The entire process from start to finish was effortless and the cake came out better than I'd envision. Highly recommended while trusting the process in designing with satisfactory outcome. Will be back soon for other ceremony events. Thanks again. read more

Mandoli's - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I went to a party with a cake from Mandoli's. I then ordered a cake from there based on how wonderful the cake I had from the party was. When I picked up my cake I ordered and got it home it was really dry unfortunately!! I was very disappointed because I had been looking forward to this for weeks. Because the first time I tried their cake was soooo good I definitely would give them another shot. Maybe it was an off day for the baker? Who knows... The cake itself was gorgeous! The flowers were perfect. read more

Mandoli's - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I went to Mandoli's for my daughters baby shower cake and am so beyond elated at what we got!! I would leave 10 stars if I could!! When I met with the owner to discuss what my daughter liked, (but I knew it wouldn't feed all her guests), she suggested a small personal cake for my daughter. I thought it was an amazing idea! When I opened the boxes and saw these cakes I was blown away!!! Not only did they taste AMAZING, they looked gorgeous. Everyone at the party loved the cakes and asked where I got them. These pictures don't do them justice! Thank you so much to the ladies of Mandoli's for creating delicious and beautiful cakes for my daughter and her guests!! And to the owner for her ideas and patience working with me!! read more

Mandoli's - My daughters baby shower cake - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Mandoli's did a fantastic job with my daughters wedding cake and cupcake tower. Everyone raved about the cupcakes at the reception and my daughter and son in-law enjoy their cake as well.. They delivered and setup at the venue and did a beautiful job. I highly recommend them for your next event. Thank you Mandoli's read more

Mandoli's - Beautiful ! - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

They did a beautiful job on my wedding cake and it tasted great too! Easy to work with through the process. Highly recommend. read more

Mandoli's - a wedding cake decorated with sunflowers - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

INCREDIBLE. I sent them an image of a tactical vest and asked them if they could make a cake that resembled it for my fiancé's 40th. There was nothing like it online. They nailed it!!! It was incredible. read more

Mandoli's - a stack of u s marshall boxes - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

I was looking to get custom cookies for a party and they were recommended. I called four times over a week and no one ever picked up the phone. And yes, I called during their posted business hours. I went with a bakery that actually picked up the phone. I'll steer clear of this place. read more

These ladies have been baking cakes for me since my daughter was 10 months old and I have not been disappointed not once customer service is always spot on and they work with you ! And cakes always melt in your mouth I've never been disappointed ! read more

See all

I walked in as a last minute cake order (week before) for a rehearsal dinnerr, the girl behind the counter was very sweet and helpful. I was very pleased with how the cake turned out, bride loved it! It was a bit too sweet for my taste and dense but again, I didn't ask them to temper it. Five stars because all the guests had sweet tooths and adored it read more

See all

What a phenomenal bakery run by two very sweet, professional young women. I found them when hunting for a baby shower cake and now return for every cake I need. I have never been disappointed. My daughter's baptism cake was simply gorgeous! I've been told that their cake is worth every calorie and I completely agree! read more

Mandoli's - My daughter's baptism cake. Vanilla cake with raspberry mousse and whipped cream frosting. - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

AWFUL CUSTOMER SERVICE I bought a cake and was asked during pickup if it would be consumed that day. It was, so I was told to leave it out at room temp. Well, the top layer of the cake slipped off the bottom layer and then the top cracked in half. I attempted to privately resolve this by email and was told that they've never seen that before, had no explanation and they were sorry. SORRY?! That's it. I got an "I'm sorry" That doesn't make up for the fact that my cake was ruined, before we even got to enjoy it, before we got to sing happy birthday. My cake, which was not cheap ($45 for an 8") looked like a pile of crap. Beyond embarrassing! Good customer service is trying to resolve a problem, not just an I'm sorry. I have given this bakery business many times over the last few years. I won't be returning again. read more

Mandoli's - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Mandolis makes beautiful cakes upon any request. I was sooo glad I found them. BUT , their cakes are very dry. I had them make 3 cakes for different occasions. All 3 cakes were dry. My sisters birthday cake wasn't even edible, all the kids didn't even finish it so most of it was thrown away. Their cake is very expensive , they look fantastic but they need to taste just as amazing. I contacted them about the third cake but they were not accommodating stating their white cake is drier than their other cakes. It's a shame because I thought I found my cake place. read more

