Most of the cookies here are a bit too dense & soft for my personal tastes (almost a cookie dough vibe at times), but the atmosphere is so friendly and there are so many fun options! We did the buy 6 get 2 free deal, and out of what I sampled, my favorites were the Oreo Crunch & the Brookie. The citrus flavor in the Orange Doodle (not 100% sure I'm getting the names right) was also really nice, despite the aforementioned overall base texture that just isn't my personal fav, and I also enjoyed the salted caramel bites in another (Cowgirl something?). They're all also very rich so I can only sample a few bites at a time. read more

Love love love Mary's Mountain Cookies! Every time I come to this location, the staff are so friendly, helpful, and available (and also very patient as I take forever to decide). There's so many delicious cookies to choose from, you can't go wrong! My personal favorite is the frosted Oreo cookie, so yummy! read more

Had a coupon for a free cookie with purchase so we got a peanut butter cup cookie and oatmeal cherry chunk cookie. They were giving some samples which we've never seen at the old town location so that was a treat. The peanut butter cup was my preferred choice but the other cookie was chosen by someone else in our group. Both were fresh and tasty. As always Mary's Mountain cookies for the win!! read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Cookie Oatmeal cherry chunk - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

So good!! I got the buy 6 get 2 free deal, the cookies are big and delicious! My favorite was the Oreo!!!

Pretty good cookies, soft and chewy. They have a good variety of flavors, sizes, and options (cookies, cookie sandwiches, ice cream sandwiches, etc.) to choose from. The storefront is on the smaller side, so it can be a bit cramped when busy. The girl working was nice enough, but seemed a bit overwhelmed when more people came in. Overall, it was good and I'll probably be back. read more

If you're Celiac and dairy free, don't bother getting a cookie here. Raw, sickly sweet slab of dough.

I love their cookies everytime I come in! The cookies aren't overally sweet or rich which is perfect compared to Crumbl's. They have two different sized cookies and many other delicious treats!! The people working are always super friendly and welcoming. The building is super cute and I enjoy the cookies everytime I come!! I would also say the cookies are reasonably priced which is even more reason to go here. read more

Soooooo many cookies to choose from! Wife and I split a Salted Caramel cookie and it was delicious! Will be back!

A friend ordered these for me from California to have delivered at my home in Fort Collins for my birthday. Great variety of cookies. They were very tasty - soft and chewy. Cute packaging, too. I moved to Fort Collins less than a month ago and I am forward to checking out this shop myself! read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Variety of tasty cookies in cute packaging - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Love the cookies here! I had the s'mores, turtle, m&m, and many more that I forgot the names but loved them all, and even gave extras to friends. Service was great, and she told me all the deals, as well as ingredients to various cookies I had questions about. I still haven't had their ice cream items, but will look forward in trying them during the warm spring and summer months! read more

On our way home out of town we stopped in here for a treat, it was great, awesome selection of cookies, we got 4 different kinds and a bonus free one for checking in on Yelp! Great rich flavors and good prices, smiling and friendly service, would go back in a heartbeat! read more

Bought a brownie and a frosted cookie. The brownie was okay - nothing special, but the cookie was horrible! It was stale and had a refrigerator taste to it. One bite and it went in the trash. First and last time there!! read more

Visiting from FL to attend my nephew's graduation from UNC. We heard this was a must try so the whole family went. As soon as you walk in you are facing a glass counter that displayed a large variety of the biggest cookies. They also serve ice cream and you have the option to create your own ice cream sandwich. The Reese's chocolate chip and the pistachio cookies were a family favorite. The kids enjoyed the ice cream as well. So many flavors to choose from so it was a great stop to accommodate a big family with different tastes. read more

See all

The Cookies here are huge! Also, there prices are very reasonable and the selection is huge. I came to this shopping area for work and decided to stop by. I regret not getting bringing home more cookies as they were very good. When taking the 10 cookies I brought home through the airport, I was stopped many times asking where I got them. They looked that good. read more

We bought these cookies for our nieces and nephews when we visited them in Fort Collins, CO. The assortment was great and the kids devoured every crumb. The staff was very friendly and helpful during our purchase. the store was very clean, bright and cheery. We plan on ordering on line and sending more delicious cookies for the upcoming holidays. Thanks Mary's Mountain Cookies! read more

My husband loves chocolate and I am allergic. So I always apperciate a sweet shop to have good options for both of us. We got 3 things from here: an indiidual sized fruit pie, original chocolate chip cookie and a double choco cookie. The fruit pie is small but very very soft. It breaks apart on touch and that's a wonderful thing. I don't remember much about the flavor. It was not overly sweet and I was very satisfied. Husband loved both cookies too. It's a great place. The people working there were very helpful too. read more

The cookies are very good. I am diabetic so can't eat them often. Service is friendly. It smells good there of course.

