Cancel

Open app

Search

Mariah's Cookies

5.0 (1 review)

Mariah's Cookies Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mariah's Cookies

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of John P.
22
10
0

6 years ago

fabulous cookies the gingerbread cookie is the best as is the triple chocolate

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Mariah's Cookies

You might also consider

The Bakeshop On Kelley Street

The Bakeshop On Kelley Street

4.6
(85 reviews)
5.5 km
$

Small community bakery offers delicious bakery items (donuts, cakes, pies, cupcakes, cookies)…read more Breakfast sandwich was exceptional too. Everything is made fresh. Lots of neighborhood regulars visiting while I was there. The prices are a bit steep, but the quality was worth it. Friendly atmosphere in small but cute shop. Service was a bit slow, but again the food was worth the wait

Another spot officially promoted to dangerously close go-to status…read more No flops. No regrets. Years later and still zero disappointments--no matter what we order, it hits. Plus, the owner is friendly, accommodating, and clearly understands the assignment. Pro tip: go EARLY or don't complain. You want the freshest picks and the full spread? Then show up on time, because this place sells out FAST--for a reason. Miss it? Yeah... that one's on you. Savory cravings? Covered. Pastry mood? Thriving. You truly cannot mess this up. Yes, the location is small--but don't be fooled. It packs a HUGE punch. Indoor seating is almost non existent, but grab your treats and enjoy the outdoor seating, during warmer months, while you ask yourself, "why didn't I visit sooner?" Hosting something fancy or need a holiday flex? Say less. They do that too. Bonus points: if you bring your fur baby by during the summer, you might catch them handing out dog treats--because this place clearly believes in spoiling everyone! And no, I don't have aesthetic, influencer-level photos. Why? Because we're too busy devouring the goods and living in the moment before I even think about grabbing my phone. Priorities.

Photos
Lobby view
Lobby view
The custom order of a wedding cannoli cake!! Absolutely amazing. (Unfortunately some of the ganache rubbed off in the box.)
The custom order of a wedding cannoli cake!! Absolutely amazing. (Unfortunately some of the ganache rubbed off in the box.)
Outside of the building, street view.

See all

Outside of the building, street view.
Puritan Backroom

Puritan Backroom

3.7
(830 reviews)
6.4 km
$$

Awesome diner style restaurant with a large dining room and a front ice cream part. Backroom is the…read moredining part. Large menu with a huge amount of choices, and the dessert menu is equally sizable! Tried the chicken tendie sampler: the coconut ones are absolutely amazing and unique. Chicken very tender and was a huge pile for an order. The portions on everything ordered were huge, come hungry for sure. Tried their dessert: our awesome waitress recommended lemon meringue which was great and the ice cream was super creamy and delish. Great spot, felt like home. Thanks

My American friend took me to this shop, and I only bought homemade ice cream from the window. The…read moreportions were huge, and there were many customers, but perhaps it just wasn't to my taste. (Most of my Chinese friends who went didn't finish it lol. Butter Pecan: Relatively unsweetened, garnished with pecans, but the pecan flavor was very faint. The smoothness was barely acceptable. Piña Colada: I only knew piña colada as cocktail, this was the first time I'd heard of it as ice cream. I ordered it out of curiosity, only to feel being betrayed... I couldn't taste any rum, coconut milk, or pineapple, it was just extremely sweet, with a thin texture and a very faint flavor, like it was made with low-quality milk. Peanut Butter Cup: Their signature item, and indeed, the best one. The peanut flavor was very strong, with a hint of caramel sweetness, but it was okay for a single bite; a whole serving was too sweet.

Photos
Ice cream and to go
Ice cream and to go
I recommend getting the kiddie size
I recommend getting the kiddie size
Inside

See all

Inside

Mariah's Cookies - desserts - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...