Very cute interior! Definitely tucked a bit away from route 59 but Google maps directions were perfect. Good amount of flavor selections (fairly standard) and some tasty looking cookies and macarons. read more

See all

The cookie was warmed up. We tried two different ice creams and a strawberry milkshake. It's small the seating is unique chairs, there is higher chairs and stools with a counter top by the window. There is a bathroom it was clean. read more

Milkshake and Cookies - I - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

See all

My sister took us to this lovely little near-hidden shop with enticing flavors of handcrafted ice cream of generous serving size and perfectly shaped macarons (house made even, she says, not frozen and shipped in). Independently owned, and sister thinks it's woman-owned so extra points. A place to go whenever we visit. read more

Very welcoming, relaxing and distinctive atmosphere! Great ice cream and terrific cookies!

Many moons ago, we came to this unassuming, hidden away, shopping plaza for a paint and sip event - we found ourselves in the same plaza while I craved some coffee. This place was so cute and quaint, but I wasn't sure about it having good coffee. Color me WRONG, coz man oh man, every last thing here was beyond reproach. Forget being beyond reproach, everything we got here was just *chef's kiss* My husband got the hot chocolate which came with two gingerbread cookies, and both the chocolate and the cookies were delicious. My husband was on seventh heaven. I got the affogato, and my GOODNESS, the affogato was SO darn good, I almost cried! Just creamy, caffeinated goodness to the last drop. The icecream is of great quality, so of course the coffee was fantastic. Lastly, we got a coconut cookie to share with a scoop of vanilla - ummmmmm, WHAT? What is this manna in my mouth? Absolutely DELICIOUS!!!! Definitely coming back here! The owner is such a sweetheart, and a powerful, impressive small business owner - she is also an author, so do go check this place out! read more

They were so sweet their food looks amazing and they even let you customize your own milkshake I love this place!20/10 if I could rate them higher I would love this place! read more

Fresh and delicious cookies, cupcakes, lots of ice cream flavors. Their cookies are amazing. Super cute environment. Very friendly staff. You gotta try this place!! read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Caramel chocolate ice cream with fresh Butterscotch Caramel Pecan cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

The Cutest Sweet Spot in Town If you're looking for a cute and cozy spot to satisfy your sweet tooth, this place is a winner! This charming little spot is a dream for dessert lovers offering, freshly baked cookies which by the way are the amazing and creamy handcrafted ice cream-one of a kind! Oh and the owner Paula is one of the sweetest people you will meet. So kind hearted and generous. read more

Great atmosphere with a wonderful variety of ice cream, pastries and specialty coffees. Our grandchildren had a great time! We'll be back. read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Great fun having ice cream with our grandparents - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

I went in to purchase cookies for a friend as a gift. The owner was incredibly sweet! She wrapped the cookies in a box with a pretty bow and was very kind and helpful. The young man at the register was very pleasant and helpful as well. There is a fun and friendly vibe to the entire store. Highly recommend. read more

It's been a while since I've been here. I remember the cookies were amazing. So I stopped in for a walnut-chocolate chip. The girl was super-friendly. She asked if I wanted it heated. When I said no, she nicely explained the heating instructions for at home. The issue is, she then put a plastic glove on to pick up the cookie. But after the glove was on, she picked up her phone from the counter checked it really quick, and put it in her pocket. And then went to pick up my cookie with the glove. I guess my question is.. why even put a glove on. We all know how dirty phones are. I don't consider myself a health freak, but that's just too gross for me. Of course, I was too shy and stupid to say anything or ask for a different cookie. I tossed it in the garbage at home. I prefer to lose $4.00 than eat it after seeing that. Hopefully the owner sees the noted information and can train the staff there for future. read more

See all

Such an adorable interior! Cutesy with a bit of a vintage vibe. This place belongs somewhere less hidden away! The birthday cake milkshake I had was nothing special (flavor was a bit bland & the consistency was a bit too liquidy), but the macarons were amazing! I got the birthday cake & hazelnut flavors. Birthday cake is my favorite flavor anything so the milkshake was a bit of a letdown, but I definitely want to come back to try out more of the ice cream flavors! The service was great too, all the employees were so helpful & sweet :) read more

See all

Great cookies especially the coconut creme and regular choc chip! They just use Hershey's ice cream for everything so as an ice cream connoisseur I'm hard to impress but I can appreciate their cookies tho still at the top are Amish cookies at Rise and Roll Shipshewana Indiana. But this place is great for cookies, and I'll try some ice cream concoctions next time and it might bump this review up read more

