Family owned. Family run. Rob is a psychopath in the best way. At 6am you want an amazing breakfast sandwich with a side of comedy? Matsons is the place to be. Great food, good prices. read more

Excellent deli , friendly staff , so many hot and cold sandwiches to choose from. Food quality on point , extra points for them because they have 6 tables to devour your food at, with some rock and roll music. Love it. read more

See all

This is one of the best bagel/breakfast places in New Windsor. I am sure this place has been within the community for a long time.

I see this deli all the time since I live nearby. Stopped in for a breakfast sandwich, bacon egg and cheese. They made it exactly how I wanted it, bacon extra crispy. Decided to get a hero for lunch the next day since the MEL appeared worth it on the menu. The MEL- grilled chicken, sautéed spinach and fresh mozzarella on garlic bread. Totally disappointed. The chicken to bread ratio was not even close, both ends of the sandwich did not have enough chicken to cover the hero. The scarce amount of spinach was disappointing, the thin slice of fresh mozzarella was a joke. Overall- breakfast I will return for another time, but the hero I got is any indication of the other sandwiches, I'll pass on lunch. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - MEL "hero" - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Passed by this place for many years. Kept hearing about their breakfast sandwiches. I finally stopped in on a Saturday. The staff & owner are amazing! The owner takes the time to introduce himself & chat for a bit. He even gave us samples which led us to buy this delicious juice that his wife makes & the delicious jerk chicken salad. They have a new menu which includes Caribbean food. Plenty of seating available inside if you want to eat in. read more

See all

Food is alway good. Broke my heart today asked for a roast beef here with American cheese with mayo. I go eat the sandwich no freaking MAYO! WALK THE PLANK SANDWICH MAKER whoever made this read more

It must have new owners or something.. not the same as it used to be. 1st time there in a while & our sandwiches were so skimpy . Chicken cutlet was very bland & simply not very good & the other sandwich we had was made wrong. Not a very good price for what you get. Disappointing. 1 1/2 stars read more

I had a very disturbing experience at Matson's Deli that left me feeling racially profiled as a young Black Amazon delivery driver. When I came in to deliver a simple package of chips, the older bald man immediately questioned my position as an Amazon worker, spoke to me rudely, and ignored me when I asked for the recipient's name. He then suspiciously examined the package as if something was wrong with it, gave me dirty looks, and continued to question the delivery for no valid reason. After repeatedly dismissing me, he finally said "have a good day" in a passive-aggressive tone, which only added to the disrespect. The most concerning part was that after I left, he watched closely me outside, watched me walk to my car, and stood there staring at me until I drove off. The entire interaction was hostile, unnecessary, and made me feel unsafe. No worker should ever be treated this way for simply doing their job. This kind of behavior is unacceptable, and it reflects poorly on the business. His actions have been reported to Amazon because of how unsafe and uncomfortable this experience was for me. read more

Food has drastically went down hill with new owner. I live near by and this was my go to deli. I will not return. The prices and quality of the food are horrible. Just look at the recent reviews. Many are agreeing.. Sad they used to be good. read more

While traveling recently in NY I wanted a good BEC PK (bacon egg and cheese with pepper and ketchup) I searched a bit on Yelp and came across this place. The sandwich was just perfect. I'd guess the roll was from the famous Rockland Bakery. If you are on the area stop by. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - BEC PK - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Great service! Since there's no many spots to grab a bite in the morning Matson quickly became our go to! But recently the sandwiches have fallen off... read more

Early morning orders for my family and friends for lunch, the Staff at Matson's took care of me and my order. I will definitely recommend Matson's Deli to my friends and family going forward. The food they made for us was delicious and well worth the price. Thank you!!! read more

Service was great and food made fresh. Served piping hot but the wrap itself could use a little more toasting. The eggs and potatoes a little bland. Overall good good at a good price. Definitely worth visiting. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - Display case. - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

Ordered a pastrami egg and cheese scrambled. There is a shaving of pastrami inside the weird not scrambled still fried and dry egg. One slice of cheese in the middle of the "scrambled" egg. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - Pastrami egg and cheese on a roll - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

Walked in and the first thing I noticed is gluten free items. So happy happy to see because finding convenient food that's actually not fast food in a pinch is hard to find around here. Made my order, they have gluten free wraps and subs. I have a terrible gluten allergy, so this was a very big deal to me. I got a egg Turkey and cheese on a gluten free wrap. It was good. I will be going back for sure. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - Gluten free cookie - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

