Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Maker Pizza Thornhill

    4.6 (50 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM
    Updated 2 months ago

    Maker Pizza Thornhill Photos

    Business Info

    MAKER PIZZA THORNHILL ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Maker Pizza Thornhill

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Marvin S.

    Definitely the best pizza I've had in Toronto. The everything bagel seasoning on the crust took it over the top.

    Pie menu
    John Y.

    Finally found my favorite pizza joint in Markham. Went on "National Pie day" where slices were only $3.14 (nice play on words). Warning- if you grew up on Pizza hut, Pizza Pizza. Domino's, Papa John's or any other generic pizza chain, you will be severely disappointed. No globs of stringy flavorless cheese, sweet tasteless tomato sauce and spongy soggy doughy crust, bye bye Felicia. My dearest pizza lovers, we are talking top quality pizza ingredients here, no joke. Got the basic cheese slice, didn't want any add-ons to distort the flavor profile. YOLO'd it and also got the pepperoni vodka sauce slice. After about 15min wait. The slices finally arrived. They were getting slammed, lines of people waiting for their slices/pies. Got bad as some people were waiting over 45mins for their orders. One thing I didn't like was that they sprinkled parmesan cheese (at least I think it was parmesan cheese) on both slices. It added to the flavor profiles but it really wasn't necessary, some people may like it. I don't. Both slices were on the thin side but packed with flavor. The rich tomato sauce profile came through with a nice balance/ratio to the cheese. Some like globs of cheese on their slice, I prefer a balance between the cheese and tomato sauce. The vodka sauce on the pepperoni slice was excellent and had a nice spicy kick to it. Both slices might be considered on the salty side (for those who are sensitive to salt), this coming from the richness of the cheese and especially from the pepperoni. Finish this all off with a nice crispy flavorful crust. It was so good, I ordered an additional two slices to go! Mamma mia. That's some great pizza

    Polidennis S.

    Tried one slice of cheese and one slice of pepperoni. I would rate the cheese slice 8/10 and the pepperoni 8.5/10. This is some of the best pizza in the GTA. Nice flavourful crust, good quality sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. Im going to come back and get a full pizza next time for my family. I look forward to trying some different toppings.

    Burnt Marshmallow cookie
    Vonny W.

    I couldn't be happier when the team from Maker's Pizza decided to open up in my neighborhood! I love using their app for easy online ordering. You can see their full menu, as well as current offers/deals, and pay through there to either place an order for ASAP or scheduled for later, via pickup and/or delivery! This visit, I saw there was a promotion for a 12" pie plus a dip and drink for $25, so I went with Frank's Best, their garlic dip, and a Nestea. I also couldn't resist to get three of their Burnt Marshmallow cookies. Frank's Best was loaded with caramelized onions, goat cheese, grass-fed mozzarella, and rosemary, making it such a flavorful pie, you don't even need a dipping sauce to pair. Despite the use of sea salt on this as well, it's actually quite sweet. To finish, they brush the crust with organic honey and sesame seeds. I love the chew on the crust and it's slightly crispier exterior. Now, I did say you don't "need" a dip to pair but their garlic dip is a must try! It literally tastes as if there's an entire garlic in this 4 oz dip, making it so good. I always save up any leftovers to use in wraps/sandwiches I make at home later in the week. It adds so much flavor and goes with everything! As for the cookies - these might not be well-known yet, but I can't gatekeep these! They're a little doughier on the inside but have a crunchy exterior. The melted marshmallows on these make them elite! They are quite sweet but I love 'em and grab them when I want to indulge. Not the mention, their size! I couldn't be happier when the employee told me upon pick up that he gifted me an extra cookie. Why? I don't know but I didn't question it! Pick up at the restaurant is super easy and efficient. Service is also friendly and efficient. I love that for takeout orders, they keep the pies in a warmer until you arrive and all dips/drinks/cookies are packaged in a eco-friendly paper bag for easy transport. You're welcome to help yourself to paper plates and (good quality) napkins which are placed on the counter. The place at a glance every visit is well-kept and clean. There are a couple tables for dine-in, not serviced, but I've never sat in myself.

