We went to Mahi Nic's on a rainy day. All seating is outside, most is under a tent, while others are only under umbrellas. We did have to wait a few minutes to be seated, and weren't sure why we weren't given menus. But we saw signs indicating to order at the back counter. We went to the counter, took a menu and came back to our party to decide what we would order. You place your order, give your table number and they bring your food. The food took about 10-15 minutes to come out, but it was warm and delicious. My husband got the blacked mahi sandwich, I got the Iron Skillet Shrimp (pictured) and a Turbo Pelican Colada. Everything was delicious! The iron skillet came with 8 huge shrimp and I opted for garlic butter, which gave a dipping sauce. The fries were HUGE! Our kids loved the fries, burger and hot dogs that they ordered. The drink I ordered was strong and tasty, the toasted coconut was the icing on the cake. The drink came with a beautiful drink decoration, which my kids found cool to play with. We would visit again and plan on it. read more

Mahi Nic - Iron Skillet Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

We had another fantastic experience at Mahi Nic! The food is consistently delicious, the prices are very reasonable, and the service is always friendly, attentive, and welcoming. It has become one of our favorite places to eat on South Padre Island. One of my favorite things is how genuinely pet-friendly they are. They even have a dog menu, so our dachshund, PeeWee, gets to enjoy lunch with us too. It's refreshing to find a restaurant that truly welcomes the whole family, including four-legged family members. After watching the KRGV Take 5 segment, I loved learning that the new owners were the cooks before taking over the restaurant. You can absolutely tell they know what they're doing. The quality of the food, the consistency, and the atmosphere have all been elevated under the new ownership while still keeping the laid-back island vibe. If you're looking for great food, excellent service, reasonable prices, and a place where everyone--including your dog--is welcome, Mahi Nic is the place to go. We'll definitely be back again and again with PeeWee and the rest of our family and friends. Highly recommend! read more

See all

My girlfriend and I stopped by Mahi Nic during our South Padre trip and really enjoyed the atmosphere. The location is fantastic, with great views overlooking the docks and water. Unfortunately, we found the food a bit underwhelming compared to some of the other restaurants we visited during our stay. We ordered the mahi tacos, and while the sauce was nice, the tacos came out somewhat cold. They weren't bad, but they just didn't leave much of an impression. The service was alright as well. We arrived about 10 minutes after opening and ended up standing around for a bit before someone came over to take our order. Overall, we loved the ambiance and location, but the food and service didn't quite measure up to some of the other spots we tried in South Padre. read more

Mahi Nic - Mahi Tacos - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

This place has only outdoor seating and you have to order at the counter. The food was good. The fries are huge and filling. The portion of the garlic shrimp for the price was not ideal. If you are in the area and need a quick bite it's definitely good for that. The drinks were a little sweet and they have self serve water. Service was friendly. read more

Mahi Nic - Fish tacos - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

I'm so excited to find somewhere on the island that is 100% gluten free!!! This place will be my most go every trip!!! The food was good! I had chicken strips and French fries. The burgers looked amazing! The service was top notch and so friendly!!!! read more

See all

Holy crap this place was good. A friend recommended this place to us, so we had it in the back of our minds, and then a boat captain recommended it, so we knew this was the place! We are so glad we came to try Mahi Nic's. The setting it percent, right on the marina and outdoor vibes. Thing fancy, nothing flashy, just downright amazing grub. The ladies were very helpful and tended to us perfectly! I could not believe the size of the fried and how damn good they were. Be careful--- Mahi Nic fries will ruin all other fries for you. read more

See all

Terrific ambiance, Good service and fresh shrimp but unfortunately they have replaced their fabulous elotes corn on the cob sides with mush in a cup. read more

One of the best places for lunch on South Padre Island. We were amazed at their mega huge hand cut fries. They give like a potato and a half and each fry is about 1/4 a potato. Generous serving of mahi for their sandwich but not so much for their tacos. So if u r hungry go for the mahi sandwich. Free refills for their kids drinks. Several different flavors of lemonade. Open seating with views of the dock. Great stop after a dolphin tour. Safe place with options for those who can't have gluten. Staff are very laid back and friendly. read more