As we walk into the establishment there is one other person there and they seem to know the clerk behind the counter. I only assume this because the person hadn't ordered anything and was having a conversation and laughing with the clerk while not having any kind of order in front of them. Meanwhile there are other employees sitting off in the back and must be on break because they were both eating and scrolling on their phones. We (family of 3) proceed to place our order (a brownie & 2 milkshakes) and we go and sit down. While placing our order another family of 4 walks in and places their order right after us. The clerk brings out the brownie from our order but no milk shakes. He then brings out the family of 4 their order. As the clerk is going back behind the counter he is still talking with his friend the entire time. Another family of 3 walks in and the clerk takes their order. One of the other employees who I assume was on break gets up and makes the orders that have just been placed and brings them to the newest family while the clerk jokes and laughs with his friend and proceeds to make him a cup of ice cream and we are still waiting on 2 milkshake!! That 7 people/ 8 if you count the friend who have now gotten their orders before we got 2 milkshakes. Long story short it shouldn't take 25 minutes to get a milkshakes while placing your order before everyone else. Save your time and effort and go to Oberweiss down the street. You'll be in and out of there before you even get your order at Milkshakes & Cookies. read more

Should these were probably the worst cookies I've ever had in my life we had peanut butter cookie and it tasted like garbage cake for the price over four dollars for a single cookie. We expected it to be delicious but it was not. It was far from it, I would never go here. I cannot recommend this place to anyone, the gentleman behind the counter was very nice even heated up, but he didn't microwave and that seemed really wrong to me like it would change the taste of the cookie by putting it in microwave and it will be set up on this restaurant read more

Well they are getting ready to open finally! The soft open has been going on for a few days now and I figured we'd pop in to try a cookie! I got fresh out of then oven chocolate chip and walnut cookies. Can't wait to try an expanded menu item of cookies. The macrons were delicious! The ice cream behind the bar looks impressive!! Tasted a couple and think it would pair good with a nice hot cookie! Great job to the girls behind the counter! Very friendly and enthusiastic! I'll surely be back!! read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Walnut chocolate chip cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

See all

We wanted a random milkshake and my mom had heard about this place on Facebook. The inside is SO cute! I loved the quartz countertops and the lighting. They have more indoor seating than a few smaller places and even have a sweets bar against the window. The cookies were huge! By the time we got there, almost at close, the only cookies left were oatmeal raisins. We both got banana cream pie milkshakes. You can make a milkshake with any flavor they have which I think is really nice. The flavor was really great! The only small complaint I have is that the milkshake was a bit thin but it was still top notch. The straw is paper which we can appreciate and it's huge! The staff was really nice. Total was around $17 for two shakes but the quality makes up for the price. It's not a McDonald's shake, for sure! We will be back! read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Banana cream pie milkshake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

My 6yr old son wanted to really try macarons. We were able to try 6 great flavors. We also tried a huge birthday cake cookie and I almost returned just for another. This cookie was delicious and so humongous. We plan to return next week to try a few more treats! Cute place with friendly people. Oh I can't forget we also tried a coffee truffle my child was bouncing off the walls all night. I totally let him taste all of these yummy treats. We were so excited about it and this place didn't disappoint. read more

Cookies are phenomenal. The man at the front is so kind and informative. The place is clean and provides excellent seating for reading a book or just enjoying your cookies and milkshake. read more

Great cookies and ice cream. Beautiful cozy place to enjoy your cookies and ice cream. Super friendly staff and owner. read more

Very nice little shop. Plenty of seating spread out, though space between tables is tight. Employees are friendly. Homemade cookies, ice cream , and shakes are the norm here. One odd thing (mentioned by other posters) which I noticed. Theres no menu or prices listed here which is strange. I decided on the Cappuccino ice cream. A mini scoop. Excellent ice cream! It has a ribbon of chocolate running thru it. The scoop was placed in a cup and turned so the ribbon was visible. Done on purpose for appearance, to enhance attractiveness. Great flavor, it was clearly, recently made. Love fresh ice cream! I also chose a homemade coconut cream cookie. My best description would be a coconut macaroon cookie in a full size cookie. It was fantastic. Nice little place. I will be back with a dessert expert... my daughter who knows desserts very well. This place is a welcome addition to the neighborhood and should be on your radar to try. Next door to the Beggars pizza. But not able to be seen from Rt 59. Do stop!! read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Inside front entrance, the greeting rug. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

See all

YUM! Shakes and cookies! Friendly service! Cute hangout atmosphere. Cookies are huge. read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Chocolate banana shake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

See all

Such a cute and new sweets bar!! It was hard to choose what flavor I wanted to make into a milkshake because they were so good. Ended up choosing the blue panda and it did not disappoint! Also got to try the milky way and Fruity pebbles macaroons and they were also really good!! Definitely check this place out when your sweet tooth needs to be satisfied! read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

See all

Cute space and really good treats! They have a nice variety of desserts and delicious ice cream.

