Lou Malnati's on Lincoln Highway is a carryout only location. It's convenient for quick pickup orders. It's next to a PT facility, so most of the parking in front is ADA. The staff is nice and the food is quality and accurate as always. The store is clean and the freezers for carry outs are well stocked. The app is def worth it for points and pop up specials. read more

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria - Large - Deep Dish uncut butter crust pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New Lenox, Illinois

This review has nothing to do with the quality of their pizza. It was great. I feel that they should not be a vendor at the New Lenox pavillion venue unless they can provide pizza more than once every two hours. I stopped by their booth 4 times spaced apart by 2 hours from earliest visit to latest. The real issue is that each time the two young girls were receiving communication that "the pizza will be here in ## minutes. Where ## ranged from 10 minutes to 20 minutes. My last stop was a mistake. I relied on a 20 minute promise. It was actually 45 minutes. I missed seeing Toad The Wet Sprocket sing 4 of their songs. I'm unable to eat the typical greasy food at these types of places. I had no other choice but one smoothy and that was not enough food since I had not ate for 8 hours. Whoever is managing or owns this franchise is totally incompetent. If I was given a truthful answer that next pizza available in 2 hours I would have ate a dried out pretzel at some other venue to sustain me. read more

Ordered a Deep Dish Chicago Classic and Traditional Wings through Uber Eats. Was notified when order was being made. Picked up on our own. It seems for some reason EVERYONE's pizza has been disappointing lately. We seldom order from this Lou's since it is a bit out of the way, but had a family member going past so ordered at New Lenox Lou's. The pizza and wings were delicious. In fact, one of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. Usually don't order wings, but those were meaty and well-sauced. Got the ranch to go with them. Perfect! Thank you, Lou's for restoring my faith in the fact that there is still good pizza out there. Hey, New Lenox Lou's, you've got a new steady customer! read more

Best pizza ever!!! Great service and wonderful menu. Building is cold sometimes but going for the pizza is worth it.

As an uber driver, I wait 10 mins minimum for my orders. This last order I was already waiting 10 mins and they came out and said they forgot a pizza and it would be another 15-20 mins. I will never take another order from this place let alone order from there myself. Absolute garbage. read more

BEST salad around! Who doesn't love a salad with pizza? The "medium salad" could serve 3-4! We had "The Lou" thin crust and it was delicious. Loved the hint of fresh garlic. Will definitely be brace to try different pizzas - they have many creative combinations read more

Pizza was good as always. Family size salad was good. But by the next morning it was all brown and nasty. I tried to pick through it to pull out some good pieces but found very little. What that feels me is that this was either not a freshly made salad, put together maybe a day or two before and kept in the fridge, or it was made fresh using produce that had been sitting around awhile. I can make a salad at home and it stays good for 3-4 days. I wound up having to throw a little more than half in the garbage. Ill no longer be ordering a salad here and is it really want one, ill just order my pizza from Beggars where the salads have always been fresh for me. read more

The food is always great. It's literally the ONLY reason I still order from this place. They make written promises of order delivery times and NEVER make them. Even now they added half an hour to a delivery time on a $100 order for my guests and me and. -- again -- broke their written promise. Also on more than one occasion they have taken an order, gotten paid and then CANCELLED OUT ON ME after over an hour, claiming they could not find a driver. I had to order from another place and wait several days for my money to be returned me. That is NEVER acceptable even if the manager needs to get into the car and personally drive the order out. So if you can afford a crapshoot as to whether or not you will even get ANY food and have to pay double (even one second is too long to be out of your money), the food is good. They just have no desire to fulfill orders at or before the promised time. And it is beyond the pale. read more

Last time I'll be ordering. Always an issue with delivery. Never even close to estimated time. Estimate given is usually about an hour. But expect to wait a least an hour and forty five minutes. Always trying to find a driver. They use third party drivers. Not worth it anymore. Plus a $6 delivery fee and you add on an additional tip. Paying way too much for poor delivery service. read more

I recently had a customer satisfaction issue at the New Lenox location and decided to send an email to let management know. As a result Eduardo (GM) and I spoke on the phone to discuss and resolve. Eduardo listened to understand then resolved it. It is employees and managers like Eduardo that makes Lou Malnati's so great! Thank you Eduardo! read more