I have generally loved Mary's mountain cookies each time I have gone to the one on colllege, however my last experience at this other locations was not as great. The way the cookies were packaged created a messy disaster. I went for lunch and decided to treat myself to some cookies for the weekend. They put them 4 to a small plastic bag. Stacking heavy cookies on fragile ones. This caused my cute cookies to break and the frosted cookies to smear onto all the other cookies. These cookies were still good even with the frosting smeared onto the wrong cookies, however it is very pricey to not have my cookies be presentable for more than 5 minutes read more

See all

COOKIES of every size and flavor! There is something for everyone here. Giant, fresh baked cookies are the mainstay of this cookie emporium. From basic sugar cookies, chocolate chip and snickerdoodle to seasonal flavors such as pumpkin, peppermint and Christmas themed. Traditional or gourmet​, they have it all. The sandwich cookies are a great treat, too. They are two soft delicious cookies with either a scoop of ice cream​ or icing inside. You can also get shaped iced cookies, baskets, ​and delivery. Yes, delivery! Warm cookies on a cold day. How perfect. You must visit this homegrown​ Fort Collins establishment. Visit their website to read more about the story of Mary and how this cookie store has grown to be a regional favorite. It's a must on our schedule every time​ we are traveling through Fort Collins. We love the buy 6, get 2 free deal. It's perfect for our road trip​. read more

I heard this was a must stop place in Fort Collins and as a huge cookie lover I had to check it out. Upon walking in I noticed the cookies were gigantic. There was a lot of variety. We settled on an oatmeal raisin and a cookie sandwich with chocolate chip cookies and chocolate frosting. The cookies were good. I've definitely had better. I prefer a more soft underbaked cookie. The frosting between the cookies did not have much flavor. I think being from Amish country PA and having their baked goods has me spoiled. I'd still go back to this place and try the cookies again though. read more

Tons of options, hearty huge cookies, and they are delicious! Great cookie spot! Family friendly, good for dessert, or even a walk by treat!

Not sure what happen, I've been told if we were in Ft Collins to try these cookies. We got the buy 6 and get two free. They put all 8 cookies in plastic bags. The two girls that worked the counter were super sweet and awesome. The cookies itself were pretty bad, I love cookies too. I'm very disappointed in the taste and if I'm going to spend over $15 for 8 cookies they should be in a box. They taste like baking powder, not very good. read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Cookies in a baggy - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

not my best photo but boy is this cookie the greatest thing on earth!! 2 peanut butter cookies stuffed with the best chocolate frosting!! read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Peanut Butter Avalanche - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

If you like cookies...and you like ice cream, don't hesitate to stop by this place! The girls are so nice and you can tell they love being there. I don't like eating it as an actual sandwich, I prefer cookie in the bottom, ice cream on top, and eating it with a spoon. I prefer it this way so I'm not pushed to eat it so fast before it melts in my hands! I do wish they had a lot more seating, especially in the summer, because it is something that can be really messy. But ice cream is great, and so are the many, many cookies to choose from! read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Great little spot for an afternoon treat. Located across from the dog park, if you want to let your pups run for a bit. There is no seating inside, but they have a couple tables and a bench out front - and are conveniently located next to a cozy fire pit with several places to sit for a while. Service was great. Cookie varieties abound. You can buy them in any quantity you'd like. They had keto and gluten free options as well as edible raw dough. They have 8-10 ice cream flavors and will make you an ice cream sandwich using any two cookies of your choice, or will break one on half if you don't have a massive appetite. They have cookie dough and ice cream concoctions in the case, as well as several beverage options. read more

I'd like to say that I tried these cookies today because I couldn't walk past this store. However, I couldn't walk past because their doors were wide open and they were apparently making peanut butter cookies, and the smells pervaded the sidewalk for 20 feet outside their doors...and I'm deathly allergic to peanuts. I didn't even go to their door, and my airways and breathing are being affected from their products. Thanks guys. With peanut allergies being one of the largest (and increasing) allergies in this country, kids are regularly told they can't bring PB&J to school, and today I couldn't even use a public sidewalk because of the overwhelming smells coming from your store. Can you at least put up a warning sign for passers-by? At least I'm not a kid with this condition. Edited to point out that I said above that I couldn't even get near your store, so having a warning sign on your door does not help if those who need it can't get close enough to notice the sign because they're already having a reaction. I was referring to the sidewalk, but as I wrote that while working on getting my airways to open back to where they had been... I understand a bakery's desire to get the smells of their products up the noses of passers-by. I do, really. It reminds people that there is a bakery with those products nearby. But for those of us who my review represents, at least I wasn't a kid because your store would've sent me to the hospital due to your practices. read more

