This place is expensive. Really expensive. Like, if you have a budgetary choice to go to a…read moretop-end steakhouse or buy your meat from Mitch, the steakhouse will be your cheaper option. And the rules can be a hassle if you are not planning ahead. It's all entirely true. BUT... Good lord is the meat good. The man knows his trade. His sourcing is top notch, and once you make it inside the store, he is attentive, helpful, and knowledgeable about how to store, prepare, and cook every product he sells. I can only afford it every once in a while, but if I need an absolute slam-dunk for a special occasion, I always hit up Mitch. His manager lady (I'm sorry I don't recall your name!) is incredibly nice and helpful, making suggestions and giving tips. The business has its quirks, and if you don't like the rules or the prices, it's best you go somewhere else. But if you're in need of one of the best pieces of meat you've ever had, suck it up and go see Mitch. Call ahead and you're golden.

This place is AMAZING! We ordered 2 prime cutes, one ribeye and one NY strip. Oh my they were…read morebeautiful, seasoned well with his secret seasoning, and he even gave us beef fat to cook it in which added to the flavor! We seared ours in a cast-iron skillet and use the juice to top the mashed potatoes we made as well as seared broccolini on the side. These two pieces were honestly large and we ended up having leftovers to sear up for dinner another day as well. I will certainly be coming back again for a special occasion dinner! Please do pre-order because it will make us so much easier for him as well as you so you can ensure that you get exactly what you need!

They officially reopened on Friday, May 22nd 2026 for Memorial Day Weekend!…read more We came in on Saturday, May 23rd to pick up some items for the holiday weekend and have some lunch. The Smoked Deviled Eggs were delicious and a good portion for the price. I ordered the Terra Major with Horseradish Mashed Potatoes and my wife got the Caesar Salad with Steak. Great Service and Beautiful Decor. We were so glad to see them reopened and thriving!

So happy they have reopened. Will miss the former owners but the new people are awesome. We've been…read moregoing for years on a regular basis. We pick out our steak from the butcher counter and they cook it perfectly every time for the cost of the steak + $15. Best deal and best steak in town. Great sides and salads. The bonus? We pick out a great bottle of Italian wine from the shelf (retail under $25) and there is no corkage fee or ridiculous uncharge. Amazing steak dinner for two w/ a bottle of wine and we get out of there for under $100 + tip. Almost seems too good to be true.

I really want to like this place. It is really close to home, the staff is nice, and I love local…read moreshops. I have gone here 4 times now since right when they opened, and the latest time being today. I have bought chuck roasts and brisket for slow smokes, some hanger steaks, and today some skirt steaks (I have not tried common things from this shop like ribeyes or strips). Every item I have bought from this shop has been significantly worse quality than Whole Foods down the road, and not even close to the quality of Pattons a bit further towards Norcross/Johns creek. Unfortunately I don't think I'll try this spot again, as they are batting a 0% average on my 4 trips. I hope they can turn their quality around - I would love to have a quality butcher shop near the house, but at their current levels I would prefer Publix.

Outstanding service and the meats are wonderful. Prices on the specials are about the same as the…read morechain stores but the quality is much higher. Try the sausages and brats! They carry fun seasonings, sauces and sides. Worth the stop!

It's tough to find a better steak in town and these guys really know their business inside and out!…read moreI also happen to try a few bags of the beef jerky they sell and Mann oh man was it delicious! I'll definitely be back for more!!!

From the owner: We cultivate deeper community by creating an unparalleled experience in-store, in the kitchen, and…read moreat the dining table. We provide our customers with the highest level of proteins and specialty food products that are typically only found at upscale, fine-dining restaurants. This allows people to recreate that level of dining experience in the comfort and satisfaction of their homes. By connecting the end-user to a level of quality they never knew about, or to which they had been previously denied access, we open their eyes to endless culinary possibilities. We create a loyal following by providing consistent and dependable quality products and an expert level of customer care.

Great selection of meats. The local store owner is very knowledgeable, helpful and cares about his…read morecustomers. I ended up getting 4 of their beef jerky bags ($10/each). Comes in multiple flavors

What a fantastic addition to the Peachtree Corners neighborhood! I frequently stop at this shopping…read morecenter for breakfast, and I was so excited to see that we were getting a meat market. I immediately tracked them down on social media and signed up for emails. The first email advertisement that caught my eye was for pimento cheese and bacon stuffed wagyu burgers. What?! Sign me up! The desire to check these out only intensified when a friend posted pics of the ones that she purchased and cooked. I immediately begged the hubby to grab some for an upcoming Friday night dinner. When he bought them, the man working the counter said they would change his life. He didn't lie. They were awesome. We are definitely ready to go back and try more offerings. Welcome to the neighborhood!

Over priced. Cute store. Sure the meat quality was solid,…read morecustomer service great, but the price not so great. And the cutting of the beef, just plain wrong. See attached prime ribeye photo. It was "cut to order" and they cutoff half of the steak! I'm a big fan of fatty tail, so that broke my heart. Once I got in the car and realized that I had a mutant ribeye, I stopped by Leonard's Farmers market to replace it. No joke. Stopped by another butcher, cause I was that upset. Needless to say, I will not be returning.

A hard to find butcher shop next to Midas auto repair and you would drive right past it unless you…read moreare looking for it. They have more than meat in the store. But, the reason we went was to try the meat. We ordered 2 prime Filet mignon and they looked really nice. They literally cut them while we were in store. It seemed to take a little while, so we browsed in the rest of the aisles. There are some interesting spices, Knickknacks, drinks, etc. We grilled the steaks last night. They were tasty at a medium rare temperature. We will return.

I have been looking for a place that sold Picanha for awhile now, after trying various normal…read moregrocery stores and farmers market and not being able to find it, it finally dawned on my to try to find a Brazilian market in the area. Did a search and this place popped up so I made a trip, walked in to a small but clean store. The butcher area was bright and clean and the guy behind the counter was very helpful (even though I don't speak Spanish or Portuguese). Very reasonably priced and fresh. I wanted to try/get some other items that looked good but since I was not familiar with everything I just got what I came for as not to hold up the line. I'll definitely be back for more and to try other items though.

They sell you Alcatra in a package and tell you it's Picanha Much Better Off using Supermercado…read moreGoianao, Costco, Publix or Kroger.

Absolutely loved the lunch special here! Amazing food and customer service at the bar. I had the…read moresteak flight with a side Cesar and potatoes. I would've loved more seasoning on the steak and potatoes but everything was cooked to perfection!

New York Butcher Shoppe is my go-to location for all things steak and meat and the restaurant is…read moreexcellent too! I've gone to the butcher shop for a while now and have always enjoyed their steaks. They are high quality and at a great price. Recently I stopped in to have lunch as well and it was amazing. I had the smoked wings which were very large and had great flavor. I also had the Sandy Springs Steak Sandwich which was super delicious! I love coming back to try new steaks and it's great knowing I can get a delicious hot meal here too!