That counter help is friendly and knowledgeable. Shop is always clean and inviting. Pastries are fresh and well prepared. There's a good selection. These pastries are more enjoyable to me since they are not overly sweet. read more

When you walk in you are greeted by a wonderful staff and the amazing smell of baked goods. The staff is always so helpful and so inviting. My favorite right now are the blueberry scones. They're so fluffy and the blueberries are so fresh. And the bakery itself is always so clean and welcoming. read more

Miss Amy's Bakery - Front counter of Miss Amy's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Wooster, Ohio

See all

Late review as we stopped by during the Merry Christmas in July Celebration! This small batch bakery in Wooster was featuring adorable sweet treats like this Aloha Sugar Cookie Gingerbread Man! We also loved the Key Lime Cheesecake & S'more's Brownie! So many good options with fast and friendly service! They share a small parking lot with a florist and luckily Ott's Coffee mobile coffee shop was parked there that day too! read more

See all

I've never had a baked good I didn't like, & everyone is always helpful & friendly! Bonus points too because Miss Amy's has donated items to local school fundraisers multiple times! read more

Great place the owners are amazing live to take grand daughter there she loves Amy's cookies

Still the best. Service is friendly, helpful, and never judges my XL orders. (Honestly, I should just buy partial ownership at this point.) Also, way to embrace so many holidays, celebrations, and causes! Miss Amy's has great ideas for special celebrations, especially May the 4th. The cannoli are 100% legit. This has saved me so many trips to Little Italy in Cleveland, and the filing and shells are every bit as good as what you'd find on Murray Hill. Great people, skillful artistry in pastries, and a wonderful business overall. read more

We used Miss Amy for our wedding cake & it turned out great. They were easy to work with. The building itself is cute with a few tables for sitting and friendly staff. read more

The cupcakes are a real treat! They taste as good as they look, perfect for any celebration.

I ordered a cake for my daughter's boyfriend's birthday and had no specifics, just a general theme idea. I was a little nervous to pick the cake up, but wow did they do a fabulous job! The cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! If you're wondering if you should order from this bakery - you should! read more

Miss Amy's Bakery - Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Wooster, Ohio

This small boutique style bakery has a large selection of some amazing baked goods. cookies, cupcakes, cheesecakes, pastries! if you can name it they probably have or will be making it at some point. i found this quaint little shop in my way to meijer from orrville and im so happy stopped by. read more

Amazing!!! They did cupcakes and a cake for me just the way I wanted it and I had them do items for a baby shower back in August. The sugar cookies are....to... die....for! I have since ordered many birthday cakes and stopped in for pastries. Their scones are amazing!! I would not step foot into another bakery in town as long as Miss Amy's is in business read more

Miss Amy's Bakery - Christmas cutout cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Wooster, Ohio

College of Wooster Parent. Received amazing service ....Woosh delivery error. Miss Amy delivered it to the college herself! Son greatly enjoyed the great Halloween treats . read more

We special ordered Vegan Peanut Butter cookies over a week ago. When we went to pick them up we were shocked to see that they were 1/3 the size of all the cookies in the case. Not only were they tiny, we asked for vegan chocolate kisses to be placed on top, and there was NO Chocolate at all! We also felt that they were very dry, and questioned when they were baked. We felt that they may have sat there and dried out. Twelve vegan cookies for $30! We expect to pay for a special baked item, but the fact that they were not at all what we discussed. We gave the cookies back and left them at the store. Asked for a refund, and have not been given one yet. In fact Amy called us, and when we called back it was a game of phone tag and was told that she wouldn't be in for 4 more days. Very disappointing. read more

Forgot to pick up my son's birthday cake on a Saturday and Miss Amy's went way over the top with some customer service and met me after hours (after 6:00 PM!!) so I could pick up my cake! Thanks so much for going the extra mile with some crazy good customer service. read more

Awesome cupcakes!! Bought 5 dozen for a Party. I ate 2 before we made it home they looked that good!!!! Best I've had!! Fair price! Thank you!!! read more

