Delicious homemade ice cream and ices. Green Apple totally amazing and delicious. So many flavors to choose from. Owner is real cook too. read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

Continues to be amazing! My new fav is the vanilla soft serve with cherry dip. There is no over powering fake flavor of cherry, it is very subtle. It kinda tastes more like white chocolate. The vanilla ice cream is so rich and creamy and has a marshmallow type texture. It tastes like eating clouds! read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Vanilla medium soft serve cherry dip with chocolate sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

Ordered watermellom italian ice. It was smooth and very sweet. Expect long lines during sunmer and parking is limited. Service is quickly which is nice, they have someone on drivethru and another one on the window for pedestrian. read more

What can I say. The place has been around forever!! Their ice cream and shakes are awesome . It's cash only but that's ok. The spot is big with benches on the outside. You can walk up to the window or drive around. They'll staff that run the place I think most are in high school which is cool and they're pretty fast with the service and friendly . I go every year as soon as they open and get me a shake ! Fairly affordable but some of the items can get pricey. Highly recommend! read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

Ice cream store been in Bayonne as ONG as I can remember. Old school , walk up and order. Outdoor covered seating and parking lot . Soft and hard ice cream. Good service. read more

See all

It's a Bayonne staple and people Revere this place, but there's not as much variety as one would think. They don't do fancy & for what they do serve, they're pricey . Servers are HS kids. I always make sure to put tip money in their jar because they do work hard. I recently saw that they added cannoli and rainbow cookie ice cream flavors. However, I stick with a traditional hot fudge sundae. read more

I come here all the time because of how good the ice cream is. The service is super fast and the workers are very nice. The ambiance is great especially at night with all the lights on. read more

Love how they have a drive through! And parking! Fresh ice cream that never disappoints and friendly service. Great spot for ice cream!

I love coming to Magic fountain in the summer! I love their birthday cake flavor, and they have like a strawberry cheesecake flavor that is unique to them and totally delicious. They have a drive-through and a few windows at the storefront to take orders. I've always found the staff really kind, helpful and quick. They also have little picnic tables for you to sit with family and friends. It's a staple! Go! read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Confetti/Cake Batter Flavor with Rainbow Sprinkles! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

See all

I'd rate it a zero if possible. Ordered a slushy and they gave me basically melted colored water and then stated that's how they make their drinks offering no help whatsoever. Bunch of young entitled teens working that have no idea where they're even at. Would find a Rita's close by or something else if I were you. read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - The watered down booty slushie they gave me and claimed this is how they make them. LMAO. Save ur money! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

We tried this place for 2 times, very good ice cream placed on Bayonne. Banana split Ice cream and Strawberry cheesecake ice cream are very good read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Banana split Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

Menu is filled with tasty ice cream items to try via drive-thru or walk up window (parking lot and gazebo is a plus, too!). A must visit!

Great place ran very well enjoyed my experience great prices and choices Would go back again read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

See all

Craving delicious ice cream and you're in the area? Visit Magic Fountain! Ambiance: Magic Fountain is located on the corner of Broadway and 43rd street. They also have a drive through window which is useful! Ice Cream: During my first visit I tried the regular vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. During my current visit I tried the Oreo hurricane which was great! If you have a cookie in every bite and it's well mixed I count the ice cream as AMAZING! Price: For two small hurricanes was $11. And the cups were huge for a small! Worth it in my opinion. Parking: There's a couple of parking spaces inside the lot. You can also find street parking. Service: Quick and easy. A lot of high school kids work here and they're always so helpful! Tip: CASH ONLY! There's no ATM on site so bring cash. Magic Fountain IS open during this pandemic (COVID-19) and they answered my questions quick on Instagram as well! read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

See all

Who would've thought frozen dairy would be such a good idea? NOT ME! ICE CREAM is AMAZING. The outdoor seating area is so cool too!

