The food was astonishing, get the juicy sauce. The snow crab was some of my favorite, as well as…read morethe potatoes and sausage. Very enjoyable experience with respectful, energetic and helpful staff. The atmosphere makes you feel like you're under the sea. And the playlist was the cherry on top.

Mother's Day is expected to be busy... but don't make people sit for 25 minutes. At a table for…read morefive. THEN tell them it's over an hour on tickets especially knowing everywhere else closes by 8-9pm. We would have gladly just left and not waited at the beginning.

Had dinner down the road and as we walked back to our cottage heard some great music so we stopped…read morein to check it out. We grabbed some drinks at the inside bar and headed to the back area. I was surprised and how much space was outside. We grabbed some Adirondack chairs on the side of the stage where we able to enjoy the music of Corey comer. We were only gonna stay for a drink but the songs were so great we ended up staying for the rest of his set... lots of dancing and drinks... so much fun. Loved the sunset views of sodus bay. Lots of dock space to arrive on boat. Definitely have to come back to try some food!

Picturesquely set on the eastern shore of Sodus Bay, this full-service water-front restaurant…read morefeatures seafood, pasta, prime rib, soups, salads, desserts and more. The restaurant is also available to get to by boat as the site also hosts a marina with slips for both transient boats and seasonal slip rentals. My wife was given a gift card for Skippers for her birthday, and over the weekend, we decided to go use it. It's situated somewhat in a residential neighborhood with a few parking spaces in front of the restaurant. We were sat right away. It was an early dinner for us, around 4PM. There were a couple other tables sat, but the restaurant was mostly open. We asked for an outdoor seat and were brought right back. The inside of the restaurant is large with 2 floors and was very dark inside. We were given our menus. Took a bit for our server to get to us, but no big deal. I ordered the risotto with chicken and a virgin pina colada while my wife got the lobster stuffed haddock with a drink special. As someone who doesn't drink alcohol, I always appreciate a restaurant that offers mocktails. Again, not a ton of tables sat, but it took a bit for us to get our food. Luckily, it was a beautiful day to just sit and look out onto the water. Our food was brought over and we got to it. Portions were large, but we both felt the food was just okay. My risotto had very little flavor, and the chicken was completely unseasoned. My wife said her food was fine, but the onion rings were the stand out of her meal. Our gift card was for $80 and our 2 meals and drinks came to $86. Our server was very friendly, but the service was slow for the amount of people there. Beautiful view on the outside patio, but for us, that was the best part of the experience.

This is a must stop for the best cocktail around!!!! The staff are so friendly and just awesome…read moreservice. I recommend the baystreet to everyone in the area and visitors!

Shrimp Cesar salad was great. When it says jumbo shrimp they really mean jumbo shrimpread more

We absolutely loved this place! Came here for date night and made reservations the day before. You…read moreget to sit at the counter and watch them prepare and cook all the food right in front of you. It was such a fun experience and quite impressive given how small the space is. My favorite dish was the New England Chowder Style Fish Soup. It was so fresh and flavorful. The cod tasted so good with the potatoes, carrots, onions and parsley. All of our dishes were prepared by a very friendly lady who immigrated from the DR. Everything tasted incredible and we left feeling very satiated. Definitely can't wait to come back! Would recommend making reservations beforehand since there's only space for ~16 ppl.

This is our second time at Rella! It always scratches that seafood itch! This time we started with…read morea millionaire chowder - if you're not a fan of seafood chowder this may be a great option as it is a chicken based chowder. It was creamy and well portioned even for two of us sharing. We then opted for the littleneck clams, which was served with chorizo. The broth/soup was perfect to dip some house rolls! We then ended with our favorite thing on the menu - the shrimp sliders, well seasoned and served with a side or chips For dessert we had the lovely, rich budino. A cup of coffee on the side hit the spot! What I truly love about this place is the transparency - the cook is right in front of you! You can see them working meticulously to put together our shrimp sliders or the octopus salad if that's your fancy I love how cozy it is yet bright and vibrant. Highly recommend this spot!

Five long years later, I'm able to revisit one of my favourite restaurants and I was not…read moredisappointed. Having made reservations for 7:30pm, we arrived early and waited for our table to be ready. We made a note in our reservation for a booth on the fireplace side, and the woman (host) worked hard to make sure that happened. After sitting down, we placed in a couple appetizers. The bacon-wrapped scallops were delightful. The bacon, crispy and the scallops incredibly tender. Served with a side of drawn butter, but these were delicious on their own. As for the loaded potato puffs, we received a generous number of puffs, and each one was also very tasty. The sriracha ranch sour cream was the cherry on top. For mains, we opted in for the prime rib, and Delmonico "cowboy" cut. The prime rim was incredibly tender, juicy and perfectly seasoned. Served with a phenomenal au jus, this is the best prime rib I've ever had. I can confidently say that about the Delmonico steak as well. This 20 oz. center-cut, bone-in was grilled to the perfect requested medium-rare. Seasoned perfectly, tender and juicy. Although I didn't care much for the gorgonzola cheese sauce, the steak was amazing. We also ordered a side of lobster tail. This was also incredibly tender and really brought the meals together. To end all things, we ordered their creme brulee served in a chocolate shell. This was a great dessert, although I would have preferred the custard to be firmer, and less chocolate sauce overall. I found the generous amount of chocolate sauce on the bottom of the plate, and on top of the creme brulee, on top of the chocolate shell they're served in to be over the top. Nevertheless, we enjoyed this dessert. I want to point out, all the staff members including the owner was very kind and welcoming. From the initial host to our server Lauren, to her boss who came around to ask us how everything was, the staff are very hospitable. Add in a warm and cozy dining room area with a fireplace, this is easily a 10/10 experience for us. We will make it a point to revisit more often and not years in between.