I've eaten here several times for lunch. This restaurant is practicing the COVID-19 protocols. Masks are required, limited and spaced out seating is available. Hand sanitizer is available too. The restaurant is clean and tidy. The menu is very big, you can get overwhelmed when you visit for the first time. All orders are made to order after you order, so expect to wait at to receive your order. Leaving here not feeling satisfied and full is not a concern, the sandwich sizes aren't small. This is not a fast food restaurant, it's a deli and café, like the signs read. I had various sandwiches during my visits here, as well as their desserts. nothing I have ordered here has ever disappointed me. Breakfast and lunch are the prime times here. Dinner is not served, I'm not sure what time they close, but its before the dinner rush starts. There is free local delivery, but you have to make a $15 dollar order to get free delivery. Cash/Credit and Debit cards are accepted. read more

This is my go to breakfast spot every morning. I love being able to call in my order before I leave my garage and it be ready 5 mins later for pickup. The staff is super friendly and greet you with a smile every morning, making it hard to be grumpy when you walk-in. read more

Came in today for the first time. Interior was clean and organized , BIG plus. All the employees had masks and gloves , another big plus . Wasn't sure what to order , so I asked this nice fella named Chris , and he recommended the Rueben , and WOW, it was incredible !!!! Thanks Chris !!!! read more

Matson's make such delicious sandwiches! They use Boarshead meats which just puts them on an entirely different level. They are a great "go to" for breakfast or lunch! read more

This is a busy deli and can get swamped quick with locals, their daily bunch and people like me who stop in here and there. Food wise I've never eaten anything but breakfast because well what else does one need from a great deli? They sell lots of different parties, sandwiches, etc but when it comes to a BOBO ( Bacon, Egg, Cheese, home fries) this place has it down! They have a nice little coffee bar that you make your own drink and it's much more than just milk creams and sugar has enough Fixn's for your usual person with flavored creamers & syrups. Breakfast sandwiches are great I enjoy the barge with has egg, cheese, ham, sausage, bacon all that's missing is some potato and it has it all! It's served on a hero of soft bread truly breakfast fit for royalty. Will have to eventually try this place not early in the morning but until then go get their breakfast ! read more

Yummy! Always busy with lots of cars in the parking lot tells ya theyre doing something right! read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - Chicken cobb salad- loaded with chicken!! - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

tried here for the first time 10/10. the staff was very friendly and patient while I was thinking what to order since they have a large section, plus I love how all numbered and on their wall so its easier to decided. so I ordered a #26 salami,ham cappi, sopressata, provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar. the sandwich was fresh and bread was soft. tasted like a advanced version of a Italian combo, but made with pride to be the best. worth price for its size and taste. got a peanut butter brownie as well and it was soft and very fudge, the peanut butter on top was creamy. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - #26 - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

The food use to be so much better, I'm not sure if the owners changed or something. They make orders wrong, I've actually been late to work cuz I had to go back in to get my order right. Maybe they don't speak English or they need new cooks. The food is ok still. Very pricey for deli food like it's a joke. read more

Wow, I will definitely go back! The amount of traffic at this place is NOT wrong. It was by far the best sandwich I have ever had. I had the Cuban with a side of rice and beans and it was all spectacular. I would recommend this place to absolutely everyone. I cannot wait to try their breakfast because I have been assured that it is their best meal they serve. I dont see how because the sandwich was amazing. This is a must try and i am so happy I finally did. Yes yes YES! So much yes! read more

See all

The quality of the food has gone down over the years. Place is all about the volume and less about the quality. You get more cold cuts on your sandwich at Subway for half the price. You're selling a sandwich..not bread.. read more

Way over cooked egg and ham. Whoever cooked my sandwich today does not take pride in their work. I know this isn't a five star restaurant but I don't buy a breakfast sandwich just to throw it away. read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Ordered a #2 and was very pleased. Chicken cutlet was freshly breaded, sub roll was delicious, and bacon was crispy. Place was very clean and staff really nice. Will definitely return when in the area read more

I just ordered a bacon egg and cheese sandwich and asked for the eggs to be scrambled and the bacon to be crispy. I got what appears to be eggs over easy with rubbery, uncooked bacon. I took a few bites but wound up throwing the whole thing out in the garbage. Now I'm driving around looking for another deli to order a sandwich. Big let down. It is almost as if the guy took my order but didn't even listen to me, as if he said "we make it the way we make it so you'll get what you get and you'll like it." Had a similar thing happen just the other day at Home Depot. I was trying to explain what I needed while the sales person was trying to get me to sign up for a credit card. I felt bad for sales people and small businesses during the pandemic and tried to tip heavily but my sympathy is waning, they want your money but they're not listening to what you're asking for. I'll find another place that listens to the customer. UPDATE: I posted this before I read the other reviews. Looks like someone posted almost the exact same complaint a month ago and still, nothing has changed. That's indicative of a business that just doesn't care. UPDATE # 2: Spent yesterday sick, vomiting to be specific. Looks like the two or three bites I took from the BE&C sandwich they sold me got me food poisoning. Horrible experience. read more

