Pros: * Michaelangelo's Little Italy is one of the few solid choices for satisfactory sit-down meals around the Bronx Botanical Gardens. If you're commuting by subway from outside the Bronx. better to come here when the weather is nice because it's a 15-20 minute walk from train station and another 15-20 to the Gardens. * Lovely outdoor backyard space that is great for large groups or parties. * Huge portions served with fresh ingredients. We were pleased with our dishes of Linguini Vongole (manila clams sautéed with a garlic olive oil and white wine sauce), Michaelangelo's Seafood Special (with shrimp and squid) and Fettuccini Alfredo Fettuccini Pasta (with chicken, cream sauce finished with parmigiano). With such immense, leftovers turned into another meal! * Heated and soft starter bread with delicious tomato olive oil sauce * Service was great Cons: * They seated us at a big table where water would not stop dripping onto my boyfriend until we resorted to moving tables...hope they fix that ceiling leak! With entree and coffee total came to $36 including tax and tip. read more

See all

Arthur Ave has become a tourist spot and a hangout for Fordham students. This place is no exception however, the food is pretty good and the service is really on point. When you go inside you want to stay and eat they take you to the back that is like a private oasis you'd never expect. Start with the stuffed mushrooms they are pretty damn good. The drinks are pretty good as well, the shark something is awesome. I had the lobster Ravioli and I was not impressed with that. Go with the penne alla vodka. The bread and dipping sauce is by far some of the best. I will be coming back to try more things on the menu. read more

Michaelangelo's - Bread and dipping sauce - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

I'm not sure what to say. This is what if the best meals I had in a long time. The pasta was freshly made and perfectly prepared. That tomato sauce would taste good off of a car tire. Cannot get enough of this food. Service was great and friendly and can't say enough about the food. Highly recommend the manicotti. A definite must try read more

Michaelangelo's - Freshly made Manicotti, amazing - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Trying to find a new pizza place to order from and this place is a strong contender. We ordered the Margarita A La Petrit and it's really good. Will order again read more

Michaelangelo's - Margarita A La Petrit - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

Come for the ambiance, stay for the food. Seriously the back porch is so cool. It feels as though your sitting in a tropical jungle. However the cuisine is quintessential home cooked Italian dishes (that are out of this world BTW)! There wasn't a single thing on the menu I didn't enjoy. Penne vodka, MichaelAngelo's Fettuccine, and the pizza, our pie was recommended off the menu by the waiter (four cheese minus pesto add Gorgonzola, arugula, and prosciutto). I'm drooling thinking about it now. Only slight ding may be the wine by the glass, but it's wine?! You're there to eat anyway! read more

See all

Casual and funky. I loved the "Old Fashioned" pizza (a Margarita pizza with more veggies). But the lemon sorbet (served inside a lemon) was the best I've ever had. read more

We just had dinner at Michaelangelo's and it was FABULOUS!! My child is a freshman at Fordham and we're still exploring Arthur Ave. The food was incredible - we had a pizza, pesto pasta, eggplant parmesan, and lasagna. The servings were large & we then treated ourselves to two tasty desserts. Everything was delicious. But our server, AJ, was incredible, too. She was running to cover extra tables as they were understaffed on an incredibly busy Family Weekend night. But she did so with humor & grace. She was professional and kind and took care of us, even when so many guests were seated at once. Her warmth and kindness will bring us back during future Fordham visits!! Thanks for a memorable meal!! read more

Food = amazing. Let's be honest, how often can you cut your chicken with your fork?! My chicken was so perfectly cooked that I didn't even need to use my knife! Good sized portion for a fair price. However, I cannot give it 5 stars because the service was subpar. Took a while for us to even find our waiter as well as pay (had to actually call him over to grab the bill with payment). I would come back but hope for better service next time! read more