I have always been a Lou's fan...until today! Ordered three XL Pizzas and they were beyond disappointing. The crust was limp on the bottom, not cooked all the way through, and was completely flavorless. There was barely any sauce and way too much cheese. The only way that I can describe these overly priced round pies left me thinking that I was eating a bland, dry, over cheesy piece of cardboard pizza. Extremely disappointed in 's. read more

Absolutely an awesome meal! Our thin crust pizza was perfectly cooked and delivered at the perfect temperature. In addition, the Lou Malnati salad was great! Another happy Lou Malnati's experience! read more

this place has went downhill big time. pizza always undercooked or order incorrect. I gave them way too many chances and will never go there again. the location in tinley is much better and that is where we order from now. edit: sure ya do Lou M. i talked to the store. nothing done about it. best of luck. read more

Placed an order online for a medium uncomplicated pizza and 2 house salads. Got a text from door dash 50 minutes later saying the delivery was cancelled and to call the restaurant for more information. Called the store for more information. Got put on hold for 7 minutes to be told that a door dash driver picked up the order 2 minutes ago. We live 10 minutes from the restaurant. 30 minutes later I call back. Got put on hold again. My husband called while I was on hold and spoke to a guy. Said we wanted a refund. He asked if we still want the pizza, my husband responded with "sure, assuming this guy shows up since no one seems to know where he is". They said they're going to have their own driver bring over the order in 20 minutes. 35 minutes later, still without anything, husband called again to demand a refund and wouldn't get off the phone until it was confirmed. Got told "sorry about that" enough times for it to lose meaning. Eff this place. Oh and still nothing. read more

Ordered delivery for large party a couples of months ago. Told them delivery at 4:30. Pizza showed up at 4! We were not ready for it. Usually complaints are for late pizza, but way early is just as bad!! read more

Their deep dish is pretty good I'd order it again but holy s*!t their thin crust pizza is the worst pizza i've ever had. Deep dish 7.8/10 Thin crust 0/10 read more

The pizza is very well made with high Quality ingredients. Salads are fantastic I highly recommend this restaurant the food is delicious.

We've been buying pizza from this location for the last couple years and it's always consistently good. The half pepperoni half sausage thick butter crush is by far our favorite, paired with a salad. read more

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria - Interior counter - Pizza Near Me - New Lenox, Illinois

See all

Slow service and snotty attitudes. Ordered a pizza to my shop for delivery and I was 1.7 miles away. 7:15 pm on a Thursday night. The 45-to 1 hour delivery time was 1 hour and 37 minutes for a cold medium pizza. Not to mention the it was $25 for a thin crust! Yes you heard that right. I hand the delivery girl a $50 bill and she actually asked me if I wanted change! Ah yes I want change. How is that even a question?? Now top that off with "well how much do you want back?" You really can't make this stuff up. I will never order from this place again. read more

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria - He's a fresh pizza from your establishment. Just terrible. Don't order from this place. - Pizza Near Me - New Lenox, Illinois

This is my go to place when company is visiting the salads are the best. I thought I'd try the bbq chicken pizza before the offer ended , sorry I did should have ordered the usual there's more chicken in a 3 piece nugget than on the pizza for the price maybe two pieces of chicken on one section. I guess specials are not always special? read more

I have been buying pizza from Lou Malnatis for years. Since they opened other carry out locations the service is not good. Getting orders wrong and when you get a credit being told you can only use credit from restaurant that originally issued. I have had issues with more than one location sorry to say. read more

My original review on Lou Malnatis was 1 star, I wasn't happy at all. The management reached out to me and I explained the problems with the meal delivered to my mother and I for Mother's Day (we celebrated the evening before). They wanted to make things right and gave my mother a complimentary meal. I am very pleased with them for trying to make things right because so many businesses use COVID as an excuse for bad service. Now for the review on the food I will paste my mother's text message to me about her meal. "The pasta and garlic bread is delicious and they gave me enough for three days. Thank you." Thank you Lou Malnatis I really appreciate you making things better for your customer. read more