Stumbled upon this cute place and grabbed some ice cream and a cookie. The service was top notch and the treats so good. We will be back! Highly recommend! read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Inside seating - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

This place is super cute and the milkshakes and huge cookies are addictive! Since I've found out about this place a few weeks ago, I've been back about 5 times!! The customer service is amazing! I went today and the cookie I love and the ice cream I usually have for my shake were out and the owner told me to call ahead anytime and she'll make sure to have both! It all worked out because my fav cookie was came fresh out the oven before I left... yummmm!! I can't recommend this place enough! Come with your friends and family or come alone, but you won't be disappointed. Bonus for the large cute straws too! read more

The service was great and gave us an uograde for free. The shakes are amazing. we got peppermint and cookies & cream. Highly Recommended read more

I utterly enjoyed myself while visiting Milkshake and Cookies this afternoon! The ice cream was delicious, the staff was friendly, and the environment was so peaceful so much so I didn't want to leave! I will definitely be back again! read more

This is a new hidden gem in the Plainfield area! The staff were all super genuine and sweet, and the manager was so kind and gentle :) She broke down all there was to offer here and we were able to sample all their flavors! We ended up with the vanilla chocolate chip (which was divine) and the bubble gum (with actual bubble gum drops in the ice cream!). They also offered fresh macaroons and chocolatey truffles. We definitely recommend the fruity pebble macaroons they are sooooo good as well as the chocolate mint truffle! My boyfriend and I have finally found an amazing local ice cream spot with comforting customer service!! read more

Sooo inviting & charming. The staff was friendly & very accommodating since it was our 1st visit. It's amazing!!! Thanks for offering vegan ice cream too! We will be back. read more

Milkshake and Cookies - Vegan chocolate dough ice cream with chocolate chip & walnut cookie...yummy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainfield, Illinois

Got a milkshake and it was delicious. Also the macaroon was good too. Delicious place and wonderful service

Love the the shop love the decor inside ice cream was awesome and the oatmeal raisin cookie is awesome they're very big have not try the funnel cake Sunday yet I will try it next time I visit which will be soon ...... read more

First time in on Saturday evening and happy we went! Welcomed in when we walked in by I'm assuming the owner because she left out the back door soon afterwards. The two guys behind the counter were quick to explain what they offered. We chose a dish of ice cream and a huge warm cookie and have to say they were absolutely delicious! Don't sleep on this one! Kind of hidden in a little strip mall but make no mistake it definitely with stopping in! Very clean and welcoming! read more

Great service, welcoming environment, and very well made milkshakes! We will definitely be back!

We just cane across Milkshake and Cookies in Plainfield IL while we were leaving a restaurant in the same shopping center. We walked in to a beautiful establishment that has, cookies, coffee, hot chocolate, candy, and a variety of ice cream. They have really nice background music playing which adds to the very relaxing and welcoming atmosphere. The two girls at the counter were friendly and helpful. I ordered a peanut butter cookie, which they asked if I wanted warmed up, it was huge and delicious. Not to resist the ice cream, I ordered a scoop of the chocolate moose tracks, again delicious. My husband had the chocolate chip cookie and mint chip and he said it was great. Give this place a try. Between the selections, friendly staff, great atmosphere and the eating tables outside that have warm lights on them, it is definitely a place to go spend some time and enjoy good treats. We will definitely be back read more

This is definitely a new go to spot!! My fiancé is moving out here in a few months and we already are planning our regular trips here. Really cute spot and the owner is such a nice person. She was great to talk to. read more

Cute ice cream shop with a good selection of ice cream treats and cookies (delicious cookies!) Excellent service, super friendly staff!

I couldn't wait for this place to open, I was so pumped and excited since I'm a huge cookie fanatic. But I don't get the warm & fuzzies from the owner who occasionally works the register. She's standoffish and she seemed annoyed. I thought maybe it was an off day, so I went again and it's the same thing. Normally I would stop going all together but they have a darn good cookie, several to be exact. I've tried the plain chocolate chip, the chocolate chocolate, the chocolate m&m's, and the chocolate & walnut. All were delicious but it's hit or miss what is available when you come, they run out quickly and usually only have 2 or 3 options left. My son tried a shake and it was good. But be advised they DO NOT have a MENU and DO NOT post prices for anything!! Which is a bit of a trick because you don't know your total until after you have ordered everything and it is pricey. They get a lot of business and the line moves slow. I think if they at least had a menu with shake options or cookie options, it would make the line move faster. Instead they say well what kind of shake do you want, and you have to look through the ice cream case to see what the options are. It's just weird to me. Even just do a shake of the week or something. Even still, I have gone 3 times now. But I probably would have gone 10 times by now, if it weren't for the above. I discovered a crumble cookie up the road away's on Rt 59. They have a menu with pricing and move really quickly. I'm just a little sad because I try to support small business's. read more

The chocolate chip walnut cookie, macaron, single scoop cone and a shake, and it was all delicious!! Highly recommend for your next sweet tooth craving! read more

Delicious cookies and amazing milkshakes! Staff is very friendly as well. Only wish they were open later for an after dinner dessert on the weekends! read more