See all

I was part of a very large group that dined at Michaelangelo's Saturday October 28th, 2023. The person who made our reservation did so nearly two months in advance as it was Family Weekend at Fordham University and we knew from past experience how crowded restaurants are that weekend. The restaurant contacted her early in the week to request that we go with a "Family style" menu that would provide us with two appetizers, one salad, two pastas and two entrees served family style. The restaurant was concerned that due to the size of large reservations that night the kitchen would be better able to handle the evening if we went this route. We agreed and made selections from the limited selections offered. It was frustrating to be told that we were subject to this limited prix fix meal days ahead of our reservation, but we thought it would make the evening go smoothly. They priced this dinner at $45/person. Our reservation was for 5 pm and our entire party was at the restaurant for that time. We were promptly seated. The service was slow to start, but quickly became painfully slow. Drinks took at least 20 minutes , bread for the table 10 minutes later, and the appetizer of calamari and a tomato/mozzarella dish came out 20 minutes after that. And then we waited until 6:20 when I finally asked the woman who appeared to be the dining room manager where our food was. Her response was argumentative to say the very least. When I pointed out that another group directly next to us (who were seated at the exact same time) was already on their entree (three courses ahead of us) she said they are a much smaller group. I asked how many and she said 17...we were 21? Not one apology, but an annoyed response of "your food is coming". And then within 10 minutes the food did come out, one course right after another: caesar salad, pasta with bolognese and pasta with broccoli and spinach, chicken parmigiana and chicken francese. Not only was the food of a very basic quality, it was all food that was clearly very easy to prepare in advance. The chicken was barely warm, which was a clear indication that it was definitely made ahead and didn't even make its way to the oven long enough to be served hot.It was not flavorful and relatively dry. They did serve steamed vegetables and potatoes with the chicken dishes that were nicely cooked and they were actually hot. What really prompted me to write this review was the fact that each place setting was a salad plate and that plate served for your bread, AND appetizer, AND salad, AND pasta, AND entree! I asked one of the waiters if we could have clean plates right before the pasta came out and I watched as a server carried plates over only to be stopped by the DR manager who clearly instructed him to not replace our plates. I think if we had had a dessert as part of this menu we would have eaten it off of those same plates! The DR manager did come over to me when the chicken came out to ask "How was the food? Wasn't it worth waiting for?" I looked at her and gave a very quiet "not really. It was very OK, and in fact the chicken wasn't even hot." Full disclaimer: I am Italian American. I am not a fan of the generic "Italian food" that make its way onto the menu of most Italian food establishments. That being said, If you are going to make Chicken Parmigiana, please don't fry an unseasoned, unbreaded cutlet slathered in tasteless marinara sauce and top it with mozzarella and ask me if that is food that is worth waiting for. All of the food we were served that night was of that same quality. I know restaurants are having a hard time: food costs, staff shortages, etc. What I would like the food industry to know is that those excuses don't make it ok to serve sub par food with slow service. Figure out some other way to serve customers a nice meal: smaller portions, fewer diners, a prix fix that works. There are restaurants who are getting it right. But if it happens that a restaurant gets caught off guard and a group of 21 diners is legitimately unsatisfied, at the very least apologize and ask for patience. You know what makes poor quality food and slow service worse, an argumentative manager. read more

Our server- Ece- made our experience very uncomfortable. Aside from not being very attentive- she cursed out her coworker within a few feet of my family with small children. The food was good but was eclipsed with the bad experience. We won't be back. Hopefully this server could be taught some manners or find another job read more

Ive been here once before with my wife and we had an awesome lunch. However today we sat down and our waiter was horrible. The busboy was great. read more

See all

last time ordering dinner take out. Two weeks ago we ordered an amazing anchovy pizza. This pizza had the best crust ever. Today we decided to order dinner entrees - one chicken, one veal. The only part of the meal that was edible were the veggies that accompanied the meat. I don't know if the meat was cooked from frozen or boiled then prepared for our order but the texture was rubbery. Not at all what you would expect from a restaurant with 4+ star rating on yelp. To make matter worse when we called the hostess said she was too busy to handle this call, placed us on hold and after 5 or 6 minutes the line disconnected. It's really disappointing read more

