Traveling thru to NY and found this gem of a place! Great, friendly staff and amazingly delicious…read morefood! Highly recommended Thank you Martinelli's

They say you never get a second chance to make a first impression, and this place blew it…read more While service was nice and apologetic, the food was just not good. They ruined the $35 steak and left it sitting on the table getting cold while we waited for all the rest of the food. The meatball was more like a meatloaf, and the pink vodka sauce might as well have come out of a jar. The very apolgetic manager refunded the steak. We did get a tiramisu, which was OK. Sorry, because I was looking forward to this place after a long day on the road. But man, it was a drag.

Tiny building from the outside but it packs a big punch of good food, the veal and eggplant…read moreparmigiana and amazing hot rolls are made in house and I had a surprisingly good house Pinot Grigio. I also had the spinach sautéed with garlic. Bellissimo! Our server was brand new and had to check on several of our questions but he did a great job

Small little place but very cozy. Excellent service…read more Yummy pasta. My wife had the clams linguini and I had the tour of Italy. Delicious bread hot of the oven.

You'd never expect the environment and ambiance when walking in, it's very elegant yet cozy. The…read morestaff were all incredibly kind and welcoming, service was out of this world and went beyond any expectations. Lastly the food here was all around amazing, complimentary dishes, just for dessert it would be worth the drive, decently sized servings and all made from scratch. All around delicious and an amazing experience!

What a unique experience!! Honestly that is how I can best describe my time here! We came with some…read morefriends while visiting town, and I absolutely loved the uniqueness of the building. It had a very vintage feel and decor and also was connected to an older gym from a school. Yet, they made the experience and vibe of your dinner feel nice and elegant. They're only open on the weekends, so make sure you get a reservation as it filled up very fast! They serve your food through many courses so be prepared to stay and enjoy for a few hours. We enjoyed the company of our friends as the environment was very laid back and took our time. You start with options for appetizers, soup/salad, entree, and dessert. They even had complimentary, adorable palette cleansers between each course! (My favorite was the raspberry sorbet-super delicious). For food we had the artichoke bruschetta for an appetizer (very different than normal bruschetta but flavorful). We also had the arugula salad which I thought was really good! For entree, I ordered the stuffed chicken and was pleased and satisfied with the flavors. It could have come out a bit hotter, but was still good. My boyfriend ordered the ribeye, which was a pretty good size and said he thoroughly enjoyed! And for dessert, we had the cheesecake which was homemade and very delicious. The staff was also friendly throughout the night but, again, just be prepared to take your time as they tend to as well! Overall, I had a great time and really enjoyed the experience. I would definitely recommend and would love to experience again!

This review is for dinner in the dining room for two on a Saturday in mid-August before a show at…read morethe Stiefel Theatre. service: Chloe was our waitress and she was just great. Enthusiastic, informed, and encouraging. She has an encyclopedic knowledge of the kitchen and bar. We must have interacted with a dozen folks: hosts, food runners, sommelier, and managers. Everyone was unfailing polite and professional. bar: I drank a Bulleit Rye Manhattan ($11) and my wife had a Grey Goose Cosmo ($13). Both were strong showings of those two classic cocktails. I followed up with a Boulevard Single Wide IPA bottle ($6) and was thrilled to see that old reliable. food: Service begins with exceptional bread and complimentary Baba Ghanoush. The menu described my wife's Pappardelle Bolognese ($25) as having, "mean mule Bolognese sauce." Have never seen the term, mean mule, but this version appeared to incorporate some cream. My 5 oz. Salmon Piccata ($25) with broccolini, asparagus, and rice was very good. We finished with Ultimate Chocolate Cake ($16) and - as the menu describes - it really is for two persons or take-home. It was my birthday and the restaurant graciously comped my dessert, which was extremely nice. details: This is a large, bustling, bright restaurant with choice of inside, outside, and bar seating. Reservations are highly recommended, at least for busy times. We parked on the street and even on Saturday night with a show at the Stiefel Theatre we had no problems.

