All in all it had a decent spot for the area. Located on central avenue and Paterson street in jersey city you'll find Stack Creamery a speciality build your own ice cream sandwich spot. A very modern take on the classic stuff we love. They had a variety of options to choose from with 6 different cookies and about ten ice cream flavors. I went with a sugar cookie base, peanut butter ice cream and chocolate chips for my topping. The service was fast as they only have one employee working there. She was polite and gave us exactly what we wanted. We went home and enjoyed, it is different worth checking out for yourself, the sandwich was a bit messy. Overall 3.75/5 read more

See all

Who doesn't love an ice cream cookie sandwich? It's nice to have an ice cream shop that specializes in ice cream sandwiches in particular. They freshly bake their cookies every day and they have a decent selection. Their ice creams are also tasty, but I wouldn't say they were remarkable. All in all, really solid place to get an indulgent dessert. I opted for a scoop of cookies and cream with just one cookie on the side, I think it would've been the same price to get ice cream cookie sandwich. I enjoyed it, but unsurprisingly it's super rich. I saw they have boxes of ice cream sandwiches to go. You can also get a giant ice cream cookie sandwich cake. This is such a fun idea for a friend that loves ice cream cookie sandwiches. You can pre-order any flavors you want for pick up - will definitely keep this in mind for birthdays or celebrations. read more

See all

For a person that loves Ice Cream and eats it every day. Stack Creamery tasted great, service was great. Smells was awesome!!!

Yummy, legit ice cream. Every bite is rich and packed with flavor, it's the real stuff. Their cookie sandwich options are plentiful and fun. Quality and portions are great, staff is sweet. Street parking. read more

Had an ice cream cone here and it was very good! No complaints. Staff was really nice. And the inside was okay, nothing out of this world. Simply go in order and be out haha read more

Stack Creamery catered the desserts for a wedding I attended recently, and it was the best wedding dessert I've ever enjoyed! Such fun options, and everything was so fresh and yummy. I loved the Cookie Monster ice cream with two chocolate chip cookies. Such a fun catering idea, and the guys serving everyone were so kind despite working a late-night Friday event!! read more

Stack Creamery - Build your own Ice Cream Sandwich - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

The ice cream literally fell right out the moment I took a bite. It turned into two cookies with some ice cream smear. The cookies and the ice cream are both normal on their own. Without the novelty of the ice cream sandwich concept it is absolutely not worth $8. read more

Stack Creamery - Melted - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

I like this place! I hit a brownie ice cream sandwich with mint chocolate chip ice cream inside. It's best eaten quickly, because the icee cream will harden the brownie fast. If you order it delivery, they will send the ice cream deconstructed so you can warm the brownie up before you put it together. I think that was a nice tough. When I ordered it delivery, I ordered half brownie, half snickerdoodle cookie. I liked the snickerdoodle cookie even more than the brownie. I also ordered it with caramel sauce. The place has a lot of options and it seems like they all taste good. You can also get half price "day old" cookies... they aren't as fresh, but I like the idea of less waste! Kudos for that. read more

Stack Creamery - Brownie and mint chocolate chip ice cream with Oreo crumbles -- Build your own Ice Cream Sandwich - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Who doesn't love ice cream in the middle of winter?! I know I do. Cute little store. There's a small counter to eat at by the window, but not a ton of other space to linger inside. You start with an assortment of cookies (one for the base and one of the top). I went with a brownie on the bottom which was soft and delicious. The peanut butter cookie was my top cookie and was a bit crunchier than I typically like; however, it probably helps to hold the sandwich together once the ice cream is added. Sampled the vegan PBJ and went with that as my ice cream - flavor is heavy on the PB and a tiny bit of J. The graham cracker crumbs were a great topping. Overall this a great desert. Something different and able to be customized. Some of the flavors overpower the others, but it's fun to mix and match. Would make for a fantastic treat when the sun is out and you can sit in the parks nearby. read more

See all

Sweet addition to Jersey City just in time for summer around the corner! This is the second Stack Creamery shop so everything was in place and ready to stack. Mohammed, 1 of the 3 sibling owners, greeted me with a big masked smile and just as excited to make my sandwich as I was to eat the sandwich. He gave me a breakdown of the very clear procedure of what's involved in ordering my specific sandwich. I went with a chocolate chip cookie top, dulce de leche ice cream middle, death by chocolate cookie bottom and brownie bites for topping. With so many selections of cookies, ice cream and toppings, everyone will surely find something they will enjoy. Mohammed told me they also have donuts to make a donut ice cream sandwich! My selection was perfect. My Chocolate Chip Cookie was fantastically chewy with little chunks of milk chocolate. The Dulce De Leche was creamy and flavorful without being too sweet. Death by Chocolate Cookie did not scare me. I nibbled, bit and enjoyed every single bite of that moist ice cream dripped deliciously decadent cookie. The Brownie topping was still fresh with softness mixed with some pieces of the slightly crunchy top of the baked brownie. I will definitely return to try some other combos, maybe with a donut! read more

