My mother recently passed away and I needed a few things catered for her going home celebration. I…read moreasked for recommendations and saw over 7 referrals for Eleazer Deli. I didn't get a chance to take photos of the ambiance or food but I ordered a full pan of creamy salmon, a pan of wings, and spicy creamy chicken pasta. I was by far not disappointed at all it was GOOD. Prior to receiving the food we were given a taste test of the items I purchased and those jerk wings which were delicious, so good they had my man dancing lol. I just want to say thank you to Jerome thank you for all of your help thank you for going out of your way to help me for my mother's service and I appreciate you.

Food was great and the service was as well!! It had the amount of ambiance you'd expect from a…read moredeli! I certainly plan on returning!

Used to hit this deli 3x week for breakfast or lunch. Super convenient. Lately the new staff is…read morelackluster. Order a special with bacon for pick up. Ask the older lady 3x about bacon as she kept repeating without. Picked up, asked again. She said yes and sounded annoyed. Get up to the LIE and open. No bacon. I call and we're told I had to bring it back. I asked if they could owe me bacon next week and they said No. Really? I try delivery today. Asked for a wrap with just onions, allergic to peppers. Eggs, ham, cheddar and peppers. Will someone open a drive up and my family will go there ​

I ordered an egg sandwich and some fried Oreos I was skeptical at first due to the lack of reviews…read morebut this place is pretty good. Great place would order again.

This deli used to be so great growing up, and even a few months ago back when the young adults were…read moreworking there. All of a sudden they let them go, and decided to hire old people who cannot remember anything or get anything right and it was very frustrating. We stopped going and then decided to come back and now i think theyve hired people who are high, they dont do their job, dont listen at all, dont pay attention. The place has gone down the drain and the food is not good at all anymore. They cant cook eggs to the right temperature and cant put the right cheese or any cheese on it if you ask. Its horrible. The place is ghetto and lazy now. How hard is it to get a good bacon egg and cheese??? Never coming again. I tried and tried and am over it.

It doesn't take much to make me happy when visiting a place. For a beer house, all it takes is good…read moreservice. I came here for two reasons, one: I had some cans I wanted to recycle (it makes me feel like I'm saving the planet) and two: my brother wanted to pick up beer for when he headed home. I pulled up to this location fifteen minutes early and found parking in their decent sized lot. The gates were still down so my brother and I stood there and talked. That's when, from behind a chain linked fence and gentleman appeared. I felt this was the perfect time to ask about the business. He immediately yelled out "we are open in fifteen minutes!" I said "I know, just wanted to ask a question." He than quickly shut that down. "I open in fifteen minutes and don't like people waiting in my parking lot, so come back than!" I felt completely offended. He couldn't even answer a question. My brother wanted to say something, but in this day and age I strongly advised him not to. We just left and took our business somewhere else. I get it, it doesn't like to be bothered while he's working. Who does? But we were customers coming to buy food and keep money in the community. What was he thinking? If that's how he is with everyone, I'm certain the doors will be closing here for good soon.

Went here around December 2024 during a week where I was on a journey to try a multiple of hero…read moresandwiches from so many different deli shops on the Island. Dont recall exactly what I ate however Im pretty certain with eggs and cheese minimum. Nonetheless a great experience and would like to come back again.

I had the Bronx bomber It was exactly what I was craving &…read moremade just the way I like it...with a little TLC

I stopped in on a whim and ended up having a surprisingly great experience. The place has a relaxed…read morelocal feel that immediately makes you comfortable. The meal came together nicely, with thoughtful portions and classic sides that complemented the main dish well. Everything tasted fresh and satisfying, especially the balance of textures and flavors. The roll was nicely prepared, and the filling was light, creamy, and easy to enjoy without being overwhelming. Even the smaller details felt intentional. Overall, it was a pleasant visit that exceeded expectations and left me looking forward to coming back to explore more of the menu.

Small hidden gem on maintain highway. I always have passed and wanted to stop and finally one day…read morewas today. I was cruising in my classic car just having me time and I stopped and had the cod fish and chips. It was so good. I talked to Kathryn/ Kathrin and Patty. I had a nice cold pumpkin beer with a rum and just had a nice time. I really want to give this small place a nice review as they had very good food and company. I felt like I was in Montauk. I will be back with my family. Thank you. Manny

Great place pleasant the food was excellent vegan options my son comes here all the time his…read morefavorite the Rice in the roti w/Chicken we definitely will return give it Tru every one

Authentic and flavorful Turkish food, great service. The ambience is just ok- kind of basic and…read moreclean, not particularly cozy.