We've not been here in about a year; and the crowded dining room would belie the experience we had this evening. Calamari appetizer - rubbery. Could be used for ring toss. Breadsticks- hard. Larger Margherita pizza- came out cold. Eggplant Parmesan - Surely didn't taste homemade. A very sad outcome for an experience we had looked forward to. We'll wait a bit before we come back. So many other consistently good choices for Italian food in Sputh Bend and Elkhart IN. read more

Even BETTER than last time we were here for GREAT Italian food. I'm not going to give you a long drawn out review. Just great service Great food and fantastic drinks. We love the bar also. read more

See all

Fantastic find! Delicious bread and perfectly dressed salad. Tried the Deluxe pizza just skip the olives next time. Great service and definitely returning!" read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Food was average Service lacked a lot, hard to get staff . They seem to be short a lot. Pizza is good, not great Nice atmosphere read more

Have been here a couple of times and sat at the bar. Alice behind the bar is amazing. She is very attentive and gave good recommendations. The Italian wedding soup is a must! read more

For appetizers, I like their cheese and crackers that they offer! Their lasagna is outstanding, but my favorite is their veal Parmesan. I usually get their sandwiches for lunch, which are also stellar. read more

Had a reservation for Valentine's Day dinner. Ordered the prime rib special with salad and tots. Fried ravioli appetizer with marinara for starters, my favorite!! Cheese and crackers and drinks came out quickly. Fresh bread and butter came out with our dinners. Greg ordered spaghetti and meatballs. We didn't even eat 1/2 of our food. We took soo much home! The little cookies were a treat. Best dinner in a long time! read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Valentine's Day prime Rib, salad, tots, bread & butter and cheese & crackers - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

When I entered Michael's on a Friday night the place was packed. We were seated before our reservation time. The restaurant is updated and modernized. Beautiful restaurant. We got our drinks quickly even though the restaurant was full. I got the fettuccine and shrimp with a side of garlic bread. My wife got grilled shrimp. They were perfectly seasoned. We really enjoyed our food and drinks and will be back. read more

See all

Delicious. What else can I say? Dining in can be a little slow and a complimentary bread basket and dipping oil would go a LONG way to improveme this issue, but the food is consistently good. Elkhart is lucky to have a place like this....homemade goodness is hard to find nowadays. read more

AMAZING FOOD AND GREAT STAFF! Been eating here for years and have never been disappointed. Would recommend to everyone! read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Chicken strips and fries - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

I've heard so many wonderful things and was truly so disappointed!!! Our reservations were for 630 on a Wednesday evening. After 1 hour and. 45 minutes we received our food. The restaurant was pretty much emptied by that time. We could not even stop our server a minute to see why we had to wait so long. No one apologized or offered any compensation. Three out of four meals were pretty good. Mine was suppose to be whole grain pasta and I do not believe it was, but server really didn't check back with us so I could find out. I believe our server was related to the owner and they were more worried about 1 single large party than taking care of first time and returning customers. read more

Christmas party at Micheal's last night and they did not disappoint. Everything was on point! read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Manicotti - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

It was our first visit to Michael's. We were very pleased! Great environment, courteous staff, and great food! Thank you so much!

7-30-2024 - I ordered take out. Lasagna with salad. The server used the caller ID and immediately called me back to let me know that they were out of the lasagna. I appreciated that call because I changed my order to meat raviolis with a salad. My meal was very delicious. The packaging perfectly kept the hot stuff hot and the cold stuff cold. When I showed up to pick up my food, the service was upbeat and fast. Simply awesome! read more

This is a place if you want good family style Italian food in a neighborhood setting. It's good... and clearly local. Our party of four had all versions of parmigiana (1 chicken, 1 veal, and 1 eggplant) and a specialty vegan/pine nut/avocado sauce dish ordered by brother from California. The margarita pizza is the waitress's favorite and 40% of the patrons were eating pizza. Wine selection was limited, but very good. Service was excellent and helpful. Parking was on the street but a church parking lot across the street was available. read more

We came by for a quick lunch between sales appointments. We were seated quickly by a friendly server that was prompt and efficient. The Italian Beef sandwich was enough for 2 - huge portion for a small price. Very tasty as well. Co worker had a huge Meatball sub with Marina - also very tasty. Both sandwiches were served with chips. In and out the door in under 30 minutes - sure beats fast food burgers!! We will be back!! read more

Food is fantastic; their bacon dressing on your salad is amazing. Family members still have a lot to do with the business everyday. Stop in & enjoy yourself a great meal and hometown bar. read more

I ordered the pasta combo with a Caesar salad and bread. We shared jalapeño poppers with ranch for dipping. The pasta was cooked perfectly and the sauce is hands down the best I've ever eaten. The salad was fresh and the dressing was delicious. The poppers were great as well. Honestly, I would have given this meal 5 stars if I'd only had a dish of pasta sauce and a plate of their soft, fragrant fresh bread with soft butter. The service was friendly and well-timed. The atmosphere is casual, clean and inviting; parking is sufficient. How could it not be pleasant with everyone happy and eating delicious food? read more

my favorite go to Italian restaurant. I love the chicken parm so much that I never try anything else's. Luckily my husband isn't like me & usually tries something new each time. Some of the yumminess he's enjoyed is the pizza, lasagna, masticholi. The house salad dressing & homemade bread are delicious read more

This place is amazing! Great food great drinks and great staff! It very welcoming and always a good time!