When picking a wedding cake, it can be a little stressful....well not at Mandoli's! I told the girls exactly what we had wanted, and they did not disappoint! The cake looked identical to the photo I had showed, but tasted amazing! We chose a vanilla chocolate chip cake with fudge filling, and it pleased everyone! It's so nice to have a bakery in town! Thank you girls for making our wedding day that much sweeter! read more

Mandoli's - Our beautiful beach themed wedding cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Cake was extremely moist and looked absolutely amazing! So pleased with how my cupcakes and cake turned out!! The people who work there are so kind! I 100% recommend this place and will be telling everyone i know to go here!! read more

Mandoli's - Cake and cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Hands down the greatest cupcakes I have ever had. The frosting to cupcake ratio is PERFECT. I hate when I go places and all I taste is the sugary frosting. Not only are the cupcakes delicious with unique flavors in addition to standard options, but they are also beautifully designed. Getting one of their awesome custom crafted cakes is amazing for a special day, but the cupcakes are perfect for the every day. I live out of state now, but I love visiting here every time I am home to see family. Haven't found a cupcake place quite as good in my city. Mandoli's is a must-go if you are in the area!!! read more

Mandoli's - Cookies N Cream, Red Velvet, Chocolate Chocolate, & Carrot Cake. (Already ate the Vanilla one oops!) - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The cake was delicious, was exactly what I wanted, very reasonably priced. Give it a try!!!

Customer Service is key and these ladies really know what they are doing. I was pleased and felt comfortable from the start due to one of the girls had attended Johnson & Wales University (culinary school in Rhode Island). I ordered a cake for my mothers 60th birthday several months before the actual event. If anyone is interested in purchasing a cake from Mandoli's I would suggest it be one of the first things to do on your list before your event. The ladies were extremely helpful throughout the whole process from start to finish plus delivery. Next, is the cake itself. The cake was the focal point on the candy bar displayed for my event and lets just say it turned some heads. I WISH I had their business cards. The cake it self was delicious ! Vanilla with Raspberry filling. After currently working in the events industry I was extremely impressed by this company compared to another cake company within the Ocean & Monmouth County area that many venues recommend (The Chocolate Carousel) Personally, I think this company blows them out of the water. You can assure that I will be purchasing another cake for another event some time soon. read more

Outstanding service that exemplified a "can-do" attitude with freindly and caring interaction. I needed a birthday cake delivered for my Aunt. I am out of state and wasnt having much luck finding a local bakery that would accept the order on such short notice. Luckliy I called Mandoli's late Saturday afternoon with the hope that a cake could be delivered that following Monday. I was pleasantly surprised that they not only accepted the order but also delivered it as soon as my Aunt got home from work. This went above and beyond any bakery I have ever encountered. I highly recommend them! My Aunt said the cake was beautiful. read more

STEER CLEAR from this place! I am EXTREMELY disappointed. I would give ZERO stars if I could. I have been a loyal customer to them for many years and they have been my go-to bakery for custom made cupcakes for special occasions. I even RAVED about them to my friends and colleagues and they too have been going to this bakery. However, that all changed today. My friend and I had ordered custom cupcakes for a birthday celebration. We were very specific and we know the drill already since we have been ordering at this bakery. They even have it written in their order form! The day came when I picked up the cupcakes, they had made a mistake on one of them so I had asked NICELY if they could change it. One of the girls in the back (dark hair) was EXTREMELY upset and started cursing and using the F WORD saying "I am so fired up!" and "This is not the day". And basically complaining in the back about the one mistake THEY did. I heard EVERYTHING she said. Very UNNECESSARY and UNPROFESSIONAL! She then came out to print out on fondant to correct the mistake but she was having a TANTRUM while she was at it! Throwing and slamming the drawer etc. That is not how you deal with a client and the other girl was very nice and apologetic when I had mentioned her unacceptable behavior saying that the other girl was having a bad day. The lady cussing up a storm in her bakery did not even come out to apologize! No excuses! It was an unpleasant experience and the 8 cupcakes were not well worth the $40 we spent! Terrible customer service!!!! Ridiculous!!!! read more

I am (almost) at a loss trying to describe how completely wonderful my experience at Mandoli's was. I needed a wedding cake for a group of people that included gluten allergies, nut allergies, and a couple of just plain really picky people. But i also wanted this cake--my wedding cake!!--to be beautiful and taste good. AND I wanted no hassle. What I got was beyond what I expected. First of all, these ladies are so kind and helpful and fun! They worked with me to make sure everyone had something they could eat, and the presentation was stunning. Frankly, spending time in Mandoli's planning the cake with these ladies wa one of the high points of all of my wedding planning. I'd hang out with these women anytime--with or without cake. :) read more