Cute and convenient market in the heart of the Hamptons! They have a very convenient market that caters to your food, groceries and household items. They have a natural juice stand inside where you can also get fresh matcha green tea, and other natural juices. The variety of foods is incredible and they carry lots of delicious baked goods, and other prepared foods. FYI, bathrooms are upstairs. It took me a few minutes to find the bathroom until I asked and had to go up the stairs. The bathroom is not very clean but it is what it is. Not what you would expect from the area (Easy Hampton). The service is ok they are working very hard so they treat you like they don't have time for your questions..I was a brand new customer and even asking where the restroom was made me feel a bit unwelcome maybe they only cater to the "regulars"! read more

Red Horse Market - The outside surroundings.. - Grocery Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

I went there to get some fried chicken, I've had it before and it was very good. Only this time I got just one fried chicken thigh. Well it was $6.00,, SIX DOLLARS!! for one thigh! seriously!!! I purchased it but was not pleased. It was very good as usual but not worth six dollars. It's not that I can't afford it, but at these prices I won't be back soon. And I'm telling everyone I know about this. They should be ashamed! They'll go out of business at this rate, especially in the winter when there's not enough people here to support them. read more

This place has become what was ALREADY ridiculously expensive now, ABSURDLY expensive. I just bought a personal sized vanilla yogurt, a ciabatta loaf and a tiny bag of frozen peas and it was over 30$. I, among many locals here find this completely insulting and infinitely greedy.... typical Hamptons hose job. read more

The great market of East Hampton. Fire sandwiches. The best grilling meats. Game over.

Red Horse is a fine spot but unfortunately they stopped making pizza seversl years ago.

My go-to in the neighborhood - yes it has new ownership and frankly it's been a positive change. Prices may be higher on grocery items but if you're shopping for bulk bargains go to King Kullen. I love the hot bar choices and the deli salads. If you're looking to prepare a meal for the evening for a small group you can find everything you need. Coffee, desserts, salad bar also excellent. Need something specific but don't want to go downtown? Try here first and you may be surprised by their inventory. I don't live in EH year round but have called it a second home for my entire life and spend time there in all seasons. Trust me we need a business like this for quality of life and we should support it. read more

Expensive but you get what you pay for in this world. Quality, selection service are best in the Hamptons.

Was very disappointed with a Panini turkey sandwich and this is the second time that it happened to me they heat the cold cuts up in the microwave and then put the sandwich on the Panini machine. Totally grossed out. Who heats up cold cuts in a microwave. You can't do that to a pure Italian person. I just threw the sandwich out. I did not have it in me to tell the girl that she grossed me out by putting it in the microwave. I haven't been there since then because it's scarred me. read more

I have been coming to East Hampton for a few years. I have driven past this place without ever thinking twice about stopping. I saw an article in the NYTIMES about the homemade mozzarella. I have to say I have had fresh mozzarella before BUT NEVER AS GOOD. This stuff was amazing and if you get the chance to have it while it is still warm...OH MAN AMAZING! read more

Red Horse Market - Fresh Mozzarella. Amazing! - Grocery Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I was deeply unhappy with the rude service at this store. We were excited to get here and explore this part of East Hampton. This looked like a cute little deli to stop for food, but the staff could not have been any ruder. We did not feel at all welcome or like they wanted us to be customers. Would not recommend. read more

Best mozzarella in the world hand's down. Put your damn hands down on the table and leave them there. Pasquale is the guy who makes it and he is cery egotistical about it. Plan ahead though because the line for this mozzarella can get backed up. The wall street journal unfortunately blew this place up already. So go there and get the mozzarella but dont tell your friends about it cause im tired of waiting. read more

Red Horse Market - Fresh mozzarella - Grocery Near Me - East Hampton, New York

They are awful. Stay away. Owner is so rude. They are nasty and during covid they have zero respect for social distancing. Overpriced and nasty! Don't give them your business. read more

Red Horse is a great place to go if you need to pick something up quickly, but it is small and does not have everything. For example, they have very few milk options and they mainly carry a brand that I had never heard of. They do have a parking lot which I've always managed to find parking in. They also are fairly expensive, but it's in line with normal Hamptons pricing. They have a small produce section which has decent quality products. During COVID, they are only allowing in one person per household to minimize the number of people in there. read more