The food is absolutely delicious and presentation is very nice. Amazing service. We have now visited twice and plan to return.

My favorite restaurant in Elkhart! The best. Great food and service! Always good. Try the Godfather sandwich.

Great food, large portions, fun atmosphere, and fantastic servers. Great for date night or family dinner.

First time here. I had high hopes and maybe they had a bad night. 13 person reservation 6:30pm. Wife's birthday surprise, so we were purposely late by 15 minutes. People got their drinks just before we arrived. Took another 1/2 hour before we ordered. 40 minutes later we got our food. Mostly pasta but a sandwich a pizza and my steak that was medium. Pizza was cool and hard to even cut with a steak knife, meatball sandwich was cool, but the baked ziti was burned on top. Waitress mixed up orders and ignored us. My wife finally said something close to the end and was blown off. Ended up with a $235.00 bill and left 75 for a tip. Should have been less but it was my wife's birthday night and I was trying to keep a positive attitude. I give second chances to restaurants and maybe they just couldn't handle that many people we will try again and I may change my review, but there are plenty places to eat around here. Seems like a very nice restaurant, but their food was soup bar and their service was lacking for a place that wasn't really that busy. read more

The food and service were great. I love their pizza and homemade Italian dishes. The friendly home like authentic atmosphere makes you want to come back for more. read more

So, here for work. I came here and sat at the bar. Met a few older guys who were full of stories and love. I was invited and welcomed. Food was good. Services was good. Making friends was great! It's hard to find spots in a new town- I'd say come here and relax. It was great and fun! I'll be back.... Oh- owner is fun and involved. He truly cares. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in my life. I also had a side salad with their creamy garlic salad dressing and I'm going to be dreaming about it for awhile. read more

My wife's sister was in town and wanted some Italian food. We went to Michael's and we're not disappointed. Our dinners and apps came out nicely and the food was classic not authentic. Overall it was delicious. I would return. read more

Great food. Small town Italian. Really good portions. Have left Mcg for tomorrow. Will be back read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Pizza and stuffed shells with meatballs - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

We were visiting relatives who suggested this restaurant was a great Italian Restaurant. My experience however was not the best. We had a reservation at 6:30 pm and were seated immediately. The appetizers mozzarella sticks and garlic cheese bread were very good and were served in a timely manner. The beverages were refilled timely also. That's the end of the great experience. It was quite busy but the restaurant cleared out quite quickly. Our food however took over an hour to receive. Two orders of spaghetti, a combination plate, fried chicken and small pizza did not seem out of the ordinary. Since the restaurant has cleared out it seemed like an unusually long time to wait. It would not have been so bad but the spaghetti was not completely drained, was watery and the sauce virtually was tasteless. My husband had the spaghetti but with meatballs and had the same issue. His meatballs were tasteless too. This is a family owned restaurant and I believe they have more than one location. This was the downtown Elkhart location. If we are in town we may try them again but definitely order something else and definitely not wait that long for our food. If the food would take anywhere near that long, we would leave. read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - a group of people sitting at a table - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

I tried this place on a recommendation and I am so glad I did. The antipasto salad was great and so was the fettuccine Alfredo. My son had the manicotti and Meatballs and said "it's amazing". Portions are perfect to be dinner tonight as well as lunch tomorrow. read more

