This is a great store. I can't believe some absolute jabroni wrote a negative review because of…read moretheir lighting being too good. And, I'm sorry, if you can't figure out parking in this area, you are an absolute idiot. Great store. Great website. Staff is very helpful, but also happy to let you browse on your own. Support small local businesses! Don't be like Matthew C.!

Awesome comic store just off of Main Street in Sayerville…read more The store is decent sized and the young lady working there was very pleasant. They have a decent selection of mostly newer comics and toys as well. They did have some vintage Star Wars toys and some other vintage stuff too but they mostly have more recent comics and toys. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in the area

Brought my Pokémon psycho son in, and the GREAT guy there both knew Everything about Pokémon packs…read moreetc, but when we bought one of them special $11 packs and pulled something which is apparently a great card, the guy (Nathan? I'm sorry I'm bad with names but you're the man!) and my son celebrated TOGETHER. Like, this guy was TRULY happy for my kid, and exciting him even more about it. So much so, my kid asked to take a pic with him and the "awesome pull"

Great selection. Lots of sports cards. Staff is really helpful. Answered all our questions and let…read moreus take our time checking out all the cards. They were very knowledgeable and were super nice. We had a great experience shopping here.

Had a great time rummaging through a vast selection of action figures and VHS tapes which were very…read morereasonably priced. Even walked out with a grail piece. Had a good convo with the Bearded Hoarder himself too - service was great. Will definitely be going back.

The bearded hoarder is a great location in the heart of Sayville. 279 Railroad avenue is the new…read morelocation. Here you can find toys from your childhood, pokemon, viral Tik Tok squishy toys, comics, and more! Kevin (The owner) also does trading too. Bring in your treasures and leave with something new or a wad of cash!

Best comic book shop in Suffolk County by far. Very helpful and knowledgeable staff. Nice place to…read morego nerd out for a few hours. Amazing selection of fairly priced slabs. Parking is horrible; be careful crossing that road; the drivers are all speeding badly.

Best comic shop on long Island in my opinion. Jason is the owner is awesome…read more A legitimate comic store - tons of keys CGC slabs, magic cards, Pokémon cards, toys, funko, statues. Magic the gathering game night on Sunday's. Can't go wrong in here -- I highly recommend

Awesome place, great prices and friendly staff. I found everything I looking for and more. Great…read moreselection and well organized. Check them out.

Located at the dying sun vet mall. It's a good mixture of comics, pop funko dolls, and hockey…read morememorabilia. While the mixture is good, they have the comics in a small area but they do have $1 comic boxes which is cool. Honestly I would recommend this place to someone looking for some sports memorabilia because they had a good amount of it.

The best shop in the area. The staff are all really knowledgeable and ready to help find what you…read moreneed. They have a good stock of recent back issues and a great selection of board games.

Amazing store filled with tons of new and old comics. Great place to try and fill runs or pick up…read morea run.

"Now popular culture Can't stop 'til it gets enough"…read more(John Mellencamp) They've only been open since June and they claim to be "home of the largest collection of pop culture items on the east coast". I can tell you that this store is huge, neatly set up, and boasts an ungodly amount of comics, collectibles, figurines, toys, games, cards, books, posters (check out the very foxy Supergirl) across the pop culture spectrum of movies, television, comic books, super heroes & villains. They even have a small sports card section, so every branch of the Nerd Tree is represented here! They don't have a website, but have a Facebook page on their business card, which I included as a photo.

I have been here 2 times and will be back, again. I bought two full comic book sets, one was a 52…read morebook set for $100, and most of these are in almost pristine condition. I then bought another 18 comic book full set for $15 and with 2 missing books (that was clearly marked as missing) and I found the other 2 online, so now I have the full set, and it only cost me $24 in all - you can't beat these prices. I'm not looking for comic books that are in perfect condition, although, most that I have received are in great condition and inside protective sleeves. I'm 54 years young and enjoying being able to buy full sets of of the classics. Great store, and I can't wait to buy my next full series.

A great local Comic and card shop that has a ton of really fun, nostalgic toys, cards, and comic…read morebooks from the late 70s, 80s, 90s, in 2000s. It's only open on the weekends, but the service is always really friendly and they have some really interesting finds, everything from Yo MTV Raps and Ghostbusters cards to Star Ward micro machines and The Simpsons toys, for reasonable prices. I can't help buying something every time I go!

From the owner: Vintage hard to find comics cards and toys!! Graded rare issues mixed with case fresh action…read morefigures.