Bought an apple pie among other items. Get home and there was actually green and black mold. Both kids ate a piece and realized after. Brought it back the next morning, the first think to woman asked is if I have a receipt, she didn't apologize or ask if everybody was ok. She was extremely rude and actually laughed. Was then directed to the owner PEDRO, who looked and said "wholly shit" he apologized but just offered to give a refund. "What else do you want me to do" he said. Should have offered a store credit or something more than a refund. Then he became rude. Reading other comments the theme seems the be horrible rude service. That was my experience. read more

See all

A few days ago I got dinner from here. The salad bar was wonderful but mychicken cordon was raw in the middle. I work in the food industry so I can tell the difference between the coloring of the ham and raw chicken. I came here a few years ago and also had a bad experience. Monday i emailed the company but never heard from them . So on top of raw chicken also bad customer service. read more

Red Horse Market - Raw chicken - Grocery Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Very inconvenient layout to move around and access to salad and prepared food counter was a mess, crowded and impossible to have a better view, with people cutting in and out. Overall, most of the merchandise they carry can be had in other gourmet shops, but with a mark-up that is unwarranted for the shabbiness of the store or the shopping experience. Salad or dessert provide nothing unique that a Roundswamp Farm would have. And check-out counter was slow and snaking. read more

Prepared foods are very good- would recommend salmon kabobs, marinated skirt steak and green chicken. Produce is average and everything else is grossly overpriced even for East Hampton standards. Better off going a mile away to Citerella's which has everything that's better except for those previously mentioned. The reason for the rating is the General Manager, who is incredibly rude and acts like he's the only store in town. The staff works as if they are scared of the guy and many customers have mentioned his rudeness. One has to wonder why an owner would hire someone who obviously dislikes his customers read more

Place is great. Treated me like family. But they also charged me like a cousin 2 years late paying back a loan ;) read more

https://www.ada.gov/service_animals_2010.htm Violating ADA civil law by refusing to let service dogs in store. Beware they will chase you out. Very rude. Know the law. It is ILLEGAL to ask for papers for a service dog. read more

Delicious authentic Italian takeout and pizza plus a nice market. Very nice, friendly staff. You can call ahead for pizza- In my opinion far better than Citarella... read more

I frequent this place. Great feel and atmosphere. The quality is excellent. Their salad bar is fantastic, as are their hot breakfast and lunch options. Sure, you will pay for the quality, but much of it is still very reasonable. Salad bar (with TONS of options, and fresh produce) is only $7.99/lb 2 Egg Breakfast sandwiches (with bacon or sausage) on a nice roll is only $3.50! Various hot lunch choices (made fresh daily) are great portions and range from $7.99 to 9.99. Their French Toast is AWESOME, and only $1.25/slice. Great coffee. Can't wait to try the pizza! Everybody's friendly and helpful. Excellent spot! read more

They are letting way too many people into the store. I will update the review after the virus passes. You have to question why are they packing so many people into such a small cramped store. read more

I've been a loyal customer spending $1,000 or more a week here(I'm a chef). I asked for ground salmon which I have gotten here 4 times this summer. They said they have never done this for me and said I was lying. I approached the owner and asked him about the ground salmon. He immediately turned red in the face and said it's up to the deli if they want to do it for you. I asked him why he was so rude about a simple question and he began to yell at me and cuss me out. After some words were exchanged he banned me from the store. He has serious anger issues and does not respect his customers at all. They lost a great customer today. I wouldn't give him your money read more

I finally had a chance to shop here today and what a pleasure it was. We picked up several items for an impromptu BBQ and while the prices are a little high, the quality of the items we purchased and the friendliness of the staff made it a good value. The layout makes it easy to shop and they have a better atmosphere than the old Tutto Italiano by Citarella. The food we bought was all great, but the hand-made-fresh-on-premesis mozzarella was the best I have ever had. Ever. Good luck, guys! read more

What can I say that hasn't already been said? I'll just add my voice to the rest of the throng telling you what an amazing place this is. For starters, the market has an incredible variety of food. Sandwiches, soups, salad bar, desserts, baked goods, prepared hot foods, and fresh meat and seafood. There are also crazy gourmet items (truffle butter, for example). The stars of this incredible show however are the fresh mozz and the pizza. The pizza is well made with crispy crust and a variety of toppings (including a lot of classic combos you won't see elsewhere, like escarole in a pizza roll). My personal favorite is the buffalo chicken roll. The mozzarella here is bar none the best I've ever had and likely the best you'll ever have unless you're blessed with a nonna who hand makes it in her kitchen. Chef Pasquale regularly dunks his hands in boiling water to expertly craft this amazing delicacy. You can pretty much eat it plain. However it's also awesome on a prosciutto sandwich with fresh tomatoes on crusty bread or on a fresh slice. If you're in or near the Hamptons, make it a point to go here! read more

Mind blowing mozzarella made by the absolute master! Not only is he talented, but he's also this warm, sweet guy. We love Chef Pasquale and this market! My 5 y/o daughter is obsessed with this cheese!! If only we lived closer! read more

Worst Italian sandwich I have ever had. Over $18 for a Snapple and a hero. Do I need to say more?

