Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    LI Toy & Game

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 6:00 PM

    LI Toy & Game Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - LI Toy & Game

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Great selection of new and vintage. Friendly service. Very competitive prices. Bill always a pleasure to deal with

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - LI Toy & Game

    You might also consider

    The Uncommons - Frose and ale

    The Uncommons

    4.2(440 reviews)
    40.4 miGreenwich Village
    $

    Very kind workers! So many games, they assisted with finding a games and purchasing the best fit…read morefor us. Drink options are great as well. Space is very small but cozy.

    I love board game cafes! So I was excited to try out this place after finding it listed on two…read moredifferent NYC blogs. First, if you're planning to come here on the weekend, RESERVE YOUR SPOT ONLINE AHEAD OF TIME!!! And I'll tell you why... My friends and I decided on Friday afternoon that we wanted to come here the next day (Saturday). Me, being the planning-type person that I am, immediately hopped onto their website. I found a tab for "reservations", so I checked it out as I had a feeling that they might be pretty busy on the weekend. Sure enough, for our group of 6, they only had availability between 11am and 4:45pm or at 9pm. That was it! We were hoping for an evening slot, but we all decided to settle on the 4:45pm slot and just go have dinner afterwards. Before continuing, it's important to note that each person pays $17 for unlimited use of the board games for a 3-hour duration. When booking online, you have to pay for the entire group's "game time pay" up front in order to get the reservation. So, since it was 6 of us, I went ahead and paid $102 to secure our spot. **They are clear that they do NOT do refunds so make sure you can actually make the time slot you are booking!! Upon arrival, we gave them my name and they showed us to our reserved table. They gave us some quick instructions on what to do with the games when we were done with them, then they left us to have fun! So why is a reservation important? Because I can't tell you how many people we watched get turned away because they showed up and the place was already at max capacity! Our table happened to be right in front of both the door and the counter, so we watched a constant flow of people walk in and then immediately walk back out. Another important thing to note is that they don't allow outside food or drinks, but they also don't serve food... They have coffee drinks available to order as well as a few smoothie options and bottled/canned beverages. Additionally, they had some bagged chips and a few pastries, but that was it. So if you book a slot during dinner or lunchtime, you might want to ensure you eat beforehand as you won't be eating a meal here. The setup inside was a little chaotic. Very crowded with little space between the tables. Also, the staff seemed to not really care to want to be there. They weren't really attentive to the patrons there nor to each other, for that matter. At one point, the trash can was overflowing and I watched one staff member struggle with it and yelling for help but no one came to assist her... Final verdict: If you love board games, definitely come check this place out!!! Reserve your spot ahead of time and bring at least 3-5 people with you for maximum enjoyment!

    Photos
    The Uncommons - Monopoly in progress

    Monopoly in progress

    The Uncommons
    The Uncommons - Exterior

    See all

    Exterior

    Highlander Games - Gaming Lounge next door

    Highlander Games

    4.8(4 reviews)
    60.4 mi

    I have been stopping at a board game shop in every town I have been visiting. This was the best one…read morenear Parsippany, NJ we were visiting for a convention. This was in Booton, NJ, on the way back to Syracuse, NY. The shop was a large room with tables for open gaming and tournaments, and the walls were lined with merchandise for sale--ranging from board games to trading cards. There was plenty of light, and the people playing Magic towards the back were very friendly and welcoming. The gentleman behind the counter was very nice! The coolest part is you can ask for the secret password, based on a quest posted outside the space down the road a little bit, and you can get into the Gaming Lounge addition. When you go in to the Gaming Lounge, it feels like you're stepping into some kind of hobbit hole, and the further back you go, the more space there is to play games with friends. There is even a fireplace! The space is super cozy and features a huge wall of games to play with friends. If I lived anywhere near by, I would go to this shop all the time! The cards they sold were even reasonably priced, so I also love that.

    I felt welcomed, the place is clean, and for a Saturday afternoon during COVID, the place was…read morehopping! But I've definitely seen places with a bigger selection and more game knowledge. The shopkeeper listened intently while I told him what kind of gaming experience I was looking for. But it didn't go a lot farther than that. I wanted something narratively heavy, with less rule complexity and overhead than Lord of the Rings: Journeying through Middle Earth. He didn't really have an answer for me, and I felt I gave him a lot to work off of. To give you an idea how small this place is - the pictures in this review represent half the games in the store. There's one extra bookshelf that I didn't catch and there's a display case in front with CCG cards. Shopping experience aside, you can tell this place has a good community. There were four tables occupied in the back around 4 PM on a Saturday - maybe representing 10 people - and there's a big communal shelf you can draw from if you want to play in house. I'd come back to play and make new friends.

    Photos
    Highlander Games - Gaming Lounge next door

    Gaming Lounge next door

    Highlander Games - Gaming Lounge next door

    Gaming Lounge next door

    Highlander Games

    See all

    Cottontails of Stony Brook Inc - Cottontails has been serving the community with quality children's specialty apparel, accessories, books & toys for 30 years!

    Cottontails of Stony Brook Inc

    2.0(21 reviews)
    6.1 mi

    This beautiful shop is found in Stony Brook. It is filled with high quality stylish children's…read moreclothing. It is rather upscale but they also do have sales. I went to return a sweater that my Grandson had received due to sizing. The return was late but, they still allowed me to return it.The staff could not have been more polite or helpful. I decide to look for a Special outfit for an upcoming event. There so many sweet outfits to choose from.The woman laid out pieces on the counter to help me compare to one another. She spent about a half hour helping to find one that would be perfect. Very few stores offer this kind of personal service anymore. It was a lovely experience and I will definitely return.

    If I could give this place zero stars I would! I came in with my MIL to buy a few things for my 10…read moremonth old. One of the items didn't have a tag so they spent about 15 minutes trying to "find" it in the system. When they couldn't find it and my son was getting fussy we suggested that they ring up the exact same item that has a different pattern, they said no and they would contact the owner and I could drive back if I wanted it. I explained I live in NYC and could not come back. They were so condescending and rude and said "This is a business, we have policies. You don't make up whatever rules suit you". So nasty. Ended up not buying any of the 4 overpriced outfits we picked and left. I will never come back to this place. All the reviews are correct. The staff is disgusting and they're overpriced. DO NOT GIVE THIS PLACE ANY BUSINESS. THEY DO NOT APPRECIATE THEIR CUSTOMERS OR GIVE PEOPLE BASIC RESPECT!

    Photos
    Cottontails of Stony Brook Inc
    Cottontails of Stony Brook Inc
    Cottontails of Stony Brook Inc - Gift basket for a newborn baby girl

    See all

    Gift basket for a newborn baby girl

    LI Toy & Game - toys - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...