We visited with my wife's family in Elkhart Indiana and they decided on pizza. Antonio's is their go to. We We had 3 large pizzas with different toppings of which I had the pepperoni. The crust was exactly how I like it, crisp and dark. The sauce had a tang to it and a wonderful flavor. It was also plentiful and not over sauced. The cheese was also perfectly done and slightly browned in places. They cut it into wedges of which I had 4 pieces. Normally I wouldn't have eaten them hat much but I couldn't stop. I wish that I had taken photos but it disappeared so quickly with 8 of us chowing down on it. J would drive miles for this pizza and next time I want to add sausage with the pepperoni. Don't miss this one! read more

When I made my first review, I guess I wasn't feeling that good and I took it out on Antonio's pizza. They have excellent food and if you really want a great pizza, try their stuffed pizza it is dynamite! read more

We came on a Friday and it was packed... So if you come then, expect a wait... But the wait is worth it. We tri led the Chicago pizza and it did not disappoint. The service was great too. read more

We arrived at the dinner rush time. The parking lot was almost full. We were seated very shortly after arriving. The staff was accommodating and friendly. Our server brought us our drinks immediately and gave us plenty of time to look through the menu and answered all of our questions concerning the menu. We never felt as though we were being rushed into ordering. My meal was okay. The bolognese sauce was delicious. I understand that most people prefer their pasta al dente and would agree that is the way it should be cooked. Not me. It's too chewy for me and I didn't enjoy it. My husband said his meal was good, but there were some elements of it he did not like. The sauce for his pasta dish was satisfactory. The Italian sausage was excellent and authentic. The problem with the dish was the vegetables. The tomatoes, green peppers, and onions were by his account undercooked. As for his drink, he was served what they called a "cola". It wasn't Coca-Cola, it wasn't Pepsi-Cola, or any type of cola his taste buds could recognize. If there is a next time, he will stick with water. We asked for bread and it never arrived. We enjoyed our desserts. The owner makes an effort to speak with the patrons to assure that they are taken care of. read more

We passed by this place and it was packed. So I made sure to mark it down for another time. We ended up going with some friends and ordered two award winning pizza's, and two pasta dishes. The service was fast and the server was friendly. The pizzas were delicious. I can see why they won awards. However the pasta dish was not at the same level. There was nothing bad about it, just wasn't the best pasta we've had. Overall I enjoyed our time and wed return for the pizza! read more

See all

It's the BEST food in town! We go at every celebratory occasion and have it at least once a month. We recommend: PIZZZAS: The Gem The Vegas The Stallion APPETIZERS: The cheesesticks Baratta read more

Antonios - Celebrating Valentitines Day 2025 at Antonio's - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

This place was amazing! We came here with a pretty big group after a Notre Dame football game. We had a great dinner. We started with the burrata and the not knots and we could not get enough. We absolutely loved how fresh everything tasted, especially the tomato sauce. We all got all sorts of different entrees, but the ones I got to try were the Vegas Fortuna pizza and the Calabrese pizza. These were exceptional. They are award-winning for a reason. Every other entree at the table looked amazing as well, and everyone left happy and with full bellies. Overall amazing experience. Nice cozy atmosphere with great staff and even better food. Highly recommend! read more

Just had my visit to Antonio's and it was excellent! The appetizers calamari, burrata, and spinach artichoke were the stars. Angel hair with chicken and the pizza were tasty. Service was good, and I'll definitely return for the appetizers! read more

Antonios - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

After three years since my first visit to Antonio's where I had a rough encounter I can say that this one was exponentially better. Service was fast and attentive. My husband and I shared bread and oil, spinach and artichoke dip for our appetizer, and a 10" stuffed pizza with bacon, pepperoni, and Italian sausage. The food was very good. The appetizer was a big which I'll keep in mind for the next time I dine in. It does take about 30 mins for the stuffed pizza to be made. The restaurant itself had a nice feel to it. It wasn't busy and it quiet. I really liked the grapes decoration and the feel as if I was walking in Italy. read more