Solid ice cream here...no pun intended. During my visit I ordered the medium size serving which included 2 scoops of their home made hard ice cream for $3.75. That's a relatively good deal, cheaper than other local shops like Torico. You may get better value in buying a pint if you already have a favorite flavor. Both the pistachio and the cookie dough flavors were very good. They had a subtle sweetness (which I like), were creamy, and had good portions of pistachio and dough to nibble on. There is a parking lot with an outdoor seating area available. Also they offer drive through service. However, the drive thru line seems to get longer than walk in. So I advise that you just park and grab your scoop. It seems to be a family owned business. They are CASH ONLY and tax seems to be included in the price, which makes their pricing an even better bargain. Normally the servers are polite. But during my last visit when I brought a big group of about 10 customers to try out their ice cream, the clerk got my second round of orders wrong. For one set of 4 orders he charged me for 5 ice creams instead. When I attempted to correct him showing him that there are only 4 people in front of him ordering and yet he gave me 5 separate ice cream servings, the man said "well I can't take the ice cream back and can't refund!" Now of course this is really not an excuse since he got the orders wrong. When I pushed that fact he disgruntedly gave me the refund for one ice cream. However, when I calculated everything after I left the stand, I realized that he actually overcharged me for TWO extra ice cream servings, not just one! Overall, this spot has good ice cream, at reasonable prices and is conveniently located. If they teach their staff to handle customer service issues better then they'll be 4 stars. But after my last experience they'll get a 3 star and I doubt I'll ever bring a large group there again to avoid the potential headaches with large orders. So always check that you got the right order and that you got charged the right price before you walk away! read more

See all

love love love. since I was a kid there is nothing better than their soft serve on a cone

My all-time favorite dessert is vanilla custard/soft serve ice cream with toppings, so Magic Fountain definitely became a go-to spot in Bayonne. I've stopped by Magic Fountain twice and both times I've ordered a Medium Vanilla Hurricane with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups blended inside. The Hurricane's are quite similar to a Sonic Blast or McDonald's McFlurry. The vanilla soft serve here is thick, creamy & delicious! It is truly the perfect base for any topping. The medium size was a nice portion, as well. I have not tried their other menu options, but I will certainely try something new once the weather warms up! Also, Magic Fountain only takes cash so definitely make sure you have some before you put in your order. Other than that, the service is very friendly and it's a wonderful spot to stop by in Bayonne if you're looking for a solid ice cream option! read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Hurricane & Oreo Hurricane blended with Vanilla Ice Cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

Still a hometown standby although the quality has been a bit hit or miss in the last few seasons. I order a vanilla (cream soda) with chocolate ice cream and I had it more than once where it tasted like pure seltzer, which means something is wrong with the fountain lines and nobody is equipped to fix it properly... otherwise a quality spot. read more

Absolutely delicious! I love the strawberry cheesecake ice cream. Great family owned business

Nice neighborhood ice cream spot. They actually still make malteds which are nearly impossible to find these days and their lemon Italian ice is classic and really great! read more

Great spot for a sweet summer treat! No inside seating, it's a walk up window or drive thru. They have a few Picin tables to enjoy your treats. Italian ice was my go to, gotta love that Cherry Ice! They have soft serve, hard ice cream, slushees , ice, and even dole whip! read more

Awesome mom and pop ice cream!!!! Yess!!! Friend lives nearby Gradr place after school ice cream. But they close 10 pm mostly and cash only. read more

See all

Growing up in Bayonne, and living here all my life so far, Magic Fountain always has a place in my heart, when I'm craving some ice cream. I look forward to when it opens St Patty's Day weekend, and stays open through Halloween. On a nice hot spring or summer day, you can't go wrong taking a trip to magic fountain, for a great treat. They have both a drive through and a ordering window right on Broadway. Their Italian ice, blend ins, hurricanes, and hard ice cream flavors, are my favorite things to order. Their yum yum ice is a classic, and a must order item at least once a season. Recently I enjoy their blend in combos, especially the peanut butter bliss. All theor ice cream always taste fresh and delicious. read more

See all

I came here on National Ice Cream Day and there were 15 cars lined up lol. And another 15 ppl on line. But I waited because the reward was too great to ignore. Solid A++. read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - One size strawberry shortcake. Served w/ 2 thin pound cake slices. Amazing. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

See all

Came here for a banana split this was the worst and nastiest banana split I ever had for one they mixed hard ice cream with soft ice cream gave chocolate hard ice cream with soft ice cream I never knew a banana split came with hard chocolate ice cream make a long story short the ice cream was smashed and completely melted when I got home mind you I live 5 min from there I was so disgusted I forgot to take a pic I just tossed it in the trash this place use to be good it's a complete dump now I would give zero stars if I could avoid coming here read more

Had such a great experience buying our Christmas tree this year! The younger staff is so helpful. If you're looking for a tree or holiday wreath, they have a variety of sizes available! read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Trees! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

Great late night ice cream destination! Parking and outdoor seating. Could use some photos on their menu. Some of the entries are confusing. read more