See all

Gone down hill. Both female employees were rude today. Rolling their eyes and inpatient because my family was deciding on what flavors they wanted. Inconsistent scoop sizes per customer. The cookie sandwiches used to to be sooo large. I'm even looking back at other customer Yelp pictures in comparison to what I got today. And a guy just before I ordered got 4 huge scoops on his ice cream sandwich vs her originally putting two tiny scoops on mine. Asked her to add more and that was greeted with an attitude. Ice cream still taste good but the selection has downsided greatly. No longer have the sorbet flavors to accommodate people with food allergies only the vegan flavors. read more

See all

Finally indulged after walking by a few times, and have no regrets! I got an ice cream sandwich, with a double chocolate chip cookie on one side, cookies & cream cookie on the other side, and filled with salted caramel pretzel ice cream. I love how you can customize everything, and the portion is generous enough to that two people can easily share - I actually asked them to cut the sandwich in half for me, which made it super easy. The ice cream and cookies were all very good. Not the best ever, but quality and fresh, and when put together, a great dessert. I will definitely go back! read more

Stack Creamery - Great JC wall-art! - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

very clean, friendly workers and fresh ice cream! shout out to sara she was so helpful.

Yum-azing cookie sandwiches! They have some really innovative flavors in both cookies and ice cream and the combo is absolutely heavenly!!! Service with a smile! A lovely storefront, beautiful display counter and the cookies are served right out of the baking racks - they're that fresh. Highly recommend for a sweet fix! read more

See all

We went here after having late lunch near by. The concept of cookies and ice cream combo was intriguing. I went in with open idea of what but I ended up asking the nice lady for her recommendation. She was very helpful, patient and professional. I got the chocolate chip and sugar cookie with sea salted ice cream in between. It was a great combo. Now I know what to do, next time I will try something different. Great place to go for dessert and good service. Stack gets a recommendation! Give them love! read more

Love this place!!! Very friendly staff and DELICIOUS ice cream!! Ice cream sandwiches are a must try!

This place is for cheat meal days only!! I've seen a few posts about this place so I needed to check it out. It sits nestled on central Ave in JCheights and it's easy to miss. It's a small shop so be prepared to take your order To go. I am of lover of icecream sandwiches and this is really the best way to do it. They allow you to build your own ice cream sandwich. You can choose your base and one of the choices is a glazed donut! I chose a chocolate chip cookie and a birthday cake cookie. They have a wide variety of ice creams to choose from for your middle. I chose a coffee ice cream. Then you choose whatever toppings that you want. I kept it classic with some rainbow Jimmies (yes I call them jimmies). Voila! I had the perfect ice cream sandwich. The sandwich is huge so you can absolutely split it with someone. It's so big I couldn't pick it up and eat it like a sandwich. I had to use a spoon. The cookies were fresh and the ice cream was sooo good. Bottom line, don't come here unless you have a sweet tooth and I recommend splitting a sandwich if you can agree on flavors. Definitely worth the trip. read more

Stack Creamery - Build your own Ice Cream Sandwiches Heaven - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Loved the Mudlside Ice cream on 2 chocolate chip cookies just what I needed! Staff was friendly and the place is very clean! read more

Stack Creamery - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

I've been disappointed with the service the last few times I came here. I decided to give it another shot and ordered a custom cookie cake for my husbands birthday several days in advance and was assured it wouldn't be problem. Not only did it almost not get made in time it also looks like a child wrote on the cake. For a $65 cake you'd expect better. Only after I asked if the writing could be fixed did he offer to take off the additional charge for the writing. read more

