Very impressed! My picky wife loved the sauce, crust, and toppings this is now her favorite pizza spot in town. I love that they offer gluten free personal pizzas too. We'll definitely be back! read more

Paesello's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Goshen, Indiana

Roach sited near employees door, left immediately. Wasn't returning to an establishment that does deliver. read more

Pretty good food, like their sandwiches & salads. Always friendly & good service... Like supporting small local businesses.. read more

So my coworker and I where driving around looking for a good lunch and spotted this little place and decided to give it a shot. I really like eating at independently owned mom and pop restaurants because you never know what to expect, we both had a meatball and spaghetti plate plus a salad and a small pizza and I must say it was all very good as it was also all made from scratch which is something you don't see often. Now let's talk about the owner of this establishment, A+ , very kind and friendly and they will go out of their way to make sure your happy, definitely a rarity and a gem this place , worth a visit ! read more

Paesello's Pizzeria - Great and filling lunch ! - Italian Near Me - Goshen, Indiana

Taste was there. Exceptional. Price was a little high but the size of it made it worth it. I hated trying to park in the parking lot. Not easy. I was greeted with a smile. I was treated well. I'd go back! read more

24" pizza totally burned over the whole bottom, totally unacceptable for the price of a pizza that size with 6 toppings. Good pizza once you get past past burn taste. Owner can't take any kind of criticism judging by the few reviews they responded to on Google (including telling a guy they had no record of serving him, and the other one where they went as far as to post timestamps from surveillance video to "educate" a customer on the facts). Guess customer is always right doesn't work there. Considered a return trip hoping ours was a fluke, but reading how aggressive the management gets toward reviews that ANYONE online can read, that won't be happening. read more

They don't answer the phone they don't tell You what holidays they are closed I've been eating here for a long time and trying to get a hold of someone is a task a lot of time besides that their pizzas are good I just wish they had better customer service. Let me add I've had this issue on days they are open where I can't get through. (If you have a website with your hours why not post your holidays on there too?) read more

Delivery was hot... Asked for packets of hot peppers and Parmesan got none.. Driver said they are extra... You can tell Pizza would be great, however I Order's spinach and it is not fresh but frozen ... Should be told since frozen spinach is WAY stronger then fresh...Therefore entire pizza tasted like spinach and very expensive... When called was not sled to be put on hold... Was told "please hold" and bam on hold... read more

Great pizza! Done on time. Highly recommend. There is not a lot of room to dine in, so best to plan for carry-out. Regardless, great pizza! read more

Best pizza around. Cannoli's are wonderful too. Carry out only and limited days open but worth it.

This place is phenomenal! First time here tonight. The food is extremely hot, delicious, fresh and SUPER over portioned. I love it. The pizza was out of this world, easily the best in town. The team and manager was wonderful and very hospitable, they even let us sit in the restaurant eating after close. Everyone should give this place a try. read more

Great place to order for takeout!! They have great pizza and sandwiches!! We especially like the homemade chips!!

Eh first time here staff is very rude. Food is good and so are the prices. They are hardly busy so I don't know what the attitude is for lol

Very good pizza and they are good sized too. If you've ever had Bruno's Pizza, you won't notice a difference. They are shockingly similar, which is a good thing, I think. read more

This is great Italian pizza. You will pay for it but it is authentic, large and made from scratch. More of a carry out spot but there are a few sit down tables in the dinning room read more

This is a great pizza place. It's been our go to place for quite awhile. We can ALWAYS count on a good quality product and it is ALWAYS done in a timely manner. We enjoy the friendly staff and knowing that we are supporting a local business. Keep it up guys!!! read more

Paesello's Pizzeria is a local joint. The pizza was good, and the service was good too. It's a place worth visiting especially if you want to avoid the chain pizza places in Goshen. read more

The food is OK. There's better options like Massimo's in Goshen and Colombos in Elkhart. The owner isn't very friendly and made a rude comment to me the second I walked in the door. read more

We're from out of town and stumbled upon this restaurant. What a gem! The pizza was tasty and the staff was fantastic. We will definitely stop at this restaurant when we pass through again. read more

My wife was craving pizza while we were in the area for RV business. She found this on line and said it was going to be worth the 35 min drive. Yeah - right. No pizza is worth a 35 min. drive....except now Paesello's! This was a true gem. Not one of those rip-offs that start the ingredients 2 inches in from the edge and then start the cheese an inch further in than that. Product out to almost the edge, and EXTRA CHEESE when I ordered extra cheese. The meat and veggies were substantial and the crust was a touch overbaked for my taste - but that's me. I like the dough a little gooier, and I'm sure if I were to return and ask, it would be perfect to my taste. John (the owner?) as also very helpful in giving us alternate directions back to our KOA in Middlebury, and since the pizza was so monstrous, he made sure the remainder was boxed well for our travels. We were the only ones eating in (the place is immaculate), but there was a constant stream of people coming in to pick up their go orders. Worth the trip. read more

While it is not the cheapest pizza place in town, the value was excellent. They are very generous with toppings and cheese. The hand tossed crust is fantastic. When my family orders pizza, this is the go-to place. read more

My family's favorite pizza joint in Goshen. We generally order the Large Combo. The toppings are always generous, the crust always perfect. I can never get enough of their pizza. One time I left my wallet at home and the owner told me to go home and enjoy my pizza and come pay later. Outstanding service and amazing food are hallmarks of what makes Paesello's the best pizza in Goshen. read more

Same pizza as many others in the area, Milano's is probably the best of all these. Columbo's, Bruno's and Paesellos are all the same darn pizza, they are good yes but the exact same recipes for sure. read more

i had all but given up on eating out until Paesello's. Excellent flavor, service and price, period. The Italian roast beef sandwich is flavorful. exactly what I expected WITH au jus. Each dish is served with a side of "fries", untraditionally sliced in circles and deep fried, but not so done that the texture is chip crispy, perfect and perfectly seasoned. The breadsticks are seasoned just right as well. The cheese cake is real cheese cake, dense yet creamy texture and the flavor is outstanding. Highly recommend, will definitely return. Great food for the price! Thank you for an uncommonly good experience. read more

the best pizza is not in new york or chicago.Its right here in goshen,in. and im glad i live three blocks from paesellos!.for family parties i recommend the 24'' pizza(the giant).i order the pizza so much they know me by name! read more