I worked with Jacki Maynard throughout the entire process and I couldn't recommend her more. From the best rates to the great advice and everything in between Jacki has been so helpful and attentive. I am so happy we were able to work together to make the process so smooth and straight forward. She is the best! Highly recommended everyone to her! read more

I am sorry to say that I had a bad experience with the agency since last July 2024 Miscommunication , lack of following up contact , jeopardized Insurance coverage on the last hurricane. Knowing that I had coverage, but I didn't. Thank god , no damages . Sorry . Finally coverage reinstated after 3, 4 months . read more

Kelly Ray is always very professional and helpful. She answers our questions and inquiries in a timely manner. We have been very pleased with all of the personnel that we have encountered at Mitchell Insurance Agency. We highly recommend them based on our experience. read more

Jacki does an absolute wonderful job each time I talk to her. Thank you for saving me over $300 .

I have been with them 2 years and while I have found them to be generally responsive I found it impossible to get confirmation of insurance coverage on a car I bought Saturday. Tried thru website but it said specifically that there was no coverage until they confirmed there was. Supposedly I have not one but two agents assigned to me but neither answered emails over the weekend. Neither did their Manager. Finally just before 10 pm Sunday night someone with the last name Mitchell emailed me to say I was covered. When my assigned agent called Monday he quite patronizing, in essence saying that I should have known that my car was covered. Am looking for another agency because of all this read more

Kelly Ray is very customer-service oriented. All of my interactions with her are great, and she goes out of her way to be responsive and helpful. I very much enjoy working with her. Bryan F. read more

Jacki Maynard has helped me get insurance for both home and auto. Jacki has always gone above and beyond. She's always taken her time and has shopped around for the best possible plan at the best rate. I have piece of mind when working with her, knowing she's thorough and has me and my families best interest in mind. Carey P. read more

Our insurance rates for our homeowner's insurance increased dramatically. Matthew Berger of Mitchell Insurance Agency resolved our issues quickly, efficiently, and accurately within two days. He listened to our concerns and found the right solution for us while keeping our auto and homeowner's insurance with one company. It has been a great partnership! read more

Personal, going above and beyond. Always willing to help, and never feel rushed or put-off.

I worked with Chrissy and she was got back to me very quickly and was extremely helpful! Would definitely recommend!

Amy Jenkins is the best!!! She is so kind n helpful and very patient bc I can be a difficult person at times..she has helped me with my sons SR22 Bond and helped me set up a claim for the roof at my home which was damaged in this crazy weather we've been having, step by step until I understood everything...Mitchell Ins should be PROUD of having VALUABLE Eployees like Amy..Thanks Wanda Stowers read more

I wish I could give my friends at Mitchell Insurance Agency more than 2 stars, but since my agent left the agency, their service and attention has gone down hill. Like most insurance agencies, once they've got you locked into a policy, it's "see ya, wouldn't want to be ya" time! In other words, "we don't need to keep in touch with you anymore unless your rates increase." Thanks for nothing! Having been a professional salesman all my life and realizing early on how important my customers base is for basic business survival and new business acquisition, it would be nice if Mitchell Insurance Agency figured this out as well. The customer is the #1 avenue to new business through referrals and is the foundation on which every business survives. Mitchell has never asked me for any referrals nor will they receive any from me, because they've never gone above and beyond the normal call of duty to serve me. Granted, they've always been able to satisfy my customer service needs when called upon, but even then, it took awhile to resolve simple issues due to the inaccessibility to my agent who apparently works out of his home instead of the main office. Handling customer service issues effectively is the bare bones requirement for survival in the insurance industry. Any old agent can provide that. Why can't Mitchell provide more? As soon as I am able, I will be switching all of my policies over to my old friend. Mitchell has already lost half of my business, mainly because they've never asked for it. Oh well. Another one bites the dust, I guess. read more

Mitchell Insurance Agency - Home & Rental Insurance Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