Antonios - Spinach and artichoke dip - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

We had a bit of a rocky start at Antonio's with a delay getting seated, but what really stood out was how the team turned the entire experience around. Jack, the manager, went above and beyond to make things right. He was attentive, genuine, and clearly cared about making sure we felt valued as customers. His effort didn't go unnoticed and completely shifted the tone of our evening. Our banquet hall waitress (I wish I remembered her name!) was equally impressive, she was kind, attentive, and stayed on top of everything throughout the meal. You could tell she truly cared about giving us a great experience. On top of the great service, the food was amazing, everything we had was delicious and well worth the visit. What started off frustrating ended up being a really enjoyable night thanks to their outstanding service and commitment to making things right. That level of care goes a long way, and it's the reason we'll definitely be back. read more

This was awesome!!! The cheeeesesticks were amazing!!! The pizza was incredible and the homemade pistachio cheesecake was to die for!!! Desiree was our waitress and she was so good to us!!! Amazing Amazing!!!!!! read more

Great food and atmosphere! We love the pizza! We've been here for parties as well and it's always been wonderful!

Bit pricey but ahhhhamazing food!! It's worth your money! We had deep dish pizza and tons of pasta dishes, and we all had to had samples of each others food! It was ridiculously good! Really takes you to Italy atmosphere with the food and environment!! The owner is charming!!! read more

Ordered the lasagna and a side of a sausage link for take out. It was really good. I was surprised how busy it was. The parking lot was nearly full. Luckily they had designated spaces for carry out customers. I would definitely repeat! read more

This felt like a hidden gem. It had a comfortable ambience. It was my first time, and I overdid it on the bread. I ordered the Pope's chicken with the potatoes and green beans. It was AMAZING! The potatoes were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. The chicken was tender, but the sauce was what gave this dish an A++. Next time I'm going to try some pizza. read more

This was my wife and I's first time here and we we very impressed. The mozzarella sticks were on steroids and the pizza we had "The Italian Stallion" had won several 1st place awards. Well deserved. Our server was awesome, and attentive, and helped us with our order. The ambiance was nice and relaxed. Open yet cozy. Dinner salad for two, mozzarella sticks, diet soda, hard cider and 14" killer pepperoni and other meat pizza; under $60.00. We will be back to try more. read more

Antonios - Mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

AUTHENTIC...ITALIAN...CUISINE Who would have thought such a GEM of a place if located in Elkhart, Indiana? This family owned restaurant makes you feel right at home - treating you like you are one of their own. Upon arriving, the parking lot was completely full so you know it must be the spot. We got a table near the bar and immediately waited on and ordered cocktails to start. We ordered the burrata, fried calamari, and mozzarella sticks for our antipasto. All three dishes were delicious and the perfect way to kick-off our meal. Next came the main courses, one person in my party ordered the Soccotini pasta and it literally came out sizzling. The wine order was placed for the meal and we ate the pizza below. Vegas Fortuna Pizza: 72-hour hand-stretched artisan dough, pomodoro sauce, housemade Italian sausage and hot honey sausage, topped with cup-and-char pepperoni and mozzarella blend I cannot say enough about how authentic these made from scratch meals tasted. I literally was transported back to Italy and it makes me want to book another trip. The owner, Paul, came out and spoke to us after our meal to make sure we were satisfied. We are so excited to make this a part of our annual holiday visit every year! See you next December :) read more

See all

The pizza is always a hit. The salad was fantastic too. Love grabbing this on the way home on a Friday. Highly recommend.

Been hearing radio ads for this place for awhile. I was in the area a few days ago and finally was able to try it out and It did not disappoint! I tried the not knots, chicken Alfredo, popes chicken, and chicken parm. The popes chicken and potatoes were amazing. Alfredo was on point. Not knots, delicious! The chicken parm was great too but the other dishes blew it away in my opinion. Can't wait to go back and try their pizza! read more

Love this restaurant. The dining only pizzas never disappoint. Nicely balanced and spicy! Pastas are great. The house salad is tasty and a nice opener. The seasonal salad inspired me for Christmas. A good red and green with beets and cranberries, spring mix and kale and chard. I love to use a bitter green with sweet highlights. Service is always friendly, attentive and informed. read more

The food was delicious, they don't take reservations so we had to wait for half an hour before we were seated, but it was worth the wait!