So sorry we went! Stood for 5 minutes before anybody acknowledged us. We had 4 people. The place looked busy. We we did get acknowledged we told her there was four and she's got menus walked into the table put the menus down on the table never spoke to us. Sat down and proceeded to wait 20 minutes for waitress to even acknowledge us. When she finally came over to ask what we wanted to drink we told her we were ready to order also she seemed like she was upset by this. We ordered garlic bread as an appetizer plus we have three Waters and one soda. About 15 minutes later she brought two salads and a soup which consisted of lettuce one cherry tomato and two halves of a cucumber. The people at the next table were very upset they got there before we did and we're saying they've been there for 45 minutes and still had not had their food she brought their salads after she brought ours. There was a table behind us and they ordered before we did and they didn't get their salads till way after we got ours. After being there an hour and 20 minutes we finally got our food what a letdown. Two people got fettuccine alfredo it was so bland it was worse than a jar of it could ever be. One person got cheese ravioli and when he told her it was me she questioned him and he did not want to order anymore after sitting there for so long she said oh you guys can just take it home. I ordered an eggplant parmesan, right before a meal came out we got an order of breadsticks not the garlic bread we ordered and when we told her she just kind of shrugged her shoulders and walked off. The eggplant which I was so looking forward to was very thick and heavily breaded and I don't know how you burn it but it was the outsides of all the eggplant were burnt it was dry hardly any sauce. When my husband told her the ravioli was wrong she just looked at him and said well I ordered you she's ravioli, he said well it's not cheese it's meat. She then said oh I'm sorry you can take it home with you. He did not want to order anything else and has we've been there over an hour and a half already. The tables around us were complaining there was a table of people who came in and they sat there longer than we did to get drinks just looking at their menu they were getting up to leave when the waitress approached them. I understand being busy but this was beyond ridiculous. It seems that all the waitresses had a scawl on their face we noticed as we watch them. When I asked for the bill she charged me for the ravioli I said oh I'm not taking that home if you're charging me for it she said oh. I told her well I'm not going to pay for it I won't take it home just take it off the bill she walked away came back and said oh you want me to take that off the bill I said yes it was wrong and it was the kitchen's mistake. I had read some of the reviews before we went. Spoke to somebody after and they told me oh we used to go there all the time but it's not very good anymore. I only give it a 2 because it was a cute old style place. read more

My second visit. Had to upgrade to 4 stars. Super friendly staff and forgot to mention how clean the place is! SPOTLESS! Started with the zucchini strips, Italian wedding soup (awesome) and the stuffed shells (ricotta and spinach) w/meatballs for my entree. The most tender and flavorful meatballs I've ever had. Huge portions, plenty left over for lunch tomorrow. I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Stuffed shells and meatballs. - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

A favorite spot. Make sure you get your reservations, especially on a weekend! Yummy pastas and pizza.

If you're in the area and craving Italian food, this is a fun local restaurant in what used to be the Italian part of town. This is an original building and not fancy- the bar is full of locals who appear to be regulars and the dining area had mostly families and folks enjoying a night out- here's what we ordered- eggplant Parmesan was delicious- each slice was battered and fried topped off with sauce and cheese- I think there were eight of these- I could only eat 3 they were so filling- cane with a side of spaghetti- my nephew had the chicken strips and fries he reported as crispy- and my Brice loved the chicken Alfredo- another had the chicken Parmesan and a meatball and another the shrimp and pasta. Every entre was huge and we all took food home! The onion rings were also crispy and delicious! If you like old school Italian- this is a great option in Elkhart! read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - Chicken strips - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

One of my favorite pizza places in Elkhart. People complaining about slow service have to realize every restaurant is struggling with help right now. Sit down, relax, and have a glass of wine or beer. Recommendations Sausage Pepperoni Onion Jalapeño Pizza Bar Meatballs Chicken Tenders Dinner read more

Love this place! It's our regular spot for lunch. Tammy is so sweet, she's basically family! She even texts me when my favorite soup is in! The food is incredible, I've literally never eaten a bad thing. Great vibes and since they remodeled it looks awesome (well minus the covid drapes but let's pray that's not forever) haha read more

Hole in the wall Italian restaurant. Unfortunately, we have had several less than desirable experiences here. Always hoped it would get better, it did not. Latest experience: 1. No Prime Rob on Prime Rob night. 2. Out of pork chops. 3. Menu advertises 8 hand battered homemade mozzarella sticks for $6, what was received, 5 frozen cheese sticks. When I asked the waitress, she had no clue that they changed it and nothing they could do about it. 3. 60 minute wait after we ordered food. Disappointed that they never could get it together after all these years. With all that being said, food and service were fair, nothing to write home about, but nothing wrong with quality. Doubt we will ever be back. read more

Another great find thanks to Yelp. Got in early for lunch about 11:30am which was right on time. Because when I left about 12:30ish the place was packed. I'll keep this review short, lol. Garlic cheese Bread app with marina sauce....delish! BLT....happiness in mouth. Not the biggest BLT I've ever had, but for $4.95 you get just the right amount with great flavor. Myself and coworker ate for about $22 bucks including sodas. Great prices, tasty grub, laid back atmosphere, good customer service. If I was a local I'd visit them often. read more

Michael’s Italian Restaurant - BLT only $4.95. - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

Service was pretty good & the atmosphere was cute. Our appetizer was burned, but our dinner definitely made up for it! The Alfredo sauce was creamy and plentiful. The pizza was cheesy and delicious. We will definitely be back. read more

See all