Visited on a Sunday evening. Service in bar area was good. Crowded though- felt like people were in…read moreyour space and the table wobbled. Best to have reservations. Drinks were good. KC strip was TERRIBLE. Thin, bad flavor, over cooked and $48! They aren't a steak house.

I asked before I ordered if it was enough for big hungry guys and your staff said yes! And never…read moresaid they enjoyed it. Won't be returning!

I ordered from door dash so I didn't go in the store. But the meat balls were VERY salty. That was…read moreterrible. The rest of the food I got though was good. Though the price ? Should be lower.

Wonderful food and the staff is always prompt and polite. Wonderful atmosphere and a great menu to…read morechoose from.

We stopped in for an early dinner and happened to hit Happy Hour. My family had chips and salsa,…read morebeers, pizza, steak, spaghetti and a kids meal and our meal was so cheap and so delicious. My husband has not stopped raving about his pizza. I haven't had steak in so long because it's pricey where we live so I was excited to have one. The only recommendation I would have for the kids menu is that they double the portion of spaghetti and take away the side. Our server was excellent. It was a little loud when we got there but a kids baseball team was finishing up. After they left, it was quiet. Nice restaurant. Glad we checked it out during our trip.

Good food!!!! Cheese sticks are super delicious and Mexican pizza is amazing. Staff is always…read morefriendly

The pizza is amazing. The Italian cheese is a family favorite. Sandwiches and pasta are also…read morefantastic.

It's an older store that's been renovated, but it checks out…read more Like other Casey's, it's clean, it has plenty of pizza and it has free air. This location only has a couple of pumps, but does have a good amount of parking out front.

Omg the pizza is so good I like the meat and cheese pizzas ohhh so good the service is super fast…read moreand the workers are always so nice and kind

We had gone here for dinner. It was right next-door to the Avid we stayed at. Our waitress was…read moretraining a new girl so we got twice the service. Friendly and helpful. Large dining with a bar with everything. Also outdoor dining but didn't see any umbrellas so we sat inside. I got the Apple, walnut salad with chicken also blue cheese and walnuts with a creamy herb dressing and it had a little spicy kick to it..Hubby got spaghetti pie -thin spaghetti Alfredo sauce, Italian cheeses, baked in a small loaf pan and topped with cheese and marinara sauce. It was bubbling hot when it came out. I got to eat the last couple of bites I think I will try to make this it was really good.

Stopped here to have a lunch meal before a large dinner was planned in the evening. We were greeted…read moreand seated immediately. The hostess was super customer service oriented and the server was also very much so as well. We saw that they had lunch specials for $9.99 and also Oktoberfest specials on beer: $4 pints & $5 tall steins. We ordered: Cheesy Sticks Starters, 2 Old Chicago Chopped Salads, 1 Oktoberfest Beer, and 1 Heineken 0% Alcohol Beer. Everything came out within a good amount if time: about 7 mins for the starter, and 10 mins after that for the salads. The cheesy bread was pretty good, hot and flavorful. It came with a marinara dipping sauce. The salads were tiny and served in small bowls. They definitely were not worth $10 each, but maybe $3 each, as they were side salad size, not lunch salad size. We had excellent customer service here so I kept it at 3 stars. The food quality and portion sizes was a bit off.

Old Chicago Pizza is great! Their pizza is delicious, but I typically go there for their salads…read more.. especially their apple, walnut, and Gorgonzola salad... it's yummy!

The pizza crust was terrible! We ordered hand tossed, which we've had before, and this crust was…read moreeven thinner than actual thin crust pizza! UPDATE: www brought it to the waitresses attention and she said it was hand tossed crust. Later i stopped a male employee that had come out from the kitchen. When I started to point out the crust he seemed to already know what I was talking about and said he would bring another pizza. Obviously, the waitress had reported it to the kitchen, but no one came out to correct the problem until I flagged a person down to complain a second time. While I'm pleased to get the pizza replaced, it wasn't until we had already eaten half of the first pizza and only then because I complained a second time.