    Amazing service and staff Amazing food quality I have never been disappointed from this place

    Franks best  Caramelized onions, goat cheese, grass fed mozzarella, rosemary, sea salt, organic honey, sesame crust (applied with honey)

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Worst pizza ever. So salty and too much cheese. The pizza was also so oily. The garlic bread was spicy and also salty and greasy.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Delicious pizza. Friendliest staff. Easy to order on App. A real asset to the neighbourhood. Will definitely return.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Maker Pizza Thornhill Reviews in Other Languages

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 10,337 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Carbon Bar And Grill

    Carbon Bar And Grill

    4.3(16 reviews)
    3.4 kmLangstaff, Thornhill
    $
    Kitchen open late
    Sports on TV

    Came by to check out this place I drove by over 100x. Its seating is comfortable el with enough tvs…read morefor a bar. The staff is patient and polite. The service was quick as well and gave us waters without asking. Not always the case in a bar. The food is not amazing but it is great for the value. It's not the 5 star Michelin fare but u definitely get your moneys worth and more. Would recommend and come back again.

    If there were an award for the most disappointing bar and grill on the planet, this place would win…read moreit without competition. From the moment I walked in, I regretted every life decision that led me to this door. The service? Non-existent. I think the servers were actively avoiding eye contact so they wouldn't have to do their job. It took 25 minutes just to get water, and by the time my food arrived, I had aged emotionally. The food? I've had better meals at gas stations at 3 AM. My "grilled" chicken tasted boiled, microwaved, then dropped on the floor for texture. The fries were cold, soggy, and somehow still burnt. Even the ketchup tasted tired. The atmosphere? If you enjoy sticky tables, flickering lights, and a soundtrack of loud people arguing over who hates the place more, then you'll feel at home. I couldn't even focus on my meal because I was too distracted by wondering if the ceiling was going to collapse. To top it all off, the bill looked like they accidentally charged me for the entire restaurant's rent this month. Save your money, your stomach, and your sanity. This place should be avoided at all costs.

    Photos
    Carbon Bar And Grill - Come and fill out a ballot for a chance to win a @paulaner gift basket

    Come and fill out a ballot for a chance to win a @paulaner gift basket

    Carbon Bar And Grill
    Carbon Bar And Grill

    See all

    Sheli's Burgers & Fried Chicken - Coleslaw

    Sheli's Burgers & Fried Chicken

    3.0(13 reviews)
    2.0 km
    $$

    I could be skeptical when a restaurant's primary audience may be those with restrictions on dining…read moreat other spots (ie. only eat Kosher). Nothing wrong with it. However, because of the limitation, those diners probably haven't tried many top spots for comparison in reviews. Overall I was pleasantly surprised and enjoyed my meal. We ordered the burger (the Ringer), onion rings, Southern fried chicken and coleslaw. The standout has to be their onion rings, probably the BEST onion rings I've ever had. The onion rings are huge and super crispy. The coleslaw is well-executed: tangy and not too much mayo, just how I like it. It complimented our fried meal well. I would love to try their hand-cut fries next time. The mains are decent too, and I would gladly have it again. They have an assortment of toppings for the burger, including sauerkraut, but we kept it simple this time with lettuce and pickles. The fried chicken is good though I can't say it's better than the original famous Southern fried chicken I had in Savannah, Georgia, a few months back. They provided a combination of 2 dark meat and 1 white meat piece. I'm thankful that I got to try fried white meat chicken. However, I prefer my fried chicken all dark meat like most places but it's extra to request it here. Staff is nice. We ordered a drink to share but they also offered a small cup so I can refill something else in the fountain if I wanted. A bit pricey, $10.99 for 2pc fried chicken and $15.99 for the burger not including sides. But such is with inflation. I guess I'll just have to catch them for their specials. I think I saw on the board a Shabbat special! Does that mean Friday evening through to Saturday? Is it only for Jewish folks? I want in on that Shabbat deal. It was a Sunday when I was there... I'm curious so would ask next time if I'm back. I could also see others not feeling right to ask if they don't practice the tradition of Shabbat.

    Tucked away in the plaza at Chabad Gate and Bathurst St in Thornhill is one of the areas truly…read moreamazing restaurants. Sheli's is legit, as I have travelled all over North America and ate at of some of the most established Fried Chicken joints America has to offer. Some Examples are Hattie B's in Nashville, Gus's World Famous Fried Chicken in Memphis, Sams Fried Chicken and Donuts in Houston and The Red Yeti in Jeffersonville IN. I've had some good Fried Chicken and Southern Style foods. Sheli's is no exception, I found the place purely by Fluke after picking up my kids from a birthday party in the plaza. I saw the sign, I saw the crowd, and I saw all the Kippahs so I was curious. Low and Behold, little did I know that Thornhill has its own Southern-Style fried chicken joint. Sheli's has gone so far as to keep it Kosher but keep it as Southern Style as possible with its pressure cooked chicken and other items. I spoke to the guy at the counter who although busy, was more than happy to share the history and the concept of Sheli's. Based on his recommendation we got an order of Home Cut Fries, a helping of Popcorn Chicken and I personally tried the BBQ Chicken Sandwich. We loved everything we got, the fries were very good, the chicken was cooked perfectly and the sandwich was out of this world. I have been back a few times with friends to try the Burgers, Beef bacon and the fried chicken. I have to say the food is top-notch, take from a guy whose been around, Sheli's is legit!!