Stack Creamery - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

I have to be honest, I've encountered some mediocre, over-hyped ice cream joints, ok? It always leaves me kinda sad, honestly, which is the complete opposite affect that ice cream is supposed to have on humans. I mean....we all scream....right? Or at least we're supposed to. Well, I did for Stack Creamery, thankfully :-). So, my friend lives near here. We'd walk by "this new ice cream spot" all the time until she finally tried it, and it became the ice cream spot that I needed to try. She spoke highly of it, and recommended that I go. I was leaving her place one night and it was legit RAINING, yes, I'm talkin' cats and dogs! But for some reason, girl, I had this CRAVING for ice cream. I mean, Stack was just there, lookin' all good n everything, and so I was like, "now's the time", even in the pouring rain lol! So I go inside, and was pleasantly pleased with the decor. It was fun, light, and was just cohesive with the product. I really just enjoyed being there. It was good feels and energy, you know? I look at the ice cream flavors and was overwhelmed by their large selection. I saw that you choose your ice cream flavor, as well as your cookie(s) flavor(s) to make an ice cream sandwich. I chose the salted caramel ice cream flavor, which....ok, let me just get into it right now. I love all things salted caramel, hear? This ice cream was no different. It was just perfection in texture. Creamy, rich, thick, and perfectly salted. I always taste each item by itself to see if it can hold its own, and this ice cream delivered. It was in that moment, that I knew this place was legit, and puts forth effort into their ice cream. Also, they have some fun, whimsical flavors to choose from, which I will return for! Ok, so for the cookie flavors (I chose 2), I chose to stick with the salted caramel theme and got the salted caramel pretzel cookie, which also just had the perfect amount of salt levels. It cut through the sweetness, which just made me happy. The other cookie I chose was the party cake cookie. I've rarely gone wrong with a party cake flavor anything, and usually enjoy it, and thought the flavors paired well with salted caramel, so felt content with my decision. It was a delicious, chewy, flavorful cookie. It was good enough where you could just buy it separately. I got my ice cream sandwich rolled in one of my favorite cereals, Cinnamon Toast Crunch. I mean, I have to say, I know how to pair cookie and ice cream flavors with cereal. It was all cohesive. They all got along beautifully, and made my taste buds happy. My friend was right about Stack. I'm glad I chose to stop by in the pouring the rain. It totally made getting my socks and shoes soaked, worth it! I'll likely stop by every time I go to her place from this point moving forward! I do believe they have another location. Take that trip if you can! Trust. read more

See all

A really good place to get ice cream/ ice cream sandwich in the heights, especially for the ones living around Washington Park. Their ice creams are really good and taste better than other ice cream places around the neighborhood. The ambience of the place is also good and the staff is friendly. I had ice cream sandwich for the first time and must say it was really good but yeah! Too much of a calorie intake.. the ice cream sandwich though is good when it comes to sharing with others else.. a scoop of ice cream is really good. I do look forward to trying out other flavors in their menu. Staff is pretty friendly here and the payment is easy to make whereas keep an eye on their cookies.. they also sell it next day at a discounted rate! read more

Stack Creamery - Ice cream sandwich - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

I am in awe! This is by far the best and most exciting dessert spot in NJ! When i walked in, i was greeted by the super sweet owner and the delectable scent of home-made cookies - the scent is so good that i wish i could be surrounded by it all the time- a friend later told me that they actually sell that scent as a candle haha! I need that candle now. Everything looked so damn good so i asked for a recommendation. The owner recommended either the peanut butter ice cream or the coffee do i went with the coffee with chocolate drizzled on it in between chocolate cookies. I took it home and devoured it immediately- i did NOt share haha. I am so happy that this place opened up right in the heart of Jersery City Heights - fantastic location, right on the same streets as some of the best lunch/dinner spots in NJ. This is the perfect place to go to for dessert or to stop by for an indulgent snack. I noticed they also deliver which is fantastic! Overall, by far the most tasty desserts in NJ and super lovely owners. Cant wait to go back and have the Stack experience again soon :) read more

See all

So freaking good! I got Half brownie half sugar cookie with cookies and cream ice cream and coco crisps. Loved it! Next time would just do brownie on both sides. Also, got brownie on both sides with dulce de leche ice cream and coco pebbles. It was good but the dulce de leche ice cream was too sweet for my liking. Definitely would go back! read more

See all

Favorite ice cream cookie sandwich ! They always taste amazing. Love both Westwood and JC locations.

