Pizza was terrible crust was like not prep correctly it tasted terrible and we got breadsticks and…read morethey didn't taste same as crust on pizza so I'm sure I should of just took it back but I won't comeback for that garbage

The 20" pie is gargantuan nearly requiring extra help to lift it into my car. Overall, the pie was…read moretasty and a decent value although I don't know what the competition offers since they were closed on the night I ordered. Apparently, takeout only so I was bewildered as to why the joint appeared unkempt and not clean. I also felt the ingredients were marginal so we're losing stars quickly. Way better than the national chains, however, that seduce the masses into believing a $6 cheese-stuffed crust and all that nonsense is pizza. SOS with tomato sauce, IMO. Cold night? Don't wanna cook? Hot pizza got your mouth watering? My "Give 'em a whirl" meter says dial one up for you!

The pizza was very good. I ordered online so I asked for a specific time which was Super Bowl…read moreSunday the only complaint was my Pizza stuff to the bottom of the cardboard.

Their pizzas are good size, but very pricey. This is my…read moresecond pizza I got from Panther Pizza, and the crust on both pizzas wasn't done. I ordered a large pepperoni with 4 different toppings. There was only 3 pepperoni on the pizza. They put way to much sauce on it, couldn't even taste the cheese. I'm a pizza lover, and couldn't tolerate this pizza!! I believe their oven isn't working properly. I wouldn't recommend this pizza place, unless you like undone crust and way to much sauce on your pizza.

I've ordered pizza here many times and then tried the pasta. Everything is made well, portion size…read moreis adequate, ingredients taste fresh. I've yet to be disappointed.

My wife and I are big fans of Halls Kitchen's pizza. Today, I decided to try their Turkey Club…read moresandwich. Their app showed the sandwich with stripes of bacon and tomato slices. It looked very appetizing. Unfortunately, when I opened the box, the sandwich looked nothing like the picture. The bacon was in bits that looked more like diced ham than bacon. The tomatoes were also diced instead of the full slices shown. Overall, both the taste and presentation was about average. As I was eating, I kept thinking the sandwich reminded me of what I would pick up at a gas station. The service was fast but a number of tables were dirty and no one came out to clean them while I was dining. Unfortunately. This visit was nothing special and what I received did not match what was advertised.

The food is unforgettable--but the friendly people who work there make the experience even better.read more

My boyfriend ordered a pizza late night on Christmas Eve, I was so grateful they were open. We…read morecarried out and the pizza was piping hot even after we got home. The crust is almost like a cracker, nice and thin and crispy. It was very cheesy which I also enjoyed. Circular pizza pie with square cut slices. The only thing I didn't love was their pizza sauce. It's a bit more acidic and sweet and tangy than I'd like. Not my favorite, but also not bad!

Great pizza and friendly staff. We've been ordering pizza from Jimtown Pizza for about two years…read morenow and have always enjoyed it. We order sausage and mushrooms on one pizza and pepperoni and sausage on the other. It's consistently good!

Consistently amazing! The food is great and the staff is always friendly. Highly recommend!read more

Perhaps not the best in the area or even the best on the strip, but better than most food chains…read morefor the area. I had a hand tossed pepperoni extreme which was full of oil, a thin crust bacon and mushroom with less oil, their Buffalo wings with ranch and their famous breadsticks with cheese sauce. The pepperoni extreme pizza had far too much oil for my taste, but the flavors were very much on point. There was some spice along with cheese that didn't quite want to stay on the pizza when I went to separate my slices. The thin crust bacon and sausage pizza had less oil and a wonderful crust with the same cheese situation as the other pizza. I imagine either pizza would be great for a party with alcohol. That's not to say it wasn't delicious because it was, but when it comes to pizza I have to be a hundred percent honest. The wings were less crispy than I prefer, but with a flavorful explosion. The meat also falls off the bone easily which is a plus for sensitive teeth situations. I must say flavor is the one thing these people are doing right over here. I just hope your stomach is young enough to handle it. Next I had their famous bread sticks with cold cheese sauce. The cheese was nothing to brag about, but the breadstick had that brick oven flavor that many people enjoy. I'm not sure if it was a combination of oils, but once I started eating my first breadstick, my stomach began to rebel, as if to say I had done something seriously wrong. I would like to see what else this place has to offer and a very much suggest visiting this establishment, but I must also add that there are other options for those of you with a sensitive stomach.

Great pizza! Toppings just right, and can be a small enough pizza that everyone can get their own…read more Thin crust (crispy) or traditional hand tossed. I've learned they use Grande brand cheese which is top of the line fresh soft mozzarella. Perfect for pizzas and reheats next day great. They have a great variety of options for toppings and predesigned pizzas. We just found this place a week ago, and have been 3 times! Addicting, plus they are quick to cook, and even a text when your pizza goes into the oven! Fun and helps with pickup orders.

I have previously left a great review a couple of years ago. Hadn't ordered from them for a while…read moredue to the very long wait times. Today, I decided that I wanted something different and had a drive until I was back in town, so it would be fine to have a longer wait time for pick up. I don't see why it takes 45 minutes to make a regular crust pizza with one topping, but at least they let you know ahead of time. My issue today was that I also ordered a sandwich. I picked up my food as the pizza was coming out of the oven, in which I had to wait on.. and the whole time my sandwich was setting there boxed up. It had been boxed up for quite some time. The sandwich was cold, and the pizza was bland and didn't have the extra sauce that I paid for. It's just very bland pizza. The crust is flavorless, and it seems like the cheese is too. The sandwich would have been good if it was hot and the oil hadn't soaked into the bread by the time my pizza was ready. Let me also add, that it's a pretty pricey pizza. So... high cost, long wait times, and meh flavor.

We have never been here before but when visiting Plymouth we stopped in to try the pizza…read more First the good, it was quick and the pie had plenty of cheese. The toppings were covered with cheese so I couldn't see the quality or quantity. The pie crust was too thick and chewy for our taste. The price for a 14 inch, 2 topping pizza was twenty dollars. Not exactly a bargain. We were expecting more.

Barnaby's has the best pizza in town! And fast, friendly service. The pizza has fresh and delicious…read moretoppings. They also off er sandwiches. The staff is always nice and polite.

I can't tell you how nostalgic a trip to Barnaby's is for me . They have that true Chicago taste…read moreItalian sausage . The crust is a real crust . The sauce is pizza sauce not too sweet . And the cheese , nothing gets that good brown going like that .i miss my calumet city days but barnabys can safely transport you to 1977 . Nothing still around beats it .sorry aunt lukie ( Gino's cc ) you're still no.1 ! Oh and get a salad , don't be cheap paisan . Tell em Goomba sent ya ,