I was delivered a delicious pie!! Really nice delivery guy brought my pizza up to my apartment even…read morethough it was hard to find. Delivered in less than 30 mins. I was skeptical when I saw the reviews and I almost thought I got a cold pizza when I saw the box top was kind of squished and part of my salad had spilled out of its container into the plastic bag it arrived in. The driver apologized before I even said anything. To my surprise the pie was in mint condition! Put the salad back together and the ice berg lettuce was really fresh and crisp, I'm glad I added mushrooms, olives and bell peppers. Mild Hot Wings were really good and I loved their blue cheese! Thoroughly enjoyed my meal. Will definitely be ordering from them again!

I ordered Pasta with Garlic Sauce. That is exactly how it is described on their menu, no more, no…read moreless. I was picturing pasta, probably spaghettI, with olive oil and lots of garlic. I also asked for broccoli in the pasta. What I received was meat filled tortellini with lots of tomato chunks and a kind of pesto-ish sauce that was made from minuscule bits of soggy broccolI. Adding insult to injury, the tortellini wasn't cooked all the way--it was actually hard, and weirdly dry around the edges as if it had been sitting cooked but uncovered a a long time. Inedible. Also, I don't eat meat! All the other pastas on their menu are described as having red sauce or Alfredo sauce. I just assumed that since the pasta I wanted had no mention of red sauce or anything else it was just pasta with garlic sauce. Come on, nobody orders pasta and expects to get tortellinI. Nobody orders anything and expects it to be undercooked and completely different than the description. So dissatisfied. And annoyed.

Franco's is a gem that is truly unexpected. Each piece we ordered (and we got 4) was absolutely…read morestunningly perfect. The onion pie was sweet from the onion, tangy from the sauce, cheesy, and crisp. The margherita was so fresh while also being perfect in execution. The Pepperoni was just really good quality pepperoni and very tasty. The scilian was so light and fluffy while being heavier than the others. It was too hot in the spot, I wish that wasn't the case. But service was prompt and felt like a bunch of Ithaca kids...the drinks were very good with glass bottle pellegrino and fun italian sodas. We'll be back - one of the best slices of pizza in Ithaca.

Great spot for pizza and cannoli in Ithaca!…read more The cannolis are generously filled (no hollow interiors here) and not too sweet. These were honestly the perfect cannolis in my opinion- not too lemony, not too much chocolate, but still sweet enough. The garlic knots were really good and a really great deal! Pizza was good too- a bit greasy but lots of toppings to choose from! Overall, I would recommend!

We placed an order for the party pack with boneless wings,extra blue cheese and 2 bottles of soda…read more I looked at their menu online so I thought I had an idea about the total cost. My order costs was $74. We had no toppings on the pizza. When I questioned the price I was told the updated menu is not online. The wings were very good and the pizza was liked by most.

I wanted to love Carrozza... I did! It's been on my Yelp list for a while. Given the Yelp rating,…read moremaybe I expected too much... I don't know. Sadly, Carrozza Pizza didn't cut it for me or my friends. Don't get me wrong, the service itself is fantastic. The employees seem to know everyone who comes in for pick-up (nobody seems to be eating at the restaurant itself), so you get this real sense of being treated like family. The folks here went out of their way to make sure I had everything I wanted for my order, and that everything was as ordered, before I left the restaurant. I'm giving this restaurant a 3/5 rating here on Yelp BECAUSE of the service... otherwise, I'd be giving it a 2/5, honestly. For me, the real downside was the pizza. My order included two large pizzas to split with a couple friends, and 1) the cooked dough was a bit "chewier" (more gluten-y?) in texture than I like, and 2) the center, say, 3rd of each pizza was not cooked well. It was basically soggy and under-cooked. I would pick up a slice and the bottom half of the slice would drop and the toppings would start to slide off. It just wasn't appetizing to any of us. The portions are generous, which they'd honestly have to be because I was initially really surprised with how much my full order cost. I had been told when ordering that I would get a bit of a better deal if I ordered a sheet pizza and just ordered different toppings for parts of it... but that wasn't really what I or my friends wanted. TL;DR Too costly for the quality. Service is great, but that's not enough to get me to make another order anytime soon.

We ordered a value "deal" as we had a small party staying at a local hotel. It included a salad,…read morewings, and a pizza. The pizza is a New York Style, and pretty good...probably a 7/10. We bought a chicken/bacon/ranch and a Hawaiian style (we didn't try "just" a cheese as recommended here on Yelp). I only tried a corner of the Chicken/Bacon/Ranch, perhaps the Hawaiian would have benefited from a bit more sauce. The salads were good (romaine/tomato/red onion/black olives), and the wings were good as well. We ordered mild and honey. There was no shortage of sauce on the wings...the honey wings in particular were really swimming! Delivery to a local hotel was fast; and the only negative aspect of the entire experience was that no plates/forks were delivered with the food. That's not a deal breaker, but when you have such a large order, included plates, utensils, and napkins would be appreciated when delivering to a hotel. So...5 stars based on the quick delivery, overall quality of the meal, and a pretty affordable price (each combo was $28 in July 2022).

