Cash only. Unbeatable price. Unbeatable speed. Unbeatable views Eat some za, drink some ice cold soda, and then walk across the way and play some video games Friday afternoon well spent. Sorry boss read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - 3 slice deal - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

We love their pizza. We get it every weekend. Called today and there was confusion about the pizza. Got there explained, then argued because they wanted me to take what was made and tried lying saying there was no garlic on it. Ordered another, thought all was fine, got home and they didn't put any sauce on it at all and it was undercooked. 21$ for a pizza and we get one each week, for them to act petty like this. read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Sicilian pizza with NO sauce - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Grabbed a slice while walking the New Castle Farmer's market. Great crust, supports the pizza well and has a little crunch. Toppings, cheese, and sauce were all well proportioned. I'll have to go back and get a full fresh pie to give a more thorough taste test. Lots of slices to choose from and with steady traffic they don't sit for long. Seating area also available $4 for the slice was worth it. read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Slice of pep and onion - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Best pizza around. Go there from NJ every time. People are very nice and always have good attitude does only take cash read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Pretty solid pizza spot inside the Farmer's Market. This place cranks out an incredible variety of pizzas available by the slice. Prices seem about typical for a premium slice. We opted to get a whole XL pizza, which is $18 (cash only). Service was friendly, prices were fair. More cheese than we like on our pies, but that's just a personal preference. We'd likely come back again if we are in the area and ask for it to be well done. read more

Love this place! Neapolitan, Deep Dish, Sicilian, it's hard to choose they're all great. Chicken Bacon Ranch is another one that is so good. read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Best pizza around. - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Quality has really went down since last year. Is someone new running the business. They are slipping

Such great pizza and the service is spectacular. I would highly recommend. Please try it cause you will be amazed.

Foods really good! And we always enjoy what we get! Here are the menus since I couldn't find them on here read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

I just love their pizza! There are all different kinds! It is right there in the New Castle Farmers Market! Yummy! Nice staff there! A lot of people go there! read more

Good pizza but what's up with no soda refills due to Covid?? 3 bucks for a cup of ice hardly any soda I asked for a refill had the same cup refilled only to be charged another 3 bucks when I asked why the guy went to the parking lot door threw it out the door and said caca bilious!! read more

By far the best pizza in Delaware. Cash only. Super friendly staff. Highly recommend!

Lets get serious - lets talk pizza. Before we get started. You're great. Thanks for reading my review. Now that I have buttered you up, (man I could go for some french bread with butter hehe) - I know pizza more than you and this place is LEGIT. Bar none the 2nd best place to get pizza by the slice in Delaware. Don't go here for a salad, don't go here for a burger. They make pizza! They get the vote for several reasons. For one, their quality is the unreal. They take pride in what they do. Their pies are made from scratch - no frozen premade crusts here B, They have a huge variety - from NY slices, that are my personal favorite, to Sicilian, and mini calzones you can get it all with creative to classic toppings. Pick to eat-in or take pizza to go. This review may not be detailed but I assure you the pizza will speak for itself. Just keep in mind this gem is only open from Thursday- Sunday. Don't mention my name... apparently you can't run an ongoing tab for pizza ;) KENT read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Your regular pizza spot! We tried buffalo chicken and chicken bacon ranch and they were delicious for after Saturday night out. Would go again if closer to where I live read more

Pizza actually isn't bad. Nice crisp crust, decent amount of cheese. Bumping this to 4 stars because a tasty cheese slice at $1.60 is nothing to complain about. read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Seating area near Mama Gina's. Tables aren't always the cleanest, but who cares? Don't drop your pizza on the table! - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Best pizza in Delaware period. If you get there at 8:30 p.m. on Fri and Sat you can get any slice for a dollar, but be aware they go quick!

I need to do more of my cooking. That being said, their tomato pies are making me violate such a need all the more.