This is such a great place for so many reasons! The service is great, the food is great, the atmosphere is great, and it's VERY popular, so you might wait for a table regardless of the time. It's worth it though. The pizza is fantastic, but so are the salads and pasta dishes. The Pope's Chicken is so good too. Just come here, you will enjoy it too. read more

We've been here before. Had a good experience then. An average experience this past weekend. First off, their website says no reservations. Yet we get there and they are taking reservations. Antonio's is popular. Very popular. A steady stream of diners were filing in while we were there. Server was polite though invisible at times. That said we didn't have to ask for refills. We started with the calamari. Probably should've skipped it. Did not seem fresh. Very rubbery. Bland breading. Not hot, just warm. Did not finish that. My wife ordered eggplant parm and said it was good. Served with pasta and sauce. The sauce was thick and stuck ti the pasta like it should. She said it lacked salt though. Very bland in that regard. I ordered the championship Fortuna pizza. It was okay. Wasn't blown away. I really like the spicy honey sausage on it. That topping is a home run. Maybe we will come back. Not ruling it out. Just not a definite at this point. read more

Not sure how this amazing restaurant flew under my radar!!! We have been to the area with our RV's, for the past 9 years and I'm so disappointed that I haven't had the opportunity to eat here for the past nine years! This is the best pizza I've EVER had! Pinsas rosemary pizza (low gluten) was perfect! Started with the arugula salad and was shocked at the size so pretty happy that we ordered one to share instead of trying to eat it and then pizza. Ended up taking half the pizza home and ruminated about eating it all day long! Service was outstanding and wine recommendation was perfect! So much so that we are headed there tomorrow and hopefully we'll get the same waitress. Now I feel horrible that I forgot her name because she was great. Ambiance was very comfortable and decor made the experience all the more. Until tomorrow! read more

Antonios - Pinsas menu - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

The house salad was plenty for 2 , the pizza is delicious and the service is fast and the place is clean and decorated like an old fashioned Italian restaurant! It's a great place to! read more

In my top 3 of local pizza. Award winning, great sauce. Great Italian dishes as well. We enjoy sitting at the bar.

Absolutely outstanding! You can tell this is the real deal when it comes to Italian food! Very cool to see the owner in the kitchen with the other chefs getting his hands dirty! Atmosphere is romantic, yet light hearted! We had 4 apps and 4 pies and not a single item disappointed! Will definitely make the 2hr trip for it again! read more

Antonios - Late family Christmas with pies - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

I'm not sure if we were here on a bad day or what but the pizza was terrible, i almost didn't try it as all I could smell was yeast as I picked it up. I took a bite and spit it out. All I could taste was yeast. So sad as they have such great reviews. But they should be able to tell their doughs not good. Won't be back but hopefully others have better luck. read more

I have been wanting to try Antonio's for a while and just couldn't seem to get there ... so tonight was the night and it did not disappoint. My daughter had the penne with vodka sauce which was delicious. We started with the mozzarella sticks and they were crispy without being over breaded. My husband and I got the thin crust pizza which was amazing! I not wait as long to go back as I did to try it out! read more