See all

Mahi Nic's did not disappoint any of the times we dined there over our long weekend getaway to SPI. We'll definitely be returning the next time we are in town. The food was delicious, the waitstaff was friendly, and the come as you are atmosphere was definitely appreciated after our full days at the beach! Definitely give Mahi Nic's a try, we are so glad that we did!! read more

See all

Fresh blackened mahi tacos with a nice view of the harbor on SPI. My brother In-laws 80th bday lunch was fun & food was delicious and healthy, except for the hand cut potato logs(skin left on w/house ranch) The local caught mahi was good in the three white corn tortillas with Pico & Cole slaw . The potatoes were a bit too big a little soggy for my liking (80 plus percent humidity makes everything soggy). Fun harbor view with some high dollar fishing boats for scenery. Order at the counter & the friendly server's bring it to your table. Huge mobile a/c unit was mercifully moving some air around the open, covered outdoor eating area that was busy at lunch.. read more

See all

So happy to see a celiac friendly restaurant on SPI! My husband loved his first chicken tenders in years, and my tacos were great! And Pina Coladas were perfect! Headed back right now for our last meal on the island read more

I felt I was attended very well here, the vibes were relaxing and enjoyable, the food was delicious and so were the drinks. read more

Mahi Nic - Mahi ceviche - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

Mahi Nick's is such a great little outdoor spot right on the bay with a beautiful view! Their shrimp tacos are HUGE, but the best thing on the menu has to be their hand-cut, gigantic fries. They're so good! Definitely a must-try if you're in the area! read more

You order and then pick your seat but they will bring the food. The mahi tacos are great. The fries are the largest crinkle fry I have ever seen. The cole slaw is creamy and on the sweeter side which I really really liked. The margs are good, recommend frozen over on the rocks. They have bar style seating overlooking the water and various tables under cover. It was nice chill vibe. read more

10/10 our hotel room wasn't ready and we had our pups with us so we headed over to mahi nics! When people say don't judge a book by its cover... this is what they mean haha not the most appealing driving by but the service and food were both TOP TIER! As soon as we got seated a lady brought our pups a cookie and water! Portion size is big too! Where else on the island or anywhere in Texas can you get a chicken breast for your dogs that size for only 3$ ?! read more

Mahi Nic - Chicken breast for pups! - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

I honestly can't give Mahi Nic's enough stars! My family loves good food...we're serious foodies and after trying four other restaurants in town, nothing came close to the flavor, quality, and attention to detail we found here. We stopped in right at opening on June 20th, and it was clear from the first bite that the chef takes real pride in what he serves. Every dish we ordered was an absolute hit. We had three orders of Mahi tacos, side of beans, elote, the blackened chicken sandwich, and a hot dog for my little one. Everything was fresh, perfectly cooked, and bursting with flavor. The fries really stood out, crisp and well-seasoned. Even the beans, which are often just a filler side at most places, were packed with flavor and paired perfectly with their rice. And the elote? Creamy, zesty, and honestly one of the best I've ever had. The service was top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and never let our drinks run low. I also loved the little touches, like the biggest, juiciest lemon wedges we'd been served anywhere on the island. They went above and beyond by bringing a bowl of water and a treat for my service dog without me even having to ask...that really meant a lot. This place is a true find. We'll absolutely be back, and if you're in town, make sure you don't miss it! read more

See all

Monster Burger and Fries. One of the best burgers I have ever had hands down. Their fries are insanely huge and taste great. Great location dockside. Really enjoyed our lunch there after our son's surfing lesson. read more

Mahi Nic - The Reel Big Burger w/Fries - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

The blackened mahi tacos are so good. Not too spicy. And filling. We also got the shrimp tacos. We all tried both. All 4 agreed the mahi tacos are better. So yummy. read more

We chose to eat here because of Texas Bucket List. And glad we did. Our favorite was the burger. The best burger we have had in a long time. Fries are yummy too. The service was excellent. And sitting outside looking at the boats in the marina is also nice too. A great place for lunch for sure. read more

Mahi Nic - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

This was our favorite meal we ate the one the island. The staff was the best. So helpful, friendly and attentive. Order the blackened mahi tacos (not too spicy). Rice and beans side were YUMMY! Loved the lemonade too. Fun atmosphere right on the pier. read more

