Yummy lunch! Forgot my carrots for my sandwich which I paid extra for. I'll be checking my orders more thoroughly from now on. Edited to add: I called up and they will make it right on my next order read more

See all

I haven't been here in years! Still pretty much the same. Friendly service. The chicken on the salad was pretty bland, but the salad was good. And we got both chili and chicken tortilla soup. Both were good and a garlic cheese roll of course. Excellent. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Ordered from Nathan's for the first time after a recommendation from my coworker. I ordered the buffalo chicken soup and was blown away by that - homemade soup is hard to beat and it was very tasty. I was less impressed with the sandwich I ordered. I felt the sauce was very bland and overall made my chicken sandwich pretty flavorless. I will 100% order soup from here again. read more

On Friday 4-4-25 we went to the cashier named LISA at 1:00 in the afternoon. We were shocked with her horrible attitude! As soon as we ordered, we both said thank you and she just glared at us, and didn't reply with You are welcome or any other answer. The ladies that prepared our order were very pleasant! It's sad when somebody working in a place that meets the public has such a bad attitude because that caused us to never want to return! read more

I had never been to Nathan's when it was on Park and I still haven't been inside their current location at the Henrietta marketplace. I ordered delivery via Yelp/Grubhub yesterday and was REALLY impressed by the timing of my order (I ordered for 12:30pm and it arrived at my door at 12:31pm), and how delicious my entire order was. If you get a soup, be prepared to reheat! It didn't come completely cold, but it came at basically room temp which I was totally good with. I reheated it to my piping hot preference and was ready to dive in. And dive in I DID! WOW - the cheesy tomato bisque is absolutely delicious. There are some small chunks of roasted tomato and the cheese makes the bisque souper creamy. I ordered a small soup with a sandwich, but in the future would likely just order a side of the rosemary olive oil bread to dip. An ideal lunch! For my sam, I went with the stuffed tuna, and stuffed it was. This is a huge, bready sandwich made with whichever of their homemade breads you prefer. Classic, cheesy garlic, rosemary olive oil and a few more options. I personally loved the soft bread and thought it went perfectly with the tuna and soup. I wouldn't necessarily order delivery from here again (fee was steep at $7) but I would absolutely order for a group from here, or do catering! I've heard great things about their chicken salad and am looking forward to trying more items in the near future. read more

See all

I went to Nathan's for lunch with a friend. The people working were friendly and the space was clean. I got a turkey sandwich with cheese, bacon, and lettuce on the cheddar bread. I was expecting slices of bread versus the roll that I got. It ended up being a lot of bread for the amount of turkey and cheese that was in the sandwich, but it was pretty tasty. read more

This was one of my favorite go to restaurants that I would order from my favorite is their broccoli and cheddar soup and they're half tuna half egg salad sandwich on the garlic cheddar bread. My issue with the restaurant is they offer delivery services but whenever I go on the website that they contract with it always says the restaurant is busy and not accepting online orders. During the week this is my way to order from this restaurant and I hope at some point this will change so I can order from there again. read more

Just left and ordered a Cobb with chicken salad .. got back to work no chicken salad on my Cobb . Very disappointing read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Cobb salad missing chicken salad - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

The soup and sandwiches are absolutely delicious in my opinion I had the seafood bisque and the tuna/egg salad

Had one of their sandwiches for lunch today. There's not much to say - the photo of the sandwich speaks for itself. Turkey and provolone with lettuce and tomato. ALL bread, and very little meat. The tomato slices were large for some reason. Not sure why they are using such gigantic rolls, but it led to a very dry and bland sandwich. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - a bag of soup and salad - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

First time today: "Special" Lobster bisque. Not ver good. I was searching for lobster meat and found one piece. The rest looked like fine shredded crab. Taste was 'ok' Not 'good' not very thick. Oh well. We SHARED one sandwich, small bag o chips, and a Pepsi. BOTH had CUP of bisque. $28. AND the receipt was not itemized read more

I grabbed a quick lunch at Nathan's with my girlfriend based on a recommendation from her co-worker. We were both rather disappointed with the meal as we tried their new Ramen Noodle dishes. The highlight of the Ramen noodle bowls was the chicken bone broth, which had great flavor. This must stem from their prowess at making homemade soups because everything else about the Ramen bowl was disappointing. The boiled chicken breast was unseasoned and poorly cut before they splashed some bbq sauce on it and set it atop some "ramen noodles." The peppers were raw and crunchy like you would want on a salad. The hard boiled egg was sliced in half and cold in the center. The final kick in the gut was the "ramen noodles", which were more like broken in half angel hair pasta with an overly soft consistency and no flavor of its own. This was so bad that I couldn't bring myself to finish my "Korean BBQ ramen" on the cold December day. I also tried the Seafood soup, which was good but not enough to redeem my overall experience. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Korean BBQ Noodle Bowl - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