Classic good ole' ice cream place. Not only does this place have great ice cream, they provide something more valuable to every customer: nostalgia. I feel like a kid every time I come here and often revert to what I used to get as a child: sundae with hot fudge, wet walnuts and whipped cream. Yum. The hard ice cream is beyond amazing. Authentic ice cream is hard to find and Magic Fountain has been able to do it. There is a drive through, streeet parking and an area in the back to enjoy your sweets. Everything I have had is great so you really can't go wrong. read more

See all

The BEST PLACE to eat ice cream in town!! Every year I wait until March when they open up just to get a vanilla cone with sprinkles. I know it's a basic ice cream cone but Magic Fountain serves the best ice cream I have ever had. I've tried many places in New York and Jersey City that looks more hip and trendy but there is something really special about this little store. They have outdoor seating with tables and benches big enough for families with kids and big dogs! Prices are low and extremely fair! The workers are high schoolers but they are very respectful and friendly plus they know a lot about the flavors and options this store has to offer! As I've included in the picture this place is strictly CASH ONLY! but there is a Bank of America nearby so don't worry about that! The also offer doggy ice cream and it's really popular! Whenever I come by there's always a person treating their dog to a puppy cone. It's so cute! Absolute gem of a place in Bayonne. I can't think of another ice cream place that could top this vintage store. It ain't summer without a trip to Magic Fountain! read more

See all

I still get the warmest feeling when I drive by this place visiting my hometown. I mean literally memories pour out from just The sight of this place. Although that might make my review biased I must explain i Don it review places dishonestly. This is the last of a dying breed.. the neighborhood ice cream spot we would play football Horace Mann school yard and walk here on an early summer night and laid up. Nothing like a soft served creamy ice cream cone dipped or sprinkled with whatever topping or flavor you want. I suggest the fruit parfait or banana split, if you just want a quick ice cream cone the twisted cone is always great. This place if so worth it whether there's a line or not. I hope they stay open many more years and generations get to experience this place. read more

My family's go to place for ice cream. The workers are very friendly. This goes to owner/manager please please get the hurricane blended making machine fixed!! read more

Go here for the Italian ice every time we're in NJ. Excellent. Yum Yum and chocolate are great!

Rudest adolescent children I've ever met in my life working at this dump. Place is filthy and their ice cream is awful which is also always half melted when you receive it. Cash only and expensive so its not nearly convenient or worth your time. To top things off, the last time I went I got sick. STAY AWAY AT ALL COSTS!!! Ben & Jerry's puts this dribble to shame anyway. read more

Dissatisfied. The hurricane in particular, which is the only thing I tried, was visually unappealing and the cherry and chocolate flavors were not very strong. The price is high for Bayonne but that would be okay with a really stellar product. This wasn't stellar. read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

When there is a line both through the drive through and the walk through you know it must be good. They have regular ice cream in more flavors than you could try in a single summer, then they have Italian ice in more flavors than you could try in a single summer, then you can mix the flavors of each together if you want, then they have generic ice cream truck popsicles as well. It is enough to make your head spin trying to decide on what you want to rot your teeth with. I had the Italian ice mocha-chino flavor and it was a glorious taste of perfect coffee turned into a perfect slushy icee, mmmmmmm. All in all I recommend this place to anybody looking for a cold treat on any type of day. read more

Magic Fountain Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bayonne, New Jersey

See all

I was walking from JFK Blvd to Ave E on a particularly muggy day and ice cream was required. Yelp to the rescue and lucky for me, this place was a block or two from babysitting at a friend's place. A traditional ice cream place! I knocked on the window and ordered one scoop of the chocolate chip mint cone. I should've taken a pic of the gigantic scoop but I was too busy trying to eat it before I got to where I needed to be! read more

I know this is an old standby in Bayonne and have been meaning to check them out. I'm glad to see they're still operating right now during Covid. They are old school - cash only, but the plus side is they have a drive through and a parking lot with about 4-5 spots. I picked up some pints of Italian ices and it was delicious. Definitely want to bring the family back so we can get ice cream with all the different toppings! read more

I love old school ice cream places. This place brought back summer memories but the price was high for the portion and the quality of the product. $4.50 for a medium soft serve cone is more than twice as much as an arguably better tasting and same sized cone at McDonalds. No biggie though, it was a hot day and it filled a need, but I probably won't go back. read more

Visited the store by chance while walking on the buzzing Broadway roads Tried a simple Vanilla cone It was probably the best vanilla ice cream I have ever had in my life !! Do not miss this place ! And be sure to carry Cash read more