Great food, affordable prices, decent portion sizes, open atmosphere and chill vibe. I enjoyed it! read more

Mahi Nic - Shrimp rancheros - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

First, check the hours as they are a bit strange - they close at 6;30 most nights. That said, it was AMAZING. The burgers are perfect and the best on the island. The hotdogs, wings and everything mahi is incredible. This all comes from a tiny restaurant on the bay that you'd miss if you aren't looking. I'm local and just found this so the mistake is on me! Go soon and go often. There aren't many tables so consider getting it to go. read more

Located on the water. Food was great and really large portions. Best food we've had in South Padre and the service was fantastic. We will definitely be back again. read more

The food is delicious and always fresh! A must-stop whenever you go to the island. The Mahi ceviche is my favorite, especially because they actually serve enough for it to be a full meal. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Food and service were both amazing. Something for mom and dad and the kiddos too. My husband and I shared the mahi tacos and nachos and the fish was cooked perfectly. Everything was delicious and the staff were all kind and attentive and great with the kids. read more

See all

So excited to give this place a try since we drove 9 hours from where we live. My husband and I love trying new foods and this was our first time going to South Padre. We came here yesterday but their system was down. We totally understood and we definitely wanted to try again the next day. Ok, hostess was seating us and not once did she mentioned that we needed to place our order at a counter. The order section is not visible at all by the way. We noticed everyone was getting their food but us. We waited 30 min and I decided to go up to the same hostess and asked what's going on and where's our waitress. Immediately, she was extremely rude and unprofessional. She took offense and told me that she already told us to place our food order at the counter with her attitude and pointing at me with her damn pen. We asked for the manager and she was very nice and wanted to help us but we lost interest. What I would change is maybe more clear for customers that have trouble hearing. Restaurant was clean but unfortunately they lost a customer. read more

Ok this place is a hit. Lunch was the Mahi Tacos and the Mahi Po boy (recommended by staff). Wife says possibly the best fish tacos she's had. And the Mahi Po boy was amazing. Very reasonable price and we left absolutely happy and full it's not a small sandwich. The staff topped it off with great service. You could tell they wanted to make sure we were happy and taken off. Don't waste your time at the other restaurant that don't even offer local fish in there fish tacos. IYKYK read more

Top Ten burgers in the world. Burger is better than McDonald's burger. Service was long. Outside enjoying the weather. read more

Mahi Nic - Best burger ever - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

Outside seating but there was a breeze and a view. They did have porta cools and fans in the dining areas so it wasn't terribly hot. For open seating I didn't see one damn sea gull. That's a good thing lol. Wife and I spit a cheeseburger and Fries and it was plenty of food. They do have a bar if you're a drinker. No complaints on our end. Totally would eat there again if we were in town longer. read more

Great little place to stop for a bite to eat and a cold drink when you're in South padre Island. It is outdoor seating with the deck, facing the water and very quaint. The staff was very friendly. The food was excellent. We just had the chips and salsa and the chips were homemade so we had to go back for a second order cause they were so good. I would recommend stopping here for a bite to eat before you head off the island. read more

Mahi Nic - Sign - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

I have been here in south padre a few days now and the places people have been telling us to go to eat have been very mediocre..however after reading the reviews on Mahi Nics I knew we had to try it out. This is my kind of place, chill vibe at the marina, looking at beautiful boats on the water. The food was outstanding! we had blackened shrimp tacos and blackened mahi tacos with a side of chips and pico, (all freshly made) and 2 frozen drinks that tasted like dessert. EVERYTHING WAS AMAZING!!! And I am not exaggerating, it has been the best food I have had since I landed here. Do yourself a favor and get out of the crappy strip mall restaurants and give this place a go. It feels like you are on vacation and it won't break the bank either...very reasonably priced for the amount of food you receive and the quality of the food. I wish I took photos but I was so hungry when I arrived and kind of forgot.. highly recommend! read more

