Food is always Top-notch I care for an 88yo man that has some dietary "no-go's" and TWICE our delivered was wrong. #1ordered Sprite 2ltr he brought Coke. (I wasn't around~bc I would have been ok with that) but he said 'I ain't gonna drink THAT. The driver then went to Get Go (approx 3 miles each way) to *make things right* (Jack's words) WOW How epic is that?! #2 Accidentally sent a Antipasto salad (Jack ) When I called MP's the gentleman was sincerely apologetic and INSISTED he would 'make things right' and have a steak salad delivered asap. I told him (bc it was the weekend) no real hurry needed; I had shared my GIANT steak hoagie. Not only was the replaced, they made another steak hoagie for me Excellent food. Excellent service. Excellent Ownership; always a blessed conversation while I am ordering. Always a pleasure doing business with them. In these tough economic times, take-out is a splurge BUT @Mama Pepinos' it is definitely money well-spent!! (taste,value &deliciousness) read more

Asked for extra chicken got maybe half a chicken breast started eating my salad and the chicken was ice cold and I know I definitely got charged for extra chicken read more

Mama Pepino's - Salad - Pizza Near Me - West Newton, Pennsylvania

Was told it was good. First time and last! Pizza was half burned and taste like cardboard! Hardly any cheese and suasage in my opinion. Soon as i opened box in car I was ready to walk back in and ask for my money back. read more

Consistency. It is always good. It is always busy. But no matter how busy it is the staff is kind, attentive and friendly. We love the breadsticks, the pizza and the wedges. And the wings are whole wings and crispy. If you are craving a good pie for take out this is the place. read more

We absolutely love this place. Great food friendly people and their food is just so good. Everything is top notch and I just like the fact that all their meats are imported and not from the trash that they sell in America read more

never give ranch for a delivery order, consistently mess up every time I order from there. lve loved their food for a long time but since they don't care I no longer do. lost a long time loyal customer today read more

I kept trying them but it's more miss that hit. Foxes or Pizza House are all that's left. $50 for two medium special pizzas that were not good. They are in consistent one out of four tries were good. I'm done. read more

See all

Went in there with an average order for 6 people to get food I called in my order at 4:20 and the women told me it would be ready in 40-45 minutes. I pull in to the parking lot at 5:10 and pay for my food, but they didn't even start cooking it nor did they tell me it would be another hour before it would be ready. After standing there for 20 minutes and witnessing one of them employees take money from his pocket twice and give it to the cash register to give him a bigger bill and they don't even want to tell me where my food was. I was very disappointed and asked for my money back as they weren't going to give me my food. I would stay away from this place as they don't have anyone managing the employees inside. read more

Food is good. Service can't be better. Menu has slot of options. Stuff that was supposed to be hot was hot.

20 years ago I use to get the pepperoni rolls. I am still craving them today. I must make a trip to West Newton soon just to get them. Just know, you are a lucky duck if you live close enough to get them at any time. read more

Always great hot pizza never had a bad one yet and it's always done perfectly and on time for pickup

If I was writing this review based solely on the food I've tasted, they'd get a 4. The Pierogi pizza is incredible. They also have beautiful Jumbo full chicken wings. However, the place doesn't look clean, there's nowhere to stand and wait for your food, and when I arrived to get my food ten minutes after they said it'd be ready, I had to wait another twenty minutes...so thirty beyond the 25 minutes they originally told me. Furthermore, in that small space were 5-6 workers, all with masks around their necks, yet no one actually wearing them over their noses and mouths. Without proper mask hygiene while making food and handling customers, I'm done. I'll miss that pierogi pizza. read more

order all the time for small birthdays and get togethers . fantastic sauce on the pizza , i mean i really like their sauce and they're not shy with the the toppings. the wings are so good too , the whole wing , flat and drum combo also good camaraderie in the kitchen with all them , haven't ever left that joint not smiling read more

We came to get dinner while we were biking. Just a little place, hardly any place to park, and no place to wait while they prepare your order. It was literally so busy, the phone was ringing constantly. That to me is a good sign that this place is popular. We got gyros because we had a coupon and they were really good! Simple toppings, but very full and tasty! We also got a side of cheese sticks and they were great. We ate at one of the picnic tables by the GAP trail visitors center and we really enjoyed everything. We will definitely try the pizza sometime. The staff at this shop are very nice, but they are busy, so we tried to make our order as quickly as possible. Final thought: a pretty good little pizza shop! read more

Great pizza and friendly service. The steak salads is huge and delicious. Try it you will love this place.

OMG!!! The Steak & Cheese Pizza is AMAZING!!! They even have French fries on it!! Porky knows what he's doing!!!