What happened to the homemade mozarella???? Very rude rude rude manager. Running the line as if airport security. Stay in the orange box he rudely demands. No fresh mozarella, rudeness = why go to get abused and harassed. read more

What is there to say? The food is always fresh and tasty, the fresh mozzarella is awesome, the service is friendly and pretty fast given the traffic. Just assume East Hampton prices. A must visit. read more

Best mozzarella I have ever tried... which yields amazing pizza! You can also get some groceries but it's a small place so the lure here is the cheese, pizza, and other italian specialties. read more

Red Horse Market makes magic with mozzarella. Make sure to finish it all with loved ones on the same day - it's just not the same the next. Their groceries and prepared food (I had their salad bar and pizza) are also surprisingly good. Solid market, and one that I'll return to again when I need groceries in the Hamptons! read more

My favorite market in the Hamptons. Must haves: -Chef Pasquale's Mozzarella - made in house, by hand. There is nothing like getting fresh mozzarella made that day. His mozzarella is simply the best. Either get yourself some bread and prosciutto and make yourself an amazing sandwich OR get tomato, basil, and some of the high quality olive oils they have at the market and make yourself the best caprese salad. -The pizza and pizza rolls - There are small little personal pies and pizza by the slice you can get to go, or you can call ahead and order. Recently had a pizza with crumbled sausage and broccoli rabe. So good! The broccoli rabe was sauteed in garlic infused oil prior to putting it on the pizza so you had that great taste that complemented the ground sausage perfectly. Another must try is the buffalo chicken rolls (when you get them home dip them in some blue cheese for some extra decadence). The grandma slice with the fresh sauce and fresh mozzarella is also phenomenal. You really can't choose wrong here. They also have a lot of fun groceries for foodies like quail eggs and truffle butter and standard groceries as well. A must try! read more

This is my favorite place to grab amazing sandwiches and salads. Anything with their authentic mozzarella is excellent. Everything is to go because it is literally a market, but the customer service is great too. I really love this place and if you're in East Hampton it's a must go. The food is awesome! read more

Great pizza, and awesome place to get food. Not really a place to go grocery shopping, because of the price, however great to grab one of their personal pizzas or a sandwich. I would recommend this place for take out. read more

There is no better place in the Hamptons then the Red Horse Market. The food, the staff and the atmosphere is fabulous. The staff treats us like family and we return think of them as family. On a scale of 1 to 10, we give them an 11. read more

Wish I could give no stars. The owners are just as rude and unreasonable as their clientele. And they ALWAYS get my order wrong. Their ticket system for ordering sandwiches is cumbersome (poorly placed) and their checkout line needs some serious work. read more

Very nice local market. Great to go in and get fresh fruits and vegetables and really tasty well prepared cooked food. All the staff is very friendly and helpful. I stop there frequently during the week, instead of going into the village to a regular supermarket just to grab a few things or lunch/dinner to take out...especially in the summer when town is so crowded with weekenders and vacationers. Highly recommend! read more

I don't eat pizza often, but when I do I want it hot and fresh with lots of veggies on it. I was hesitant to get a slice here because the market specializes in everything from butchered meats to prepared food, fresh salad bar (huge), hot foods, homemade mozzarella, etc. with so much going on, I didn't think the pizza would be anything great. Boy, was I wrong! This $3.50 slice was worth every penny. Piping hot, gooey cheese that I bet was their homemade cheese, freshly sautéed vegetables, and little to no grease. The pizza maker was happy and friendly too! I'll definitely be back! read more

Great pizza, however the new pizza guy is an even bigger, nastier jerk than the last one. Best fresh mozzarella anywhere, better than Casa mozzarella on Arthur Ave. The butcher is fantastic also. The salad bar is disappointing as is the deli counter, that could use some nice, healthy salad selections. read more

Great deli. Pleasant service. Pizza and calzones were a great to go item. Highly recommended.