I ordered a large pepperoni and onion pizza and a large meatball with extra cheese. The large "meatball" and cheese pizza turned out to be a meat sauce and extra cheese- no meatballs. Both pizzas were very large [18"] and large slices. The pizzas were a 6 or 7 on a 0 to 10 scale. The crust was fairly bland and on the harder side. If the crust was softer, more chewy, and tastier, I would rate these pizzas a 7 or 8. I probably won't go back there again. I still like Pat's thin crust pizzas as my favorite, rating them a 8. I'm still looking for the perfect pizza in the 9 or 10 range! read more

Listen carefully this is the BEST pizza in the area. Every option I try I love whether it's a traditional slice, Sicilian, or stuffed pizza. If you're at Farmers Market and undecided you can't go wrong with this option. Italian is one my favorite types of food and with that being said I have consumed a lot of pizza. If you don't like this place then something may be wrong with your tastebuds. read more

Real New York Italian style pizza the way it's supposed to be! Thin and crispy! The crust was warm and soft like a vendor style hot pretzel, so good. The pepperoni was excellent, bam! Like Arnie said, "I'll be back"! read more

Mamma Gina Pizza - Real Italian style pizza. Flavorful, thin crispy crust, the way pizza was meant to be. Bam! Like Arnie said, I'll be back! - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Tried and tested by a pizza-loving friend. He was extremely happy with his slices and even brought a few home for his wife. I had the white pizza with ricotta ... so good! I usually don't get too thrilled with pizza nowadays, but this was great. I definitely recommend this place if you are nearby! read more

I created a Yelp account just to give this place the review it deserves. Mama Ginas by far has the best pizza for this area. I am originally from Long Island and my pizza standards are very high especially on the crust. I have to say that outside of NY I have not found better pizza crust. It was perfect, so that excuse about the NY water is why the pizza is so good goes out the window in my opinion. Up until today I believed that myself. The toppings are very good quality, the sauce is homemade and very very good and the only thing I can say that I wish was different - they are only open on Friday and the weekend when the farmer market is. This place is a hidden gem and when they are open I would go out of my way to get it. read more

Best pizza in new castle! Love the variations of white pizza they always have a slice ready. Great crust too - new york style. Located inside new castle farmers market Wish they were open all week long! read more

My family & I have been going to Mama Gina's since I was really young. It's my favorite pizza to this day. When I was pregnant with my daughter, I made my husband make a trip there to get me pizza every weekend as it was my biggest craving. The crust is crispy, the sauce and cheese are delicious. There's usually a long line and still manage to have an order ready in minutes. Love this place! read more

Acquaintance of mine calls this place "The home of the half-cooked pizza," and there's certainly some truth in that. The slices are dirt cheap and freshly made. It's not stellar pizza by any means, but gets the job done. Free refills on sodas are a big plus. Lots of seating, but tends to get crowded when the Farmer's Market is busy. read more

Great Pizza. They have thin crust and thick crust, but the thin crust still has some consistency to it. Slices are huge and only cost $1.50. If you want a whole pizza, the sizes are right...a small is 12 inches, Med 14 inches, Large 16 inches, and an Xtra Large 18 inches for only $11.00! Super friendly service. I can't walk past this place without getting a couple slices. By the way, for those that don't know. This place is located inside the New Castle Farmers Market which is only open Fri Sat and Sun. Highly recommend. Not cheating. read more

My whole family just loves their pizza. We get it every weekend & for Parties. It is by far the best around. No matter if you get, Sicilian, deep dish or regular, hands down the best. read more

This is without a doubt the best pizza I've ever had anywhere! The crust is always lightly crisp on the bottom but not tough. Toppings are generous and tasty. Never could figure out why it doesn't show up in the readers choice awards. But maybe it's better that way. They're busy enough as it is! read more

I really love Mamma Gina's Pizza- it's one of my favorite pizza's out there. I actually like it better than any of those chain's out there. The only thing that makes it a pain in the butt is that they only take cash. So when you're picking up your pizza it's a huge inconvenience since no one really carries cash anymore. read more