Well I just figured that I shall update my review in honor of my lady . While I received and enjoyed my meal , she had received the wrong food . read more

I love the pizza and wings, but the best part is the awesome owner. Porky is a great asset to our local community and the region. My church loves his pizza and he is always giving special deals to his clients. They have great Italian and steak subs as well as gyros. Try them out and they'll become your favorite go to place. read more

gave me food poisoning! the service was taking forever. it's just bad! i got the ham and cheese hoagie and it didn't taste right. i came home from the drive and i threw up many of times read more

The pizza was ok, but I like my pizza with a lot of sauce ("juicy" as I say). Cheese was good but a lot of dough on the edges. Dry under the melted cheese. This pizza needs to be better constructed evenly distributed not a diughybrim, and balanced among toppings, sauce and cheese. read more

By far my favorite pizza in the area. It is now our 'go to' for take out. Staff is super friendly. Also excellent customer service. Recently I went there and there was a mixup with my order. They really went out of their way to fix it. read more

This is the best pizza I have ever had. Just had it for the first time yesterday and I'd never even heard of the place. I can't believe I've gone my entire life without having it. I don't even like pizza that much but I would eat their pepperoni pizza every day of my life if I could! read more

Stayed in West Newton this weekend for a rafting trip. We got a very big deluxe pizza and a large cheese pizza. Both were very very good. Quality ingredients. Very friendly people at the restaurant when I went to pick up the pizza. Surprisingly good for such a small town. I recommend read more

They have some of the best flavored pizza sauce around. If you're not in the mood for pizza, order anything chicken. I swear some of the best chicken tenders I've had in a long time. read more

Not a great white pizza period . Have had other Mama Pepino's from various stores and they were great . This was BLAND no spices on it tasted like oily pizza with tomatoes and brown cheese ( I do NOT like burnt cheese )no flavor lots of burnt areas on the crust . Will not order from again, Ended up throwing it away read more

Not ony bad food twice in one day but was told " maybe shouldn't call here anymore" Guess they didn't realize i spend over $50 a week there plus my company spends there. Just cost then about $1000 a week. Never again. read more

Whoever the man is that answers the phone is one of the nicest, most personable men I have ever had the pleasure of talking to. We have ordered from here for years now and he is always so helpful and kind. The pizza is always very good, as well. Highly recommend. read more

Finially got a good pizza with no burnt crust. Edges or bottom ! Had fries they were dark not cook much and tasted kind of like fish. Not good when you dont like fish. We also got a calzone which was good . Not getting any more fires for awhile. read more

It's hit or miss. Sometimes the food is great sometimes it's disgusting. Nine times out of 10 it's a 30 to 45 minute wait for pick up, for delivery it's usually an hour to an hour and a half. Kind of overpriced be expected to pay close to $30 for large pizza and a dozen of wings. But there cheesesteak pizza can't be beat! And also the wings are whole wings so you get two dozen for the price of one. read more

Average to good pizza. It is more less take out only, unless you don't mind a lot of traffic outside.

Great Food, Owner and Employees are exceptional. I really like their pizzas. The owner is really cool, they go above and beyond. I rate them as high as white oak food wise, they are very much appreciated in West Newton. Delivery is hard for them as such a large service area, I usually pick up. Food is always hot, fresh and delicious. read more

We really like their plain pizza. Always has lots of sauce on the pizza too which we really like.

Love the breadsticks to die for! But it just depends on whose working we have gotten really great pizza and really bad pizza! Learned to only order when Ozzy is working!! read more

Pizza was very good! We also got wings and they were whole wings! They were cooked perfectly and the pizza had the perfect amount of sauce, cheese and pepperoni! I would recommend them to anyone in the area! read more

I will never support this establishment. Young guy who is the manager belittled yelled and cussed at an older man employee because he couldn't keep up. Very rude and unprofessional. I should not of heard it being a customer and he should act like a man and not a out of control toddler. Food is mediocre. Not worth my money after this incident. read more

When calling to place an order, I asked what the specials are. I was told about a extra large pizza with 3 toppins for $16.99. When I agreed to purchase that, I was asked if I had a coupon. I explained that I did not. I was told that I could not purchase the special without a coupon. Very unprofessional and not very customer oriented. I was a previous dedicated customer who will never purchase another thing from their establishment. read more

I haven't tried much beyond pizza, but the pizza is fantastic...saucy, lots of toppings, and delicious. Expect to wait a bit longer for your order than what they tell you over the phone, but the wait is worth it. Beyond that I've tried the italian hoagie and it was somewhat disappointing in the amount of meat and toppings. The sampler of fried goodness is delicious though. read more