Found this place on Yelp after a long day At re botanical garden. Dropped in around 3:30 PM on a Sunday and they were pretty empty. The service was nice and got our situated pretty fast. We were pretty exhausted and hungry so it could've been a recipe for disaster but we were greatly pleased by the ambience, quality of food, and service. I got the rigatoni bolognese which I thought was great. I also tried the buffalochicken personal pizza which by the way is a good decent size. I personally would get it to share with another friend. My friend had the white wine clam linguine which he said was yummy. Another friend had the chicken Marsala but complained that the sauce was a little too salty. My other friend also got the old fashioned pizza but didn't enjoy it too much. The restaurant in the back is huge and a cool chill spot. Even though it was chilly outside it was nice and toasty in the back. read more

See all

We had a high school reunion in June '22 here. They did a great job accommodating our group of about 60 people! Food was very nice served family style. Started with rolled eggplant, fried calamari, some rigatoni then veal, chicken and salmon . Our group had a special sheet cake for desert. Atmosphere was comfortable and accommodating. Excellent service and party was fun. Other customers were also being served but we hardly noticed. Street parking is difficult so get there early. Many wonderful shops within a couple of blocks ENJOY! read more

The pizza is just okay, the dough, nothing special, just a regular $1 slice pizza dough, the toppings very regular, overall it does not worth it, nothing special about their pizza and overpriced for the quality, expected something better, especially with the claim it is an Italian cuisine, unfortunately none The white cheese pizza was supposed to have garlic flavor and some olive oil on it, nothing and taste like an old cheese sandwich. The portions are okay, but does not worth 1/4 the price for the taste, overrated even for 1 star I would never order from there again read more

Always a must go when we are in the bronx. The service is always excellent even on the busy Friday and Saturday nights. Its a nice, family friendly location for dinner. Get their house Alfredo! read more

This is an excellent restaurant for a quick dinner or a party. The food is very good and the staff does a great job. I go to Arthur Ave a lot and this restaurant ranks with the best of them. read more

Had a high school class reunion. About 60 attendees. Perfect space. Attractive room. Staff is fabulous. Great service, friendly, responsive, on point. Food was family style l. All good. Parking in little Italy is notoriously tight. Leave time to snag a spot. My wife and I will be back! read more

I'm so in love with Michelangelo's of Little Italy! There are lots of great Italian restaurants in this area! Last week, me and my boyfriend came here. I chose this restaurant based on the great reviews that I read on Yelp. I came here last Friday, early evening. On the outside, the establishment looks small; due to the fact that the place itself is a house that was converted into a both fancy but casual eatery at the same time. As soon as we entered, we were greeted by a very polite waiter. Carlos caught up with the accent; referring to it as French. At the front, there is a small but cozy seating area with a wine bar. The rest of the action happens in the backyard! It's beautifully but simply decorated. The patio itself has been conditioned with roofing, so it can be enjoyed all year round. It has simple ornamental plants and flowers, along with night lights hanging above. Both great music and ambiance complimented one another; with a really cool Italian old school vibe. Frank Sinatra songs played in the background. This place attracts an after work crowd for happy hour. I saw patrons enjoying artisinal pizza, either with a glass of wine or beer. The pizzas were served rustic-style, on wood cutting boards. It also has a bar area. The food and wine menu are quite simple. Coincidentally, Blue Moon was having a promotion that evening, and our nice, tall glasses of beer, were free! Courtesy of the house! The complimentary garlic bread was brought to our table. The dipping sauce for the garlic bread is a combination of extra virgin olive oil, that was heavily laced with marinara sauce. My boyfriend ordered penne pasta a la vodka, I ordered the classic chicken marsala with a side of linguine pasta. Both were portioned to perfect size and it was cooked and seasoned beautifully. The marsala sauce was excellent for dipping the garlic bread! It has the perfect consistency, and I also loved the tender mushrooms. The best part of this wonderful experience, was the house salad. Although it was a simple side dish, all its ingredients were incredibly fresh. Nicely seasoned with its delicious balsamic vinaigrette. I was thankful that the salad plate was big enough for the two of us to share. We were both really satisfied with our meal. Next time, we will leave room for dessert, and of course, I will have a glass of wine! I highly recommend this restaurant for any occasion. I can't wait to come back when the weather gets warmer! read more

See all

So tasty. Service was good. Drinks are strong. Service is prompt. Highly recommended if you like Italian food!

