gaming. This keeps the main store open, easy to navigate, and free of clutter--perfect for collectors and casual browsers alike. Whether you're a Magic player looking for rare cards, a comic collector searching for that elusive issue, or just someone who appreciates a well-run local shop, this location is definitely worth a visit. And don't forget--they're always buying Magic cards and comics too, so bring your extras! Greg Bartholomew

I've been shopping and playing card at All American since the early 2000's. It is a friendly and…read moresafe place for gamers of all ages. They have events for different TCG's (I personally know about MtG) and TTRPG's (D&D bi weekly) (Warhammer 40k). So weather your a Pokemon Master, Planeswalker, Battle Hardened General, or just D&D Character who violates the Geneva Conventions. There is something for the nerd in you.

They are simply "the BEST! I've shopped only this Christian store for many years. Love it. Always…read morefind the perfect selection of gifts. If I don't find something, they take time to try to get it in store for me!! Debe V.

Great place for all things religious. Definitely a hidden little gem! The service was great and…read moreeverything is affordable.

Trip Review 15 All American Cards and Comics…read more All American Cards and Comics (Downtown Warren Location) If you grew up in Northeast Ohio in the '90s and were into Magic: The Gathering, you probably already know this place--or at least the vibe it gives off. All American Cards and Comics in downtown Warren isn't just a comic shop--it's a piece of hometown history, built and maintained by the unofficial mayor of Warren himself, Greg Bartholomew. Though it's changed locations slightly over the years, it's still planted firmly in the heart of downtown Warren, and the magic (no pun intended) has never left. If I were to open my dream comic shop, it would look just like this one: a charming old brick façade opening into a space packed wall-to-wall with everything a fan could dream of--Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Pokémon, action figures, Funko Pops, D&D manuals, tabletop games, and comics galore. And we're not just talking modern comics--this place is loaded with back issues from the Bronze Age, Silver Age, and even Gold, not to mention pristine wall books in glass cases that will stop you in your tracks. The Alex Ross prints decorating the walls are just the cherry on top. If you ever get the chance to peek into the back room--do it. It's a treasure trove of books that haven't hit the shelves yet or are prepped for upcoming cons. Greg knows his stuff and keeps the shop stocked and vibrant. New comic book day every Wednesday? Yep, they've got that too. All American Cards and Comics in Warren is a cornerstone of comic culture in the Mahoning Valley, a must-visit for anyone who loves comics, games, and that old-school shop atmosphere where community still matters. And once you've stopped here, make sure to head about a half hour over to their Youngstown location too--it's worth the trip. Support the old guard. Visit All American.

By far the best place to buy comics around and it's not even close, they have a wide selection of…read morewhatever you're looking for at pretty reasonable prices and the guys there will help you out if you're looking something in particular, 10/10

I had no idea this store was even opening in the same building as Coach's in Salem, we happened to…read moresee it when we went there for dinner earlier in the week. Just stopped in to see what they were about since we were kind of on a limited time schedule for eating. Awesome selection, a neat and appealing showroom, and friendly staff. Will definitely go back again as they have some retro video games like Sega Genesis and Star Wars collectibles that have some interest for me personally. Wishing the owners and the new business the best of luck!

It's a nice flea market and they have a lot of unique items you just have to go there and see…read morewhat's in each alcove.

Love Love Love this Place!!! I Try to make it out at least once a month. Prices are very very…read morereasonable (they're non goodwill thrift-like). I rarely leave empty handed. The staff and the 3 pups are always very welcoming! Here's a lil tip, don't avoid the attic. I've found tons of treasures up there!! :)

Charming little book shop. Lots of neat books. They also had lovely jewelry and incense…read more The gentleman was very friendly and helpful.

What a charming little book shop! Very friendly service, loads of character, and pinball games…read moreright outside of the shop!

Great place - they sell everything from vintage to handmade. The service is excellent too and it's…read morenice to chat with the owner. I always end up getting a few treasures and he prices are great. Highly recommend!