This was my first and most likely my last visit to Nathan's and it went like this...First off, there's plenty of safe parking on the side of the building...Next, the room is easy to get around with very tall ceilings, almost industrial in its appearance...Now onto the food, well there's various salads to choose from with the usual stuff like any other salad places...Cobb, Greek, tossed etc. also a variety of soups to enjoy like cheddar broccoli, Italian wedding, Chicken etc. There are also cold drinks such as various soda's and tea's...I decided to make my own salad choosing up to five ingredients and an iced tea...Total cost of around $14.60...So, the only thing that caught my attention was the less than friendly woman at the order station, even when I said it was my first time there and looked as if I needed some help with all of the choices to choose from, she was stone cold that was all I got from her, hardly a word spoken...The salad was fresh and the tea ice cold and nothing more in my opinion, maybe I should have tried the soup...Anyway give them a try and make up your own mind. read more

I had the tuna/egg salad combo sandwich on wheat and the garden veggie soup. Both were great! I like the classic deli feel and the service was good. I'll come back! read more

Really nothing like the old Nathan's. Disappointing sandwich. They forgot the lettuce, tomatoes, onions. Just a heap of flavorless egg salad on a bun. Order was wrong and guy was grumpy when I asked for missing item. read more

Mmmm it was OK, a decent selection of soups and sandwiches (didn't try a salad) that they serve fairly quickly. I was a bit disappointed in the existence and amount of filler items in the soup lots of potato or in my buffalo chicken overcooked elbow macaroni? I never think elbow macaroni when I think buffalo chicken. The chicken, roasted red pepper n limp bacon sandwich had good flavor. I'd agree with other reviewers that the chicken seems like the solution injected prefab stuff. We sampled a jalapeño bread, which they forgot to give us the first time around. It would have been so much better if the cheese was melted or warmed, what magic bread gremlin can cook bread without the shredded cheddar melting? I tucked it away and toasted it into a magical ham sandwich the next day, well worth the wait. Lobster bisque wasn't on the menu but a crab chowderish option was. There was a hefty portion of imitation crab, I think a disclaimer would be nice when not using the real thing since real lobstah is reportedly used in the lobstah bisque. read more

See all

I used to love this place when they were located on Park Ave! I feel the quality has gone downhill, unfortunately. Ordered Italian wedding soup today. Had to toss it. It was a bowl of grease! Asked about the Turkey salad on chalkboard menu. Was told "we haven't carried that in 3 years" (then why is it still on menu???) Asked for saltine crackers, was told "We have been out of crackers for 3 months now" (Ok but grocery stores have them). Not a good experience all around and I just threw my $5.00 bowl of greasy soup in garbage! read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Grandma's Italian Wedding Soup - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Had a New Orleans crab chowder yummy great customer service kind sweet ladies I will return thank you Nathans

Scrumptious soup. Sandwich was amazing, too! Quick service, perfect for a shopping out and about with a yummy lunch. read more

Most of the soups at Nathan's are legitimately the best I've ever had. Grandma's Italian Wedding is next level amazing and I crave it most days but especially when I feel under the weather. The lobster bisque and crab chowder are always a good choice when they're on the menu too! Service is always fast and everyone is always so friendly! read more

I love this spot for a quick work lunch! Sandwiches are fresh and delish! I recently tried the Korean Ramen. It was ok...I really was hoping for the actual ramen noodles. Especially since it was labeled as such. However it turned out to be spaghetti. Or at least tasted just like spaghetti. I hope eventually they can get better noodles or change the name of the soup just Korean noodle soup. That was my only disappointment. I love this place and other food! read more

