Came to Montauk on the off season and had to get ourselves a bacon egg and cheese while we were out here. This deli has been here for as long as I can remember coming out this way, and I was thrilled to see it was still opened during off season. We ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go. Service was fast and friendly. Ambiance was giving clean, well stocked, and well organized. Prices are what they are given that it's Montauk. But my sandwich was piled high with bacon, eggs were cooked well and cheese was melted, so I really can't complain. read more

Excellent $10 Turkey and cheese with mayo and hot peppers sandwich. Big bag of Hal's salt and pepper chips - expensive but excellent.

This was a very decent deli and bagel spot. They have all the sandwiches, paninis, and platter. There are chips, candy, and drinks. There is coffee - you scoop your own ice for the iced coffee. Coffee is self serve so you don't hold up the ordering food line! My Italian sandwich was good. PARENTS! They have chicken tenders and fries!!! The most important thing- they are fast! And the staff are younger so please tip! read more

Second times a charm - four years later. Good service, good food, good options. A nice deli option in the heart of montauk. read more

M&R Deli - a close up of a menu - Delis Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Food was great! Get PITATA bowls and own this beach! You're açaí was an amazing bowl- see you again before we leave

Favorite and best no frills deli for a quick bite. In the heart of Montauk it's location can't be beat and I'm convinced these are the best sandwiches in all of MTK. Get the Anna Marry or Standing up!!! So good! read more

Incorrect order. Owner was rude and unwilling to correct it, called me unreasonable, difficult and other unsavory things all because I called to complain about the order. He slammed the phone down on me and cursed at me. Ordered a gluten free wrap, which they do not have. Ordered ketchup on the side instead received a soggy sandwich. All of this could have been settled with a simple acknowledgement and offer to amend, instead of all of this hostility. Terrible restaurant with terrible food and even worse customer service. read more

packed every day in the summer. decently priced sandwiches and wraps. so so good for a quick bite at the beach. absolutely would eat here every day. great selection of drinks and chips. clean and also some counter stools to sit and eat if you don't want to take it to go. read more

M&R Deli - customers at the counter - Delis Near Me - Montauk, New York

Definitely order ahead or it's a wait. Reasonably priced which is a nice surprise for Montauk ... menu and quality is what you're would expect for a deli. read more

What a great deli added to Montauk! Grabbed sandwiches from here before heading to the beach. They were excellent. Felt the prices reflected most delis in the area. What makes them better however, is that the sandwiches are huge and really really good. I truly recommend this place. Also, wanted to add that we came in on a Saturday. They were very busy between phone orders, online orders, and customers ordering inside (like myself). The three women behind the counter were working really hard. Happy to share this place with family and friends staying in Montauk. read more

Meant to save half of my Italian sandwich for later and failed. Perfectly constructed and extremely delicious.

I would just like to preface this review by saying that I am usually never that person who runs to yelp after having a bad experience anywhere but I felt compelled to share this experience. I have never been to an establishment with such rude and unmotivated staff in my life. I would say "maybe they were just having a bad day" but keep in mind the place was completely empty and it was only noon. From the snarky attitude of the girl at the register to the outright rudeness and impatience of the man behind the counter this deli definitely left more to be desired. The food was mediocre at best so If you're thinking of coming here spare yourself the trouble and go to ANYWHERE ELSE. read more

Are the people who work here being held hostage? Everyone was so rude here, I'm shocked. I have never experienced that level of disrespect for trying to order a sandwich. If the food was good I would give it a higher rating, but the food wasn't good enough to see past the horrible customer service and nasty employees. I have never written a yelp review but I am so shocked by this interaction. read more

My friend and I went to this deli before the beach to get a sandwich. The girl working at the front was so nasty and not friendly at all. My friend has a peanut allergy and she was asking what oil they cook in. They looked at her like she had 10 heads. I will not be returning read more

Ordered through Uber eats. Waited an hour - fine .. COVID I understand Then got delivered half the order. When called, the person ( Stephanie) was rude.. asked that I send a new Uber ( I already spent $149) then.. said an employee will bring us.. an hour later - nothing.. They were rude on the phone. Salads were tiny Disappointing read more

Just walked out after waiting 15 minutes for 2 sandwiches to be made while waiting the next 5 minutes starting at my sandwiches as they sat on the back counter while the woman made "to go"orders.I asked if those were my sandwiches sitting there and she answered "yes" and turned and continued to make other orders.We were the only customers at the time so I didn't understand why she would start on orders for people that were picking up and let me stand there like a schmuck.It was way too beautiful of a day to waste 25 minutes in a deli.We walked to the next deli and were on and out in less than 10 minutes. read more

I've eaten here twice and have had good experiences so far. I would recommend calling in your order for even more ease. Their deli has a lot of great options for their specialists sandwiches and making your own. Unlike most restaurants around town, I feel that this restaurant is way more reasonably priced. My one complaint is that I ordered a cheese sandwich and they just stuck a whole half pickle in without slicing it and evenly dispersing it. That was a little strange. Other than that, great deli. read more

First time going in and there was a man waiting before me to order and one of the women working completely skipped him and asked me if she could take my order. The guy was upset and made the woman upset. And then she was short with me and slammed her pen down and was huffing and puffing. Please don't take out frustration with a customer on another customer. You work in a good industry u fortunately customers are always right and should be helped professionally. I know the owners are amazing sweet people. So don't give their deli a bad name. read more

Love the M and R Deli! In a town of understandably overpriced eateries, they give you a surprisingly average priced meal served fast and delicious, whether it be one of the breakfast specials, or the delicious lunch sandwiches! Quite amazing since they are walking distance from the beachfront properties, on the main drag. My tasty full breakfast was less then I paid for a donut and coffee from the bakery, and the food is top quality! Highly recommend!!! read more