Made reservations for 8:30 - just to note that the place closes at 9 and on opentable, their last…read moretable is at 8:45, but we didn't feel rushed at all during our meal. For anyone interested in the prime rib, I highly recommend getting the 20oz (look at the picture!!) because this was massive and could easily feed two people, especially considering it comes with a side. My only regret is ordering my own meal (the Sheridan) and not splitting the prime rib with my BF. Luckily our leftovers made a great second meal. We also tried the garlic bread which was great, and I have to give a shoutout to the free bread that came at the beginning of our meal, because the sweet butter on the side was to die for. Also, love that our servers came to ask if we wanted more bread (we declined because we knew we ordered a ton of food). Finally, please get the raspberry margarita. This was the best raspberry margarita I've ever had. I wish I ordered this to start instead of the strawberry margarita, so that I could've had TWO raspberry margaritas instead of one raspberry and one strawberry. Can't wait to come back!

SO GOOD! We stopped here on our first night of a few days away and we are so glad that we did. The…read morerestaurant appeared clean and nicely decorated. We were promptly seated. Our waitress was friendly and checked in on us often. I had the lobster lollipops with a side salad. Both things were delicious! The dipping sauce for the lobster was pleasant! It wasn't overly salty or buttery. We really enjoyed our meal here.

Beautiful views! Affordable and great service. Food was awesome. I had the chicken sandwich .read more

This is the closest you can get to authentic Italian dishes. The seafood Alfredo was so good. And…read moretheir vodka sauce is incredible. Everything was fresh and delicious. Our dishes came with a whole loaf of perfectly cooked bread! I'd recommend the blue cheese dressing for salads. It's a cute ambiance and service is very quick and friendly.

Spur of the moment decision to revisit Peppinos while we were in the area on a Saturday evening. We…read morewere greeted by a personable, young hostess who informed us that there was a table available. Our server acknowledged us arriving and said she'd be over shortly, which she was. A generous glass of house red was only $10. Soup or salad comes with each entree; the soup of the day was seafood in a tomato-based broth. The salad was fresh. Our entree choices were pasta with a huge meatball and chicken cacciatore. The CC was fantastic. Peppers and onions and sauce was spicy and the boneless chicken was sautéd perfectly. The portion was enough for another meal. Bread and garlic butter, as well as water, was kept replenished. Another outstanding meal at a reasonable price.

Great food great service great atmosphere and great views of the lake this place is great a mellow…read moreplace where you can be yourself and unwind and enjoy a great meal and have some cocktails

I had the Salmon special this Friday and my husband had the broiled Haddock. My salmon came with…read morespaghetti squash and risotto , both sides were delicious! Their seafood has always been consistently good this year

This is a place in the middle of nowhere. Our house is looking building. The seafood, however, is…read morefresh, delicious and reasonably priced. Unfortunately they do not carry whole fish therefore only four stars. Also a lot of fish is frozen, still good but not as good as fresh. Mostly they have fresh haddock. And of course good clams and oysters. Highly recommend it

It LOOKS like a warehouse in the middle of nowhere and it IS a warehouse in the middle of nowhere…read more I don't know who this wholesaler delivers to, but walk-ins are welcome. Every year, I drop a small fortune here. Center Port (don't know where the nearest port is...this is surrounded by pastures) sells a good variety of great quality seafood (at least for what can be expected in the middle of farm country in upstate NY) My Christmas Eve dinners are a seafood extravaganza and it all pretty much comes from Center Port. The staff is friendly and helpful. If you need preparation advice, they'll give it. I've paid with cash and with checks over the years. If you live in the area (or in my case-within a 45 mile radius), at least check it out.

We love Doug's and have been coming for years. It's simple and consistent and comforting. The fish…read moredinners are fresh and tasty. The service is efficient and friendly. The dining area can get busy and crowded but it's a warm and friendly environment

We got a lobster roll, fish, fried clams and all were AMAZING. The clams were absolutely the star…read moreof the show. Fried clams are a favorite when dining at a good seafood restaurant but these were the best we have ever had!