Wow. I can't believe I waited so long to give this place a shot. I had been going to another spot…read morein town (Lockhart) that ho early has really crappy service, so wanted to try something new. And boy am I happy we decided to go grab dinner here. The choices were unique and standard, definitely something for everyone. I have to say the taco pizza was probably my favorite tho. I loved the setup and ambiance, really felt like a small town family diner type feel. Definitely felt welcome and appreciated for being there. We will absolutely be back!

It's the good stuff!!!!! From scratch, beers cold, awesome service, kick back and enjoy the…read moreatmosphere

I want a domino but I got a pizza I was so angry and yelled at the waitors but they just kicked me…read moreout.

Absolutely terrible manager. I ordered thru the website and it was incorrect. And the toppings were…read morenot proportionate to the crust. I was "upselled" on extra cheese. This is not extra if you ask me it's barely enough x the manager interrupted me several times and raised his voice - said he doesn't have the authority to give out a partial refund because his weeners too small. Classless customer service skills then I get on here to post a review and see dozens others have been confronted by this PIZZA MONSTER!

To start off the garlic knots were amazing, didn't even snag a pic lol!…read more The knots had great crust, good level of moisture and just the right amount of oil. Paired with some marinara it was perfect! Pizza 8.9/10! SO good, great crust, perfect balance of cheese and sauce and overall cooked to perfection! Toppings also were evidently fresh and of high quality! 1000% you have to get the hot honey drizzle on your pizza, it was incredible! The only bit of feedback I would give to management is to replace the cactus plant with something that doesn't have little pokies, sadly my wife brushed her arm past it and we ended up going on a 45 minute quest to get all of the little cactus pins out :( The plant was also in a broken ceramic pot- broken ceramic is potentially as sharp or sharper than a razor, and I wouldn't want anyone to hurt themselves badly! All in all, great experience and we will gladly be swinging by whenever we're in San Marc

From Chicago, just moved to Kyle. Here are some thoughts from my first visit to PS tonight…read more.. -This is a vibey, cool, but pretty simple college pizza hangout near Texas State University. -We ordered a create your own 16" pizza with pepperoni and onions. -It had a nice thin crust with a slightly burnt brick oven pizza flavor. Good, but not great. -I enjoyed their Maine Root fountain soda. I got the "Dr. Pepper" flavor and it was sweet, but didn't have a very strong cherry flavor. -The price point was really good. Cost less than $20 for a 16" pizza, $25 out the door with drinks and tip : ) Recommended.

Wow! The absolute best pizza in Texas that I've had in my 12 years of living here!…read more I moved to Austin from NY and If you like a NY style crust with the finest quality ingredients , than just like me, this is your place! The dough is thin with the perfect amount of chew to the crust . Even though these pies are all 12" personal sized , the pieces still fold like A Slice from NYC. The sauce is delicious , toppings are limited but amazing quality ! We had the pepperoni and sausage and the white pie and both were just incredible. The chef/owner is clearly passionate about what he creates and his Wife handles the front of the house friendly and poised. The Family that owns this place are just super cool. All In all Sylvia Pizza has really Great service , cool LA vibes with great NY Pizza. My only wish is that they made larger pizzas too! I highly recommend this place! Give them a try you won't regret it.

I wanted something new so I tried Sylvia's. I ordered from the grocery store parking lot since it…read morewas so close. I wanted to choose my own toppings and assumed cheese would be on it so I didn't choose cheese. They sent a text asking me to confirm that I did not want cheese on my pizza. I didn't see the text because I was driving there, but when I arrived they had not made it yet, since I didn't respond. That really impressed me. That was great customer service! It's a small place back in a corner, so I see how I missed it before. While I waited they let me sample a small cone of their homemade ice cream. It was chocolate cinnamon. It was not bad, but not something that I would have put together. The ice cream was creamy and it they had another flavor I would have bought some! I ordered a small pepperoni, with onions and peppers. They don't use green peppers but they had red and yellow. It was delicious. Their pizza doesn't come with a ton of toppings but the sauce and crust are so good, you won't miss it. I will be back for more!

Great place to dine right on the courthouse square Pizza is…read moreawesome garlic rolls are wonderful Everything we have had there is delicious

Service was bad. We waited about 30 minutes before our order was taken. We would have left but the…read moreguy said he would be right with us. Ambiance was ok but not spectacular. Food ordered was Caprese, Baked Ziti. The caprese salad was something else. It contained string mozzarella that was chopped up. And had shaved parmesan. It was pretty bad. The baked ziti was plentiful. And the taste was so, so.

First-time visit and overall a mixed but positive experience. The place has a very down-home,…read morecountry feel, and everyone we interacted with was genuinely friendly. There were plenty of drink options to choose from, and the menu definitely caught our attention, which is what brought us in. We started with the nachos with beef. They were pretty good overall, though the Velveeta-style cheese wasn't our favorite. The meat lovers pizza was a hit -- thin crust, well-cooked, and full of flavor. The main reason we came was for the chicken wings, and unfortunately, those were a bit disappointing and left us wanting more. However, the owner personally came over to apologize and explained that those were not the wings they normally serve. He even comped us $10 in cash, which was a very appreciated and classy gesture. The staff was friendly throughout our visit, and because of how the situation was handled, I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt and plan to come back again to let them redeem themselves.

Cool little spot in Smithville. My buddy and I stopped in on Sunday. Great environment with TV's,…read moreopen seating area and lots of land (grass) out back. I ordered the burger and fries. It was a good burger, but not my favorite. The bun was a bit hard and the meat was a little tough. On a high note, they did pack it high, lots of bacon on it. The fries were excellent! Staff were nice. We'd come back.

It was a while ago that we were here, but we really enjoyed the pizza and wings! Atmosphere was fun…read moretoo with cool arcade games to places! Will definitely be going back!