I would think twice before using Mitchell! I was promised a refund my Insurance of my Car because I went elsewhere! It has 5 weeks and no refund! I called the Home office and told them what was going on and they said they would call me back in Two days. I have not heard back! FUCK Mitchell Ins. They will gladly accept your money but won't payout! read more

Florence, KY office., Doesn't get better than Chrissy Carr. Always willing to find the best policy for my needs, as well as explaining details and getting me the information for an annual bundled house/auto quote, and when necessary helping assist when I have had to file a claim. Chrissy has always been there when I have questions and explains them until I understand. I can't see ever going to anyplace else. read more

I've been with this company for around 4 years and would highly recommend them. Every interaction I've had with them has addressed my issue quickly, efficiently and I have always had a friendly, seamless customer service interaction leaving me feeling as though my needs had been addressed. I also feel that their rates are very affordable and customizable to meet your needs. I spoke with Tim this evening needing to make a change to my policy, he got right back to me and served as an advocate for me to ensure a fair outcome. Would highly recommend! read more

Needed an insurance change due to some vehicle changes made recently. Stephanie and Jared, once again, took care of things immediately, These are the best insurance support folks I have ever dealt with! Give them your business and you won't be disappointed. read more

I have found Mitchell Insurance to be quick, reliable, and flexible. They, specifically my agent, Chrissy got me my insurance quote quickly at a fair price and set up my new policy with me over the phone at the dealership so I could purchase my new car! Super grateful for the quality customer care and service provided! read more

I've been with Mitchell Insurance now for 5 years, maybe more. They were able to lower my rates with Erie initially as I was no longer willing to pay a higher price with NW. My original agent left the agency several years ago but every time I call, I speak to knowledgeable and helpful staff members. Now that my adult daughter had a couple minor, no injury accidents, we received a nonrenewal cancellation over the weekend. Before I was able to call an agent, I had a new renewal quote with another carrier offered by the agency. Turns out, I'm saving almost $1,000 a year by switching carriers for my home, autos and motorcycles. I have no intention of leaving this independent agency. They are worth the call! read more

We have been with Mitchell for many years. They have helped us with home, car and umbrella insurance. Our agent retired a few years ago - to us he was the face of Mitchell Insurance and looked after us. We are re-establishing that relationship with a new agent but can (and have) worked with a number of people with simple requests. We are happy with the quality and cost of our insurance plans. Well worth speaking with Mitchell. read more

Mitchell insures 6 of our rental properties and have alway been cordial and professional. Zero complaints - highly recommend!

This company was great until my agent left. No one knew who would take our policy and answer my questions. Finally when it came time that I was involved in two accidents, both not my fault and can be seen in the photos I sent to them, I was the one who got the markings on my insurance. They paid the woman who hit me to get her car fixed yet mine had hardly any damage. I reported everything in advance right after the incidents happened. NOW, because I have had 2 wrecks, they will no longer offer me car insurance and I just received a letter in the mail with date or cancellation. They have been no good to me since my agent left and I strongly advise anyone who is accident prone or gets hit a lot, this is not the company. They will insure you and once you get in a wreck, they will send you a letter of cancellation on your policy. Crooked people. It's not right and the fact they paid for someone else to get their car fixed when they backed into me......backed into my passenger rear tire, as if I Tokyo drifter my car into her bumper. Come on people, its easy to see who's at fault. But I guess its my fault for taking pictures, getting insurance information and sending them to my agent 10 minutes after the wreck. Thanks for notifying me she wasn't my agent anymore as well as continuing to take my money from my account even though I changed it with 4 people and they still didn't get it right. Ridiculous. Sometimes small business' are not the way to go! read more

Been with Mitchell Insurance for over 20 years and couldn't be happier. They have always been there for me and let me know what the best insurance is for my needs. They keep an eye on costs for me and keep me informed on any better deals for my insurance needs. Looking forward to another 20 years with Mitchell Insurance! read more