Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

    3.8 (14 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Order Mayflower Seafood Restaurant Takeout or Delivery

    Mayflower Seafood Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    MAYFLOWER SEAFOOD RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Two Different (create your own) Catfish and Crab Cakes w/ Coleslaw, apple sauce and hush puppies
    Min S L.

    There were 7 of us in the party, 5 adults and two children. Two of the people had been there prior, I ordered the Two Different-create your own: Catfish and crab cakes. The catfish was very good and fresh, crab cakes were mmmehhh at best. Definitely frozen and fried over hard They give you a ton of popcorn shrimp and pile it on top of the food- it was very good. Service was decent- I do not remember our waitress name, but she did ask to take our families photo to post on their facebook page, I opted out of the photo. The order is completed on a "tally" page and taken to the cashier to be rung up and they have to include the tip in the charge if you're paying with a card. I'd prefer an "itemized" printed bill, but the "mayflower" has yet to make it to 2022. This place is decent at best, three stars for the service and good catfish.

    uncooked could get someone horribly sick. disgusting
    Thomas M.

    For firsts, the manager i believe her name is Jacinda- was absolutely horrible, ive never seen a "manager" act and treat customers and employees soo disrespectfully. keep in mind moat employees at this establishment are teenagers, it's absolutely SICKENING! i do not recommend this restaurant too anyone, especially with a manager that is beyond an adult who acts like a complete child with no remorse or consideration for others terribly lead establishment. wont be returning unless there is a management change.... absolutely RIDICULOUS.

    a plate of fried food

    See all

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    I had the catfish and popcorn shrimp. I think they needed to change the oil, it tasted burnt and the catfish was extremely dry.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of B H.
    0
    1
    0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Min S L.
    13
    177
    598

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Good selection on the menu, good food, good prices for seafood, peaceful atmosphere, and nice, efficient staff. We'll be back!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    The food was ok, uses cheap ingredients. Portions are very large, enough to share with one other person.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 128 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cape Fear Seafood Company - Hush Puppy Basket

    Cape Fear Seafood Company

    4.1(125 reviews)
    15.3 mi
    $$

    Before moving to TN, my best friend and I had our final lunch together at Cape Fear Seafood Company…read moreat the same location she introduced me to the company when we first met. It was a bittersweet moment and I'm glad we chose Cape Fear. Kelly was our waitress and she was outstanding, truly making my last meal at Cape Fear a special one (being that they're a very small chain in NC, I'm unsure if I'll ever be back). The drinks were constantly filled and her service was one of the best I have ever had at any restaurant. I ordered a bunch of food, knowing it would be my last time ever having their risotto, clam chowder, and hushpuppies, along with their delicious fried seafood platter. I had told Kelly I was moving so she made it a spectacular visit and went above and beyond. I will miss Cape Fear. It reminds me of The Hamptons. It's casual but classy. It was a fantastic meal with phenomenal service with an amazing friend. Truly, what could be better?