I was pleasantly surprised! I ordered a medium cheese pizza. It was baked nicely. The crust was…read morecooked through with a bit of crunch on the outside and a soft tasty inside. The sauce was good, not over spiced/herbed, (So many places over herb the sauce with oregano), not too salty and just the right amount on the pie. A good basic pizza. I will order from them again. The service was good. The woman who cashed me out was friendly. Over all a very good experience.

Excellent pizza! Fresh ingredients, plenty of tomato and basil on our Napoli. Cooked to perfection…read more Absolutely would recommend.

The service was very poor and almost nonexistent, idk if the guy had a horrible breakup or what but…read moreI felt bad for him, no hi when we walked in, no 'can I help you' or 'can I take you order' nothing like that at all, he just stood there, we were the only ones in there too. Another guy walked in and he did the same thing to him and the guy said thank you and the worker said nothing. It was very strange. The pizza somehow only tastes like a tomato, the cheese on both the regular and vegan pizza had no taste, the crust too, it all definitely needed seasoning. The bathroom was sooooo nasty and the toilet had something on it that I won't even discuss on here, just use your imagination, maybe the guy was mad about that?

Driving through the southern tier and I am always looking for a new pizza place to try. Stopped…read morehere and grabbed a couple slices of cheese. I came at the right time because the pie just came out. It was a solid slice with a decent crunch when you bit into it. Sauce was ok. The workers were friendly and place was alright. Not blown away from this place but it's a solid 3 stars.

The pizza was definitely good for reheated cheese slices with toppings added later. Counter staff…read morewas pleasant. Had dirty mushrooms on the $14 vegetarian salad. Found after several bites of manure grit in my mouth. Live and learn. Won't be back to repeat the $29 take out order consisting of 2 slices, a vegetarian salad with manure mushrooms, and a small dessert.

This is a classis New York pizzaria. I had a pepperoni and a mushroom slice the first day I ran…read moreacross it. I was blown away! I enjoyed it enough to go back the next day and order an entire pie of each. When I am in the area next I will be going again!

Great small-town pizza place. Really good right off the menu, but they will adjust your pizza the…read moreway you like!

Great local joint with the two owners who call you by name! Avoid eating inside - it's hot and the…read moreTV is blasting. The pizza is INCREDIBLE. The crust is so good. Get the hot wings or ask them to make garlic Parmesan, yum! They did mess up our kinda complicated pizza. We wanted sausage & pepperoni on all, lt. cheese on 1/2, mushrooms on 1/2. Instead, the side with mushrooms had the light cheese and no sausage/pepperoni. The other side didn't have light cheese. A minor detail because the pizza was still fantastic! Will come again.

Ordered Food at 530p for a pickup in 30 minutes. Didn't get food until 630p after waiting in the…read moreshop for 30 mins.

Ordered delivery online at 2:55 and it said it would be here by 4. At 4:35 we called them to ask if…read moreit would be here soon and they said the driver just left. We are less than a 5 minute drive and they still didn't get here for another 20 minutes, finally arriving at 4:55. I was planning to call and cancel which I should have because everything was lukewarm, and wet and soggy. So upset with their quality and delivery service. It's not like it's cheap food either. Never ordering here again. Go to Carrozza's instead.

The service was friendly. We had a gluten free pizza, a garden salad and an order of hot wings. The…read morepizza crust was on the bland side as many gluten free crusts are but it didn't taste like a cauliflower crust so that was good. It was very thin which was a plus too. The salad was exactly what you would hope for nice variety and nothing shriveled. The wings were good but with bones in the name I was expecting more flavor. The only reason I can not give them five stars is because even though the wings were hot and provided the heat I expected it did not have a robust flavor. It tasted like franks with some butter in it. Again not terrible in any way but not what I expected based on the store name. The prices were very reasonable. Anyone staying at Greek peak or passing through the area can safely eat here and have everyone find something to eat without breaking the bank.

I took my son to dinner here while I was in town. He had been before with friends and recommended…read moreeverything. We had an amazing waitress and a series of back-up help who were so attentive to every detail. The food was delicious. We both left feeling like it was time to go to bed....satiated and relaxed. Would recommend.

Cozy (if a touch loud), excellent Italianesque pizza/pasta/salad joint. Good cocktails, beer and…read morewine cards. Experienced and personable servers. Bougie uni crowd, but good value for money nevertheless -- not always the case in Ithaca. Pasta Alla Vodka was particularly fine.