Stopped in to pick up my favorite pizza and salad yesterday. I purchased gift cards around the holidays to receive the bonus gift cards they offer, great deal! I was having trouble with my LM app and not only were my reward points not correct, I couldn't find anything that showed the $200. In gift cards I purchased in December. (I purchased on line) The manager Ru Shah immediately came to my rescue and explained they were having IT problems with the app. He helped me, made me feel I was important and asked me to call him if I was having any issues in the future. Also the sweet young girl working there was extremely nice and helpful when I told her I had received a coupon for a free order of wings but couldn't find how to get them with my app. My food was hot and delicious, so thank you both for making my experience stress free and for your service excellence. Cindy G. read more

Went to lous and the service was excellent. The staff was friendly and the manager Doro was exceptionally kind and courteous. Hard to find a better staff that was friendly and wished me a good day. All in all I was very pleased with this business. I will be going back frequently. The food was the best deep dish around. Love the butter crust. The place was clean. I only wish they had a sit down restaurant. Still great pizza. The sauce was great cheese melted in my mouth. read more

They always burn my garlic bread. It was hard as a rock and tasted very burnt. Who would make that, cut that, package that, and serve that. Absolutely no quality control. read more

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria - Burnt garlic bread...again. - Pizza Near Me - New Lenox, Illinois

I loveeeee lou malnati's! Definitely my favorite pizza place in Illinois. I love their thin crust and their butter crust is also really good. However the one thing that stops us from coming more often is that the pick up time always ends up being later than what we schedule. Sometimes we wait up to 20 mins past the time they say it will be ready. Totally understand that they are busy but would really appreciate more efficient timing. Otherwise they are a definitely a family favorite and worth the price. read more

The deep dish is fabulous! The manager Doro was kind and compassionate after the passing of my nephew. Our entire family appreciated your kindness. Thank you so much. read more

The real deal. Sets the standard for Chicago deep dish pizza. Great balance of golden crust, zesty tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. I had the veggie but I imagine anything from this place is great. Oh, and the salad is super-fresh. read more

They told us 1 hour 15 minutes for a pizza. 2 hours later, we didn't get a pizza and when we called, they said it would be another 45 minutes. We like Lou's, but the service at this location is terrible. Fixing a Costco Motor City Pizza now. Never going back. read more

I don't eat pizza often due to it's high amount of calories, but if I ever want to have some, it would be Lou's. They serve the best pizza.

Whenever we go to Chicago we get Lou Malnattis deep dish some of the absolute the best in Chicago land... and the USA quite frankly :-)

The Personal Lou has been disappointing lately. Turning into a cheese pizza. The sauce is no longer the best part.

We ordered carry out from Lou Malnati's in New Lenox tonight and were very disappointed. We ordered 2 pizzas, wings, and garlic bread. Out of 4 items 2 were burned. One pizza and the garlic bread were noticeably burned and should not have been served. UGH. Will not be going back anytime soon!! read more

Best pizza in Chicago I send as gifts during the holidays and everyone love them as well. The pizza is amazing

Best deep dish pizza in New Lenox! The garlic bread and marinara sauce is so delicious!

I like Lou Malnati's pizza, but this wasn't what I have come to expect from them. We ordered the thin crust and it was a lot thinner than I thought it would be. This is a take-out only place and prior to this we've always eaten in one of their restaurants. I haven't had Lou's in a while and was really looking forward to it. I was disappointed. The crust was over cooked, the toppings were bland and it was really pricy for thin crust pizza. I'll still eat at a Lou Malnati's restaurant, but I won't order from this take-out location again. read more

I love Lou's. Always have. My family not so much. So when they went out of town and left me alone for a few days, I instantly ordered Lou's pizza. It is just as good as ever! There was a slight glitch with the order, and it was picked up by the wrong person. The manager came out as I walked in and explained the situation and made me a new one and refunded my money. We all make mistakes, it is how you handle them moving forward shows the character of a person and establishment. I will define be back! On the plus side, I got free pizza :) read more

A small child would be knee deep in grease in their deep dish pizza. I eat a lot of pizza and never have got a stomach ache like I did after eating the deep dish here. Save your cardiovascular health and don't order it. read more

Great pizza. Excellent service. We were traveling and decided to stop off and have a pizza picnic in our truck. They supplied us with everything we needed. Plates and utensils and drinks too. Great experience and very nice people. Probably the best deep dish pizza we've ever had. read more

I love this pizza I have eaten here two times already and it is amazing possibly my favorite and best pizza I have ever had. The Malnati salad is amazing too. The Calamari is my favorite starter. This place is all around the best pizza place I have ever been to. read more