    Zero stars. I could…read morebe wrong, but I believe this is the first "terrible" review I've left on Yelp. We just left this "restaurant" after horrible service before even finalizing our entree orders. This was our first time trying it, and we were excited because we love all kinds of seafood. The restaurant was not very busy. The waitress was friendly and helpful at first. We ordered a mini-crab cake appetizer, which was brought out promptly. At that point we began placing our entree orders. My wife ordered a flounder basket. I then ordered the shrimp taco meal. My order was to come with 2 tacos. So, I made a simple request: one with grilled shrimp and one with fried shrimp (since they serve both). I then received a lengthy, stammering explanation of how "they" don't let them do that. I offered to pay the higher of the two prices and explained, since it was our first time there, I was hoping to try different options. However, she maintained this could not be done. So, I requested to speak with a manager. She seemed surprised, but said, " okay," and went to the back. For the next 5 minutes, I waited (a bit annoyed, since I was hungry and knew our order was not even in process). After a little more than 5 minutes, she came back and said, "you can still talk to a manager if you would like, but they asked me to explain ..." Then she went into an explanation that didn't make a lot of sense. I also, at this point was not interested in explanations. It was clear to me that this restaurant has no interest in accommodating even the simplest of customers requests. I asked her for our check and told her we would finish our appetizer, pay, and leave. She told me she could get the manager, but at that point, I told her there was no need. It was clear to me the manager tried to avoid having the initial discussion in the first place, hoping the waitress could get me to accept the answer and move on. We paid and left. I'm usually a very generous tipper (maybe even too generous sometimes). I try to error in the direction of more, but less. My wife is the same, having worked in the service industry, including waitressing for many years. In this case, I left no tip, and wrote a brief explanation on the merchant receipt. I had noticed some of the "don't recommend" reviews on Yelp prior to checking it out, but sometimes I view those as one-offs. In this case, I found myself agreeing wholeheartedly with the reviews indicating they will never be back. Even if ultimately I could not get what I requested, and was even still unconvinced as to a legitimate reason, had this been handled with even a modicum of respect for a paying customer, I likely would have refrained from reviewing at all, instead of this negative review. At no point during this situation was I rude, loud, argumentative, or inappropriate in any way. When a manager doesn't care, that attitude permeates the business. As for the mini crab-cakes, they were okay, but not what I would have expected for the price.

    Photos
    Cape Fear Seafood Company
    Cape Fear Seafood Company - Coleslaw and hush puppies

    Coleslaw and hush puppies

    Cape Fear Seafood Company

    See all

    Tasty Crab House - Rocky Mount - Sausages, we opted to put them on the side bc we don't eat pork but the hubby and youngest do.

    Tasty Crab House - Rocky Mount

    4.3(44 reviews)
    28.4 mi

    Why 5 stars? Because the food was delicious, Service was…read moreamazing, ambiance was chill. We went on a holiday and fortunately for us we did not have to wait a long time. I think we waited 2 minutes before we were seated lol. I had seen this restaurant once before and totally forgot about it until we were in the area and wanted seafood. The hubby is not a big crab boil fan so he usually opts for a fried seafood dinner. They have your usual menu items....pick your preference of seafood, seasoning and spice level. It was cheaper for us (myself & the cubs) to get the family platter instead of individual meals. Let me tell you something!! It did NOT disappoint!! Food was prepared fresh and very flavorful & plentiful. We decided on the Big Bang with a medium spice level. Our server was very nice and friendly and didn't mind answering a few questions and making sure our food was to our liking. Per usual, the hubby ordered a shrimp and fish platter which was also a nice portion. This is a great restaurant, so much so I have recommended it to several people!

    Stopped in for lunch with a couple of old dawgs (dad and his buddy) and we all left feeling the…read moresame kinda way - happy. Service is quick and friendly - the young ladies really were on their game at getting you situated and taking your order. Food came with the right amount of time (shows that freshness without making you wait too long, and delivered as promised. I foot the Maryland crab cakes and dries, it was good. Pricing is fair, food was tasty and the service was sweet, I will be back! I imagine this place is hopping on weekends/evenings. The atmosphere, vibe and food would ensure people line up.

    Photos
    Tasty Crab House - Rocky Mount - Family Special Platter....this feed 3-4 people and we had leftovers. Very seasoned.

    Family Special Platter....this feed 3-4 people and we had leftovers. Very seasoned.