Miss Amy's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Wooster, Ohio

Wnet in for mother's day for some Cannolis and they were the freaking bomb. Brownies, cupcakes, sticky buns, and pecan bourbon bars were awesome as well. It is not cheap by any means, but as an occasional treat worth it! read more

Miss Amy's Bakery - Cannolis! - Bakeries Near Me - Wooster, Ohio

We usually go through Katie when ordering. What an asset Amy is blessed with as Katie is one of the sweetest and kindest individuals you'll ever meet. We know how important these qualities are to Amy and how her business is represented. Beyond that... you'll never be disappointed with the flavor and appearance of your order. Check it out!!! read more

Got a RAW apple pie bottom for thanksgiving. When a pie costs $19 I would hope it would be baked all the way through. My guests wouldn't eat it and I was embarrassed I served them this pie. read more

Very good Bakery, can't wait to return. I look forward to stopping in whenever I get in town.

First stop in at Miss Amy's Bakery. What a cute place! Great, friendly customer service and the pastries are the best around. The cream puffs and sugar cookies are TO DIE FOR! Definitely be back here! read more

Miss Amy's Bakery - Sugar cookie, pumpkin cheesecake muffin, lobster tail, and cream puff. Yummy - Bakeries Near Me - Wooster, Ohio

They are great for the Holidays! I like to grab a quiche for an easy breakfast while making Thanksgiving and Christmas dinner

My kids live going into Miss Amy's. They ask to go anytime they get a date day with me. I love their gluten free and keto options and my kids love the giant cinnamon rolls. I'm always the life of the party when I show up with Miss Amy's cupcakes. read more

Although the cake tasted good it was not what I ordered. I specifically said to ice the cake in the same coconut, pecan icing every German chocolate cake is iced in. The birthday cake was for my BFF's 60th birthday and he's a he and didn't need or want roses. they also didn't put the coconut pecan icing between the layers. Ugh! What's a custom cake if it's not what you ordered? I'm not sure I'll use them again. So sad to mess up his birthday because someone couldn't follow directions. read more

Miss Amy's Bakery is AMAZING!!! They have a variety of delicious and unique pastries, cookies, cakes, and cupcakes! And always a huge selection! Reasonable prices considering the quality of the products! Very accommodating for custom orders! All of the staff members are wonderful and very friendly! The owner is very generous. She often gives discounts close to closing time on Saturdays! Their coffee is great, too. Also, they recently expanded their storefront to include many more seating areas and a public restroom! It makes for a great place to meet with friends for breakfast or a mid-day snack, or get some work done on your laptop! I love Miss Amy's! read more

My mom has come here several times before and placed many orders that went very smoothly. This year, however, she called the store several hours before picking up an order that she had made weeks prior and the order was neither ready, nor did it seem like it was ever placed. After several calls back and forth, the order was luckily pulled together but even when we got to the store an employee was still asking us what kind of cupcakes we wanted to order despite the fact that our order was in the back all set and ready to go. Very disorganized this year, unfortunately. And on the day of event, it is not a risk my mom is willing to take this time next year. If my mom had not called ahead, who knows if the order would have been ready before the event. read more

The staff is amazing, owner has a heart for people, her staff & the community. Beautiful shop, clean & the products are amazing. They always have done a great job with custom cakes for special occasions. Once you've been to Miss Amy's you won't want anything else! read more

All desserts look amazing and everyone I have had-cookies, cake, cupcakes, tiramisu are delicious!!

Mike drop.....I am a dessert addict, and WHOLY COW!!! We had some friends from Wooster come celebrate Thanksgiving with us and they brought a box of assorted desserts from Miss Amy's Bakery, one was better than the next!!! Next year I'm starting with desserts first!! Please open up a bakery here on the east side of Cleveland!! Highest recommendations!! read more

Everything is AMAZING...but my favorite are the cinnamon rolls. Bread is great as well as the sweets. Go early!

Miss Amy's is the best bakery I've ever been in!! Everything is fresh and amazing! It's cute and an amazing addition to Wooster! If I'm out that way I can't just drive by. I love giving her treats to people read more