    Photos
    Sheli's Burgers & Fried Chicken - Gigantic onion rings cup for size comparison

    Gigantic onion rings cup for size comparison

    Sheli's Burgers & Fried Chicken - Burger

    Burger

    Sheli's Burgers & Fried Chicken - 3 pc chicken

    See all

    3 pc chicken

    St. Louis Bar & Grill - Super dry. It was not enjoyable

    St. Louis Bar & Grill

    2.7(13 reviews)
    1.1 km

    It's been ages since I went to a St. Louis location and I'm pleasantly surprised. Service was great…read moreand what's even better are the prices. We were lured in through some mail in ads that showcased their daily specials. which are pretty great. When we were there it was $15 for a burger with a side and a pint of beer or $2 less for pop. We each got one of those and ordered a lb of wings to share as well. They serve wings in the original format which is less breaded and the breaded version is bigger and more crispy and maybe caloric. We opted original for the wings and fries. For our burgers, we went for veggie sticks and an upgraded bowl of salad to balance out the meal. I'm just surprised that the greens were super fresh for a bar. I'm so used to crappy old salads from a pubs. Burgers were nice and juicy. Wings are as consistent as I last remembered it. The server even allowed me to customize a sauce blend because it wasn't too busy that night. We even peeked at their drink menu and cocktails are like only $8 something and it's regular price. Overall great experience.

    St. Louis' chicken is simply not good. I came here for the all you can eat boneless chicken promo,…read moreand the chicken were overly seasoned inside (super salty and msg-ish), super dry and under seasoned outside with the sauce. To mind you, I think this location is one of the better St Louis restaurants... (I definitely like it more than the downtown bloor location). It got three stars for the atmosphere and the fact that it's better than the other St. Louis I've been to - it's new and comfortable. The service was ok.

    Photos
    St. Louis Bar & Grill
    St. Louis Bar & Grill - Boneless wing (they were really just dry nuggets)

    Boneless wing (they were really just dry nuggets)

    St. Louis Bar & Grill

    See all

    S-Rank Chicken - Lunch special (yangnyeom chicken)

    S-Rank Chicken

    4.4(8 reviews)
    3.1 kmLangstaff

    Came here after a friend shared an IG clip about this place. It's a bit hidden in what looks like…read morean industrial complex. It's takeout only and they recommend ordering 20 mins before pickup so it's ready. They were not selling the UFO fried chicken sandwich so I was a little disappointed. I did order wings, boneless fried chicken and a poutine. The spicy sauce had some kick to it but it comes on the side so you can control the amount you use. Note there's a non spicy version too so order the right one. Chicken was all very crispy and not greasy. The poutine was good with one of the longest cheese pulls I've seen but no squeak in sight if that's the type of poutine you enjoy. All the fries were soggy by the time we got home. It was also put on the bottom of the bag and left partially open. This got squished by the chicken boxes and the gravy went all over the bottom of one of the chicken boxes. Bit of a packing miss. Would come back if in the area for the sandwich but overall I felt it was a bit pricey for what we ordered.

    Visited S-Rank Chicken in Toronto for lunch. Parking was easy, and the spot is small and simple,…read moremainly for takeout. The one staff member working was friendly, and pricing felt fair for the quality and portion sizes. I ordered the chicken sandwich on egg brioche and asked for it to be cut in half to share. The chicken was cooked perfectly, crispy, juicy, and flavorful. You can customize your order with toppings and sauce, which adds a nice touch. I chose their yangnyeom sauce, which had good flavor but wasn't spicy at all. The bun was dense, seemed a bit overbaked, and didn't have enough sauce to balance it. The UFO-style shape was interesting but left the edges too dry for my liking. I'd come back just for the chicken next time. Everything's made to order, so expect about a 20-minute wait. Ordering online helps make pickup smoother since payment is done through their single kiosk. Overall, great chicken, reasonable prices, and good value for what you get.

    Photos
    S-Rank Chicken
    S-Rank Chicken
    S-Rank Chicken

    See all

    Maker Pizza Thornhill - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...