    Tasty Crab House - Rocky Mount - Combo Shrimp & Catfish

    Combo Shrimp & Catfish

    Tasty Crab House - Rocky Mount

    See all

    Mad Flavorz Wing Lounge - Coconut Shrimp

    Mad Flavorz Wing Lounge

    4.5(17 reviews)
    0.7 mi

    Great Wings and More…read more Mad Flavorz is hard to describe. First and foremost, it's a wing shop - a very good wing shop. The wings are big, chunky, meaty, tender and smothered in a variety of unusual (and unusually tasty) Flavorz. I highly recommend the bone-in Mad Flavorz Bourbon Wings - a lot of flavor with a balance of sweet, heat and tang. I'm running out of adjectives, so I will simply say that these are some of the best Wings I ever ate. As the name would imply, it's also a Lounge with a full service bar, relaxed atmosphere super friendly service and extensive list of beers. It doesn't get much better than a pile of world-class wings and an ice cold Red Stripe. We were impressed with the diversity of the menu - everything from Burgers and Hoagies to Salads and Seafood. The Coconut Shrimp was institutional but delicious. The Specialty Sides are as good as the Wings.. The French Toast & Chicken Tenders Plate was a mixed bag. The Toast was disappointing (not restaurant quality), but the three good-sized Chicken Tenders were nicely done - crunchy on the outside and juicy on the inside. The Fish Whopper Sandwich lived up to its name. The very large filet was golden brown, crispy and served on a fresh soft bun. Add a side of perfectly fried Okra and you have a satisfying meal. The Jamaican Beef Patty - much like an oversized empanada - had a nice crispy shell filled with flavorful minced beef. It was extra tasty with a little of the Cajun Jamaican Jerk Sauce. My biggest issue with Mad Flavorz is that they are often out of several menu items and beers (Lobster Pops, Banana Pudding, Cheesecake, Red Stripe, Modello to mention a few). I hope this is a temporary situation. Having said that, I still very much enjoy eating at this somewhat quirky eatery.

    Best wings around! Always go extra crispy if you like em like that. Def recommend it!read more

    Photos
    Mad Flavorz Wing Lounge - Bar

    Bar

    Mad Flavorz Wing Lounge - Maple Ginger Wings

    Maple Ginger Wings

    Mad Flavorz Wing Lounge - Bourbon Wings & Rings

    See all

    Bourbon Wings & Rings

    Latitudes On The Lake - Awesome view from the deck!

    Latitudes On The Lake

    4.7(3 reviews)
    40.9 mi

    Who doesn't love a Restaraunt that you can ride up in a boat to the dock, tie off, grab a table,…read moreand enjoy the view. What a treat. This was our first visit to this establishment. Our expectations were high. As we walked down the dock checking out the other boats tied off along the way we could hear laughter and good music. (Be mindful of any loose boards) We were greeted as soon as we walked up and seated at an 8 top right on the deck viewing the lake. The menu had a lot of appealing items to select from. A majority of them being fried seafood fair. The prices were reasonable for the selection as well. The six of us all ordered something different. I had the Firecracker Shrimp (huge!), my wire ordered the crab cakes (disappointing due to more filler than crab at $22 for two), son had the 8oz burger (he loved it), tenders for the little guy, my uncle ordered the alligator bites which they were out of so he picked the catfish nuggets, and my aunt got the chicken nachos. The portions were rather large. Down to stars. I'm on the fence between 3 or 4 for these reasons. We arrived around 2:30pm and probably waited just over an hour for our food. The little ones were restless and cranky. The food was decent with the exception of the crab cakes. Servers were overwhelmed somewhat due to customers sharing stories from what I could gather from nearby tables. People are chatty when the mixed beverages are flowing. However, I love the experience, vibe, and the view. So 4 it is for this trip. You should check them out. I would definitely like to come back. It was really fun and I can only expect that place to get crazier as the summer goes on. Side note: If you order water, there is a $0.95 charge. Also there is a membership discount, but I don't know what that entails.

    Has a great expeience on my first visit. Although we drove instead of going by boat, we were…read moreescorted by golf cart to the restaurant. Good food, relaxed atmosphere, and decent prices. We ate on the deck and enjoyed the water.

    Photos
    Latitudes On The Lake - Firecracker Shrimp (Appetizer)  Huge and tasty!

    Firecracker Shrimp (Appetizer) Huge and tasty!

    Latitudes On The Lake
    Latitudes On The Lake - Crab Cake's (more crab please)

    See all

    Crab Cake's (more crab please)

    Mayflower Seafood Restaurant - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...