A great place for a sandwich! There were some contractor types in for a pick up sandwich when I was there which is always a good sign. Friendly staff and amazing food. I was a bit surprised that there weren't more customers but that's OK for now. The sandwich I had was HUGE. I'll be back. read more

I've been in East Hampton for three weeks working and M&R happened to be right down the street and over the LIRR tracks from where I was staying. Discovered it on the first day and it was love at first bite. Have gone every day since for either a breakfast sandwich or lunch/dinner sandwich. I've done both and think I've tried everything; created my own sandwich and ordered off the menu. Delicious fresh rolls, Boar's Head cold cuts and cheeses, a plethora of beverage choices and it's just plain good eating'. We don't have many (read any) delis in Honolulu to speak of, so this was a treat for me to have so close to where I was staying. There is something about bread baked in NY. Cole Slaw or mac salad and pickle included with sandwich surprises and delights. read more

Rude employees and terrible food. We had a $50 order and I gave them the chance to make it right. Which obviously they chose not to do. Avoid at all costs. read more

M&R Deli - This is how my sandwich was delivered. Like day old leftovers. - Delis Near Me - Montauk, New York

Great place was our go to for breakfast and coffee while in town for a few days. Reasonable and great service. The lines were shorter than most. I feel it's a hidden gem in Montauk! read more

I grew up going to Ronnie's deli at this location almost every day of my childhood. It's nice to see a new local deli in it's spot. I have been here multiple times in my travels because I am no longer a Montauk resident, although I have yet to be disappointed. The servings are larger than Goldberg's and the prices are better! Be sure to stop in and check this place out for a great breakfast or lunch, you won't be disappointed read more

M&R Deli - a burrito cut in half - Delis Near Me - Montauk, New York

We were stuck in the hotel due to rain , so we ordered through uber eats . We had an egg white veggie wrap and Two eggs platter. The food arrived hot and was delicious. My daughter said that the wrap was one of the best she has ever had. It was huge and stuffed with lots of veggies and cheese and hot sauce. My breakfast was also delicious, eggs were just right and bacon was crispy. I was only missing my coffee as they don't deliver it but OJ was cold and hit the spot. The price was so reasonable, especially for the area. I highly recommend, it must be great to sit in the restaurant. read more

Great deli but worst customer service I've had in a long long time. I'm surprised no other comments say this because even back in 2020 (I spent the whole summer in Montauk and was a regular there) I remember always walking out of there in a horrible mood because everyone was just so rude. Young girl behind the counter looks like she'd rather be anywhere but there and seems like she doesn't know any word other than "yup". Bigger guy who took our order and made the sandwiches told us to "pay attention" when none of our sandwiches were even ready yet and the place was completely empty. Great food just wish they hired friendlier people. I'll go to the deli down the road just to avoid the workers here! Oh and they forgot my macaroni salad and pickle two days in a row and looked annoyed when I asked for them. Maybe I'd excuse the service if they did their jobs correctly. Smh both stars are for the food read more

If you want a solid sandwich this is the place. Roast beef was delicious. My fiancé had turkey and ham. Both pressed. Sandwich maker was a man of few words but for what he lacked in charisma he made up for in straight up skill making our sandwiches. Will come here every time we make it to Montauk. Bonus Note: take the sandwiches to Montauk Brewing (just a 5 minute walk away). read more

Ordered breakfast here. Great portions for the price. Fed a family of 4 for just $20. Don't look any further if you're looking for a quick bite to eat for a great price. read more

Food (breakfast sandwich) was amazing and customer service was to. Thank you for providing quality service will return for lunch today & whenever I work out here or visit this will be my new breakfast spot read more

I found this too be a great place for lunch when we are doing dock work we always do on day of sand which's from here of course I like the "Perception". And if you have there menu call in order ahead of time and you won't have to wait. read more

Love this place! Its easy and portions are great sizes for their price! Owners are lovely and service was amazing. Food tastes great as well. (My favorite is the chicken caesar wrap!) read more

This is seriously the BEST deli we have ever had. We are vacationing in a beach front resort here in Montauk. I have already ordered from them TWICE!!! (Looking forward to breakfast tomorrow...our last day.) We ordered BLTs, sausage peppers & onion hero, bacon cheeseburger, fries, macaroni salad and "the Viking!) ALL OF IT WAS ABSOLUTELY OVER-THE-TOP AMAZING. We visit once a year and we have only just discovered this gem. The delivery is super quick. (Had our food hot and delivered within 20 minutes!!!. Definitely going to be a repeat customer. I only wish we could take them home with us!! read more

Wow.. great food!! Lots of variety in their sandwiches and paninis...very generous portions.(And so glad they are open after Labor day.)

Super easy pickup, finished earlier than originally said. The breakfast sandwiches were amazing!

One of the worst experiences I ever had from a deli... first of all I ordered on 2 hero's . They sent in my delivery both of the sandwiches on rolls. There was left over lettuce and tomato on the bread of both sandwiches which shows they used a dirty knife to cut. Not to mention the sandwiches were subpar at best. Will never waste my money here again. read more

Great sandwiches and made to order salad bar. Generous portions and reasonable prices for Montauk. Romo sandwich was great

Loved "The Anna Mary" Panini with Boom Boom sauce! We got it to go and ate at the beach

2nd day eating here...great deli in town of mtk... excellent sandwich choices. Husband and wife team very friendly. Will be back .

Awesome breakfast sandwiches! Sausage, egg and cheese and an iced coffee... we had breakfast there twice while on vacation! You won't be disappointed. read more