This is the fourth bagel place I have tried in Staten Island and this is by far my favorite. The bagels have a nice chew and actually have flavor! They aren't small and one with cream cheese enough to fill you up! read more

This spot opened up when I was going to the middle school down the block and is still my go to when I'm back visiting home, 13 years later. Bagels are always perfect and so are the sandwiches. They renovated not too long ago too so it's very nice and clean inside. Super quick service too. read more

Mikey Bagels - Egg Bagel BEC - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Best place in town! By far, been in NY and surrounding, tried many bagel houses, this one is super especial. Not only for the tasty bagel, but the owner, best guy you will ever meet. read more

I've always loved Mikey's bagels. Recently the older women who works there is so so so nasty and rude I could not believe it. She was cursing to someone then I got my bagel she was so rude if she does not like her job or people she shouldn't be working there. After dealing with her nasty attitude I will never go back there. It's ashame because this has always been mine as well as my families favorite bagel store. read more

Terrible customer service. The owner is an awful person and the food quality is in the dumps. The only reason he's around is because so many bagel stores in the area have gone belly up. His location just so happens to be extremely convenient for school children and school staff alike in the morning and afternoon. Thats where he makes his money and those are the people he treats with the least respect. read more

Great bagels and coffee too. Always a fresh pot brewing. Friendly service, try the French toast bagels!

Best Bacon, Egg, and Cheese in Tottenville. Good service, clean, and all around great breakfast spot. read more

BLT ON A WRAP WAS EXCELLENT! Good selection of food. Good selection of drinks. Can sit inside.

Being without Mikey Bagels for an extended period of time is like living on a deserted island and having to forage for food like fish and bananas and clams. You see, here in TN you can find bagels but there is no comparison. Mikey's Bagels are one of a kind on planet earth and believe me I know, I am from NYC. Yesterday UPS delivered a box of Mikey Bagels of all kinds and now I'm in my glory for a long time. I cut and freeze them and now every time I want a real treat, I heat one up and voila instant exstacy. It may sound like I am being paid for a commercial, but believe me I'm not. They are just that GOOD; once tried, you are hooked and only a Mikey Bagel fix can satisfy it. read more

Mikey Bagels - ABSOLUTELY THE BEST MONEY CAN BUY ANYWHERE !!!!!!! - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

They put a new cook on the grill on Father's Day. Waited 15 mins for a single sandwich and had to leave. Other people were waiting before me and still were waiting read more

Digusted will never patronize this store again! Don't care how good the bagels are. Owner not wearing mask taking orders. The guy behind register has no mask. Noticed 2 customers men without masks and a police officer from 123 pct who had mask on was waiting for his order and doesn't even say a word. What gall all other customers were with mask on following guidelines where there is even a sign posted on front door to enter with mask. I work in Healthcare and was so mad inside but kept myself from saying anything not to start a problem for myself. How disrespectful to all of us who are following the NYS guidelines. I happen to wear a mask for an 16 hr shift and I survive. Shame on u Mikey Bagels read more

So second time I've walked in and staff wasn't wearing masks I was under the impression this was mandatory I love the bagels and all their food but they need to follow the state mandate I felt very uncomfortable one customer came in said he forgot his mask and was told don't worry about it we'll I'm worried I have a husband with an auto immune and a new born in my house Please follow the rules read more

If you want to wait 30 mins for a bacon egg and cheese and get a messed up order this is the spot. Terrible service. Even calling the order in won't help. Still had to wait 20 mins. Terrible bagel store read more

Love their everything bagels. They make the best bacon, egg and cheese on bagel. Put that on an egg everything bagel and it's a done deal! Hands down the best bagels in Tottenville. If you're an iced coffee person, you'll appreciate that they give iced coffee cubes. read more

Fresh and delicious! I finally tried this place out, after several referrals from friends. The French toast bagel was probably the best bagel I've ever had! read more

Mikey Bagels - French toast bagel = total deliciousness! - Bagels Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Great bagel store in town that always has a fresh assortment of bagels and makes a delicious bacon & egg on a bagel. Place is very clean and it's great to have a good bagel store in Tottenville for all the local residents read more

We recently moved here from Brooklyn and had a couple of go to places near the old house... Mikey's Had everything we were looking for and everything was delicious... They definitely have new customers with our family! read more

Highest Recommendation for delicious New York Bagels. It's no 5 Star restaurant (only reason for 4/5 stars) but I'd easily go out of my way to come back here. While on a mini-sightseeing vacation from Virginia with the family I needed to make good on a promise to get the kids the "best bagels in New York City." After scouring bagel bakeries on Yelp I decided to take a chance on Mikey Bagels. The only thing that put me off where a couple of scathing reviews that noted inhospitable staff (but good bagels. Go figure. lol!). Well, that WAS NOT our experience. The regulars and the staff, to include Mikey, couldn't have been any more welcoming/helpful. Oh, and did I mention how good the Bagels were? I suggest getting the French Toast Bagel as an egg and Sausage Sammich (Makes me want to buy a McGriddle just to throw it in the garbage where it belongs). (In my best Austrian accent)....I'll be back. read more

Greatest bagel store in Staten Island! Freshest bagels! Mike is an awesome guy, everything is always on POINT! Coffee ice cubes is a PLUS! Wish you were open late nights!! read more

