Does everyone know that besides being the best bagel shop on the North Fork, GOLDBERGS actively supports the local community? YES THEY DO! GOLDBERGS continues to support the Southold Historical Museum each year for their annual "History In the Making" pickleball tournament, which takes place next Saturday, May 30. 2026, at Tasker Park in Peconic. There are still some spots left! So next weekend, as you're rushing out the door for the 9 am tournament start time, know that GOLDBERGS will have free bagels waiting for you!!! Thank you GOLDBERGS for the great food and generous support. You are invaluable to this community. read more

Food was good but expensive and some of the staff members were kind of rude. The menu could have also been more clear with regards to when breakfast food sales start / end. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

Goldberg's is the only place I frequent on the east end of Long Island. The bagels are made fresh every morning and there is a lot of variety. My personal favorite is the French toast bagel with eggs and bacon, as you get the perfect blend of sweet and salty. There's always a line, so that does show how popular and in demand they are. If you want a solid, New York bagel, this is the place to go. Service is fast and staff are excellent. Highly recommend. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Sesame bagel - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Terrible service. Went in around 2pm to pick up a couple of bagels. Place was empty. Asked for two plain bagels to go. When I opened the bag at home, one bagel was fine - the other had already been sliced in half and had some red oil on it, as if it was turned into a sandwich, then someone changed their mind, and the server thought he could just give it to someone else. Disgusting and will never be back. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Wanted a whole bagel to go and instead found this pre-sliced with some odd red oil was snuck in instead. Had to throw it out. Terrible. - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

I'm not sure how this goldbergs is connected to their other locations as it's significantly inferior. After it giving multiple chances I'm giving up. This location has managed to engineer the driest egg sandwiches known to man and the sloppiest bagels. Switching to black sheep bagels read more

I waited nearly an hour for an egg sandwich. I was told 10 mins. Then the staff was rude installed if apologetic. They need someone that knows how to run a griddle and has a clue on service. read more

this place was way overpriced, they forgot my sandwich and when I finally went back for a new one they forgot to add bacon. do not come to this establishment they will forget items and give you horrible service, the line was also Way longer than it should have been and took 5 minutes just for a customer to be rang up. read more

Lox Spread on a bagel is 5.95 (plus tax). It's not worth it. I got the thinist amount of spread again. It's a very meager amount consistently. Last time for me. Bagels are great - but the smear/spread is a rip off. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Goldberg bagel with the lightest amount of Lox Spread. Some of the bagel doesn't have any spread! - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

Excellent bagels Great service Very clean environment Always a delightful experience .Nice place to enjoy a quick lunch read more

Goldberg's Bagels has been on my bucket list for months due to the great reviews on yelp and the neighborhood gossip. I must say, I was very impressed by their Bagel quality and so curious about what the taste and texture would be like for a Long Island bagel The exterior decor is really simple and humble but you won't miss it since there is always a line outside. The wait wasn't bad and the staff served everyone quickly. Face mask is mandatory to go in due to this corona virus scamdemic! There was a great variety of options of bagels, cream cheese spreads, smoked salmon and desserts. I had a difficult time making choices and ended up getting 8 bagels (4 kinds: Everything, Sesame, Onion, and And whole wheat) and 3 spreads (Low fat cream cheese, Scallion, and cream cheese with bacon in it ). Their bagels were amazingly delicious with chewy texture. The spreads were also great and my favorite was the Scallion and it matched with the Everything bagel greatly. I will definitely visit again and try different options like sandwiches and other breakfast wraps etc. Really good bagels and a $h&+ load of options! More than just bagels. read more

Somehow I had gone my whole life without ever going to a Goldbergs. I had some time before work so I stopped in for an egg sandwich. Absolutely no complaints. Everything was great, and their bacon is super thick which I love! Bagels were very good, not the best I've ever had but tasty. I wouldn't go out of my way to come here, but I probably will return eventually. I'm leaving this review mostly because I saw other negative reviews noting bad service, but I experienced good service here. But--it wasn't busy at all. Maybe things change when the breakfast rush comes in. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Bacon egg cheddar with hot sauce! - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

First of all the place is packed; the logistical layout is smart in one door and straight out the second door. The staff is super friendly and their bagels are pretty decent. They do a good job covering the bagels with whatever flavor they are be it sesame or poppy or whatever. The bacon is pretty good too; better than the crap you get at most delis in the city. The scallion cream cheese lacked the abundance of scallions it should have so the flavor was minimal. The spicy hobo is good it just needs a little more spice! If I'm in the area and want a bagel I will go here. Plus, they have fresh squeezed orange juice! read more

For the extra lox and poppy seeds... where else would one go out here? Goldberg's with a smile, super friendly guys in here who took great pride in their place. On the way out after talking good bagels .. they sent me out with a complimentary French Toast bagel. Gave it to my friends son... who loved it. They have a mean poppy, cinnamon raisin, French toast and others will have to try. Lox cream cheese was super. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Best lox cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