Never had been here. This location is in the same plaza as Lori's and Palmers off Jefferson. The service was really good. Went about 1pm on a saturday and most of the breads were sold out but still managed to get the garlic cheese which was amazing. Fresh baked and warm. Tried the tuna salad on croissant and the cream of potato soup. The meal as a whole was very satisfying . You know how after some out to eat meals your left with that "bluuuuhhhh" feeling? Here I was left with "mmm yes delicious" . The tuna was really good. The soup was perfect for this blast of cold weather we just encountered. The calories are low for a cup of soup which just gives it that 5th star!! . There are 2 other locations on Park Ave and Memorial Dr. If you haven't been I highly recommend you try. Hours: Spring Mon-Fri 10am-6pm Sat-11am-2pm Closed Sun. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Cream of potato - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I'd never ever been here although I'm here at the Genesee market sort of frequently to go to Lori's and Palmers and 2 friends at work clued me into it as a good lunch spot. I've been here twice and loved it. I mean... the soups? please. They will give u tastes of whatever they have on special for the day to help u to decide if ur up in the air about what u want. I ended up gettin grain/broth bowls both times and they were delicious..they have vegetarian and meat options for those. I got a chicken one.... with tons of fresh veggies in the mix. they also have sandwiches and salads. U order at the counter and they call ur name when the order is ready. The counter people and the people putting together ur meals are so super helpful and efficient. Drinks from their cooler... I get an unsweetened iced tea usually. My friends have gotten the awesome soup and sandwiches and have loved them. Oh!! And the little mini loaves of bread!! There are several varieties and I got a cheddar cheese one with my bowls... yum!! Butter on request. I ate half of both and was full.. meal later. This was quick and we were easily able to get back downtown on our hour lunch. Regular spot... going forward, as corporate America says read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Fire roasted veggies and ancient grains w/ bone broth Yummmm!! - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

Nathan's is always good no matter which location you choose. A little expensive for soup and sandwich but worth the extra cost. Soup is homemade and tastes it. Breads are fresh. Very good, I'd give it 5 stars if I could justify giving a soup and sandwich place 5 stars. read more

Stopped and picked up lunch to go yesterday. Got the Crab chowder and chicken salad on a croissant. They have numerous choices of soups, salads and sandwiches. All are made fresh no soggy bread. Never had anything I didn't love. read more

All the Hype, only to be disappointed twice. OK so everyone raves about Nathan's soup. So my first visit, I order broccoli and cheese, and after I paid for the food, they said, ohh sorry we are out choose another. Well I tried another and it was only fair. So let's try again. On a different day I went, and I asked, is there broccoli and cheese, and they said YES. So I ordered a large. Well the rest is so sad. They scrapped the bottom of the barrel, and then for some strange reason, put it in the microwave cause it was cold??? What??? So I was with friends and had it to go. Upon eating it, there was NO broccoli, just cheese broth, and I was still in disbelief they nuked it. The favor was ok, but with no content. So disappointing! Some people give a place 3 tries, I am sorry after 2, I am done. So a huge thumbs down for this establishment, that I thought I would really like. Customer service is slow, as you will wait, and they have NOOO problem giving you their scraps for the high price you paid. I am sorry folks, for almost $6 for a little cup of soup, it should be amazing, no so here. Save your money! read more

Cream of potato bacon... mac 'n cheese soup... cream of broccoli... I'm incapable of ordering the "healthier" soups when I come here. I'm tempted by the cheese and the carbs in all aspects of life. It's a top pick for me for lunch, especially in the winter. I love to warm up with their hearty soups and their breads! While it's not a gourmet loaf, it's a nice bread to dip into your soup. I opt for the ones that have special additions like the pepperoni cheese loaf and the jalapeño cheddar. I've tried the garlic cheddar one, but found the garlic a bit to overpowering as it was slightly browned from baking, which blasts out the flavor. Top choice of them all is the jalapeño cheddar. I also tried a small salad, which isn't actually that small. I'd only get the large if it was the only thing I was ordering. I added a scoop of tuna on top which replaced the need for dressing as it was enough moisture to coat the spinach (you can choose between spinach, spring mix, and romaine). Salads come with 5 options for toppings. Hearty! I choose to add carrots, olives, cucumbers, tomatoes, and celery. My whole meal for a small salad and a small soup was ~$8. This particular location is the largest and has space to sit if you're coming for lunch. It fills up during the 12-2pm lunch rush. It isn't open for dinner, unless you swing by before 6pm to grab a pint of soup to go. read more

See all

Got takeout from here on a day when we just didn't feel so great and it was really gloomy outside. It was good comfort food, and I didn't have to cook! We ordered the broccoli cheddar soup, cheesy tomato bisque, cheese bread, and garlic cheese bread. They all had pretty good flavor and the bread was REALLY soft and perfect to dip in the soup! If you're ordering for dinner, I'd suggest ordering the large soup and one of the breads - it was the perfect amount! The reason for the three stars is that I just felt like this was nothing over-the-top or really special. Pretty basic soup and bread that fits a need when you don't want to cook, all for about $7 a person. read more

Addicting the egg salad sandwhich. The soups are amazing. If a type sounds good it probably tastes even better. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Today is a cheesy tomato bisque & Jalapeño cheese bread kind of day. - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

