PIzza and wings were amazing. We had the garlic parm wings and three cheese pizza. Wish we had…read morethis at home.

The best part of this spot is the staff! Every employee was over the top friendly and…read moreaccommodating. The food always came out hot and fresh and full of flavor, and the service was excellent.

Unreal bar. Opened early. Has a nice outdoor patio. A few food options as well. Extremely nice…read morestaff. Anna Maria I believe was her name. Super sweet and nice. The food we did not try but has many options. The drinks were great. They had a "shot of the month" it was called Golden Tea. It was delicious. The Rum Runners were fabulous. Definately a must return. Overall a great experience. 8.9 out of 10

Brought by a local to Put-In-Bay and was told I had to try Frosty's. Restaurant was classic island…read morefeel. The service was very quick and friendly. The food for me was pretty average but I will give them kudos for their portion sizes for at-least the tots. It could feed a full family of 4. Happy to recommend but probably will check out a different restaurant next time I visit.

BEST breakfast on PIB!!!…read more I was so happy we tried this place when we were at PIB! It was packed but we got sat quickly and the service was awesome! I got the visitor sandwich- it was pretty big and it was good! I was more excited to know that ALL their sandwiches come with tater tots and not fries!!!!!!!! My friends got many different places but devoured them all! I do have to give a shout out to the banana bread because- WOW! Is this not the prettiest banana bread you've ever seen? It even has an orange marmalade! It was PHENOMENAL!!!! Next time I'm back - I will be eating all my breakfasts here!!

Excellent restaurant for brunch. A varied selection of delicious food options…read more We dined here multiple times and had their omelettes, pancakes, and eggs Benedict. Their Grilled Banana Bread is do very good. Would definitely dine here again when we visit the area.

Cool little brewery on PiB! Popped in for a drink after dinner and really enjoyed it. Our server…read morewas friendly and our drinks were served quick!

A big selection of beers. Very neat building. Can see the brewing process from right outside the…read morewindow. The staff wasn't the friendliest. It was Noon on a Friday. Not a big crowd. The bartender acted like we were bothering her ( no other customers). No complete answer, just 1 word. I ordered the Watermelon Wheat. Not the best. Wasn't refreshing. Luke warm beer. The flavor wasn't packing a punch. Average. The Margarita we ordered was very, very strong. Almost too much salted brim and almost too much syrup Not the greatest. Bad sticker selection. Overall a 6.9 out of 10.

Stopped by for the view and to have a Brandy Alexander! So glad we did. It was a beautiful…read moreafternoon and our wait for a table outside to view the water was minimal. Jocelyn the hostess was very friendly and helpful! She got us as soon as a table was ready. (They don't have many by the water). We had our dog and they quickly offered her water. The bar is fun! Dollar bills stapled to the wall. Patrons who wrote on them! We did too of course ;) Our server Lily was great. My husband and I each ordered a Brandy Alexander and we split the red pepper popper. The ranch dressing was yum as,a,dipping sauce. The poppers were a very good spicy. The Brandy Alexander was so delicious, we ordered another! Great afternoon to sit by the water, watch boats and people! Definitely recommend. Service was great on this Friday afternoon.

Stopped in here to kill some time on a rainy weekend and loved the dive bar dollar bill on the wall…read morevibe.

We came here after my sister got married and had an absolutely wonderful meal!…read more First off our server Will was awesome and very attentive. He was on point and had a friendly personality which was perfect for our celebration. Everyone absolutely loved their meals too. My crab cake salad hit the spot, the kids loved their burgers and the buttered lobster roll was definitely the star of all the meals. Soo soo good. We were so glad we picked this spot and now we have a wonderful memory for life. Thank you!

We came on a day trip. Recommendations were en pointe. Get some type of fish. We shared a fish…read moreplatter$38 (6 pieces of fish-- perch, battered fries and condiment cup of coleslaw) It was worth it minus the slaw. I saw the lobster bisque after and got instantly jealous. No pics due to starving Later went upstairs and got a margarita Great views

Recommend this place for the location, food and the service…read more Located right at the water with great ambiance around it, really makes it feel like it's the Florida Keys. Food was really good and the service was very friendly and hospitable. Highly recommend!

This is my favorite place on the island, hands down. The service is always immaculate! The walleye…read moreRueben was so different, yet delicious. I love their mocktails and piña colada's from here. They have great bands that play often. I also loved that this restaurant is very kid friendly.

Great views. Overlooking the water. They have a good selection of wines but a somewhat limited food…read moremenu. We got their pizza, a bit doughy but pretty good. A nice place to sit back and relax. Service is casual. You order inside and they bring you your food.

No you're not in Napa, but for a hot and humid island based winery, I was quite impressed! The…read moreproperty is beautiful with a lovely outdoor patio and great views of the lake. I got the 3 pour tasting, and while I wouldn't imbibe a bottle, the chocolate wine was quite a tasty surprise. Blackberry wine was also noteworthy with a lot of summery fruit forward tang. We also got the cheese pizza, which was very well made. I'd happily recommend this as a stop for your put in bay getaway.

In all fairness- the stars are mainly for the WTF band who was playing that night- they were great!…read more And I liked the smaller crowd although don't expect that on every night. This is definitely a "last person standing" kinda vibe, and you can buy drinks by the bucket. But they have some tasty greasy grub to order right there in the bar, which as you know, can be a lifesaver for the next morning.

Really enjoyed Mist on a Saturday afternoon. Pool was packed, and the "contests" were a ton of…read morefun. This was our first stop after The Battle of the Bay. Great service and fun people!

We arrived a group of 5 people right at the peak of dinner time, Didn't have a lot of people In the…read morerestaurant but we gave it a chance. Apps were great & came out quick. We got the mozzarella stick, potato skins, & fried green beans. We all ordered water and we were parched and our server brought us a pitcher to Quench our thirst. We all ordered our food and everything came out great. Overall we had a great experience & would recommend this place.

We went for the brunch menu. I ordered the only omelette on the menu (ham/cheese/onion/peppers). My…read moreomelette arrived and it was sausage and cheese? My husband ordered the breakfast sandwich with sausage, egg and cheese. His sandwich that arrived was bacon, egg and cheese. We literally were the only two diners in the restaurant and our orders were incorrect. Our waitress was apologetic but she didn't cook our meals. No offer to reduce our bill. I wouldn't recommend this restaurant at all.