My fiancé and I stayed in the area for a vacation to visit family and this became our daily spot for the week we were visiting! Nothing beats New York bagels and these were the best! Through the week we tried both the breakfast sandwiches and the plain toasted bagels! Both were amazing! Especially the hobo with the hasbrowns on the sandwich... mmmmmm read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - the HOBO - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

I've been going here for quite awhile for bagels and breakfast sandwiches. I will not be purchasing egg sandwiches anymore from here. Awhile ago there was egg shells in my egg sandwich, and I gave them another chance saying people make mistakes. Today I found plastic wrap in my egg sandwich. I guess they prepare the bacon ahead of time and wrap it up, because the plastic wrap was on the bacon. I like my bacon crispy so when its not the way I like it, I usually take off the bacon and that's when I saw the plastic wrap attached to the bacon. See attached picture. They need to be more careful when preparing food. No more chances I'm done! read more

See all

Great quality bagels. Always crowded. Be prepared to wait. But quality is definitely worth the wait.

They're pretty good, they never got my order wrong like others who complained, it's a pretty busy place so people have to speak up so they could understand your order... like a few times the Customer ahead of me would Whisper Their order, I like the bagels and it's never a miss for me read more

Can't sing enough praises for this neighborhood favorite of ours. The stellar staff serves with smiles, the bagels remind me of my hometown Sayville bagels and the announcements on the board are a testament that we live in one great community of happy worker bees . Thank you for feeding us with love and support! read more

I got the everything flagel with lox spread. Good stuff! Bagel is huge, ate half and saved the rest for later.. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Everything flagel w/ lox spread - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

I'm done with this Goldberg's. Very slow and unorganized. We waited over 20 minutes and we're given the wrong sandwiches. Went back and they didn't have our order and had to make it again, that took another 15 minutes. Then to add insult to injury they left out the bacon on my sandwich. That's it no more Mattituck Goldberg's for me. How dare you leave out my bacon. I was so hungry I still ate most of the bacon free sandwich with tears in my eyes. Very sad. I did go back and ask for a refund and the owner did give me a refund so that was ok. read more

Dudes, I gotta tell you. Super lame Bagels. I rarely eat bagels but I had a craving. Treated the guys to bagels after a long work week. Check out this pic of a flagel toasted dark with lox spread. This is sad. I mean truly, how hard is it to toast dark and put enough spread on to at least cover the bagel. It's going to be long time until I cone back here. Btw, Goldberg's in Southampton did me right but mattituck location is for the birds. read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Always excellent! Sure they get backed up and you have to wait but that's the sign of a good place. They get several rushes of people at the same time and get through it. New bagel express line seems to be helping. The bagels are some of the best in NY! read more

I was out east and wanted a quick bite. I saw this place and decided to stop in. On a hot, muggy day, walking into this small bagel emporium only served to make me hotter, as if that was possible. There were 3 people behind the counter doing their very best to act as if I didn't exist, even though they all made eye contact with me within 15 seconds after I stopped at the ordering spot. I finally get to order and ask for a cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese. I then told the order taker I also would have a bottle of Yoo-Hoo. She gave me a total of $5.40. I thought that was on the high side but said nothing, as I hadn't seen the size of the bagel I was going to eat. Well, the bagel was nothing to brag about. And it wasn't even a cinnamon raisin bagel. It was a whole wheat bagel. I was hungry so I said nothing. It certainly was on the small side but did have a decent amount of cream cheese on it. I went to the cooler to get my drink and another worker was actually filling it with Yoo-Hoo. I asked for one. He gave it to me and I could feel it wasn't very cold. I asked if he could reach in and get one from the back of the cooler since it would be colder. He looked at me with some anger and said they were all the same temperature. I said they weren't because the bottles that had already been in there would absolutely be colder than the ones he was just putting in. He gave an audible sigh and reached in. I was handed a VERY COLD bottle. Mission accomplished. So, to summarize. Decent tasting, but wrong variety of bagel and too small for the price charged. Service with a grunt when you ask them to make the slightest effort to please a customer. I won't return. read more

"Whitefish salad" is just mayonnaise, and costs 10 dollars. Complete ripoff Don't go here. read more

The bagels are amazing! No denying that. However, if you're okay standing in the blazing hot Sun to grab and bagel and coffee, I'd skip this place. They never have enough help (Sunday's are the worst, but Mon-Sat are bad as well) and are always unprepared. When you finally get into the store you have to yell your order across the counter because they can never hear you. It's summer time! Increase your staff! read more

I don't know how many times I have to complain about this place in order to get their act together. Every time I order anything the order is messed up. Everyone I know who goes there say the same thing. The order is always wrong. I don't know if they're not understanding what customers say or what. The butter and cream cheese have been tasting like refrigerator as well. Don't waste your time or money here. The bagel place a little further west in Jamesport plaza is 100x better. read more