I stopped in for lunch and it happened to be on a Wednesday so I thought I would try the lobster bisque that is raved about in previous reviews. It was good, but not great. I was however, seriously disappointed by the selection. For a salad place, I thought there would be more than just romaine and a couple very basic veggies to choose from. The sandwich selection is also limited. It consists of only salads. read more

I loved this place. I called ahead because I had a lunch order for my office, and everything was ready. Overall, the food was great. I had the tuna/egg spinach wrap with onion, lettuce and tomato. It was great. I would have taken a picture but I didn't think about it until my last bite. Lol. I'll definitely go back again. read more

12/23/13 Cheesy Tomato soup was outstanding, velvety, rich with a few chunks in there. The chicken salad with walnut and grapes was a disappointment because it seemed to be made with processed chicken. I might be wrong but the flavor and texture definitly suggests that. I will however be back. May have just been an off day for that read more

I don't think I'll be going to this location ever again. I will just stick with park ave... they do a much better job there. First off they gave me the wrong sandwich. And I am really not into imitation crab. Yuck. It was too sweet and all I really wanted was the chicken salad sandwich. The cheesy tomato bisque soup was super gelatinous and mealy. I ordered my sandwich on the garlic bread, which didn't even taste remotely like garlic. Pretty disappointing lunch. And their chalkboard in the front had Fridays specials on it... And it's Saturday. The door says "fall hours" you'd think someone might update some things. read more

A lovely gesture on the part of the Brighton Central School District PTSA was to provide all teachers and staff at Twelve Corners Middle School with a complete bagged lunch from Nathan's near the end of the school year. The issue for me was that there were no fully plant-based options. I was going to let it go, but the PTSA rep who was at the school distributing the lunches last Friday insisted that I be included. She took down my contact info and said she'd make sure I received a lunch that was compliant with my diet, but nothing materialized, either that Friday, or the following Monday, as promised. I gave Nathan's a call to see if there might have been some miscommunication. I spoke to Rick, who got right on board and made sure a vegan lunch was delivered on Tuesday, which consisted of a generously-sized crisp garden salad with balsamic dressing, gluten-free bread, red grapes and a bottle of water. I know Nathan's doesn't generally cater to my food demographic, so I was very appreciative of this effort. read more

They make a mean Italian Wedding soup, *almost* as good as my home made...but with a lot less effort :)

My officemates seem to love Nathan's and have made Wednesday a weekly Nathan's adventure for their Lobster Bisque. I definitely enjoyed the bisque, and it was priced about right considering it had real chunks of lobsters in it. I've tried several other soups since(they have a continually changing plethora of soups), but nothing has really come close to the lobster bisque. The only thing that really turned me off about Nathan's is their bread. The bread is served extremely doughy, not to mention it is cold. When you have soup you definitely want a warm, crunchy bread to dip into your soup. If they could just toast the bread a bit I think that alone could bump this to a 4 star review. I really want to love you Nathan's, so please take my constructive criticism to heart. read more

This is a Rochester Bucket List item for me. Living in Las Vegas I have to say, I miss Rochester food. I really, really love the chicken salad sandwiches on croissants. I don't get the soup because I am messy eater and soup is dribble. I mean I've had the soup many years ago and I like soup and if I wanted soup I'd get it from here, but sandwiches have my heart. I always get two loaves of cheese bread, one for lunch, one for later. This is my first time at this location and I already have a lunch date for tomorrow. Two days in row. It's that good. I never had any complaints about the Park Ave location. This location is just as good. Lots of seating and very efficient. The chicken salad was tasty but seemed a bit heavy handed with the mayo. We'll see tomorrow if that's the norm or not. Good salad to croissant ratio. They have snacks too like chips, fruit/veggie crisps. Oranges, bananas, kettle corn and glazed almonds. read more

Very nice place, great atmosphere, food was fresh good and healthy. Very satisfied. Glad to find a healthy place for once. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

Not sure what took me so long to try out Nathan's. I live just around the corner and within walking distance. On my first day, I made two trips. One for myself! And one for a friend who was a bit under the weather and craving soup! My chicken salad sandwich was really good. The homemade bread was excellent. And the soup! Yep, I had to taste it. Yummy! I will definitely go back. The staff was friendly and helpful. Thanks for the 15% off my first online order coupon! I will definitely use it. read more

Nathan's Soup and Salad - The store front view - Soup Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Nathan's is a Rochester tradition and a personal favorite for nigh on 25 years. For an inexpensive, healthy and delicious lunch you can't beat this place. My one complaint as a vegetarian is I'd be happier if Nathan's introduced more veggie soup options, but I still love their tomato bisque and cheesy broccoli. read more