Best bagel shop in the neighborhood, and possibly the best bagel shop since I left Brooklyn and having Dyker Park bagels everyday. They are CASH ONLY so bring cash or use the ATM located in the bagel shop Staff is super friendly- I want to relay this story about Mikey Bagels. When I first moved to the neighborhood I went in to get a sandwich. I was completely hungover and it was before I knew they were Cash only. I went in, ordered, went to pay with my card, was told I could use the ATM- but it was out of service that day. Scrambling for what I thought was going to be a semi-inebriated search for a bank machine when the owner steps up to me (Mikey? Lol), hands me my order, and says "don't worry about it- bring it to me when you go to bank". I was floored. He didn't know me at all. That trust and kindness would ensure I use them daily- it's an added plus that the bagels are great. Yes, I ate, slept it off, and brought them back the $ I owed them. read more

Owner Mickey and staff very nasty ...bagels ok...not great...never enough butter or cream cheeze just ok in a jam

The best bagels on the planet and the nicest people too. I'm here once a month for business and they greet me like family every visit. I always load up on the delish bagels Everytime. FYI 90% of their bagels are vegan so a perfect place for me!!!! read more

I should've listened to the previous reviews. At the beginning, staff was wearing masks. And then it was below the nose, until it made its way down to their chins. A customer came in without a mask and there was no attempt to ask them to put it on. The customer was talking to staff the entire time, again no mask, walking up and down the entire store. They were making our food with their mask either on their chins or below their nose. We ended up throwing them out and going to a different bagel spot. Living in NYC after this long being in COVID times, I am not only disgusted but appalled. It's really not that hard to wear a mask, especially when you're breathing all over people's food. read more

I have always enjoyed a Mikey bagel, it was my go to place when I was in the area. As of lately, during Covid I have been in this establishment twice and neither staff or customers are wearing mask or gloves when handling food. Although a mandatory mask sign is on the front door no one follows it. As I was waiting for my order, I was extremely uncomfortable and annoyed that they are not taking the safety of their customers into consideration. read more

Not crazy about the bagels i give it try a couple of times. I got an French toast bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese. The bagel was hard and they was so little cream cheese on it. My kids got an everything bagel and they had the same issues. read more

A bagel is just a bagel? New Yorkers know better. Mikeys has the best bagels on Staten Island and maybe in the entire NYC. The French Toast is incredible. When visiting friends out of state they always require that I stop there to bring them bagels. When you see NYPD cops & FDNY fireman line up to get their bagels, you know it has to be good! read more

What could be more delightful and surprising than to find an unexpected bushel of Mikey's bagels outside your door, at 8 AM in the morning when he is over 1000 miles away and you are as hungry as a horse. The last time I tasted them was about 45 months ago, but this time they were even better, fuller, more flavorful and simply delicious. Thank you Mikey, my friend. Many of my friends and family will relish these morsels. Joe Savage read more

Incredibly rude! Oh the nerve...My class had an over night trip to D.C so prior to loading the busses we walked up to Mikey's for bagels, nothing out of the ordinary. As Im waiting in line I hear the lady of who I used to see working everyday when I walked up the block after dismissal, mutter not so under her breath, "Are these kids parents parents really too lazy to make them breakfast." Disgusting! Appreciate your customers, if everyone made their own breakfast you'd be out of business. The one thing you never do is question someone's parenting..especially your own customers. Unbelievable. Never coming back. Bagels themselves are nothing special, rather walk another block to the food mart. read more

Good bagels. The only issue is they aren't consistent with the same size of the bagels and the vegetable cream cheese is priced very high for the lb. read more

Great Bagels and good coffee !!!!! My favorite . Very busy 7:15 to 7:45 with 3 schools a half a block away but worth the wait.

This is the best bagel I've personally had. Plus, the workers tend to miss calculate in your favor, so you always pay less then your supposed to. read more

The best of the best. the everything bagel is the best i have ever had. the owner is round and delicious just like his bagels! always smiling too... we love mikeys! read more

I had great bagels at Angeline Christmas Tree Lighting that they gave for free and bagels were great so much we went to look for them the following weekend...and they were ok....too far from me. Thank you for those great fee bagels that night at Angelina's! read more

The little blond girl who works Saturday morning isn't the brightest. She messed up everyone's orders and we waited for 20 mins for a bacon egg and cheese that was wrong. read more

Officially DONE with this place. I have been here a few times, and something is always wrong. Ask for a bagel lightly toasted, and got it BLACK. I repeated myself 3 times when I ordered the bagels.. WTH is so hard to understand about LIGHTLY TOASTED??????? Happened the last 2 times I was there. Much better choices in the area. Will NEVER go back. read more

These bagels are so soft and chewy. I got then after work and are them the next day and they were still so good. I recommend the French Toast, Pumpernickel, and Everything bagels. read more

Great place in the neighborhood. Staff and owner are very friendly. Food is great. Prices are decent. Would come here before I go to the Bagel store on the corner of Page Ave and Amboy road. Being courteous goes a long way! read more

This is my bagel spot, best in the neighborhood. Saturday's and Sunday's when the bagels are hot/ warm, you will find no better.

The bagels are always fresh and delicious! Their veggie cream cheese is like no other. I am forever cursed, as I can no longer eat veggie cream cheese from anywhere else ! Get there early, they sometimes run out of bagels! read more

Hands down the best bagel store I've ever visited. So lucky to have it in my nabe. My weekly ritual is popping in there early on a weekend morning for bagels for me and the wife. Bagels are HUGE, delicious, and the employees and owner are very friendly. Once during a particularly busy morning, he noticed me waiting 5 minutes for someone take my order, came out from the back, asked me what I wanted, popped behind the counter, got me my bagels, and handed them to me with a smile saying "No Charge". LOVE THIS PLACE !! read more