When my boyfriend and I go out to his summer house on the weekends this is our favorite place to grab breakfast! The line could get long, but it's totally worth the wait. The food is great and the staff is very quick! read more

Goldbergs Famous Bagels - a display of baked goods - Bagels Near Me - Mattituck, New York

This place is so amazing the line snakes out the door into the parking lot sometimes. The flagels and bialys are terrific and the bagels sell out so everyone gets there early. We love it so much they catered our recent birthday brunch and did a great job! Will definitely keep coming back and will use them again for another event. read more

Good bagels. I love the flagels, flat bagels keeps me from.having to scoop a normal bagel out. Living in Florida we don't have flagels so of course I had to try one. I also ordered an everything bagel, it was good but I've had better. It had a ton of poppy seeds but not enough of the rest of everything and I don't think there was any salt. Since they don't put salt on the everything bagel here, I purchased a couple to take home but was disappointed to find no salt. The bagels are good but I've had better in other places in NY. I also had a small jalepeno cream cheese, very tasty. Overall a good stop read more

This space has been home to several bagel stores in the time we've lived in Mattituck. All have been OK but none really good. My first experience with the chain was in Easthampton last Thanksgiving when our host brought in bagels and smoked salmon the morning after the "feast". The bagels were not tough as is usually the case, and the freshly sliced salmon was buttery and delicious. The new store in Mattituck in just what the neighborhood needed. The bagels and flagels are texturally wonderful, and the cream cheese mixtures tasty. Bravo Goldberg's! We've got a Sunday morning treat to look forward to. Of course a shorter line would be nice as it's always out the door, but I guess that comes with serving stuff that people like!! read more

1/20 times when I get food here, it comes correct. Never order açaí bowls from here because you will never get what you asked for and there's more ice on the frozen fruit than there's even fruit... I give this place many chances because in the beginning they were amazing and they have just gotten so terrible over the years.. today I found eggshells on my sandwich for the second time and my sausage patty was burnt to crisps... just do yourself a a favor, and go to Black Sheep Bagels instead.. the hype over Goldberg's is way over done and unless you're a local, your food will definitely not come out right. Plus the prices are a little high. They really don't give a crap about how your food comes out once you place your order. It's not that they can't hear you and you need to order more clearly. There's no excuse. This place is just getting worse and worse. Today was my last chance I'll ever give Goldberg's. read more

The staff really make this place amazing. They always cheer me up in the morning with hot coffee and an amazing breakfast sandwich. I love all the people who work here, especially the manager, Nataly, because she always makes my food exactly the way I like it. There is no other breakfast café which offers the level of customer service that happens to provided here. read more

Best Bagels on the North Fork. We love their breakfast sandwiches and have tried them on a variety of their bagels. We will go back again and again. For the folks who write reviews and complain about the long lines and waiting time, its because the food is good and they have lots of happy customers. read more

Good food. Easily all ordered over the phone and pickup. Good egg sandwich and great omelette

I like this place. I would come back however I just paid $12.00 for ham and cheese on a roll and a drink and only got 1 slice of cheese. That's pretty lame and there are 3 people working right now, no customers in the store and I had to wipe clean the 1 table they have in the whole place from the person who sat down before me and there's bacon and a little garbage on the floor. I'm more upset about the 1 slice of cheese because the place is otherwise very clean. read more

Number one issue is they close at 3PM! That's right, not 3AM, but 3PM. What a joke, it is a breakfast and brunch crowd place only, I guess. Why would a bagel place, the only bagel store for literally miles, close in the middle of the afternoon? Very disappointing. Also, the smear they give you is pitifully small. It is much less than other bagel stores. They are cheap with their cream cheeses. read more

Finally a place to get decent bagels on the north fork. Since living here there have been about 3 bagels places in here and they all were terrible. Place is extremely small but that's not fault to them. But please please take something away from your Hampton locations and add a BAGELS ONLY line. You could wait in here for 30 mins to get two bagels and that's a huge down fall I just walk out when I see the line almost to the door. The workers work extremely slow and can never seem to understand the costumers they need you to repeat the order three times until they understand Bottom line bagels good service EXTREMELY SLOW. If there's a line expect to be here a while never mind if you order an egg sandwich. Could be there until the be morning. read more

We just recently stumbled on Goldbergs in Mattituck. The bagels are terrific. Just had lunch there today amazing chicken salad, terrific grilled chicken, and the owner a gave is a sample of the chili which was fantastic. They have a great selection and they are really really super nice people. read more

Best bagels in town! Get the everything with flavoring on both sides and veggie cream cheese and you won't be disappointed. Christopher was accommodating for our large group and made sure our breakfast was perfect. read more

Best everything flagel and sandwiches on the North Fork! Never a disappointment always fresh.