Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mariah's Cookies

    5.0 (1 review)

    Mariah's Cookies Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mariah's Cookies

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of John P.
    22
    10
    0

    5 years ago

    fabulous cookies the gingerbread cookie is the best as is the triple chocolate

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mariah's Cookies

    You might also consider

    The Bakeshop On Kelley Street - Decadent goodness...

    The Bakeshop On Kelley Street

    4.6(85 reviews)
    5.5 km
    $

    Another spot officially promoted to dangerously close go-to status…read more No flops. No regrets. Years later and still zero disappointments--no matter what we order, it hits. Plus, the owner is friendly, accommodating, and clearly understands the assignment. Pro tip: go EARLY or don't complain. You want the freshest picks and the full spread? Then show up on time, because this place sells out FAST--for a reason. Miss it? Yeah... that one's on you. Savory cravings? Covered. Pastry mood? Thriving. You truly cannot mess this up. Yes, the location is small--but don't be fooled. It packs a HUGE punch. Indoor seating is almost non existent, but grab your treats and enjoy the outdoor seating, during warmer months, while you ask yourself, "why didn't I visit sooner?" Hosting something fancy or need a holiday flex? Say less. They do that too. Bonus points: if you bring your fur baby by during the summer, you might catch them handing out dog treats--because this place clearly believes in spoiling everyone! And no, I don't have aesthetic, influencer-level photos. Why? Because we're too busy devouring the goods and living in the moment before I even think about grabbing my phone. Priorities.

    Small community bakery offers delicious bakery items (donuts, cakes, pies, cupcakes, cookies)…read more Breakfast sandwich was exceptional too. Everything is made fresh. Lots of neighborhood regulars visiting while I was there. The prices are a bit steep, but the quality was worth it. Friendly atmosphere in small but cute shop. Service was a bit slow, but again the food was worth the wait

    Photos
    The Bakeshop On Kelley Street - Lobby view

    Lobby view

    The Bakeshop On Kelley Street - The custom order of a wedding cannoli cake!! Absolutely amazing. (Unfortunately some of the ganache rubbed off in the box.)

    The custom order of a wedding cannoli cake!! Absolutely amazing. (Unfortunately some of the ganache rubbed off in the box.)

    The Bakeshop On Kelley Street - Outside of the building, street view.

    See all

    Outside of the building, street view.

    Puritan Backroom - Lg chicken tenders

    Puritan Backroom

    3.7(824 reviews)
    6.4 km
    $$

    This place puts the PURe in Puritan. Everything was so fresh. Completely agree with Mr. James…read moreBeard! 1) I'm forever ruined for chicken tendies. They simply won't suffice elsewhere. 2) prepare to come hungry! 3) the restaurant is called Backroom for a reason. Make sure you go to the back of the restaurant ;) My husband and I were STUFFED by the end. He got the tender sampler - and I got the buffalo chicken tender entree. Complimentary bread (with my entree?) + soup du jour or Greek salad + entree and choice of potato (fries, baked, mashed, etc.) The tenders tasted SO fresh. Breading didn't slide off the tender and the batter was just right. Everything melted in your mouth. We also decided on the chocolate cake (with a scoop of almond coconut chip ice cream) it was so creamy and fresh tasting! Our server was incredible - didn't miss a beat and was so friendly. The colonial-diner vibes inside were also their own special touch. It was quite loud and pretty full - but a ton of seating. A note: your party won't be sat unless everyone is present.

    Ah yes the Puritan Backroom is a great restaurant my favorite there is the lazy-man lobster…read morefantastic. I just am not a lobster roll person I like mine hot buttery n delicious n that is why I go here when I want one Also there Steak I love as well as there's fried broccoli n cheese. Yum They are big on large crowds n service is great. I have ones in the family who love chicken tenders n there is the best very large n juicy. I don't think you could be disappointed in anything they have, from fish to beef dishes are wonderful. Also make sure you get their Strawberry Short cake yum again Enjoy n tell them LorraineP sent you.

    Photos
    Puritan Backroom - Ice cream and to go

    Ice cream and to go

    Puritan Backroom - I recommend getting the kiddie size

    I recommend getting the kiddie size

    Puritan Backroom - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Mariah's Cookies - desserts - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...