I've stopped and tried this place 5 times for breakfast. Everything has this weird taste to it. Almost like moldy or the food is old, maybe it things aren't kept at temp, I can't figure it out, but it's bad. I was getting breakfast sandwiches and they all had that weird overpowering taste to it so I tried just a toasted everything bagel with cream cheese, it was still there. The service is decent, last I was in I was looking at my food sitting in the window for a good five minutes. Not one of the five staff standing around had a sense of urgency when the cook rang the bell to signal it was done. Maybe lunch is better, but breakfast is pretty bad. read more

Came in here the other morning for something quick to eat. I was greeted by the woman behind the counter, which made me feel welcomed. Didn't wait too long with my order. My sausage egg and cheese tasted great. It was really fresh. The price was right as well. Will be coming back for breakfast soon. read more

Waited for the burnt bacon over cooked egg and cheese . I ordered chicken breast with mayo on a roll one side had mayo ??? I phoned to let them know the poor quality of the breakfast product and the dry sandwich . I got an apology and request to come back to have they remake it and instructions on ordering mayo both sides . Never again ... read more

Matson's Deli & Cafe - Burnt bacon egg and cheese - Delis Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

I stop 2-3 times a week for breakfast & lunch and don't want to go to any other deli. I will go out of my way on weekends! Great selection, fast service by the awesome ladies up front, always fresh food whether it's cold cuts or prepared meals! Other deli's simply don't measure up!!! read more

The food especially on lunch menu is always good and I love the turkey platter which they served this past Thursday. I also like the number 7 on a hero. The reason for 3 star is the customer service slacks big time. You can call in your order and when you walk in they ask you for your name and then they actually point and tell you it's ready but make you wait and take other customers ahead of you when those customers aren't even ready yet. read more

While the food is usually good, their business practices leave a lot to be desired. Was there this past week, paid with a credit card, and was charged an additional "non cash adjustment". When I asked about this, I was told, well, we are just like the gas stations, we have to charge for more when you use a credit card. What ??!! They are the only deli in the entire area to charge this additional fee, and you'd be hard pressed to find another food establishment that charges this additional fee as well. I mentioned something on their FB page, and they took down my comment. BEWARE ! They could at least build this fee into their pricing, so it doesn't appear that you are being nickel and dimed. They definitely lost my business, and others too, I'm sure. Bad business practice ! read more

Very obviously there's a new owner. Very disorganized now, workers are stressed and not smiling and not working smoothly like before. Portions are small now, food looks different and you don't get what you ask for. Ask for well done bacon and you'll get nearly raw bacon. Not impressed. No flavor to food anymore either. read more

Sandwiches, salads and breakfasts are awesome! Everything is fresh to order and there is always a line of loyal customers. Wish they stayed open longer hours! read more

I love this place especially on weekend mornings. They have the freshest bagels I've tasted since I lived in NYC! They have various hot & cold foods but my impression is "fresh" when I visit for a sandwich or some breakfast. read more

Always excellent service and great food!!!! Keep up the great work!!!!! Clean and always changing up thier menu!!!!!!

I have breakfast here every other Saturday! Friendly staff and the food is always fresh! Never disappointed! Typical deli with everything you need for breakfast and lunch! The store is always clean and everyone is always smiling! Have had many things of the menu and it's always been delicious! If you are looking for a great local deli with an awesome staff, do yourself a favor and stop in! read more

See all

First time getting something from here - called first thing on a Saturday morning for some bagels and some heroes for a pick up order. The establishment itself was very nice inside, clean and had a nice selection of beverages and cold items (i.e. puddings, hard boiled eggs, pasta salads, etc.). I didn't see where the chips were but I have to look next time. When I arrived I had assumed my order would have been bagged up already but my items were mixed with other items off to the side and so they had to ask me what was in my order and grabbed those items. Our bagels were good - not Jersey bagels - but still tasty. I had ordered a salt bagel with butter but the girl made a mistake and grabbed instead a plain bagel with cream cheese. I had a hero of roast beef and fresh mozzarella and it was good - fairly good ratio of meat and cheese to roll - the roast beef wasn't as rare as I like it but I also didn't ask if the roast beef was rare when I ordered my sandwhich. I do tend to like more meat on my sandwhich but it was still good - very good bread. I would like to sample some of their wraps and other items in the future. The only thing is it needs a bit more parking because when it gets crowded you have people trying to pull in the same time people are trying to pull out and it can cause a bit of a traffic jam due to its location and one way in and out. read more