Different city, every week. So hard to find small gems like Antonio's. Thanks Yelp! I found it. And when I did, my expectations started to climb. Got a bit nostalgic when I saw the "Established in 1979" sign. The year I graduated high school. Nostalic and a bit old. Different city, every week. So hard to find small gems like Antonio's. Thanks Yelp! I found it. And when I did, my expectations started to climb. Got a bit nostalgic when I saw the "Established in 1979" sign. The year I graduated high school. Nostalic and a bit old... The restaurant! Walking in I was greeted by a big smile and taken straight to an open table! The place is small and elegant I expected to wait a while. My server greeted me with the same welcoming feeling as our hostess. Knew I was in the right place! Drink? Their complex and delicious Aged Manhattan. Signature drink and it shows! The Starter? Perfectly roasted garlic bulbs mixed tableside with parmesan and olive oil and a full crusty roll of bread. Good for the blood pressure, good for the tongue! Awesome. The Meal? More than I could finish. A huge portion of Eggplant parmesan on perfect pasta. Eggplant cooked through without being soggy. Pasta done right. Only two ways right mom? Sauce could have used a bit more punch. but still delicious! Thank you Antonio's! read more

Antonios - Roasted Garlic - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

Hidden gem! We can't help but come at least once a week! Everything on the menu is amazing, never get sick of eating here! All the staff are just as great as their food! Wish would've found this place sooner! Love love love it!!!!! read more

This place is by far the best Italian restaurant in Elkhart. When we pulled in after work the parking lot was full of cars. It was a 20 minute wait but we were informed that there were two seats at the bar out back if we wanted them. We decided to go for it. Great decision. We started off with a couple of cocktails which were served up quick. The bartender was phenomenal. Given that the restaurant was packed wall to wall, she was extremely attentive. Funny, too. I had the chicken tortellini soup. I could have eaten that by itself. It was a giant bowl. Seasoned perfectly. Huge pulled chicken pieces and tortellini. I also had the pasta ala carte. Soccotini with marinara sauce and mushrooms. It was superb. Perfectly seasoned. The soccotini was stuffed with Italian sausage. Large portions. I took it home for lunch the next day. The food, service and ambiance of Antonio's was like eating at home with my family and friends. Everyone knew each other. My buddy had lasagna which he raved about. He also took home leftovers for lunch the next day. We decided then and there that we would back to try the award winning pizza. I can't say enough good things about Antonio's. When you travel for work it is nice to find a jewel out there wandering around. Peace and love! read more

Great food and service. Very popular place for good reason! Decent vino selection and the lobster bisque was one of the best I've ever had. read more

Antonios - Library room. Pinsa was on point and the pasta was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Family owned restaurant that's a definite "go to" if you're wanting Italian food! They add seasonal items frequently to keep the menu fresh and many of the ingredients are straight from their own garden. I've been a customer for many years (20+) and I still look forward to dining at Antonio's because I know that my meal will be delicious and you can't beat the quality of the food. I highly recommend if you happen to be in town. read more

I don't have enough good things to say! It was packed, but the food and service were not impacted. Garlic knots are amazing. Mozzarella sticks delicious. Salad. Pasta. Pizza. Someone from our party got it all and everyone enjoyed their meal. We left fat and happy. Waitress was friendly and did a great job with our big table! read more

Your pizza is really superb, I hope you guys will always be around, the service I had on 3/22/23 was really great, I just picked up the pizza but I have to say all the staff was so sweet and courteous!! Thank you Antonio's for all that you do, keep up the great work!!! read more

Great pasta & pizza. Red wine choices are really good too . Service is good especially with them being so busy.

Read so much about how this place is involved in world pizza contests and makes a great pizza, so I gave it a try. Their normal pizza crust is very doughy with no crunch - i guess i should have ordered thin crust. The sauce is a bit bland, i find myself having to add seasoning on the pizza to make it enjoyable. The cheese is good. Not a great pizza imo, kind of disappointing - Barnaby's, Oliva's, and Polito's are definitely a step above. Maybe the thin crust is better? read more

I absolutely love this place! Amazing food and service! I was in town for 2 weeks on a business trip and I dined here 4 times before leaving town. read more

OUTSTANDING. We came in late after a horrendous ND loss, and this made a terrible day so much better. We had the lasagna, vodka rigatoni, sausage soccotini, meatballs, traditional pizza, and stuffed pizza. Everyone loved their food, and we took home leftovers. Great atmosphere. Drinks were great, too. read more