For those who know me, know that I love dessert, especially when it's a fusion of multiple desserts in one. I have been patiently waiting to try Stack Creamery and I finally checked that off. I ordered a cookie ice cream sandwich: chocolate chip top and bottom cookie, cookie monster ice cream, and fruity pebbles topping. The cookies were humongous stuffed with creamy cookie monster ice cream. The fruity pebbles added the perfect crunch factor and made it more colorful. I was ready to tackle the sandwich and within seconds it was completely devoured. The cookies were chewy, soft and filled with chocolate chips in every bite. An excellent creation indeed. read more

Stack Creamery - Cookie ice cream sandwich - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

AMAZINGNESS - I am in love with the ice cream sandos here and YOU will be too! Their cookies for their ice cream sandwiches alone are worth a trip, but together with some quality ice cream is maybe the best I've ever had! Do yourself a favor and get the brownie/chocolate chip cookie combo and thank me later :) read more

Stack Creamery - Build your own Ice Cream Sandwiches - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

I finally got to check this place out. It is a big place with tons of options to build your best ice cream sandwich. I opted for the cookies which were soft and moist. I was a little disappointed in the ice cream flavor. I chose the cannoli, which lacked a lot of the flavor I was expecting. The sandwich overall is pretty huge and definitely shareable. I would give it another try for sure. read more

See all

I felt the ice cream and cookie were really average and weren't special. I was hoping they'd be some homemade kind of cookies but tasted like frozen ones :( I think the idea of the cereal around it is super cute! Just wish they used better cookies or homemade ones! read more

Stack Creamery - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

This place was super lying I love the fact that you can make your own ice cream sandwich with extra snacks inside! The wait was kinda long but worth it. Although renovations aren't completed still a cute place. Staff was friendly. Will be back read more

See all

I enjoyed this cute ice cream parlor. It felt very welcoming. I had cotton candy and it sent me back to when I was a little girl and eating my favorite ice cream flavored ice cream! It is wonderful, friendly workers. read more

Stack Creamery - Art on the inside wall of the store! - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Full disclosure, I don't think I've ever written a review that wasn't positive. I was excited for Stack to open up. I went by today and didn't feel entirely welcome at first. No one explained much to me; just asked what I wanted. I asked for a sugar cookie sandwich and the employees both turned around behind the counter and sniffed a bunch of cookies - one even did so by pulling her mask down first!! I was taken aback and didn't even say anything as I was feeling quite uncomfortable already. They seemed to be completely frazzled not knowing which cookies were which. They had to breathe all over them to identify the cookies before making any sandwiches. During Covid this is honestly unacceptable. I didn't even try my sandwich. It went straight in the trash. My partner said their cookie was stale and was underwhelmed. read more

Stack creamery was delicious. There were so many options for me to choose from, thankfully no one was waiting behind me and I was able to take my time to decide. I ordered cannoli ice cream on sugar cookies with vanilla drizzle.... Wow! Yummy yummy yummy! read more

See all

First time going here, only street parking nearby. They have cute ice cream cart which is great for insta photos. It was $6 for one ice cream sandwich. It was pretty big portion that I couldnt finish at that moment but ended up finishing it later that day. We got smores cookies, cookies n cream ice cream, and brownie crumbs and chocolate chips cookies, cookie dough ice cream, and brownie crumbs. It was not busy when I went. People passing by saw our icecream sandwiches and went inside to get some for themselves. They should have chairs and table for people to sit on. read more

Good ice cream, delicious cookies and treats, friendly service. On the pricier side but worth it! read more

Stack Creamery - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

super disappointing.... when they started out, it was great. Has gone straight downhill. You used to get 2 chunky cookies on top of 3 giant scoops of ice cream.... now it's a measly scoop and cookies are paper thin. Also nasty hairs stuck in the ice cream. Will choose better dessert spots on Central Ave from now on. read more

My first time getting icecream there and it was a 10/10 experience! The worker there was very friendly and my money was well spent. Can't wait to stop by again especially during the hot days in summer. read more

Looooved my ice cream sandwich from Stack. Everything was delicious: the cookies, the ice cream, the toppings. There's plenty of options to choose from. Plus they have ice cream pints and cakes ready to take home, and day-old cookies for 50% off read more

Took the little one, wife and brother in law here after playing in the park. Very impressed by not only the ice cream, but with the very personable staff member working today. I resisted temptation and avoided the donut, but had to get the matcha green tea. We certainly will be back and plan on getting one for the birthday cakes, instead of our usual Carvel. Glad to see this in the neighborhood, hope they do well. read more

Order on the go... I love how they mixed two of the best kind - Cookies & Icecream!!! You have the option to pick what kind of cookies (half & half) you like to go with your favorite flavor of ice cream. Not overwhelmingly sweet. Must go spot! read more

Stack Creamery - Chocolate chip & Sugar Cookies with Salted Caramel Ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Great ice cream! The workers are really friendly, and great atmosphere! Cookies are really flavorful as well :)