We love the pizzas! We have ordered the specialty pizzas including the all meat, veggie, dill…read morepickle, deluxe 5, and deluxe 9. Each was fresh and generously topped.

Ordered online for delivery today (10.10.25). Said it would be delivered around 12:37pm. My…read moreinstructions asked that it be dropped at the front door of the hospital and to text/call me at 419.306.9261 It is currently 1:50pm and no delivery. I've called about a dozen times and no answer. I was excited to try the pizza while in town but now, I will never know because I won't give it a second chance

Delicious food, speedy service and pleasant atmosphere…read more Friendly service as well as clean environment.

I was in Findlay Ohio for work and we were looking for a lunch spot when a local employee…read morerecommended this spot. As soon as I looked at the menu I was sold. The location is in a strip mall so there is plenty of parking. There are enough seats inside and there was even a large group there when we stopped on. It was very clean and the delicious smells hit you right when you walk in. I had a hard time deciding between pizza and a grinder but settled for a half size (9") Grinder this was plenty of food and served open face. It was the perfect ratio of meat and cheese toppings. The bread was toasted perfectly. My whole group was happy with everything they got. The staff was super friendly and seemed happy to answer any questions. This will definitely be on my return list. Especially since I still want to try the pizza! If you get a chance to try this out I highly encourage it!

all I can say is thank God I live an hour and 15 minutes from Tiffin!…read more I went to college in Tiffin and I lived off of Napoli Pizza. That was 20 years and 70 pounds ago. If I lived in Tiffin, those 70 pounds would be right back because I would stay at Napolis picking up fold overs. I was in town visiting my mom last night and for old times sake, decided to pick up a cheeseburger fold over. It did not disappoint! It was ready very quick. I picked it up, they are so generous with the toppings and the cheese. It still looks and smells exactly the same when you walk in there. There's a convenience to ordering delivery, but picking up yourself just ensure you get a perfectly piping hot meal. One more reason to visit my mom, definitely needed it

The thick crust Jethro pizza is fabulous! 2 people and took half of a 12 inch home. It was…read moredelicious.

Susie's pizza is my favorite pizza! Whenever I come to visit family (I live in NC now but grew up…read morearound Upper)I order their pepperoni and green olives- their crust is light and crispy. I literally order when I am 30 minutes away as a I drive from Columbus airport. They only take cash!

Yes the service good and restaurant was all amazing I really love the pizza there and the prices…read moreare great

Bland, doughy, floppy, bizarre sweet sauce, flavorless cheese…read more It's not even close to Detroit style. I don't even know what to call this.

AJ's is honestly my favorite Pizza place in Tiffin, but Reino's is a close second (but two entirely…read moredifferent styles, so not a fair comparison). If we're ordering Pizza on a Friday night, it's almost always going to be AJ's. Either the Jr. Jumbo, or if we're really hungry or have company, a Jumbo. I'm particularly partial to the Pepperoni rolls (highly recommend trying). Unfortunately, (just recently), I've noticed a decline in the consistency of the food. Sometimes it's great, which is what I've come to expect, and sometimes is just ok. I've also never been exactly "wowed" by the staff/service. This is just an observation, but a lot of the staff seems to be comprised of high-school or college age kids. I can say I don't recall EVER being greeted with a smile when picking up my order. It's almost always a young lady (different ones) who seem irritated that they're even there. Which is whatever... I just want my pizza. Just an observation though. I haven't been to the new location yet, so I can speak to the new dining area, etc. we switched over to doing delivery since we moved closer to town. Overall, highly recommend because generally the food is delicious.

Excellent menu,, everything looks good, high rating on hamburger but we can't get past the pizzaread more

Great local hangout for a pizza and a beer at reasonable prices with fast, friendly service…read more Fair warning: At peak times you will wait long periods of time. Try the Broasted Chicken. Especially if you've never had it. It's wonderful. Crispy outside, moist inside. You can easily split meals here. They go crazy with the fries. Pro Tip: If you order the double meal, you'll end up with the same amount of food for less money. Their 1-per bathroom can be a challenge. Parking is just as bad. Looks like you'll find something across the street. 08/24

Have had the pizza once ..not bad. But the Buckeye Bone in Wings are AMAZING. We have had wings…read morefrom many places but Gionino's are the best

I give them five stars because their food is very very good and I won't takeoff for this but the…read morewait times are very long because sometimes they only have one driver in the store but I'd like their food enough to wait those long times so I will never delete my star for long wait times

I order from Mellow Yellow 1-2 times a week. They have the BEST pizza. I prefer the Thunder Pickle,…read morebut everything they make is delicious. The owners are extremely friendly & they accommodate my "switching up" ingredients without hesitation. I highly recommend giving them a try. *Warning: Prepare to become addicted! Missy Seidel

Saw their advertisement on social media that the food truck was going to be at a location for…read morecertain hours. Was excited to try something different locally! Arrived well within advertised hours, saw people leaving with pizza boxes, was excited! Stood behind a woman at the window who was talking to the worker. Talking and talking and talking. I thought for sure she would help me in a moment. Nope. She looked at me, said nothing. Another worker walked by, saw me. Said nothing. So after feeling so awkward for so long, I asked if they were closed, and the woman looked at me so rudely and said "yeah".