Outdoor patio is definitely a nice ambience. Food and drinks were nothing out of this world (still satisfactory with respect to simple platters like chicken parmigiana). read more

A group of 7 of us arrived on a Friday evening for dinner. Upon arrival we were immediately seated although we arrived early for our 8:30pm reservation. We ordered a few appetizers to share which were yummy ( baked clams, calamari & etc). For our entrees we each ordered different things; some people found their food ok like it was missing seasoning, two people that ordered shrimps items felt that it was not fresh & a Ceaser salad was beyond seasoned which made it salty. The place was quiet empty for a nice Friday evening. The staff was attentive although when we ordered a second round of drinks it seemed like they definitely forgot about it because we waited very long & had to reorder our drinks. In general, this is a nice family friendly spot with ok Italian food. read more

See all

Awesome staff and amazing food!! I love everything there but Seafood pasta is my fav of all read more

Michaelangelo's - Skirt steak - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

Obsessed with this lovely restaurant, specially the outdoor. The food is great, I bring some of my favorite clients here, it's a nice setting to have a lovely time. Good is great, good portions. The staff is really friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend this restaurant. I normally have the pear salad, it's soooo delicious. And the pizza as well, I also love their cheese platters. read more

Michaelangelo's - Pear salad - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

Great back room for a reunion or big family gathering. Friendly, inviting, fun!

Don't let the little store front fool you, walk up the ramp in the back..what a beautiful place! Garden Terra e room with plants and twinkly light, a beautiful bar area, a menu to die for, handsome waiters dressed well and with polite and respectful attitudes. This is why I go out for dinner; I'm a fairly good cook myself, so it's all in the details for me. Upper level and wine cellar party rooms available too. Only kicking myself for walking by about a 100 times and not going in. Delicious!!!! read more

My girlfriend and I went for dinner on a Saturday evening. Shrimp scampi and linguine with pasta and red sauce were delicious. Nice place and very professional service. Will definitely come back again! read more

We came here for @ happy hour. Other ways sangria thing was really good I had two I ordered from Mario was really good as well and the fry rositto is rich and creamy cocktail shrimp as good as well with comes with my favorite a arugula read more

Michaelangelo's - What's the name of this white sangria happy hour half price - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

5 Stars; 5 I's ;-) Impressive service* Impeccable salad Incredible steak I loved the vino It was grrreat! * (party of 12) read more

Michaelangelo's - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

I loved it...great service...food...everything was wonderful...drinks and desserts are a must I was very satisfied...coming back soon read more

Michaelangelo's - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

Probably one the best Italian restaurants in the Bronx. Service is great which is a plus for me I came for a late lunch early dinner. But I was with my newborn son It is a great relaxing environment Our appetizer was great and came in a fashionable time. Our main course melted in the mouth read more

Michaelangelo's - Chicken franchise and lasagna. - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Simple put..delicious food, good happy hour deals and beautiful ambiance Basically everything you could ask for lol read more

Tasteless! Service is good. Bread with tomato-olive oil dipping sauce is really good. Everything else was tasteless! Margarita pizza and chicken Michael Angelo. Go elsewhere. read more

Disappointing, especially for the price! Took a chance on a new restaurant while trying to support my community during covid-19. Vegetables were old and soggy tasting. Unfortunately I won't be back. read more

Such a great spot. Ate in their garden in back of the restaurant, and it was such a pretty spot. The guests were all social distanced and I felt very comfortable in the space. The food was great - had a personal pizza. Their tiramisu was great too! I would definitely go back. read more

Amazing place and the food is delicious as well as their sangría. I try to go there every time I can after work to have dinner. Ther patio is very beautiful and the staff is very friendly. read more

Michaelangelo's - Chicken Caesar Salad - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