Let's start with drinks--not worth the money. We ordered the mango margarita swirl and there was absolutely NO tequila in there. When we brought this to the attention of management, she brought us some white paper cups with tequila diluted with water. It did not smell nor taste like tequila. So disappointing after spending almost $8.00 on 1 drink. We then ordered a hot dog which was surprisingly decent. The bun was even toasted. It also came with jalapeños and I swear they put at least 20 jalapeños on one hot dog--but if that's your thang, you'll be happy. Overall, it was not the most scenic view in my opinion. It was a sunny day out, but it was pretty dark and gloomy in this space. I personally would not recommend this spot--Really surprised at the high review. read more

Mahi Nic - Watered down tequila offered to us because there was no tequila in our margaritas. - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

See all

Cannot say enough about this place! Hubby & I planned to eat here after seeing a YouTube video on visiting SPI....did not disappoint!! We both had the Mahi tacos his with fries, mine with the beans & rice...the Mahi blackened tacos!!! Flat out some of the best I've ever had!!! So fresh & delicately seasoned & prepared! The homemade coleslaw...yeah probably top 3 of my life!!!! The Elote corn...better than any I've ever had even in Mexico! The view pretty awesome too...the staff was incredible, attentive without being obnoxious....very nice people....the prices very fair. The portions are large...bring your appetites, it's all good!! Highly recommend! Even the Great-tailed Grackle birds were awesome read more

See all

well... with a solid 4 1/2 stars and over 1K in reviews i was expecting more. nice location, right on the dock, outdoor but covered dining, with smells of burgers and blackened seafood mixed with whiffs of fishy smells you get near docks. was there at 7ish on a saturday - off season so not packed, but busy. walk up ordering - keep walking forward til you find it. i was hankering for shrimp tacos or mexican style shrimp cocktail, but when i asked, was told shrimp was not deveined. i dont get seafood restaurants that want to feed you shrimp poo - for me its not a preference - its right - deveined or wrong - not! so... decided on mahi tacos, hubbie decided to get the islander burger. i got the elote corn - hubbies burger came with the fries that people raved about in reviews. we also decided to start with the mermaid: chips, queso, salsa & pico. lets start with likes: burger was very good - the soft, sweet bun made it. wasnt so soft it fell apart though. salsa was very good, pico tasty, my tacos were pretty good - but fish was tasty but very dry. the elote corn was a MESS! WAY overdressed with gobs and GOBS of chipotle mayo. maybe i missed it, but i did not see "chipotle" in the description. corn itself was ok once i scraped off all the sauce - thats a personal preference. queso was straight up ricos from a can. fries were not great, big huge, steak style but waffle cut, soggy, not crisp, but they were cooked through. also not much service going on, so be prepared to go find someone to refill your tea. there was a self serve water jug. sodas are canned, but only $2, so not overpriced. overall an ok meal, but not as good as we were expecting. read more

See all

Definitely come here get the french fries they're unbelievable. Incredible $5 bloody Mary and nobody can beat $2.25 beer. read more

Mahi Nic - Fries - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

Amazing food 5 * And we ordered delivery. Fab fish tacos! Fresh food crunchy salad and just order the Caesar salad dressing! Well done Mahi Nic read more

Fantastic Mahi sandwich and mahi tacos! The real winner is the rice and beans, though....amazing! Great bay views and friendly service.

Mahi Nic IS just a great as all the reviews say!!! And more!! The staff were so friendly and over the top hospitable. When you walk inside Mahi Nic, there is an order station (in case you get confused on how it works). The order board lists amazing food items and drinks. We ordered the Mahi tacos with double fries no slaw, the elote corn, and Chief Burger with sweet tea. The fries were huge and fresh. Our Mahi taco tasted THE BEST I've ever had, especially with lime squeezed on top, FANTASTIC! The chief burger was delicious as was the Elote corn. I have no complaints in any way. This is definitely the place to try :D read more

Mahi Nic - Elote - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

This place was GOOD! From their ginormous French Fries to their perfectly cooked shrimp! It's by the water so it also provides an excellent view. read more

Mahi Nic - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas

Many dockside restaurants I've been to are a miss on the food, and seem to sustain themselves with the allure of being on the water. Mahi Nic is the exception and the food is the highlight. The seafood is so delicious and fresh. We went twice during our visit to SPI. We had the iron skillet shrimp, ceviche, and blackened mahi sandwich. And the fries are incredible!!! read more

Mahi Nic - Iron skillet shrimp - Seafood Near Me - South Padre Island, Texas