Went in yesterday and had some basic questions about the cookies and the girl was extremely rude, won't be back

I ordered a cake for my fiancé and couldn't be happier of the outcome. This was the best gluten free chocolate chip cookie we've ever had! Highly recommend! Staff was super friendly too! read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

In my opinion this is the best cookie place in town. I've been let down by other spots I've been too, but this place is always great. The pre-packaged cookie ice cream sandwiches are always excellent! read more

Yummy cookies! We really love the almond frosting, but they are all always delicious!

Really big cookies in downtown Fort Collins! Lots of options but super cool people to help make the decision!!! Will definitely come back! read more

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Chocolate chip with coffee ice cream! - Bakeries Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Visiting the area from out of state and came here based on the recommendations of some friends. I got the salted caramel cookie, turtle cookie, and chocolate chip avalanche (cookie sandwich with icing) to try throughout my week there. The turtle was by far my favorite but they were all delicious. A few dollars each but HUGE and well worth the price. Fresh and soft, and loads of flavor. If I ever make it back to CO I'll come here again. read more

They have their hours wrong online so we went at 8pm and they were closed! It is so frustrating when information like this is wrong online! We really love Mary's mountain cookies because there cookies are the best in town and we love to treat ourselves to them for special occasions so we were really bummed. read more

My daughter and I stopped in to get some cookies for dessert. We got 4 different kinds and the turtle cookie had a large piece of melted green plastic in it. When I called this establishment the young lady I talked to did nothing to rectify the issue. Very disappointing. The snickerdoodles that we got were doughy and not cooked all the way through. Again the young lady was not concerned. read more

These cookies are some of the best I've had! Snickerdoodle, peanut butter and Oreo were all divine

Hands down, the BEST cookies you'll ever eat! The cookies are so soft, and they have most creative flavor combinations! Major props to Mary and her quick genius - that almond glaze... to die for! Not to mention, they're huge! How they keep that monster of a cookie so soft and chewy, is a marvelous mystery. I always tell myself I'll save some for later, but let's be real... I eat the whole thing, in one sitting, every dang time. I've been around this store more times than I'd like to admit, and you really can't go wrong with any cookie. The S'mores one, though, tops them all! Oh, and the peanut butter one! In the summer, snag yourself an ice cream sandwich made with peanut butter cookies, and you'll be in heaven! The store itself is super cute, and there's space to sit down and enjoy your quick treat. They even have some coffee or hot chocolate - major win, in my book! Sometimes you'll come in at just the right moment, and see the staff working away on cookies right behind the bar! I love that they do that right up front; it's always refreshing to be able to see what you're getting - real, hand made cookies! The staff are always friendly, and they'll give you their opinions on their favorites...which, with the abundance of options, can be super helpful! Over and over again, one of my favorite stops in Fort Collins. read more

Lots of options for cookies and cookie sandwiches. They also offer ice cream sandwiches, milkshakes and edible cookie dough. All delicious! The staff is very friendly and helpful. This place is also great to go pick out cookies to give a gifts. Great quick stop for dessert. read more

Amazing selection of excellent cookies. We wandered in after dinner and got a couple of butter cream filled cookie sandwiches. I could not even eat all of mine it was so rich. They have cookie cakes and all kinds of other unique cookie treats. read more

THE.BEST.COOKIES.EVER!!! I was lucky enough to sample a few of Mary's latest creations and here is my review: do you like Ding Dongs? I luv them! Try Mary's creme filled brownie bites and it's like a gourmet Ding Dong! Wow!! And cheddar walnut choc chip cookie....sounds unusual?!! But actually it's amazingly delicious! The bits of cheddar that bake into the cookie actually crisp the cookie! That is now my new favorite!! To be honest, there is no average cookie at Mary's! She is always adding a new twist to her creations and mixing pure love into her sweet treats! By far the best cookies I've ever tasted!! read more

See all

Warm, soft and buttery. Much better than I remember from college about 10 years ago. Def stop by and get a cookie!