The food is insanely good. Everything is so tasty and fresh. No wait and absolutely quick. Great service. read more

the mussels were not fresh, the sauce was ok. The pizza was just bad: watery, raw dough, plastic-like cheese, no fresh ingredients (canned mushrooms and artichokes). Service was ok, though they advertised happy hour at the door, to later say it was only applicable to some tables by the bar...we were the only people there, yet we weren't seated in the happy hour tables(three plants separated us from them). some girls arrived and they had to change table 3 times until they were in the exact spot where they could enjoy happy hour read more

Michaelangelo's - Four season pizza. All those olives on that piece only. - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York

During this covid19 pandemic I was away from home and missed the great eateries in the bronx. As soon as I returned I decided to order in. I had lunch at Michaelangelo's once and decided to order from there. I ordered a Ribeye steak with veggies and spaghetti, chicken francese, and Michaelangelos alfredo cream sauce pasta. It was amazing. My food came within 30 minutes. It was hot and cooked to perfection. the steak was excellent! They followed every direction I gave. My portions were BIG. I was so satisfied I ordered again the next day. The second day I ordered they forgot one of my dishes. I called the restaurant and they brought me the dish within 15 minutes. The lady who brought it was so apologetic. The customer service was so outstanding! they were great. They have definitely made a loyal customer out of me.I spent $60 each day and I got so much food. So worth the money. I would recommend to anyone who just wants a different vibe from regular home cooked meals. It was 5 star service and 5 star food. No complaints! read more

I should've known my experience was going to be difficult once I called to ask about their hours since it says 11AM-2AM on google. I called about 4:30pm and was put on hold for about 2mins while the hostess went to ask someone for the hours, and it's not like she put me on hold to answer a call because I could hear everything going on in the background. But I also called to make sure it was appropriate to bring a 10 year old, but she let me know that it was so I asked if I could make a reservation and if we could sit "outside". We arrive close to 7pm and the hostess tells me there's seating at the bar, I had to remind her I'm with a child and I don't want her at a bar. She then corrects herself and says that it's a table near the bar. It was fine, so we walked up the little ramp into the outside and was seated on the far right, away from the beautiful dining area and near the bar. But once I sat down I see several couches available but the host tells me they're only for parties of 4 or more and walks away. As I'm sitting I can see a gentleman with his girlfriend sitting at a couch but it seems he has crutches so maybe that's why he's at a couch. As I'm reading through the menu, here comes the host sitting a couple at a couch next to the gentleman with crutches. (Wow). At this Point I don't want to be a pain but there's another couch by the gentleman with the crutches and so I ask the hostess if we can sit there instead. She immediately tells me "No!" and I let her know that I just saw her sit a couple at a couch! She then tells me "they had a reservation" , WELL I DID TOO. (Why is this girl fighting with me, is this a restaurant or my phone company) This doesn't end here, she asks me what time did I make my reservation because they made their at 12pm (never was it my business to know that) and I tell her I made it around 4:30. She finally stops TALKING, and asks a manager or however was next to the bar if she can sit us there. (Lawd) We get moved, greeted by a server who only spoke to us twice the whole night (which is fine but still) and ate some fried rice balls with mozzarella, lasagna, and their Michael Angelo fettuccine alfredo. let me rate the food for you * Fried rice balls with alfredo - It was okay, it's 3 small balls for $13.(It would've been worth the price if it was fried mac and cheese balls, just saying.) * Lasagna $16 - Delicious! * Michael Angelsos Fettuccine Alfredo $16 - Blander than a MF. I liked the spinach and broccoli but there was absolutely no flavor which kinda confuses me because there's Mexicans working in the kitchen and I know their mama taught them how to at least use some salt and pepper. I won't return, and I think the only thing saving this place is the decor, the waterboys who actually seem to care about the customers or at least have personality, and maybe the drinks (I didn't drink but I saw many people with Sangiras). Btw! Don't use the middle stall in the women's bathroom because the lock is missing ;) read more

Michaelangelo's - The start to a shitty experience. :) - Lounges Near Me - Bronx, New York